BROOKLYN, N.Y. -- A lawyer for New York City on Monday denied that the NYPD has a surveillance program to spy on Muslims.
Responding to an ACLU lawsuit claiming religious discrimination that seeks to force police to turn over surveillance records, city lawyer Peter Farrell claimed "there is no Muslim surveillance program. ... I 100 percent disagree that there was ever a Muslim surveillance program."
The hearing in a Brooklyn courtroom dotted with spectators wearing conservative Muslim religious attire was part of a federal lawsuit filed by Brooklyn Imam Hamid Hassan Raza and other Muslims. The Raza lawsuit is the testiest of three simultaneous legal fights over NYPD surveillance of political activities, which include challenges by civil rights groups and New Jersey-based Muslims.
The Associated Press has reported that, beginning in 2011, the NYPD had a broad-ranging practice of spying on mosques and Muslims. But the city has argued in response that it only follows leads when it visits Muslim neighborhoods, and does not target Muslims as such.
Nevertheless, Farrell said it was logical for the police to be concerned about extreme members of the faith.
"Since 2001, the terrorist threat against New York City has been by Islamists who are radicalized to violence," Farrell said. It would be foolish, he said, for the NYPD to act "in this vacuum that plaintiffs ask this court to work in."
Farrell's argument seemed to highlight what ACLU lawyer Hina Shamsi said was "the heart of this lawsuit" -- the idea that law-abiding Muslims should be subject to surveillance because perpetrators of 9/11 terror attacks were Muslim.
U.S. District Judge Pamela Chen did not say during the hearing whether she will allow the ACLU to peer through the NYPD's files. She said she would consider a motion the civil liberties group is likely to file seeking an injunction halting police spying on Muslims.
In an effort to show its surveillance is rooted in reasonable suspicions, the city laid out allegations against the plaintiffs in an incendiary filing last month. Shamsi said the city's accusations in that letter were "based on factual inaccuracies, innuendo and guilt by association."
The city is trying to limit the documents it must hand over to the ACLU to those that concern the plaintiffs. But Shamsi said that would essentially allow the city to show only documents it wants.
The plaintiffs must have access to documents detailing surveillance on Muslims and non-Muslims alike, Shamsi argued. Only turning over information on her clients, she said, would "hamper our ability to meet our burden … while solely bolstering defendants' ability" to claim that the lawsuit's plaintiffs were not being singled out.
Also on HuffPost:
Bill de Blasio
Currently the city's Public Advocate, <a href="http://www.billdeblasio.com/" target="_blank">Bill de Blasio announced his bid for mayor in January 2013.</a> He has supported the paid sick leave bill,<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/bill-de-blasio/humane-alternatives-for-h_b_821291.html" target="_blank"> banning horse-drawn carriages</a>, and has been fiercely <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/19/nyregion/19homeless.html" target="_blank">critical of Mayor Michael Bloomberg's homeless policies. </a>
Former Democratic congressman <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/05/22/anthony-weiner-2013-mayoral-race_n_3316704.html" target="_blank">Anthony Weiner finally announced his bid for mayor</a> in May after months of intense speculation by the media and politicians alike. In 2011, an embarrassing sexting scandal forced Weiner to resign from Congress. The lewd photos, along with his denial and subsequent admission, kept him out of the political spotlight until this spring.
As the city's current comptroller, <a href="http://johnliu2013.com/" target="_blank">John Liu</a> oversees New York City's finances. <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/03/25/comptroller-john-liu-ackn_n_1378211.html" target="_blank">Despite a federal investigation accusing two former aides to Liu of breaking campaign finance laws</a>, Liu announced his candidacy for mayor in March. In a recent interview, <a href="http://www.dnainfo.com/new-york/20130319/new-york-city/john-liu-says-all-democratic-mayoral-candidates-are-basically-same" target="_blank">Liu said, "We are all liberal Democrats"</a> and suggested Democratic mayoral hopefuls were all the same, differing on only a few issues such as stop and frisk. If elected, Liu would become the city's first Asian-American mayor.
<a href="http://www.quinnfornewyork.com/announcement?splash=1" target="_blank">Christine Quinn</a> is the current City Council Speaker of New York City. She is said to be Mayor Michael Bloomberg's favorite candidate.
