China Earthquake: Death Toll Could Reach 50,000, Says State TV

stumble digg reddit del.ico.us news trust

WILLIAM FOREMAN | May 15, 2008 11:37 PM EST | AP

Compare other versions »

Show your support.
Buzz this article up.
Rescue workers carry an earthquake victim evacuated by boat from Yingxiu to the Zipingpu Dam as roads are still inaccessible near Dujiangyan, southwestern China's Sichuan province, Thursday, May 15, 2008. China warned the death toll from this week's earthquake could soar to 50,000, while the government issued a rare public appeal Thursday for rescue equipment as it struggled to cope with the disaster. (AP Photo/Ng Han Guan)

LUOSHUI TOWN, China — Troops dug burial pits in this quake-shattered town and black smoke poured from crematorium chimneys elsewhere in central China as priorities began shifting Thursday from the hunt for survivors to dealing with the dead. Officials said the final toll could more than double to 50,000.

As the massive military-led recovery operation inched farther into regions cut off by Monday's quake, the government sought to enlist the public's help with an appeal for everything from hammers to cranes and, in a turnabout, began accepting foreign aid missions, the first from regional rival Japan.

Millions of survivors left homeless or too terrified to go indoors faced their fourth night under tarpaulins, tents or nothing at all as workers patched roads and cleared debris to reach more outlying towns in the disaster zone.

On Friday, Chinese President Hu Jintao flew to Sichuan to support victims and express "appreciation to the public and cadres in the disaster zone," the Xinhua said.

State media said that rescuers had finally reached all 58 counties and townships severely damaged.

Health officials said there have been no outbreaks of disease so far, with workers rushing to inoculate survivors against disease, supply them with drinking water, and find ways to dispose of an overwhelming number of corpses.

"There are still bodies in the hills, and pits are being dug to bury them," said Zhao Xiaoli, a nurse in the ruined town of Hanwang. "There's no way to bring them down. It's too dangerous."

But the ministry said on its Web site that to prevent disease, bodies should be cleaned on the spot and buried as soon as possible.

Troops in the town of Luoshui in a quake-ravaged area used a mechanical shovel to dig a pit on a hilltop. Two bodies wrapped in white sheets lay beside it. Down the hill sat four mounds of lime.

In a sign of nervousness, 50 troops lined the road outside Luoshui. Five farmers watched them dig the burial pit, after performing brief funerary rites. Local police detained an Associated Press reporter and photographer who took photos of the scene, holding them in a government compound for 3 1/2 hours before releasing them without explanation.

Across the quake zone in Dujiangyan, troops in face masks collected corpses and loaded them onto a flatbed truck. Thick black smoke streamed from the twin chimneys of the town's crematorium.

Fears about damage to a major dam in the quake zone appeared to ease. The Zipingpu dam had reportedly suffered cracks from the disaster, but there was no repair work or extra security at the dam when it was reached Thursday by an AP photographer, indicating the threat to the structure had likely passed.

People trying to hike into Wenchuan walked on top of the dam as water spilled from an outlet, lowering levels in the reservoir and alleviating pressure on the dam.

Just behind the dam, soldiers set up a staging area preparing speed boats to lower into the reservoir and ferry soldiers in lifejackets, engineers and medical staff up river to Yingxiu, a town flattened by the quake.

The government says "the dam will hold, but then the longer-term question is what to do with it _ to keep it or dismantle it," said Andrew Mertha of Washington University in St. Louis, author of a book on Chinese dams, "China's Water Warriors: Citizen Action and Policy Change,"

The emergency headquarters of the State Council, China's Cabinet, said the confirmed death toll had reached 19,509 _ up more than 4,500 from the day before. The council said deaths could rise to 50,000, state media reported.

The provincial government said more than 12,300 remained buried and another 102,100 were injured in Sichuan, where the quake was centered.

Experts said hope was quickly fading for anyone still caught in the wreckage of homes, schools, offices and factories that collapsed in the magnitude-7.9 quake, the most powerful in three decades in quake-prone China.

"Generally speaking, anyone buried in an earthquake can survive without water and food for three days," said Gu Linsheng, a researcher with Tsinghua University's Emergency Management Research Center. "After that, it's usually a miracle for anyone to survive."

Amazing survival stories did emerge, and were seized on by Chinese media whose blanket coverage has been dominated by images of carnage.

