Supreme Court Rules In Favor Of Death Row Inmates Who Have Low IQs

05/27/2014 10:39 am ET | Updated Jul 27, 2014

(Adds details of ruling and reaction)

By Lawrence Hurley

WASHINGTON, May 27 (Reuters) - The U.S. Supreme Court on Tuesday threw out a Florida man's death sentence by finding that the state's method for assessing whether defendants are mentally disabled violated the U.S. Constitution.

The court ruled on a 5-4 vote that Freddie Lee Hall, 68, who was on death row for two murders, should have another chance to show he should not be executed.

The decision gives states less latitude in deciding how to determine eligibility for the death penalty of people who say they are mentally disabled.

The ruling follows a 2002 decision in which the high court said the mentally disabled cannot be executed. It could help other inmates in Florida and some other states who are challenging their sentences.

Florida had initially determined that Hall was mentally disabled in 1992, but later found him competent after he scored 71 on an IQ test, the minimum under Florida law.

The court found that the Florida process was unlawful under the Eighth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which bans cruel and unusual punishment.

"Florida's law contravenes our nation's commitment to dignity and its duty to teach human decency as the mark of a civilized world," Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote on behalf of the majority.

The Supreme Court concluded that states should defer to the clinical consensus for determining whether people are mentally disabled.

Hall's attorneys said experts, including the American Psychiatric Association, said that IQ tests should include a standard error of measurement of five percentage points, meaning results could vary that much either higher or lower.

Florida's test has a hard cutoff at 70 on the IQ test and does not take into account the standard error of measurement.

Writing on behalf of the four dissenters, Justice Samuel Alito wrote that the court had embraced a "uniform national rule that is both conceptually unsound and likely to result in confusion."

Hall was convicted of the 1978 shooting deaths of a sheriff's deputy and a woman who was seven months pregnant. Only his death sentence was at issue in the case.

Jenn Meale, chief spokeswoman for Florida's Republican attorney general, Pam Bondi, declined to comment, saying officials were reviewing the decision.

The American Civil Liberties Union's state executive director, Howard Simon, said he hoped that the ruling signaled increased Supreme Court scrutiny of Florida's capital punishment laws and court procedures.

"The strict IQ rule struck down by the Supreme Court today is just one example of the many ways in which our state's death penalty system falls short of constitutional and human rights standards," he said.

The civil rights group opposes the death penalty.

Kennedy was joined in the majority opinion by Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Elena Kagan, Sonia Sotomayor and Stephen Breyer. In addition to Alito, the dissenters were Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas.

The case is Hall v. Florida, U.S. Supreme Court, No. 12-10882. (Additional reporting by Bill Cotterell in Tallahassee.; Editing by Howard Goller, Dan Grebler and Jonathan Oatis)

Also on HuffPost:

  • 29 YEARS ON DEATH ROW
    South Carolina Department of Corrections
  • NAME: Edward Lee Elmore
    STATE: South Carolina
    RELEASED IN 2002

    In 1982, Dorothy Edwards of Greenwood, South Carolina, an elderly white woman beloved by her community, was brutally murdered and raped in her home. Edwards' neighbor offered up Elmore, her handyman, as the perpetrator of the crime, even as he maintained his innocence. Elmore was arrested, went to trial 82 days later, and received a death sentence -- a conviction that he received three times as appeal courts overturned each verdict. The case was riddled with bad (even planted) evidence, an incompetent defense, a tainted crime scene, and police coverups. He spent 29 years on death row until his defense argued that he was mentally disabled and legally could not be executed, so he was reduced to a life sentence. In 2002 -- 29 years later -- he pled guilty to murder in exchange for release.

    Check out CNN's original series "Death Row Stories" (Sundays 9pm ET/PT) for a deeper look into this case.
  • 25 YEARS ON DEATH ROW
  • NAME: Krishna Maharaj
    STATE: Florida
    COMMUTED TO LIFE SENTENCE IN 2002

    One-time millionaire and business magnate Kris Maharaj was convicted on two counts of murder in 1987. The case was plagued by covered-up evidence, false eyewitness accounts, and a shoddy defense (who didn't call any of his many witnesses to the stand as a "tactical" maneuver). Clive Stafford Smith has worked on this case for years, and in 2002, succeeded in commuting Maharaj’s death sentence to a life term following serious misconduct on the part of the judge and prosecution. Smith continues to fight for Maharaj's release, saying: “It is unfathomable to most rational people that the US Supreme Court says that innocence is not a reason to set a prisoner free. That Kris has spent 10,000 days in prison for a crime he did not commit is little more than legal kidnapping.”

