CRIME

Family Flees New House Over Creepy Letters From 'The Watcher,' Sues Prior Owners

06/24/2015 05:07 pm ET | Updated Jun 29, 2015

It sounds like a plot ripped straight out of a horror film, but for one family and their three young kids, the anonymous man who referred to himself as "The Watcher" and sent terrifying letters about the new house they moved into is decidedly real.

A Westfield, New Jersey, family has filed suit against the previous owners of the six-bedroom home they purchased for $1.3 million, arguing in a court filing earlier this month that they "knowingly and willfully failed to disclose" the home's history -- namely, that it was the focus of "The Watcher," an individual with a "mentally disturbed fixation and claim to possession and/or ownership of the home."

The first of the letters arrived on June 5, 2014, less than a week after the family moved into the house, according to Courthouse News.

The letter informed the buyers their house "has been the subject of my family for decades," and that the writer had been "put in charge of watching and waiting for its second coming."

"Why are you here? I will find out," the letter read. "I asked the [previous owners] to bring me young blood ... once I know their names, I will call to them and draw them too [sic] me."

Additional letters, sent in following months, grew more threatening and ominous.

"I am pleased to know your names now and the name of the young blood you have brought to me," one allegedly said. "Who has the bedrooms facing the street? I'll know as soon as you move in ... it will help me to know who is in which bedroom, then I can plan better."

One letter asked, "Have they found out what’s in the walls yet?"

When the alleged stalker's identity couldn't immediately be resolved by police, the family vacated the property and sued the prior owners.

"Our police department conducted an exhaustive investigation based on the factual circumstances and evidence available," Westfield Mayor Andy Skibitsky told CBS2 at a town hall meeting on Tuesday. The station said no charges have been filed in the case.

The couple attempted to sell the house multiple times, NJ.com reported, but the would-be buyers all backed out after learning of the letters.

Also on HuffPost:

  • Michigan
    In 1941, The Haught Mansion (Brush Park, MI) was used as a brothel for upscale gentlemen. Years later several dead bodies were found in the cellar of the mansion. Each body had been marked by a what appeared to be a perfect circle on the torso and chest areas.
  • Kentucky
    So the story goes, after both parents committed double suicide in the Sayer House their four small children raised themselves for more than a decade in this home.
  • Ohio
    The Nova House (Youngstown, Ohio) was the place where Benjamin Albright shot and killed his son by accident then killed himself and his wife after being struck with anguish and guilt in 1958. The home has been vacant ever since and still has personal belongings inside.
  • Michigan
    The Temple Haunted Mansion (Detroit, MI) was the home of a triple murder that took place in August 1942.
  • Texas
    The Hooley Haunted Mansion was home to several strange deaths throughout the 1970s when the mansion served as a bed and breakfast for passing transients.
  • Ohio
    The Milan Mansion has long been suspected as a home of witchcraft. The owner was a practicing witch known by locals as the Milan Witch, and is said to be buried underneath front porch.
  • Pennsyvania
    The Doll House Mansion (Philadelphia, PA) is an abandoned mansion full of nothing but dolls and organized metal saws and tools neatly displayed on metal shelves through out several rooms.
  • Connecticut
    The Bailey Mansion (Hartford, Connecticut) is the haunted house that inspired the popular television series "American Horror Story."
  • Ohio
    This Cleveland home was where serial killer Michael Madison toutured and killed his victims.
  • Pennsylvania
    This is the Oliver Family Mansion in Chester, PA. The Oliver family went missing in 1898. The mystery baffled investigators and the family was never found but locals say they can see them in the windows of the mansion.
  • Ohio
    This is the Akron childhood home of one of the most notorious serial killers in American history, Robert Berdella (also known as the Butcher of Kansas City). In his prison psychiatric profile, Berdella spoke of his rough childhood in Ohio. Specifically, he mentioned his rape at age 16, an act that triggered his desire to move to Kansas City, and kill off everybody in the sex industry in the process.
  • New York
    The Cater House Estates in Buffalo, New York was home to the local sheriff Donald Caters when he shot himself. The home went into foreclosure in 1968. The house remained vacant and haunted ever since with locals alleging they hear voices coming from the house regularly.
  • Ohio
    This abandoned house in East Cleveland is where Serial killer Anthony Sowell hid victims' bodies. The house is now demolished but locals would cross the street refusing to walk on the sidewalk directly in front of the house claiming that the home made noises.
  • Wisconsin
    The Tillmore House
Suggest a correction
138 Comments

CONVERSATIONS