In Dujiangyan, a 22-year-old woman was pulled to safety after more than three days trapped under debris. Covered in dust and peering out through a small opening, she waved and was interviewed by state television as hard-hatted rescuers worked to free her.

"I was confident that you were coming to rescue me. I'm alive. I'm so happy," the unnamed woman said on CCTV.

Premier Wen Jiabao, who has been in the quake zone since Monday, urged those helping the injured to keep up their efforts. Repeating a phrase that has become a government mantra this week, Vice Health Minister Gao Qiang said every effort would be made to find survivors.

"We will never give up hope," Gao told reporters in Beijing. "For every thread of hope, our efforts will increase a hundredfold. We will never give up."

With more than 130,000 soldiers and police mobilized in the relief effort, roads were cleared Thursday to two key areas that took the brunt of the quake, with workers making it to Wenchuan at the epicenter and also through to Beichuan county, the Xinhua News Agency reported. Communication cables were also reconnected to Wenchuan.

Power was restored to most of Sichuan for the first time since the quake, although Beichuan county remained without electricity, Xinhua said.

Much of the official publicity dwelled on efforts to reach the trapped but actual ground operations focused on delivering food and medical aid to survivors and disposing of the dead.

In Dujiangyan, on the road between the provincial capital of Chengdu and the epicenter, a dozen bodies lay on a sidewalk as police and militia pulverized rubble with cranes and back hoes. The bodies were later lifted onto a flatbed truck, joining some half-dozen corpses.

The government said it had allocated $772 million for earthquake relief, according to the central bank's Web site. That is up sharply from the figure of $159 million two days ago.

At the crematorium, some grieving relatives were rushed through funeral rites by harried workers. Scores of bodies lay on concrete in a waiting area _ outnumbering the handful of chapels usually used in funerals.

Thick black smoke streamed from the crematorium's pair of chimneys as families cleaned and dressed the dead in funeral clothes, including fresh socks and sneakers for children.

Fireworks were set off every few minutes and families burned incense, candles and spirit money. Such traditions meant to send the dead peacefully into the afterlife were once banned by the communist authorities but have revived in recent years with free-market reforms and rising prosperity. Burial, which likewise the government once tried to stamp out, has become common in the countryside, although still difficult for people in crowded cities.

In an appeal posted on its Web site, the Ministry of Information Industry called on the Chinese to donate rescue equipment including hammers, shovels, demolition tools and rubber boats _ 100 cranes were also needed, it said.

The International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies has also issued an emergency appeal for medical help, food, water and tents.

After initially refusing offers of foreign aid workers, China welcomed a Japanese rescue team. Made up of firefighters, police, coast guard and aid officials, the first half of the team arrived in Beijing on Thursday and would head to the disaster area Friday, Xinhua said.

Japan and China have been at odds for years over disputed borders, Japan's treatment of its wartime invasion of China, anti-Japanese protests in China, and general Japanese unease over Beijing's rapidly growing diplomatic, military and economic power. Leaders of the two countries met in Tokyo earlier this month to try to resolve their differences.

The Foreign Ministry said Russian, South Korean and Singaporean teams would join soon.

China had so far received international aid worth more than $100 million and materials worth more than $10 million, Foreign Ministry spokesman Qin Gang said at a briefing. But it still needed supplies of tents, clothes, communication equipment, machines for disaster relief, and medicines, he said.

"The Chinese authorities have done a fantastic job mobilizing troops, but troops are not everything. You need specialist teams with equipment otherwise you're not going to find them," said John Holland, operations director of Rapid UK, a search and rescue charity with two decades of experience handling international disasters.

___

Associated Press writers Audra Ang in Mianyang, Christopher Bodeen in Dujiangyan, and Cara Anna and Anita Chang in Beijing contributed to this report.

 
 

Comments
55
Pending Comments
0

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:

This is a remote impoverished area and human beings are suffering greatly. As an American in China I hope my friends here do not see some of the posts here. I guess if we are going to judge people by their government some of these comments reflect our government pretty well---a bunch of heartless assholes!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:40 AM on 05/16/2008

Suffering is what suffering does. As long as there is clinging to the flesh, there is suffering. You should see what the Chinese did to the TIbetan. This earthquake is "god send", by the Will of Heaven, there will be more.

