* South Carolina conservative left Senate looking for more influence

* Heritage Foundation immigration study tests clout of new leader

By Caren Bohan

WASHINGTON, May 6 (Reuters) - When Jim DeMint announced in December that he was leaving the U.S. Senate to head the Heritage Foundation think tank, he said he thought he could wield more influence outside rather than inside the Congress.

Any doubt about that may have been put to rest on Monday with the release of a study by the foundation lambasting a bipartisan immigration proposal in the Senate as a budget-buster that would cost taxpayers trillions of dollars.

While the report was written by a scholar, Robert Rector, the main attraction was DeMint. That was true for boosters of the study and, as it turned out, for as detractors as well, who used DeMint's name to discredit the findings.

The publicity tour started on Sunday when the former South Carolina senator plugged the Heritage study on ABC's "This Week," not normally a venue for think-tank wonks.

It continued on Monday with DeMint defending it in advance on Fox News. Hours later, DeMint presided at the news conference where the report was released.

"He obviously has some influence as a former senator," said Tevi Troy, a former deputy secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services under President George W. Bush.

Troy said the immigration fight would be an "interesting test case" of Heritage's clout since it is the first big issue it is taking on under DeMint's leadership.

Having DeMint as the star cut both ways, however. He is a long-time opponent of immigration reform and as a senator he helped kill a similar bill in 2007. Critics of the Heritage Foundation report - and there were many - used that fact to attack the study.

Among the most outspoken was Haley Barbour, the ex-governor of Mississippi and former head of the Republican National Committee. He noted pointedly on a conference call with reporters that "it was probably more than a coincidence" that Heritage, under DeMint, would be opposing the immigration bill. The study, Barbour said, "is a political document."

DeMint's "reputation as a researcher is, um, questionable," said a statement from America's Voice, a liberal advocacy group that favors the Senate legislation.


The content of the Heritage study was controversial enough. It estimated that the bill's provisions giving undocumented immigrants a 13-year path to citizenship - "amnesty" in DeMint's words - would cost $6.3 trillion over a lifetime because of government benefits that would be paid to them.

Conservative critics of the study called it deeply flawed because it failed to consider the benefits to the economy of the bipartisan immigration bill, which includes provisions sought by industry to fill high-tech and low-tech jobs that companies say are going begging.


OPENING SALVO

The foundation said it followed respected scholarly methodology in producing the study. "We are a research institution here," said Derrick Morgan, a Heritage vice president. "We can't necessarily speak to the motivations of other people. "But we very much want the fiscal costs to be part of the debate because it protects the American taxpayer."

The argument about the study, which took place just days before debate is scheduled to begin on amendments to the Senate immigration bill, marked the opening salvo in a war of talking points and studies that will play out over the next few months.

Heritage is at odds with liberal think tanks such as the Center for American Progress and also with analysts at the libertarian Cato Institute as well as some scholars at the conservative American Enterprise Institute.

The divisions mirror a split within the Republican party itself, with stalwarts such as Barbour as well as Florida Senator Marco Rubio, a rising star within the party, supporting immigration reform. Others such as Senator Jeff Sessions of Alabama and Senator Ted Cruz of Texas have lined up against it.

DeMint, a leader in the conservative Tea Party movement, is known for his outspokenness. In 2009, he helped to fire up conservative opposition to President Barack Obama's proposal to overhaul the healthcare system by declaring that the bill would Obama's Waterloo. Republicans were unable to stop the bill from becoming law.

DeMint's role is all the more interesting because of his ties to Rubio, a member of the so-called Gang of Eight senators who wrote the immigration reform bill under consideration.

DeMint was a strong supporter of Rubio's Senate candidacy in 2010 and the Florida senator, who is seen as a possible presidential candidate in 2016, has credited DeMint with helping him to win the seat.

"Immigration reform pits Rubio against mentor DeMint," said a headline on a CNN blog post.

"By the time that appeared on Monday afternoon, DeMint, unfazed, was back on television, telling Fox News: "what we need to do is put aside this whole idea of amnesty and fix our system one piece at a time."

The immigration bill, he said, "is going to be another Obamacare." (Additional reporting by Thomas Ferraro. Editing by Fred Barbash and Christopher Wilson)

Also on HuffPost:

Loading Slideshow...
  • The American Conservative Union's 2012 Rankings

    On Feb. 21, 2013, <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">The American Conservative Union</a> released its 2012 conservative ratings guide. Which members of Congress had a perfect score?