From 2002-2009, <a href="http://billthompsonformayor.com/" target="_blank">Bill Thompson served as New York City's Comptroller. </a> Thompson, a Democrat, ran for mayor in 2009 against Bloomberg. He was outspent 14 to 1 by Bloomberg, and still only lost by a few percentage points.
Adolfo Carrion Jr.
Adolfo Carrion, Jr. was the Bronx Borough President from 2002 to 2009 and was appointed by the Obama administration as the Regional Director for HUD's New York office. <a href="http://www.carrion2013.com/" target="_blank">He is running for mayor as an independent. </a>
Staten Island's <a href="http://www.salgadonyc.com/" target="_blank">Rev. Erick Salgado </a>announced his Democratic candidacy for mayor, despite a socially <a href="http://politicker.com/2013/02/erick-salgados-odd-coalition/" target="_blank">conservative agenda</a> which includes anti-gay marriage, pro-life policies.
<a href="http://www.salalbanese2013.com/" target="_blank">Sal Albanese</a> is a former city council member also hoping to win the Democratic primary. He also worked as a New York City public school teacher. <a href="http://www.capitalnewyork.com/article/politics/2012/12/6850576/former-brooklyn-councilman-sal-albanese-make-third-try-mayor" target="_blank">This will be his third bid for mayor of New York City. </a>
Before launching his GOP candidacy for mayor, <a href="https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=2&cad=rja&ved=0CDoQFjAB&url=http%3A%2F%2Fjoelhotaformayor.com%2F&ei=TOJ2UeXyAqT00QGe8oHYBA&usg=AFQjCNHVt6kspcgFB31wwgs6FO44kr2fSQ&bvm=bv.45580626,d.dmQ" target="_blank">Joseph Lhota</a> served as MTA chairman and served as the City’s Budget Director in Mayor Giuliani’s first term, and Deputy Mayor for Operations during the second. In 1999, he fought a public battle against the Brooklyn Museum to remove a portrait of the Virgin Mary containing elephant dung. <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2013/03/28/nyregion/for-lhota-mayoral-hopeful-who-lost-fight-to-remove-art-no-regrets.html?pagewanted=all" target="_blank">He lost. </a>
<a href="https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=3&cad=rja&ved=0CEcQFjAC&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.cats2013.com%2F&ei=SON2UaHQG6nq0gGq3oCoDw&usg=AFQjCNELoeyQyeiyb-RKgsBoAZmaMq38vA&bvm=bv.45580626,d.dmQ" target="_blank">John Catsimatidis </a>. a Republican candidate for mayor, is a billionaire supermarket mogul. He is known for his pro-NYPD policies and <a href="http://www.nypost.com/p/news/local/mayoral_hopeful_john_catsimatidis_JtW3R5pgD1OwpRnbvWSuyM" target="_blank">supports the continuation of the department's controversial stop-and-frisk program. </a>
<a href="https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=3&cad=rja&ved=0CEwQFjAC&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.mcdonald2013.com%2F&ei=9uN2Ub7OAc-C0QGmooCQCA&usg=AFQjCNFKEjqwcjPtmMrF_o2C8pw_dLzGjA&bvm=bv.45580626,d.dmQ" target="_blank">George McDonald</a> is the founder and president of The Doe Fund, a non-profit that seeks to help homeless and formerly incarcerated individuals find work. He has never held public office. He initially identified himself as a Democrat but has since switched to the Republican party. McDonald has received criticism for trying to challenge <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2013/03/25/nyregion/george-t-mcdonald-ends-effort-t-o-sidestep-a-city-cap-in-mayors-race.html" target="_blank">campaign contribution limits. </a>
Former Democratic congressman <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/05/22/anthony-weiner-2013-mayoral-race_n_3316704.html" target="_blank">Anthony Weiner finally announced his bid for mayor</a> in May after months of intense speculation by the media and politicians alike. In 2011, an embarrassing sexting scandal forced Weiner to resign from Congress. The lewd photos, along with his denial and subsequent admission, have since dogged his political career, but a <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/05/28/anthony-weiner-nyc-mayor_n_3347673.html" target="_blank">recent poll revealed many New Yorkers were willing to forgive and forget</a>, with voters putting him at second only behind frontrunner Christine Quinn.