Is Wright Right About Racism?

Posted March 28, 2008 | 01:52 PM (EST)



stumble digg reddit del.ico.us news trust

Is Jeremiah Wright right about racism? There, I asked the question - a question that should be at the center of the "controversy" surrounding Barack Obama's former pastor, but which has been completely ignored. Somewhere deep down, I am guessing Wright feels some shred of vindication, because the entire "controversy" surrounding him now answers that question resoundingly. As I discuss in my newspaper column out today, Wright has become the latest target of the media lynch mob - and in becoming that target, he has proven his very assertions about the persistence of racism in our culture.

There are some things Wright has said that I strongly disagree with, and I certainly may disagree with more of his statements that come to light in the future. However, as the column shows, the specific statements at the center of the Wright "controversy" today are rooted in undeniable fact. Yes, there is a black community in America - and acknowledging that does not make one a "black separatist." Yes, terrorist attacks are often the product of what our own government calls "blowback" - even if that "blowback" is undeserved, criminal and immoral. And yes, bigotry is still a powerful force in American culture - and our society would do well to understand that bigotry makes African-Americans unhappy. As archconservative Mike Huckabee (R) said, "I grew up in a very segregated South and I think that you have to cut some slack...we've gotta cut some slack to people who grew up being called names."

But the intolerance the media lynch mob has shown toward Wright - and the tolerance the same media has shown toward the real extremists around John McCain and Hillary Clinton - is a telling double standard proving Wright's fundamental thesis correct. While Wright has dominated the news, anti-Catholic pastor John Hagee and anti-Semitic Reverend Billy Graham have received scant attention for their close relationships with McCain and Clinton, respectively. The Serious Media have followed modern day Bull Connors like Sean Hannity, Pat Buchanan and Charles Krauthammer into the ugliest gutter - the gutter of racial politics. And these three racist lynch mob leaders will undoubtedly retain their perches on cable networks and on the op-ed pages of Serious Newspapers. They will continue championing what one expert calls "colorblind racism" - the kind of racism that hides itself in platitudes against racism and extremism itself.

Clinton, of course, has fueled the fire. Just this week, she granted an interview to the fringe right-wing Pittsburgh Tribune Review - the tiny newspaper owned by the same Richard Mellon Scaife who financed Republicans' anti-Clinton infrastructure in the 1990s. Clinton used the interview to specifically stoke the Wright "controversy" ahead of Pennsylvania's primary. Her much-vaunted political "firewall" that she says will stop Obama has very clearly become a "race wall" (more on this in a new In These Times article set for release on Monday).

This was a very difficult column to write. It took a long time to craft, because racial and foreign policy taboos (especially those that question American exceptionalism) are such sensitive topics - and I've gotten some hate email already this morning. But I'm glad I wrote this. With so much of the well-heeled, white Establishment simultaneously preening around like they oppose racism while pushing this story in a fundamentally racist way, I felt it was important to make the basic point that started out this post. And that is, again: This whole "controversy" has confirmed Wright's fundamental assertion that our culture is still deeply afflicted by bigotry. If the media is a mirror reflecting what we as a society consider acceptable and unacceptable, then that mirror is right now telling us just how powerful racism still is in American life.


You can listen to my discussion about the column on Colorado radio this morning here. Or, read the whole column at Creators, Credo Action, The Denver Post, The Vail Daily, The Ft. Collins Coloradoan, In These Times, TruthDig or Alternet. The column relies on grassroots support, so if you'd like to see my column regularly in your local paper, use this directory to find the contact info for your local editorial page editors. Get get in touch with them and point them to my Creators Syndicate site. Thanks, as always, for your ongoing readership and help contacting local editors. This column couldn't be what it is without your help.


 
 

Comments
220
Pending Comments
0

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
Page: 1 2 3 4 Next › Last » (4 pages total)

The best way to combat the Fox and MSNBC new that you find so distateful is to not watch it. The ratings are what drive their shows. If you vote whenever you can, and you use your pocektbook and your television viewing to send a message to the corporate world, you can change the world. Stop watching the bullshit and you won't have to hear it.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:37 PM on 03/30/2008

Yes!

Turn off the crap!

They don't call it "programming" for nothing.

there are 5 sources that do not follow the MSM War Profiteering agenda:

Daily Show, Colbert, Olberman, NOW, Air America.

Then if you want fact, go online.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:16 PM on 03/30/2008

Regarding the myth on HIV?AIDS some data on where such myth is rooted....