    Check out CNN's original series "Death Row Stories" (Sundays 9pm ET/PT) for a deeper look into this case.
  • 33 YEARS ON DEATH ROW
    Florida Department of Corrections
  • NAME: Manuel Valle
    STATE: Florida
    EXECUTED: 9/28/11
    LAST MEAL: Fried chicken breast, white rice, garlic toast, peach cobbler and a Coca-Cola.

    Manuel Valle killed a police officer in Coral Gables, Florida, in 1978 after being stopped for a traffic violation. In the dissenting opinion of Valle v. Florida, Supreme Court Justice Stephen G. Breyer stated that the inmate's long stay on death row amounted to cruel and unusual punishment. He said, "I have little doubt about the cruelty of so long a period of incarceration under sentence of death."
  • 33 YEARS ON DEATH ROW
    Georgia Department of Corrections
  • NAME: Jack Alderman
    STATE: Georgia
    EXECUTED: 9/16/08
    LAST MEAL: Did not request a last meal. Ate regular prison meal of baked fish, peas, cole slaw, carrots, cheese grits, bun, fruit juice and chocolate cake.

    Jack Alderman was convicted in 1975 of killing his wife, Barbara Jean Alderman. At the time of his execution, he was the longest-serving death row prisoner who had been executed in the United States.
  • 31 YEARS ON DEATH ROW
    Texas Department of Criminal Justice
  • NAME: David Lee Powell
    STATE: Texas
    EXECUTED: 6/15/2010
    LAST MEAL: Four eggs, four chicken drumsticks, salsa, four jalapeno peppers, lettuce, tortillas, hashbrowns, garlic bread, two pork chops, white and yellow grated cheese, sliced onions and tomatoes, a pitcher of milk and a vanilla shake.

    In May 1978, Powell fatally shot 26-year-old Austin police officer Ralph Ablanedo 10 times after he and his girlfriend were pulled over for missing a rear license plate. The two were on the way to a drug deal at the time of the crime. Opponents to his execution cited his exemplary behavior in prison and argued that he was no longer a threat to society, which is a legal requirement for capital punishment. Thirty-one years, three trials, and multiple appeals later, he died by lethal injection.

    He spent the longest time on death row of anyone in Texas since the state resumed death penalty executions in 1982.
  • 43 YEARS ON DEATH ROW
  • NAME: Gary Alvord
    STATE: Florida
    EXECUTED: Died of brain tumor in 2013

    In 1974, Gary Alvord was sentenced to death for strangling three women in their home in Tampa, Florida after he escaped from a mental hospital. Although Alvord faced execution several times, his history of mental illness prevented the sentence from being carried out. Last year, after 43 years on death row, he died of natural causes. In the time he spent awaiting execution, 74 other inmates were sent to their deaths. Bill Sheppard, who represented Alvord, has said: “Gary is a product of a sick system. He was a living example of why we should not have the death penalty.... I would love for the state of Florida to tell us how much money they wasted trying to kill a guy they couldn't kill."
  • 33 YEARS ON DEATH ROW
    Death Penalty Information Center
  • NAME: Reginald Griffin
    STATE: Missouri
    CHARGES DISMISSED IN 2013

    Reginald Griffin was implicated in the 1983 stabbing death of a fellow inmate at the Moberly Correctional Center in Moberly, Missouri, where he was serving time for an armed assault conviction. He along with two other inmates were charged with capital murder in 1987. There was no physical evidence linking Griffin to the crime, and in subsequent trials, the two inmates who served as witnesses for the prosecution in were offered benefits to testify. In 2011, the Missouri Supreme Court found that the state had withheld critical evidence and overturned Griffin's conviction. In 2013, all charges were dismissed. Upon his release, Cindy Short, one of his attorneys, said: "We humans are flawed, and those flaws have led to wrongful arrests, wrongful convictions and, unfortunately, this situation where time and time again you see prosecutors holding onto cases, even when evidence of innocence is clear."
  • 36 YEARS ON DEATH ROW
    AP
  • NAME: Michael Selsor
    STATE: Oklahoma
    EXECUTED: 5/1/12
    LAST MEAL: Kentucky Fried Chicken’s crispy two breast and one wing meal with potato wedges and baked beans, a chicken thigh, apple turnover, two biscuits and honey, salt, pepper and ketchup.

    In 1975, Michael Selsor shot gas-station clerk Clayton Chandler six times during a robbery in Tulsa, Oklahoma along with his accomplice, Richard Eugene Dodson. Although he was tried by a jury and sentenced to death in 1976, the U.S. Supreme Court and Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals ruled the death penalty unconstitutional later that year. Selsor's conviction was overturned by the U.S. Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals in 1996; however, his 1998 retrial ended in another death sentence. After 36 years, Selsor was executed in Oklahoma by lethal injection.