Huffpost Sports

Oscar Pistorius Trial: Neighbor Heard A Man Crying

Posted: Updated:
Oscar Pistorius arrives at the Pretoria High Court on May 5, 2014. | Foto24 via Getty Images

PRETORIA, South Africa (AP) — Oscar Pistorius was accused of making a "sinister" remark to a friend of Reeva Steenkamp in the courtroom Tuesday during a break at his murder trial.

Pistorius denied the allegation that he said to the close friend of the girlfriend he killed: "How can you sleep at night?"

The accusation by Kim Myers provided a bizarre twist during the trial of the world-famous double-amputee Olympian, who is facing 25 years to life in prison if convicted of premeditated murder for shooting dead Steenkamp, a 29-year-old model, at his home last year.

Pistorius, 27, denies murder and says he killed Steenkamp by mistake thinking she was an intruder when he shot her multiple times through a closed toilet door.

He also denied to reporters in the courtroom that he made any comment to Myers. Pistorius said he hadn't spoken to members of the Myers family for weeks, despite sitting a few feet away from them during proceedings. Myers' lawyer said she told him it happened.

Myers was approached by Pistorius and he made the remark to her in a "very sinister way," the lawyer for Myers told The Associated Press. Attorney Ian Levitt said Myers was "shocked" and did not know what it referred to. Levitt said she found it "extremely disturbing."

"It's important to confirm this. It was in front of witnesses. Journalists have witnessed this," Levitt said of the alleged comment. Levitt was not in the courtroom but said Myers phoned him to report it.

Reporters said Pistorius apparently made a comment to Myers as he walked close to the court benches reserved for family and friends of both Pistorius and Steenkamp. Levitt added that he made a complaint to state prosecution officials, although officials at South Africa's National Prosecuting Authority said they would not be acting on the report.

The Myers family was very close to Steenkamp. Steenkamp lived with them after moving to Johannesburg to further her modelling career and they referred to themselves as her second family. They have attended much of Pistorius' trial.

Pistorius' lawyer, Brian Webber, said Pistorius also told him that the allegation regarding the remark was untrue.

"I've asked the client and he denies that he said it," Webber said.

During trial proceedings, two women who lived on either side of the house where Pistorius killed Steenkamp were called by the defense as witnesses and were asked to make high-pitched wails while testifying. The defense was trying to show that Pistorius' cries on the night of the shooting could be confused with a woman's screams.

The prosecution maintains that Pistorius killed Steenkamp intentionally and after she screamed during a loud fight. Other neighbors testified that they heard a woman screaming before and during the sound of gunshots — evidence of the heated argument between the couple, according to prosecutors.

The defense says only Pistorius screamed, first to warn off a perceived intruder and then in desperate panic after realizing he had shot Steenkamp by mistake through the stall door in his darkened bathroom. In total, three next-door neighbors were summoned by the Olympian's defense on the 27th day of testimony. They all testified that they heard a man's high-pitched cries, but not a woman screaming.

The neighbors were briefly cross-examined by chief prosecutor Gerrie Nel who sought, simply, to show that they had heard events after the fatal shooting and their testimonies were irrelevant to a possible fight between the couple.

During the testimony, Pistorius sat on his wooden bench looking impassively at times at his former next-door neighbors, who all described him as friendly and a good neighbor. His legal team says they could wrap up presenting his defense by next Tuesday.


Imray reported from Stellenbosch, South Africa.

Also on The Huffington Post

Oscar Pistorius Trial
Share this
Current Slide

Suggest a correction

Around the Web

Video: Watch live: Oscar Pistorius murder trial - Telegraph

Trial of Oscar Pistorius - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

BBC News - Oscar Pistorius trial: Evidence -

Oscar Pistorius Trial on Livestream

Witnesses Tell of Pistorius's Anguish After Shooting Girlfriend ...

Oscar Pistorius was 'praying, crying, torn apart' after shooting, witness says

Oscar Pistorius Murder Trial Resumes After 17-Day Break

Oscar Pistorius trial: 'Blade Runner' defense enters critical phase

Oscar Pistorius trial: Live updates as Blade Runner's defence team resumes its ...

After 2-week break in Oscar Pistorius trial, witness says athlete 'in anguish ...

From Our Partners