Huffpost Detroit

Detroit Bankruptcy Judge Steven Rhodes Will Hold First Hearing Over Pension Legal Challenges

Posted: Updated:

DETROIT — A federal judge on Wednesday swept aside lawsuits challenging Detroit's bankruptcy, settling the first major dispute in the scramble to get a leg up just days after the largest filing by a local government in U.S. history.

After two hours of arguments, U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Steven Rhodes made clear he's in charge. He granted Detroit's request to put a permanent freeze on three lawsuits filed in Ingham County, including another judge's extraordinary decision that Gov. Rick Snyder trampled the Michigan Constitution and acted illegally in approving the Chapter 9 filing.

That ruling and others had threatened to derail the bankruptcy.

Questions about Detroit's eligibility to turn itself around through bankruptcy "are within this court's exclusive jurisdiction," Rhodes said.

He said nothing in federal law or the U.S. Constitution gives a state court a dual role. It was a victory for Detroit, which had warned that it would be "irreparably harmed" if it had to deal with lawsuits in state courts while trying to restructure $18 billion in debt with thousands of creditors.

"Widespread litigation ... can only confuse the parties, confuse the case and create serious barriers," attorney Heather Lennox told the judge.

Creditors "will have their day in court" – bankruptcy court, she said.

The courtroom was jammed with lawyers representing creditors as well as rank-and-file city employees and retirees eager to know the outcome. Some wore T-shirts that said, "Detroit vs. Everybody."

Detroit emergency manager Kevyn Orr, who recommended bankruptcy, sat in the front row for part of the hearing. Outside the courthouse, protesters held a banner with a message for Wall Street: "Cancel Detroit's debt. The banks owe us."

Detroit has about 21,000 retirees – police, firefighters, City Hall clerks, trash haulers, bus drivers – who are owed money and fear their income is at risk in a bankruptcy. Orr has said the city has underfunded obligations of about $3.5 billion for pensions and $5.7 billion for retiree health coverage.

The Michigan Constitution states that public pensions "shall not be diminished or impaired." An Ingham County judge cited that provision last week when she ordered Snyder and other officials to take no further action in the Detroit bankruptcy.

Sharon Levine, an attorney for a union that represents city workers, urged the bankruptcy judge to let those lawsuits run their course. She said there's no federal insurance for public pensions once they're broken, unlike pensions at private employers.

"Our members who participate at most are at or below $19,000 a year. There is no safety net," Levine said.

Although Rhodes ruled in favor of Detroit, he said opponents will have opportunities to make the same arguments in his court in the future. He has many critical issues ahead, including whether Detroit really is broke and entitled to greatly reduce or wipe out debts. The process could last a year or more.

Michael Nicholson, general counsel for the United Auto Workers, was disappointed with Rhodes' decision.

"State courts have the power to decide what the state constitution means," Nicholson said outside court. "In our view, retirees' rights are a matter of Michigan constitutional rights."

Snyder signed off on Detroit's bankruptcy on July 18, calling it the only practical choice for a city whose population has plummeted to 700,000 from 1.8 million decades ago. Detroit's long-term debt has become an urban millstone.

The governor called Rhodes' decision "excellent" and said it allows one place to settle the city's finances.

In March, Snyder appointed Orr, a bankruptcy expert, as Detroit's emergency manager. Orr had sweeping powers to reshape city finances but recommended bankruptcy after failing to reach any significant deals with creditors, including Wall Street bankers and Detroit pension funds. Many of those creditors, however, accused him of being inflexible and believe bankruptcy always was the plan.

Detroit has more than double the population of Stockton, Calif., which had been the largest U.S. city to file for bankruptcy before Detroit trumped it last week.

Detroit fire Lt. James Edwards, 43, attended the court hearing Wednesday with some anxiety.

"It seems as though we're going to end up being the patsy for a lot of bad decisions that have been made over the years," said the 18-year department veteran, referring to his future pension. "You base your life decisions on promises made to you when you came on the job."

Belinda Myers-Florence, 59, said her pension is her only income after working nearly 36 years for Detroit, from bus driver to social services. She can't believe she may lose money because of the bankruptcy.

"It's going to have to hit me in the face," she said. "I just can't believe that they can go that way."


Follow Ed White at

Around the Web

It's feds vs. state as Detroit heads to bankruptcy hearing -

Fight over Detroit bankruptcy begins in federal court | Reuters

Detroit bankruptcy court judge to decide pension case - USA Today

Eastern District of Michigan | United States Bankruptcy Court

It's feds vs. state when Detroit heads to court for bankruptcy hearing ...

Detroit hurtles toward first bankruptcy hearing Wednesday - NBC ...

Hearing Set for Lawsuit Disputing Detroit's Bankruptcy Filing ...

Court Puts Challenge to Detroit Bankruptcy on Hold -

Michigan Court of Appeals suspends orders blocking Detroit ...

Court halts order to withdraw Detroit bankruptcy | The Detroit News

Fight over Detroit bankruptcy begins in federal court

Michigan court stays challenges to Detroit bankruptcy filing

Detroit bankruptcy court judge to decide pension case

It's feds vs. state as Detroit heads to bankruptcy hearing

Michigan Court of Appeals suspends orders blocking Detroit bankruptcy filing

First hearing in Detroit's bankruptcy case, Cipriano sentenced: What to know ...

Judge to set course of Detroit bankruptcy at Wednesday hearing

Judge Sets First Hearing for Detroit Bankruptcy

Judge delays hearing on Detroit bankruptcy, pensions

Detroit bankruptcy case heads to Wednesday hearing on challenges