Bodhiratna

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:26 AM on 05/18/2008

"This is a remote impoverished area and human beings are suffering greatly. As an American in China I hope my friends here do not see some of the posts here. I guess if we are going to judge people by their government some of these comments reflect our government pretty well"

Everything is interconnected, dude. You said the area is "remote impoverished area", well then we know you CAN NOT be impoverished and have tall building in CHINA! you must be kidding?

"a bunch of heartless assholes!"

Well, stay in China and you should be grateful that the earthquake has not crushed you YET. True compassion has no pity for the flesh! After all those people were bunch of living corpse, now they really "die" so what?

Bodhiratna

Bodhiratna

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:23 AM on 05/18/2008

Most of religious zealots are abysmal fools.
I thought Buddhism mostly avoided this paradigm... until I read the comments of BodhiRaTna.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:20 AM on 05/18/2008

What makes you think he's Buddhist? Seems like nothing but someone trying to sound like they're a Buddhist but in reality nothing more than a hateful bigot.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:47 PM on 05/18/2008

For all the might and muscle that China flexes now, they can't even deal with an earthquake. The US dealt with a few if i remember correctly. From 1906 to 1989. Never, and I mean never have thousands of people die like this. My advice to China would be to stop building your army for an imaginary future war against america and taiwan and fix the infrastructure of your country. This is what happens when you pack hundreds and hundreds of people in small spaces. China wont help the US out so I say we let them float for a bit. Maybe we can now bring some of those jobs back here that we lost because they pay their people like a bunch of slaves.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:17 PM on 05/15/2008

Clearly ignorant comment, when Katrina hit China donated $5million in cash and $2million in supplies. What has the administration thus far donated to China? $500,000 in cash. The wealthiest and most powerful nation in the world donates a measly $500K. Granted that is only an initial amount. China is the most populous nation in the world, the US is not that is why should a large natural disaster strike anywhere in china you're going to have massive casualties. On the other hand this was a 7.9 earthquake that struck during the afternoon when everyone is out and about. Ask any geologist of how that translates to the worst possible timing that relates to the highest death toll, when everyone is out and working or in school.
Loss of jobs to China, who's at fault there? Did chinese companies bribe US companies to move over there? No it's how capitalism works and the profit from producing there is far more than it would be producing here. Why don't companies produce domestically, that's for another topic but I'll give you a hint - union overhead costs.
Your comment is nothing but hateful and bigotry towards something that you're obviously ignorant of and worse yet you don't care to find out.
Quite sad

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:54 PM on 05/18/2008

I agree, you seem to have the most intelligent assessment of the whole situation. You look at the situation with impartial, but fair mind.

Bodhiratna

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:25 PM on 05/17/2008

*

bkholmes79
=============

You are an Arrogant, Selfish, Unhuman ................ and the list goes on.

Shame on you and your way of thinking.

*

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:35 AM on 05/16/2008

Ms. Holmes-

You are so delusional I do not know where to begin?

I and my ancestors are from America. I have not a drop of Asian blood in me. Yet you would like to believe I am squatting in some corner with my bowl of rice?

As others have pointed out to you......China DID help the victims of Katrina. I flew back from China to lead a benefit that raised $5 million to aid the victims, myself.

You forgot to add GWB to your list of leaders that "murdered" innocent civilians.

I also was present in California for Whittier, Loma Linda and Northridge and have felt the extreme power of the earth moving.

You are just a hate spewing hack with little education on the subjects in your line of sight. Admit it.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:46 PM on 05/15/2008

Im not ashamed of myself one bit. I unlike yourself and half of the people on Huffpo am very proud of my country and the way it treats the majority of its citizens. Are there instances when the govt is wrong? YES. 100%, but this country is always first up to the plate when disaster strikes. In the case of China though I think we need to play it different. They're a legitimate superpower. They are actively working to undermine the US in all parts of the world. They threaten Taiwan, an ally of ours everyday. They also are always a roadblock to getting anything accomplished in the U.N. They are building underwater nuclear bases for pete's sake and you're telling me that they need our help because they crammed 1,000,000 people in small, dingy, hazardous buildings and the US should bail them out? NO NO NO. Let the Chinese govt and people step up to bat on this one. This summer is supposed to be the "coming out" party for China where they show the world how far they've come. WELL, they cant even provide disaster relief for their fellow countrymen. I guess i should be ashamed of myself for telling it how it is. Poor me.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:22 PM on 05/15/2008

Your assessment is correct, Bravo@! at least you are thinking straight unlike most people who are like a drunk asking money for alcohol. No pity, that is compassion. It teaches them by creating calamity like this and teach them NOT to cling to the flesh and to go to the spirit!

