Huffpost Food

New York's Iconic Gray's Papaya Hot Dog Joint Closes, Marks The End Of An Era

Posted: Updated:
Print Article
GRAYS PAPAYA
The outline of where neon signs were attached on a Gray's Papaya restaurant that recently closed on Sixth Avenue and West 8th Street in the Greenwich Village section of New York January 27, 2014. (Photo credit should read STAN HONDA/AFP/Getty Images) | STAN HONDA via Getty Images

No more "Recession Specials," neon lights and cheap bites washed down with papaya juice: New York has lost one of its most iconic hot-dog joints after three decades.

"Gray's Papaya" in Greenwich Village, a reputed favorite of late rocker Lou Reed, has fallen victim to the near daily roll call of New York institutions crushed by exorbitant rent increases.

Shops, bars, cafes and restaurants that for generations are considered integral to the world's most exciting city suddenly disappear overnight, no longer able to pay the rent.

"I'll miss getting those hot dogs at midnight," jobbing actor Peter Coleman, 28, told AFP in a nearby bar, waxing lyrical about the shuttered premises on Sixth Avenue and 8th Street.

"It's sad to see another neighborhood staple go the way of Ray's Pizza," said Coleman, who works in the neighborhood and still misses the beloved pizzeria that closed a few years ago.

Famous for its "recession special" -- two hot dogs and a medium soda for $4.95 -- Gray's Papaya was a veteran culinary landmark.

Kids, late-night drinkers, clubbers and the homeless counting out their last coins came for a dog and the legendary papaya drink "made from the magical melons of the tropics".

They flocked to the 24-seven joint, as much for its food as its quirky decor -- paper-mache fruit hanging from the ceiling and its witty ads: "If you're hungry, or broke or just in a hurry".

Another fan, filmmaker Ashbey Riley, paid tribute in an emotional blog on the Huffington Post.

"I can hardly remember the first time my father took me there. I must have been about three. It doesn't matter really. Gray's became an everlasting part of my life," she wrote.

"Gray's has always been there through every phase. Gray's was enduring, never changing, always dependable, forever delicious and conveniently, Gray's was always open," she added.

Tourists came for a genuine taste of the Big Apple.

The place featured on the small and silver screen in among others "Sex and the City," "How I Met Your Mother," and the 1998 rom-com "You've Got Mail" with Meg Ryan and Tom Hanks.

Owner Nicholas Gray confirmed the reason for the closure was the sharp increase in renewing the lease.

"They wanted to raise my rent to $50,000 from $30,000," he was quoted as saying in the local media.

Employees and the manager of Gray's remaining branch, away from the Manhattan bar scene on the Upper West Side, declined comment.

Journalist Jeremiah Moss who has written for The New Yorker, Playboy and the Paris Review, has cataloged rent casualties on his blog "Jeremiah's Vanishing New York" since 2001.

Moss blames much of the loss of "6,926 years of history" on billionaire mayor Michael Bloomberg, who left office in January after 12 years of rising inequality and booming property prices.

"It's been 12 merciless years of destruction and loss, from 'significant' losses to countless 'smaller' ones -- neighborhood laundromats, shoe repair shops, drugstores," Moss wrote.

Besides "Gray's Papaya" 2014 has already seen the loss of a clutch of other businesses, including the "Famous Oyster Bar", which shuttered after 55 years Seventh Avenue and 54th Street.

It put up a sign saying that it was closing "due to exorbitant rent prices". The owner was quoted as saying that four years ago the rent was $12,000 and now it's more than $30,000.

Another was well-known clothing store "Camouflage" in uber-chic Chelsea, kicked onto the kerb after 38 years when the rent more than tripled from $7,000 to $24,000 a month.

Also on HuffPost:

Nathan's Hot Dog Eating Contest
of
Share
Tweet
Advertisement
Share this
close
Current Slide

Suggest a correction

Around the Web

West Village Gray's Papaya Has Closed [Updated] -- Grub Street ...

What Is Happening to Gray's Papaya Right Now?! - The Shutter ...

Gray's Papaya - CLOSED - Greenwich Village - New York, NY - Yelp

There's Now Only One Gray's Papaya Left In New York City: Gothamist

New York City mourns closing of iconic eatery Gray's Papaya

How Gray's Papaya Helped Get Me Drunk at Age 4

From Our Partners