Medical Apartheid is the first and only comprehensive history of medical experimentation on African Americans. Starting with the earliest encounters between black Americans and Western medical researchers and the racist pseudoscience that resulted, it details the ways both slaves and freedmen were used in hospitals for experiments conducted without their knowledge"a tradition that continues today within some black populations. It reveals how blacks have historically been prey to grave-robbing as well as unauthorized autopsies and dissections. Moving into the twentieth century, it shows how the pseudoscience of eugenics and social Darwinism was used to justify experimental exploitation and shoddy medical treatment of blacks, and the view that they were biologically inferior, oversexed, and unfit for adult responsibilities. Shocking new details about the government"s notorious Tuskegee experiment are revealed, as are similar, less-well-known medical atrocities conducted by the government, the armed forces, prisons, and private institutions.

http://www.s193082824.onlinehome.us/

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:36 PM on 03/30/2008

Considering Rev Wright was preaching - "God will damn America if she thinks she is God" it is obvious politicians are attacking him out of context confirming some of his rhetoric to be true..

Last Americans rushed to read Noam Chomsky's book "Hegemony or Survival"
" the repression of other nations' citizenry is, in fact, the very reason Americans support certain foreign leaders. The charges made throughout the book are severe, as are the dire consequences he posts if current trends are maintained"
American foreign policy simply the continuation of a consistent half-century of foreign policy-an "imperial grand strategy"-in which the United States has attempted to "maintain its hegemony through the threat or use of military force." but Chomsky builds his arguments carefully, substantiates claims with appropriate documentation and answers expected counterclaims. Chomsky is also deeply critical of inconsistency in making the charge of "terrorism." Using the official U.S. legal code definition of terrorism, he argues that it is an exact description of U.S. foreign policy (especially regarding Cuba, Central America, Vietnam and much of the Middle East),

There has never been any uproar about Chomsky who is by far a more influential figure than Rev will ever be, instead he is a distinguished Prof of MIT.

Neither the media, nor Pat Buchanan will of course not engage either Chomsky or Michael Moore -(Stupid White Men), on any of the issues raised by Rev Wright. One wonders why.....

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:58 PM on 03/30/2008

Yes, thank you for this post. It is by far the best analysis of the race issue by a journalist that I have read.

It turns my stomach that The Clintons are stoking the fires of racism in their campaign. I look at Maggie Williams and wonder how she can continue to work for them. She has to be a hugely cynical woman to support them even if she is getting paid. I used to defend them when my republican mother, who had friends from Arkansas, would shake her head and say, "you just don't know". And I didn't know then. There was so much right wingnut noise that I simply couldn't hear the real Clintons. I can hear them now, though, and it's not just the race baiting that shows them for what they are.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:47 PM on 03/30/2008

what CNN, Fox and MSNBC did to Rev. Wright, along with New Gingrich with his newsletter
(who is the origin of Barack Obama sitting in church for 20 years soaking up Wright's hate), and Rush
Limbaugh with his hate talk on radio, is as close to a black lynching we you can get without actually
tying the rope.

Racist bigots

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:44 PM on 03/30/2008

Comment on Sen. Obama's acceptance of Rev. Wright is overwhelmingly and irrationally centered on a single, arguable phrase. It would be more useful going forward to address Wright's participation in the HIV/AIDS conspiracy theory, which, according to Rand, has had a demonstrable effect on the community.

A 2005 Rand study found that due to the accompanying distrust of the health care system, "Conspiracy Beliefs Among African Americans Deter Condom Use."
http://rand.org/news/press.05/01.25.html

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:35 PM on 03/30/2008

THE WHOLE GUILT BY ASSOCIATION ARGUMENT IS LUDICROUS. I had a disagreement with my mom the other night. She is a child of God, a great mom, sister and daughter. And sometimes she says the STUPIDEST THINGS. Well the other night she said a whopper. (and i'm sure i have too) In any event, she is still one of my mentors and I love her and she's smart. If i run for office do i need to disavow her? My dad, one of THE most intelligent people I've ever met is also one of my mentors. Sometimes he says the most racists stupidest things (usually after a day of teaching in a particularly bad inner city school). Do I denounce him? What about my pastor who allows gays to be in the ministry? Or what about on of the other ministers at my church who used to be a drug addict? Or what about our President who believes it is fair to put some people in jail for $500 worth of drugs and others have to have $500,000.00 worth of drugs? Or what about other Presidents in our recent history who have turned a blinds eye to the HUGE disparity in the court system/prosecution of people of color? What about them? Perhaps we should reject and denounce the WHOLE STINCKIN' govt for not doing something about the atrocities Native Americans face on the reseravations.