Bodhiratna

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:09 PM on 05/17/2008

I don't disagree with your assessment of the actions of the Chinese government, but unlike the United States, in China the government is not the people. I don't blame the people there for the actions of their authoritarian government. I especially don't blame the children. You can express your distaste for the Chinese government without dismissing the suffering of the earthquake victims.

You say, "[T]hey cant even provide disaster relief for their fellow countrymen." I suppose you think our government did a bang-up job of preparing for and responding to Katrina.

And who says I'm not proud of my country? I'm just sorry that we have people like you.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:49 AM on 05/16/2008

They have been around 5000 years. America about 250 years.

Any bets who will STILL be around in say 200 years?

They have survived this long for a reason.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:06 PM on 05/15/2008

This was a very large earthquake. The US has been very fortunate not to have had an earthquake this big since 1964 (in Alaska). The Pacific Northwest and LA could see even bigger earthquakes than this one. These could cause an enormous amount suffering, damage and death as the many brick buildings fall down and the steep slopes slide on the building covered hills. It is true that there was much poor construction in China that lead to collapse, but it is difficult to design buildings to survive these very big earthquakes because the shaking goes on for such a long interval (three minutes?). We should also remember that China was very poor until very recently. Since the economy has prospered, the Chinese have invested huge resources into earthquake research and response.

The Northridge and Loma Prieta earthquakes did a lot of damage in California despite being much smaller than this one. Some large buildings were close to failure and would have collapsed if the shaking had continued longer. A veterans hospital collapsed during Northridge.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:09 PM on 05/15/2008

Shanghaislim---I might be a class A jerkoff, but the fact remians that China did nothing for us during hurricane katrina. China is an oppressive regime whose "godfather" (mao) is responsible for the deaths of 50 million people. That puts him up there with Hitler and Stalin. Show me evidence of China offering any aid during katrina and I might change my mind. Until then, you can take your allegiance back to China. I think we all know where your ancestors are from.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:51 PM on 05/15/2008

Didn't even accept help from cuba..why would USA accept from china..(oh..)

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:59 AM on 05/16/2008

China gived five million USD worth of aid to Katrina victims, Now The United States government payed that back today to China by giving just $500,000 ( five hundred thousand ) USD for earthquake victims. Please don't be jealous that China did more for their citizens then the government did for Katrina.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:18 PM on 05/15/2008

Your hatred and anger are sad and disappointing. Again, the aid is meant to help the people of China, not the government. Yes, they are a brutal and oppressive regime, but they are not the topic here. The suffering victims of the earthquake are, and they need help, regardless of where they live. Even if we Americans should never expect help in return.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:05 PM on 05/15/2008

We the USA shouldn't do anything for them. They're big boys. They have an army and some emergency rescue teams. They walk and talk like a superpower, so now it's time to be one. Awwww, Poor China. They undermine The United States, They abuse their citizens and they have no respect for anyone but themselves. When they're ready to cooperate with America on a personal level instead of only business then we can send some aid. When was the last time they came to our aid? Oh right, I forgot they're on the side of Iran. Good luck boys.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:23 PM on 05/15/2008

The children crushed in the rubble aren't big boys. This isn't about politics; it's about ordinary people suffering.

You should be ashamed of yourself.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:37 PM on 05/15/2008

Why should he be ashamed of himself? he did not kill those people, the careless builders did! so what if the children are crushed. You shot deer, do you care if mama deer does not come home to her baby deers? stop being a hypocrite! most redneck like yourself is playing the guilt game, but they don't think too well. Too bad, that is their inclination and there is nothing you can do about it, LOL

Bodhiratna

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:26 PM on 05/17/2008

China offered relief and help during Hurricane Katrina.

They can do this by themselves.

But you sir are a class A-1 jerkoff.

Good luck with that.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:37 PM on 05/15/2008

Show a link that says the Chinese, especially the government of China that helped the Katrina victim! Or you are just a liar?

