Huffpost Parents

Titanic Mystery Solved? DNA Tests Disprove Shocking Claim By 'Survivor' (VIDEO)

Posted: Updated:
Print

Everyone who survived the 1912 sinking of the Titanic is dead, and now one of the tragedy's oldest mysteries has been laid to rest: DNA tests confirm that the sensational claim by a woman who said she survived the sinking was all wet.

The bizarre saga begins more than a century ago, when two-year-old Loraine Allison set sail on the Titanic along with her parents and baby brother, Trevor. With the help of a maid, Trevor made it onto a lifeboat and survived the ship's sinking. But Loraine and her parents were never seen again and were presumed dead, according to the Telegraph.

Three decades later a woman who called herself Helen Kramer surfaced with a shocking claim on a radio show, asserting that she was actually Loraine Allison. She said she had survived Titanic's sinking with the help of the ship's designer, Thomas Andrews, and that she was entitled to a share of the Allison family fortune.

The woman tried to convince the Allison family that she was telling the truth but never succeeded. She died in 1992.

But the strange story doesn't end there.

(Story continues below.)
allison family

The Allison family before their fateful voyage on the Titanic in 1912. Loraine is pictured at center.

In April 2012 -- the centennial of the sinking -- Kramer's granddaughter, Debrina Woods, renewed her grandmother's claim, launching a website and posting the following on a Titanic Historical Society forum:

I am the granddaughter of Helen Lorraine Kramer who was told that she was actually Helen Lorraine Allison and who was listed as a victum of the Titanic disaster. She was the Daughter of Hudson J. & Bess Allison, first class passengers and who are known to have both perished with the sinking. This is a mystery that has had much speculation and is a story that I grew up with from my earliest memory.

Bottomline...all anyone need do is see a photo of Hudson Allison and my grandmother and if there was ever a father and daughter it is they. I have the photos I have letters I have her daughter Adele, my mother with me to interview and am seeking to tell and share this tale in it's truth and it's entirety once and for all.

In response to the renewed claim, a group led by forensic scientist Tracy Oost founded the Loraine Allison Identification Project. They obtained DNA from members of the Allison family and had it compared to a sample from Woods' half-sister, Deanne Jennings (Debrina Woods declined to give a sample).

In December of 2013, the results finally came in: Helen Kramer was not Loraine Allison.

Case closed. Or is it?

Members of the Allison family told news outlets that they had finally achieved closure and expressed their gratitude for the DNA work.

"I would like to thank Deanne Jennings and [great-niece of Bess Allison] Sally Kirkelie for offering their DNA to stop this harassment," David Allison said, according to the Irish Independent. "This was a courageous, selfless act, and I will remain forever indebted for their act of kindness."

But Debrina Woods isn't giving up. In a recent post on her website, she wrote that the findings of the Loraine Allison Identification Project "have ONLY steeled us to commit EVEN MORE to telling the real TRUTHS of this story!!!"

Also on HuffPost:

Close
Memories Of The Historic Titanic
of
Share
Tweet
Advertisement
Share this
close
Current Slide

Suggest a correction

Around the Web

Titanic's last great mystery solved, Canadian 'heiress' is exposed as fraud

The lost child of the Titanic and the fraud that has haunted her family

DNA solves one of Titanicand's oldest mysteries

The Last Titanic Mystery - Home

Titanic's last great mystery solved, Canadian 'heiress' is exposed as ...

DNA tests clear up Titanic's last mystery - USA Today

Titanic's last great mystery: DNA test proves woman impersonated ...

DNA solves one of the Titanic's oldest mysteries | Cutting Edge ...

'Last great mystery of the Titanic' solved | Mail Online - Daily Mail