Just a thought...

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:41 AM on 03/30/2008

"Lynch mob," you say.-- An amusing bit of fatuity. Has someone suggested any sort of punishment for the clownish old fool? (Hint: No.) Try to calm yourself enough to see what's up here. The fact that a candidate for president willingly listened to the clown's obloquies for nearly two decades, plus the fact that the candidate's wife sat beside him and apparently absorbed at least a part of her admitted disrespect for her country in the process is a legitimate news story. Still, we've heard enough of it. It showed unequivocally that Barack Obama is not someone we want in the White House. No further reinforcement of that particular one of the vast herd of reasons is necessary. Let Clinton's wife have the stage to emphasize more of the other reasons.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:08 AM on 03/30/2008

Again with the twenty years. Anyone who has seen the entire sermons will realize that what the "old fool" was doing was bringing up the mythology of the black experience, as vividly as possible, and then attempting to put it to rest through faith. It will not play any longer, neither the tapes or the fallacious argument about some seed of hatred being sown, when it is obvious that just the opposite was the purpose of the sermons in question.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:57 AM on 03/30/2008

What I don't understand is why some people expect all people to feel about the US the way they do. More specifically why do YOU think that I or Wright should feel this BLIND love for this country the way you do? How are we going to fix what's wrong with this country if we refuse to admit that anything's wrong? My laundry list of problems with this country does not make me want to necessarily live anywhere else. My laundry list of problems with this country did not stop me from weeping on 9/11. My laundry list of problems with this country did not stop me from wanting revenge on the people who did it. Nevertheless, while I was weeping I knew that we had just received payback for one of the 100 atrocities that our govt NOT ME AND NOT YOU our govt committed in the name of imperialism, arrogance, cultural colonialism. or just plain greed.

AND WRIGHT IS RIGHT. Just like a human being - until this country rights the wrongs it is committing at home and abroad IT WILL NEVER EVER EVER be a Perfect Union. NEVER.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 02:33 AM on 03/30/2008

Urban, read my post, arguing right and wrong is pointless, as you are arguing against deep racial dread. Only the truth of the sermons, that was cut out by Fox, is any repost to the bigot class.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:00 AM on 03/30/2008

THANKS FOR TELLING THE TRUTH!

THANKS FOR TELLING THE TRUTH!

THANKS FOR TELLING THE TRUTH!

AGAIN THANKS FOR TELLING THE TRUTH DAVID SIROTA!!!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 08:57 PM on 03/29/2008

Tavis Smiley on "Real Time with Bill Maher" made a point that needs to be brought up every time this Wright controversy keeps coming up. That is this. That Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. made this statement in April of 1967. King called the United States "the greatest purveyor of violence in the world today." Here is a link to my source.
http://www.fair.org/index.php?page=2269
My point (and Mr. Smiley's) is that lots of people, even American heroes, can be quoted as saying controversial statements that sound anti-American. Does that mean we need to condemn them? I don't think so.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:27 PM on 03/29/2008

A very insightful, articulate and succinct article to date on the Wright issue.
It is very odd, when using 'guilt by association' argument that some people come to think, that, it is valid and plausible. Even identical twins differ in their personality as distinct as two individuals can ever be. How many of us have grown up in a family (from infancy to adulthood) where your parents or siblings have different political and religious views? You spend ~18-20 or so years with them, but yet you can develop your values, ideas and aspirations differently and distinctly.
Wright's MSM 30sec marathon and Obama's speech made it possible for all the likes of Pat Buchanan, C. Krauthammer, & Sean Hannity that have suppressed their deep prejudiced view of race so far, to voice it out over TV. Not only is it clear how distorted their views are but how receptive the general public is to their views.
At least, the voices of moderates and of reason are speaking out -objectively.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:19 PM on 03/29/2008

People,

Google the names of Drs. Boyd E. Graves and Richard Gallo and find out the real history of the HIV/AIDS virus.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 06:10 PM on 03/29/2008

I think a legitimate argument can be made that his central argument is correct. However, his rhetoric is incendiary, his assertions are looney (AIDs, drugs, prisons), and he is now a divisive figure. For Obama, who spoke about the One America, this remains a problem. Wright was the man who married Obama and his wife and baptized the Obama children. He sat in on 20 years worth of these kinds of sermons. His attempts to dodge criticism has only made his situation worse. Wright may be right at heart, but he is wrong in how he makes those arguments.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 05:32 PM on 03/29/2008

Well, it seems Obama is UP in all the polls.... so Sean Hanity and Rush Limbaugh, with your able assistance, didn't get the job done.