Bodhiratna

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:24 PM on 05/17/2008

I think we should provide aid, because the issues you mention are with the Chinese government, not its people. Its the people that are suffering today, and they deserve the help of all nations, including the U.S. That's the compassionate thing to do.

Just because the Chinese government would not come to the aid of Americans does not mean that we should behave the same way. Two wrongs don't make a right. Love your enemies as your brother, and do not repay evil with evil.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:34 PM on 05/15/2008

The US needs to use this opportunity to demonstrate its ability to help with a major disaster relief effort coordinated from the US fleet nearest to the disaster. As one who was in Mianyang and Chengdu only 2 months ago,I believe the people there would respond with gratitude that would benefit our international relations with Asia.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:17 PM on 05/15/2008

China is asking for help and showing images of quake damage on TV. This is a big shift from the once reclusive China. Major sea change in how China is being run.
Hope they get the aide.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:26 PM on 05/15/2008

This is sad beyond words, a tragic degree of loss and human suffering. We must do what we can to help our brothers and sisters in Asia.

But I hope that you will also do this, today, or as soon as possible: Prepare yourself and your family for an emergency.

For most Americans, it's not a matter of if, but a matter of when, until there is an earthquake, storm, etc., in your area.

The sad truth is that our Nation is not prepared to deal with disaster either, as was demonstrated in the wake of Hurricane Katrina. And don't count on the government to help, because you will be sadly disappointed.

Set aside enough supplies to get you and your family through a minimum of 3 days, a week, a month, or more would be even better. It doesn't cost that much to do, just pick up a few extra things to set aside, buy some extra food, water, and other necesary supplies each week until you have enough to get you through an emergency. And then just keep rotating these items in and out so nothing is wasted but you always have what you will need in an emergency.

And when the worst happens, do what you can for your neighbors and community. We are all in the same boat here, and we have to pull together, especially in difficult times.

Shalom to all.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:00 PM on 05/15/2008

Well said! There is almost always an outcry against the government when disasters happen, as if citizens' entire welfare and survival after such events is entirely dependent on the government.

While we expect our government to come to our aid to some degree after such disasters (the failure of which was painfully evident after Hurricane Katrina), ultimately, as you accurately pointed out, we must keep ourselves prepared and vigilant at all times, and be ready to helps ourselves and our neighbors. Doing so will provide faster "first aid" during problem times and foster more brotherhood and strengthen the community, than just sitting still and waiting for the government to come rescue us.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:09 PM on 05/15/2008

"Premier Wen Jiabao visited Qingchuan in northern Sichuan province, site of a collapsed school that buried dozens of children, to encourage doctors and nurses aiding the injured. "The party and the government are grateful to you. The people need you," he said in footage shown on CCTV. "They see you as a relative. Every act and word of yours represents the government."

In 1976 an earthquake struck Tangshan in China; 255,000 people officially died. However, it is thought that over twice that amount of people actually did die. We cannot yet predict earthquakes but we can build safer housing if the goal is to support the population. The subsequent earthquakes in the 30 years since 1976 should have reinforced this concern to the Chinese Government. The sorrow experienced by just one untimely, unnatural death overwhelmingly subdues the human spirit. The Chinese people are malleable to the suggestion of the Chinese Government.

We, as citizens, must learn from this.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:27 PM on 05/15/2008

We should do as much as possible for the Chinese victims. 50,000 dead is horrible, but what about the 10,000 dead ( high count) in Tianamian Square. I know it's history, but it's the same government. I know it doesn't matter because to the Chinese because they weren't productive workers or something, but I thought the whole purpose of the U.S. of A. was to spread democracy. We have no moral authority.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 01:17 PM on 05/15/2008

If the USA had given Katrina victims a third of the attention other countries are getting...

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:24 PM on 05/15/2008

Despite our general misgivings and dislike for China's regime, what with the Tibetan oppression, dismal human rights and "justice" system, massive military buildup, etc., I think we could agree that this crisis transcends all that. There are innocent people dying and suffering from this, so regardless of how we feel about the government in China, our sympathy is real for the people of China.
And previous comments about this earthquake wiping out a portion of China's over-population, "thinning the herd" so to speak, are hateful and counterproductive. We should react with more kindness than that. A plurality of people does not diminish the value of a single human life.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:12 PM on 05/15/2008

+1

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:28 PM on 05/15/2008