08/01/2014 09:27 am ET Updated Aug 01, 2014

How To Score A Table At An Impossible-To-Book Restaurant (VIDEO)

Have you ever tried to score a table at a hot new restaurant, only to be told the wait list is three months out? OpenTable exec Caroline Potter has a tip for getting into notoriously busy restaurants.

"The most common mistake that people make when they're trying to get a reservation at a hotspot is that everybody wants to dine out on Saturday night -- table for two or table for four at 8'oclock -- and there's just not enough inventory to meet demand," Potter says.

So what's the best night of the week to get a reservation? "Tuesday is the new Saturday," Potter says. Last-minute reservations and multiple time slots are more likely to be available on this weekday night.

"I love mid-week dining because you enjoy a much more relaxed dining experience," she adds. That means more time for leisurely conversation, chatting with the sommelier, and Instagramming your plate without getting an eye roll from the party of four waiting to be seated.

More from #OWNSHOW: Secrets from the hostess stand

Like Us On Facebook |
Follow Us On Twitter


  • You're Making A Reservation On The Phone
    Even great restaurants have empty tables sometimes, and while you might be able to snag one by calling at 5:00 on the evening you want to eat, online services like Savored and OpenTable do a fine job of searching for availability -- plus, they reward you with a discount. If you use Groupon-owned Savored, for instance, which currently lists restaurants in 10 cities and is adding more soon, you could pay 30 percent less for food (and drinks, too) if you want to dine that night at 8 p.m., and up to 40 percent if you're willing to eat at 6 p.m. (bonus: no coupons necessary).
  • You're Walking In Hungry
    You've heard it's not wise to go grocery shopping when you're famished -- and it turns out that advice applies to dining out, too. Aaron Allen, a restaurant consultant who has advised clients including The Cheesecake Factory and TGI Fridays, says over-ordering is a common mistake among the ravenous. Two ways to avoid this pitfall: have a small snack before you leave home, or split an appetizer, which will leave you plenty of room for your entrée (and save you some money, too -- especially since appetizers are some of the most high-margin items on the menu).
  • You're Hoodwinked By A Smiley Face
    Allen sees tip inflation growing at an even higher rate than food inflation: It used to be that a gratuity of 10 percent was acceptable and the norm; then it went to 12 percent, because customers wanted to show that they weren't just satisfied -- they were impressed. This cycle continued, and now the typical amount is 20 percent, with some restaurants even suggesting 22 percent and higher at the bottom of the bill. Obviously, there are times when a very generous tip is appropriate (and it's still true that most servers make below minimum wage, so they really do depend on the extra cash). But base your tip on the service itself, says Allen -- not on what a restaurant "suggests." And beware tactics like the smiley face (one study found that people tip 18 percent more when a waitress draws one on the check).
  • You're Drinking The House Wine
    Although it sounds like a bargain, "house wine" is usually the worst value on a restaurant's list (unless, that is, you're dining in a quaint Italian village). Allen says the markup on these bottles -- which can be domestic or imported -- is often very high, since restaurants know they're an easy sell. Instead, consider the imported wine section of the menu -- these bottles used to cost much more than American ones but have become much more reasonable. Chilean varieties, in particular, are a great deal; Allen finds many restaurants are responding to customers' increased interest in reasonably priced Malbecs. (And, as always, consider ordering a bottle if your group is going to drink more than four glasses.)
  • You're Ordering The Wrong Vodka
    Allen has noticed that if he orders a vodka tonic, a waiter will often ask, "'Would you like Grey Goose or Belvedere?' -- as if those are the only two choices." The truth is, if you're having a mixed drink, you don't necessarily need a premium spirit, and having your drink made with whatever is in the well -- bartender-speak for 'non-fancy liquor' -- is an easy way to lower your drinks bill. The well (also called the house pour) might be Absolut or Smirnoff, which are both perfectly fine mixed with tonic or juice but cost about two-thirds less.
    Next: 7 things to stop spending money on right now