That is your problem....the 20 years.... cause if you want to know what Barack Obama was listening to all those years, you have to listen to whole sermons, which will prove you barked cause Sean Hanity said so.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:46 PM on 03/30/2008

Just like the quintessential American, "the gift is good, but the packaging is not perfect, hence I'm not going to accept the gift from the giver". Listen, people have labelled Rev Wright a Racist and tried to tie Obama to his "racist" comments. Yet when asked, what's not true about Statements Rev Wright spoke and they're not able to come up with stuff. The next thing is they talk about his tone.

Just like back in the day, people complained about Malcolm and Martin. Eventually, Martin was humanized and honored, while some segments of society still try to demonize Malcom to this day. It took both Malcom and Martin along with a host of other people of other races to get the civil rights movement going. In this day and age, Rev Wright speaks lile a Malcom, but acts like a Martin. People will rather define him based on his speech, which is a reflection of Malcom, rather than his true deeds which is a reflection of Martin.

Nothing changes the fact that the Rev spoke truth to power. Accept the gift (message of America's misadventures that is hurting us), and look past the gift wrap (the rhetoric that conveyed the message).

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:56 PM on 03/29/2008

do you know for a fact that wright, every sunday (or every other sunday, or every third sunday or even once a month) made "controversial" sermons for 20 years? i'm assuming you don't, unless you, in fact, attend that church. you're spouting the typical media-hyped bullshit line. there's lots of things in the bible, i'm sure wright spoke about quite a few of them w/o making uppity remarks.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:34 PM on 03/29/2008

Thank you! Even the blogs on ABC news have been beating this drum ignoring the other candidates religious affiliations. Doug Coe and the fellowship is a concern that merits a lot closer look due to his overtly political stance on 'power elites,' which Clinton as well as Pol Pot is a part of.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:33 PM on 03/29/2008

Thank you David. I was outraged when I read Pat Buchanan's article and amazed that his opinions are still valued by MSNBC and CNN. There are plenty of other conservatives who are intelligent enough to express their opinions on these programs and are not blatantly racist. According to Pat Buchanan, we rescued the Africans, brought them over on a cruise ship while being wined and dined, and gave them not only a piece of the American pie when they got here, but also gave them Christianity. We saved their lives and their souls at the same time. How generous of us and how ungrateful they are.
I don't believe that Pat Buchanan actually believes the things he wrote. He and Fox news knowingly tell lies to manipulate the less informed or if you will, dumb Americans. Sad but true. If we must take a test to drive a car, graduate from school, and prove our knowledge for acquiring a job, why shouldn't we have to take a test to vote? All Americans should be required to learn the issues and have knowledge about the candidates before casting a vote that will affect the lives of all citizens.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:55 PM on 03/29/2008

I may be wrong but Sirota sounds like an Italian name ... HOw do you respond to looking down your garlic nose ? Sorry Obamaciders , You have done well with the art of Deflection but that game is over.Wright spewed racist, anti american, anti semetic , Italian defamation for 20 years , and you are trying to let it go in the name OBAMA. Ferraro resigned because her fact based comment was not PC.Really , the rationalization by the followers of the cult is nauseating and despicable and is actually teaching the youth of America it is OK as long as it is only towards certain groups, Kind of like the way Bill condoned oral sex .

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:47 PM on 03/29/2008

Wright's statements were based in fact too, people do hate America because of its bombing of other countries.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:36 PM on 03/29/2008

Well, I am Italian and I am not offended at all.
I agree with Sirota's column completely.
Rev. Wright has been wrongly assualted by the media and the likes of a Pat Bechanan who is a racist but no one says anything negative about him. But he can quote all the Catholic rhetoric quite well and that is acceptable?Ah! The double standard of it all!

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:20 PM on 03/29/2008

I notice that you don't like specifics and seem to only spew hyperbole.

On one of your rambles below I said, Wright is not running for any office so he's allowed, via First Amendment, to say what he pleases with apologizing for it. If you're offended, you have a right to tell him so. Or you could just not attend his church (though he is retired so too late for that) or not invite him over for dinner.

Are you a right-wing nut trying to stir up trouble amongst independent thinkers or a Hillary surrogate hoping to bring back a story that is deader than her candidacy?