  • Sen. Ron Johnson (R-Wis.)

    (Photo By Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Sen. Jon Kyl (R-Ariz.)

    (Photo By Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Sen. Mike Lee (R-Utah)

    (Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Sen. Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.)

    Andrew Harrer/Bloomberg via Getty Images <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.)

    (Photo by Brendan Hoffman/Getty Images) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Fla.)

    (SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Sen. Pat Toomey (R-Pa.)

    (Photo By Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Michele Bachmann (R-Minn.)

    (MANDEL NGAN/AFP/GettyImages) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Diane Black (R-Tenn.)

    (Photo By Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Marsha Blackburn (R-Tenn.)

    (Photo by Mark Wilson/Getty Images) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Paul Broun (R-Ga.)

    (Photo By Douglas Graham/Roll Call/Getty Images) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Dan Burton (R-Ind.)

    (Photo by Alex Wong/Getty Images) <em><a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/01/31/dan-burton-retirement-indiana-gop_n_1244141.html">Editor's note:</a> Burton retired from Congress in January 2012</em> <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Jeff Flake (R-Ariz.)

    (Photo By Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call) <em><a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/11/07/jeff-flake-election-results-2012_n_2049514.html">Editor's note:</a> Flake became a U.S. senator in Jan. 2013</em> <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Mike Conaway (R-Texas)

    (Photo By Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Jeff Duncan (R-S.C.)

    (Photo By Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. John Fleming (R-La.)

    (Photo By Bill Clark/Roll Call) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Bill Flores (R-Texas)

    (Photo By Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Trent Franks (R-Ariz.)

    (Photo By Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Scott Garrett (R-N.J.)

    (Photo By Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Trey Gowdy (R-S.C.)

    (Photo by Chris Maddaloni/CQ Roll Call) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Tom Graves (R-Ga.)

    (Photo By Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Wally Herger (R-Calif.)

    (Photo By Tom Williams/Roll Call) <em><a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/01/10/wally-harger-retirement-california-republican_n_1197156.html">Editor's note:</a> Herger retired from Congress in January 2012.</em> <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Duncan Hunter (R-Calif.)

    (Photo By Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Lynn Jenkins (R-Kan.)

    (Photo by Scott J. Ferrell/Congressional Quarterly/Getty Images) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Jim Jordan (R-Ohio)

    (Photo By Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Jeff Landry (R-La.)

    (Photo By Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call) <em><a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/12/09/charles-boustany-wins_n_2267276.html">Editor's note:</a> Landry was defeated by fellow Republican Charles Boustany in Dec. 2012's special election.</em> <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Randy Neugebauer (R-Texas)

    (Photo By Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Pete Olson (R-Texas)

    (Photo By Bill Clark/Roll Call via Getty Images) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Mike Pompeo (R-Kan.)

    (Photo By Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Bill Posey (R-Fla.)

    (Photo By Bill Clark/Roll Call) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Tom Price (R-Ga.)

    (Photo By Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Ben Quayle (R-Ariz.)

    (Photo By Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call) <em><a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/08/29/david-schweikert_n_1838371.html">Editor's note:</a> Quayle was defeated by David Schweikert in the Republican primary for Arizona's 6th congressional district.</em> <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Ed Royce (R-Calif.)

    (Photo by Scott J. Ferrell/Congressional Quarterly/Getty Images) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Steve Scalise (R-La.)

    (Photo by Bill Clark/Getty Images) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. David Schweikert (R-Ariz.)

    (Photo By Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Tim Scott (R-S.C.)

    (Photo By Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call) <em><a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/12/17/tim-scott-senate_n_2315830.html">Editor's note:</a> Scott was appointed U.S. Senator by S.C. Gov Nikki Haley in Dec. 2012, taking the seat of Jim DeMint.</em> <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Cliff Stearns (R-Fla.)

    (Photo By Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call) <em><a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/08/15/cliff-stearns-planned-parenthood-reelection_n_1777602.html">Editor's Note:</a> Stearns lost the Aug. 2012 GOP primary to retain his House seat.</em> <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Marlin Stutzman (R-Ind.)

    (Photo By Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Lynn Westmoreland (R-Ga.)

    (Photo By Bill Clark/Roll Call) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Joe Wilson (R-S.C.)

    (Photo By Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>

  • Rep. Todd Rokita (R-Ind.)

    (AP Photo/Michael Conroy) <a href="http://hosted-p0.vresp.com/1174985/8b2d5dc5f6/ARCHIVE">Source: American Conservative Union 2012 Rankings </a>