'Gilmore Girls' Michel Wasn't Necessarily Gay, But Sookie Was Supposed To Be

06/06/2015 06:21 pm ET | Updated Jun 06, 2015

The question of Michel's sexuality on "Gilmore Girls" is perhaps best summed up by this fan page asking if he is "gay or just French." The show's creator, Amy Sherman-Palladino, spoke with The Huffington Post at ATX Television Festival in Austin, Texas, Friday and gave us what may be the closest thing we'll ever have to a definitive answer.

"We all know men who seem creative, who have wives and children," she said, giggling. "So we never actually pursue it one way or the other and sort of let it lie."

"We left it ambiguous and I think that was a choice," said Yanic Truesdale, who played Michel. "I actually never asked Amy! ... I've never asked, swear on my mother's head."


As Sherman-Palladino noted, early on in the series Michel makes a few comments insinuating he is straight. "We sort of went on record saying he was into women, because we put it in the script once," she said, "but things can change or shift."

Truesdale remembered that people speculated his character was in love with Lorelai, though his sexuality was never really part of Michel's character. "They couldn't figure it out and Amy liked that," he said. "That's why she made it like, 'Oh, he loves Celine Dion.' But he's French. French guys are more feminine. French guys are more sophisticated... If you go to Paris, it's like, 'Oh my god, is he gay?'"

Sherman-Palladino did, however, explicitly think of other Stars Hollow residents as gay. "We had characters in the town that we thought of as gay," she said, refusing to reveal who. "And we just thought of them as characters."

When the show started in 2000, LGBT characters were few and far between (read: mostly limited to Showtime's "Queer As Folk"). Sherman-Palladino actually intended Sookie (Melissa McCarthy) to be gay, but executives wouldn't approve.

"Things were different back then," Sherman-Palladino said. "The networks were very different in how permissive they would allow you to be. So, Sookie was originally supposed to be gay, but that was a non-starter at that time."

Although she has said the show couldn't exist today, if it had started a bit later, things might have been different.

"It changed so quickly," she said. "By the time 'Gilmore' had been on a year or two, that shit was starting to drop right and left. But by that point, Sookie was in a relationship. It was really right at the cusp of when things were starting to turn. You know, today everyone would be gay. Lorelai would be gay!"

Lauren Duca is currently covering the ATX Television Festival for The Huffington Post. Follow her on Twitter @laurenduca and expect much more to come!

  • Season 1, Episode 1: "Pilot"
    The WB
    We meet Lorelai, we meet Rory, we get introduced to Stars Hollow. No matter how well you think you know "Gilmore Girls," you can't get away with not re-watching the pilot episode.
  • Season 1, Episode 7: "Kiss And Tell”
    The WB
    Rory's first kiss with the tall, dark and handsome Dean. Need we say more?
  • Season 1, Episode 17: "The Breakup, Part 2”
    The WB
    Because Rory's heartbreak is so relatable that it breaks the heart of every "Gilmore Girls" fan. She will not wallow!
  • Season 2, Episode 1: "Sadie, Sadie”
    The WB
    In "Sadie, Sadie," Lorelai gets engaged to Rory's teacher, Max. Scandalous.
  • Season 2, Episode 9: "Run Away, Little Boy”
    The WB
    Here, we get one of our first hints that Rory may have a future with bad boys. Tristan (Chad Michael Murray) is super into her, and Dean does not like it.
  • Season 2, Episode 19: "Teach Me Tonight”
    The WB
    Why hello there, Jess! We see Rory get herself into quite a bit of trouble when she attempts to tutor Luke's nephew. Broken bones, crashed cars ... it's not pretty, but it's certainly thrilling.
  • Season 3, Episode 7: "They Shoot Gilmores, Don't They?”
    The WB
    This episode is mostly great because it involves a Stars Hollow Dance Marathon. Even better, a ton of drama happens on the dance floor ... like when Dean announces that Rory's into Jess and dumps her.
  • Season 3, Episode 9: "A Deep-Fried Korean Thanksgiving”
    The WB
    First of all, fall in Stars Hollow is magical. But also, watching Lorelai and Rory bounce from Thanksgiving dinner to Thanksgiving dinner is hilarious ... and further proves that the mother-daughter duo are bottomless pits.
  • Season 3, Episode 16: "The Big One”
    The WB
    Rory was supposed to go to Harvard, right? Wrong. In "The Big One," Rory gets accepted to Harvard, Princeton and Yale, and her good friend Paris humiliates her on live television.
  • Season 3, Episode 20: "Say Goodnight, Gracie"
    The WB
    More Jess drama! He's nothing but trouble; Rory loves him so much, and it's heartbreaking. Also, Dean gets engaged. Rough.
  • Season 4, Episode 2: "The Lorelais' First Day at Yale”
    The WB
    Going away to college is tough. Just ask anyone who's done it. It's even tougher when your mom is your best friend, so this episode is obviously an emotional (and great) one.
  • Season 4, Episode 22: "Raincoats and Recipes"
    The WB
    Rory loses her virginity! And not to whom you'd expect.
  • Season 5, Episode 3: "Written in the Stars”
    The WB
    Luke and Lorelai, together at last!
  • Season 5, Episode 22: "A House Is Not a Home”
    The WB
    Rory goes to jail thanks to a little adventure she went on with her latest flame, Logan. Oof.
  • Season 6, Episode 18: "The Real Paul Anka”
    The WB
    This is Jess' final appearance. And no true "Gilmore Girls" fan ever stopped missing him.
  • Season 7, Episode 7: "French Twist"
    The CW
    Sorry Luke, but Christopher made his move in a big way in this episode ... by proposing to and marrying Lorelai in Paris. Talk about sweeping a girl off her feet!
  • Season 7, Episode 21: "Unto the Breach”
    The CW
    Although her mother has had a couple marriage proposals, this is Rory's first. And she says she has to think about it! Such an independent woman.
  • Season 7, Episode 22: "Bon Voyage”
    The CW
    It goes without saying that the "Gilmore Girls" season finale is a must-see, but this is especially true because Rory ran off to work for Obama before Obama was really a thing, and Lorelai and Luke look like they're going to get back together. Phew!
Suggest a correction