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:09 PM on 03/29/2008

Here is what our next generation is saying: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r9IldaegAB0 There is something truly amazing happening, which I fear will be jeopardized if Clinton is allowed to carry off her coup. Share this. There is more than thoughtful reflections going on. Obama is already transforming our kids to aspire for more in themselves. I'd hate for Hillary to succeed and have these kids realize our democracy is a sham.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:14 PM on 03/29/2008

Amazing, wonderful video! It's so great to see the young people so inspired.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:36 PM on 03/29/2008

Dear midwestvoter,
What an awsome video!
Thanks for sharing with us.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:36 PM on 03/29/2008

Thanks for posting that video. It brought tears to my eyes listening to those kids speak of hope and a future. Bless that teacher too, for introducing them to the politics of hope. Barack is already making a difference. Just imagine what he'll be able to do when he's president.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:23 PM on 03/29/2008

It's so much more than Wright being right about racism... The media's handling perhaps is the greater story in touching off this unavoidable dialogue and long before the attempted massacre of this man.

In recent weeks it has become difficult for me to watch MSNBC programming featuring Pat Buchanan. Why the NBC Network supports his racially bias rhetoric is incomprehensible, and after he yelled "shut up" to a fellow pundit, a black female, without offering a public apology, his opinions are now intolerable. Thankfully, Rachel Maddow from NPR rebuked him immediately on-air, however Chris Matthews should have insisted he apologize. Are we to believe there is no Republican pundit who can provide an objective Republican view on political issues without unabashedly spewing racist hate?

The dumbing-down of America by exploiting fear and ignorance further weakened us and unfortunately the Clintons willingness to further pierce America where she is weakest, racial bigotry is troublesome. How does any leader justify cashing in on discrimination?

It is common in Christian churches for a pastor to explain bad things as "reaping what we've sown." I've heard the late Jerry Falwell, Pat Robertson and others "damn" America because of its stance on abortion; John Hagee is about the most hateful person I've ever heard speak (Sean, Pat and Rush's mentor?). God help America to get-smart about WE HOLD THESE TRUTHS ... ALL MEN ARE CREATED EQUAL.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:00 PM on 03/29/2008

JFaye, loved your comment. To be clear it was Dan Abrams show where the "SHUT UP" comment was said not Chris Mattews. Dan looked shocked but stayed quiet. I've watched Pat Buchanan have heated debates with several quests on different shows, he never once told anyone to "SHUT UP" because their intelligent response differed from his.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:17 AM on 03/30/2008

Thank you JFaye for those comments, regarding Pastor Wright. I think the media has unfairly characterized this man's whole body of work on a few statements. Why don't some of these Pundits try walking in the shoes of a Black man who has been shaped by the policies in this country during his lifetime. Obama tried to transcend the race issue and say we are all in this together. Geraldine Ferraro wants to make Obama the reason White women have not been able to get ahead in this country by making him the Affirmative Action candidate. I ask you how many White Women are in U. S. Senate and Governors of States versus Black men? It looks to me White Women have been treated pretty good. Your comments about Pat Buchanan are on target. His Peers have tried to reign him in. I have written most of the Political Talk shows on MSNBC to talk about his biases. If more people like yourelf would write to MSNBC, maybe we could get an objective Conservative Analyst on to speak fairly about issues. Because Conservatives believe it or not, there are a lot of us out here who believe in some of things they have to say if it comes from an angle of uplift and not divide the country into blue states and red states. The future of the U. S. A is too important for the next generation to let the Pat Buchanans of the world turn it into mush.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 04:20 PM on 03/29/2008

I thought that what Geraldine Ferraro said was ridiculous because women have benefited from affirmative action as much as anybody. We seem to forget that affirmative action is not just about black people. It's about any group that has been denied a seat at the table and it attempts to even the playing field some. That includes blacks, women, Indians, Hispanics, etc.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:41 PM on 03/29/2008

I feel your pain about MSNBC I find myself turning it off from the consistant racist pushes (And that is more then just Reverand Wright). Its about the only network that even leans toward the middle Fox and CNN are usually even more difficult to watch.

When you look at the media on all 3 networks you can see why things are the way they are. There is so many hosts that are heavy leaning to the right wing politicians. (I say politicians because I think right wing politicians are much different from republican voters cause I think many of them prey on republican issues to fuel their own greed) You can also note the majority of the hosts of the shows or the hours of live coverage are mostly white and many are older (possible alive during segregation being the norm). Sure they have some black analists but I can only think of one black lady that hosts an hour on MSNBC.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 03:11 PM on 03/29/2008