Huffpost Crime
David Lohr Headshot

Jodi Arias Trial: Prosecutor Accuses Defense Expert Of Misrepresenting Herself

Posted: Updated:
ALYCE LAVIOLETTE
Alyce LaViolette in court Friday. (Photo via Pool Camera) | In Session -- Pool Camera
Print

Jodi Arias' murder trial turned nasty again Friday as an Arizona prosecutor accused a defense expert of misrepresenting herself.

The allegation was made by prosecutor Juan Martinez when the judge finished putting the jurors questions to domestic violence expert Alyce LaViolette.

Martinez zeroed in on LaViolette's response to a question about how many men she has testified on behalf of in criminal court. She had told the jury she thought she had done so once or twice. When she was unable to remember the name of either man, she relented and said she had wrote a report in one of the cases and did not actually testify in court.

"So you misrepresented something to the jury, didn't you?" Martinez asked.

"I did not testify, I wrote a report on his behalf to go to criminal court," LaViolette replied.

"That's different than testifying in court, isn't it?" asked Martinez.

"Yes, it's different than testifying in court," said LaViolette.

Hammering the point home with the jury, Martinez said, "There was no second man that you testified in criminal court on his behalf, isn't that true?"

LaViolette replied, "I said one or two because I don't remember Mr. Martinez."

Arias, 32, is accused of the June 4, 2008 slaying of her ex-boyfriend Travis Alexander, inside his Mesa, Ariz., home. The prosecution contends Arias stabbed 30-year-old Alexander 27 times, shot him twice in the face and slashed his throat in a jealous rage. Arias told jurors she killed Alexander in self-defense during an argument over a dropped camera that followed his escalating sexual demands.

LaViolette said all the information she gathered on Arias, including interviews and the review of case materials, support her opinion that Arias was physically and emotionally abused by Alexander.

Earlier in the day, LaViolette was grilled by the jury about her opinion on domestic violence in the case. Arizona is one of three states that allow jurors to pose questions to witnesses after prosecution and defense lawyers have finished their questioning.

The jury's questions Friday, paraphrased below, included:

Is there any reason to believe Arias has not manipulated you, as she has others?

"I didn't use Jodi as my evidence. I didn't. I used so many other things to look at, so I don't believe that Jodi manipulated me because the areas I looked at were corroborated by other people," LaViolette said.

Other than what Arias has told you, what evidence have you seen that Alexander was physically abusive?

"I actually didn't see other evidences of physical violence by Travis," LaViolette said.

How can Arias remember the alleged physical abuse so clearly when she never wrote about it in her journals?

"I know that people remember things that they don't write down," LaViolette said.

Is it possible your definition of manipulation differs from others?

"Yes," LaViolette said.

Is it possible your definition of manipulation is wrong?

"Yes," LaViolette said.

Would someone with low self-esteem say, "No jury will ever convict me?"

"It sounds like a really foolish statement to me," LaViolette said.

The jurors' questions and LaViolette's answers could prove to be a defining moment in the trial that will ultimately have a large impact on Arias' fate. Arias could face the death penalty if convicted.

The trial is scheduled to resume at 4:30 p.m. Eastern time Monday, when the defense is expected to call their next witness.

FRIDAY'S LIVE BLOG:

live blog

Oldest Newest

The judge has called the evening recess. The trial will resume Monday, at 4:30 p.m. Eastern time.

Share this:

After the jury question Martinez again asked if she had earlier said the shooting occurred in the closet.

"I misspoke," LaViolette said

Share this:

Was miss Arias story from October 2011 consistent with the story as we know it today?

"I was not privy to her testimony" LaViolette said.

Share this:

The attorneys are at a sidebar with the judge.

Share this:

LaViolette said she took an unbiased approach to the case.

Martinez has ended his questioning of the witness.

Share this:

Share this:

Martinez is now pointing out that LaViolette cannot see or hear inflection when she is reading text.

Share this:

LaViolette said Alexander told a lot of lies.

"That is a liar, correct?" Martinez asked.

"Correct," LaViolette replied.

Share this:

Martinez is again pointing out LaViolette is being paid to testify.

Share this:

Martinez asked LaViolette is she told the jury Alexander was perpetrator and Arias was the survivor. She said she does not remember saying that. Martinez asked to approach the bench and the attorneys are now at a sidebar with the judge.

Share this:

Judge Sherry Stephens just announced Juror 11 is ill and has been excused from the trial.

Share this:

Court is back in session.

Share this:

The defense attorneys are in chambers with the judge..

Share this:

The judge has called a 10 minute recess.

Share this:

The attorneys are at another sidebar with the judge.

Share this:

"You don't have a doctorate, correct," Martinez asked.

"Correct," LaViolette replied.

Share this:

Martinez again asked LaViolette if she misrepresented herself when she said she had testified on behalf of a man when she "only wrote a report."

"I did not remember if I had testified," LaViolette said.

Share this:

Martinez asks LaViolette if she would have to reconsider her opinion if she discovered Arias had lied to her.

"It would depend on what Ms. Arias lied about, once again, I'm looking at a pattern. I look at patterns Mr. Martinez, I don't look at three isolated incidents. I'm not black and white, there's a whole lot of gray here," she said.

Share this:

Share this:

The attorneys are at another sidebar with the judge.

Share this:

Martinez asked LaViolette how her assessment on the case could not be affected by Arias' proven lies in the case, such as the story about the intruders.

"My assessment about domestic violence remains the same Mr. Martinez," LaViolette said.

Share this:

Martinez asked LaViolette about her opinion that Arias is not manipulative.

"I said I had no evidence of Ms. Arias being manipulative," LaViolette said.

Share this:

The attorneys are at a sidebar with the judge.

Share this:

"There was no second man that you testified in criminal court on his behalf, isn't that true," Martinez asked.

"I said one or two because I don't remember Mr. Martinez," LaViolette replied.

Share this:

LaViolette now says she wrote a report in one of the cases and did not actually testify.

"You misrepresented something to the jury didn't you," Martinez asked. Willmott objected.

Share this:

LaViolette now said she does not know one of the names of the men she testified for.

Share this:

Martinez wanted to know the names of the men LaViolette has testified for. She said she is not allowed to share the names.

Share this:

Willmott asked LaViolette if it is common for a battered woman to snap.

"Anger is sort of a byproduct of being victimized," LaViolette said.

Share this:

The attorneys are at a sidebar with the judge.

Share this:

Willmott asked LaViolette if she thought Arias was the abusive perpetrator in the relationship.

"No, I don't," LaViolette said.

Share this:

Related on HuffPost:

Close
Jodi Arias Timeline
of
Share
Tweet
Advertisement
Share this
close
Current Slide

Suggest a correction

Around the Web

How is Jodi Arias tweeting from jail?

Jodi Arias Expert Tells Prosecutor to...

Testimony Resumes in Jodi Arias Murder Trial

'HLN is an acronym for Haters Love Negativity': Jodi Arias uses Twitter to ...