Huffpost College

Judge Upholds $1.17 Billion Patent Verdict For Carnegie Mellon University

Posted: Updated:
Print Article
CARNEGIE MELLON CAMPUS
UNITED STATES - JULY 21: The Collaborative Innovation Center at Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, where high tech companies like Apple, Intel and Google are operating, is seen on Friday, July 21, 2006. Pittsburgh colleges are benefiting from partnerships with three of the biggest names in computing: Google Inc., Intel Corp. and Microsoft Corp. The companies, which operate campus labs in Pittsburgh, are contributing to the city's transformation from symbol of 20th-century i | Bloomberg via Getty Images

PITTSBURGH (AP) — A U.S. judge has declined to reduce a $1.17 billion patent infringement verdict that Carnegie Mellon University won against a California technology firm in 2012.

U.S. District Judge Nora Barry Fischer previously rejected Marvell Technology Group's bid for a retrial in the case involving use of the university's 1998 patented technology in chips manufactured for computer hard drives.

In a 73-page opinion released late Tuesday, the judge also rejected Marvell's argument that that the amount should be reduced by $620 million because of the university's lack of diligence in protecting its patents.

Fischer said the university "inexcusably" waited five years before suing, but that delay was offset by Marvell's "deliberate and sustained" infringement. She has yet to rule on university motions to increase damages

Around the Web

Judge denies firm's bid to cut CMU's patent verdict in half

Marvell loses bid to reduce $1.17 billion US patent verdict

Marvell Loses Bid to Halve $1.2 Billion Patent Verdict

Marvell Can't Halve Carnegie Mellon's $1.2B Patent Award

Why Marvell Technology Group (MRVL) Is Down Today