American Idol: David Cook's CD Yanked As He Wows With "Phantom" Song (VIDEO)

David Cook has emerged as favorite in this season of "American Idol" and he's making news in more ways than most. Roger Friedman reports:

American Idol contestant David Cook's album, Analog Heart, is now completely gone from amazon.com's MP3 library.

I told you yesterday that after we discovered it was the number 1 downloaded album on Amazon's service, "American Idol" had it partially pulled. The cover and a listing for it still remained. But as of last night, Analog Heart is gone like it never existed.

But one other current contestant still has an album that can be bought or downloaded. Carly Smithson, nee Hennessy, made a much loved CD in 2001 for Geffen Records, Called "Ultimate High," Smithson/Hennessy's CD was produced by the New Radicals' Gregg Alexander.

On Tuesday's American Idol he wowed the crowd with "Music of the Night" on Andrew Lloyd Webber night.

Watch:

Comments

[PhDiva]

Why do these people already have albums? This show was supposed to be for new artists. It's annoying.

[SharonB]

Jason gives me the creeps.

[americanwomaninpa]

He is adorable.

[Manni]

I like Jason. He is so original. David Cook I think is going to win AI

David A.he is ...hmm. He is kid like.

But I am glad that fraud Carly Shitson is out!

[Manni]

My fav AI moment happened today.

Porky Carly Shitson got voted off!

The loser! LLLLL

:)

Ah ha!

[Manni]

IF you are wondering why I am so happy about this... Well... She is an evil person. thats why.

She is also a liar. She is a plant on the show. The Judges all knew her before. Randy worked with her on her earlier CD that bombed. They tried to hide it before they were outed.

[hardcorebrooklyn]

Why isn't anyone talking about how good Syesha was? She blew the roof off. (And...she looked real hot, too.)

[ZimboChick]

Amen...and she was even better today...at least for me!

[Daniel8168]

Not having heard the song before, I thought David Cook did a great job last night. I've been very surprised by him, and am starting to see him as the one with the best chance to win this whole thing. He just has to woo David Archuletta's teenage girl fan base away, and I'm not sure if he'll be able to do that or not.

[jadez]

do you want to see HOW this song should be sung?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FHLXrDZUwaY

by the Great Russell Watson

[jplass]

why does HuffPo even have an entertainment section? I think we have more important things to talk about...

[observing]

It is possible to care about real news and then soften up life with the fluff. It's called balance.

[SharonB]

So folks like you can come in and get lost and complain.

[FridaC]

David Cook is truly special. His rendition of "Music of the Night" was wonderful. Sorry to see that David A. and Jason didn't do their homework regarding their song choices...Carly made an excellent choice. Brooke should have chosen "Don't Cry for me Argentina"...it would have been a perfect fit. She always seems so sweet but alas she's on a plane ride home.

[beekeeper]

Cook and Smithson are both amazing. Cook wasnt as great singing last night...he had pitch problems...and I thought he'd bust it our rocker style towards the end which he did not.

[Manni]

Cook was awesome!

Porky Shitson was awful

[blueraven]

Porky???

Who do you think isn't fat, Kate Moss?

[SharonB]

Andrew Lloyd Webber's beautiful music! The man is phenominal.
Jason showed his ignorance of music and lack of grace by rolling his eyes and sticking out his tongue.
I know some folks on here say they didn't care for Carly's performance of "Jesus Christ Superstar", but I thought she did a good job and she sure looked like she was having a good time up on stage.
I didn't care for Brooke's performance, it was kinda... meh...
The other 3 did very well.

[beekeeper]

Carly was smoking hot last night.... are you kidding me when people say they didnt like it? Did you all not notice how loud the crowd was after she perfomed!

That was hot.

[SharonB]

I have read a couple of posts here that say she did not do well. (One idiot hit her with the ultimate insult you can throw at singer... she called her a "fat porky".)
I thought that was a rather intellegent way to judge a person's singing, don't you?
My own opinion is that she looks just fine.
My opinion of her voice is, "WOW."
I thoroughly enjoyed her performance and choice of song.

[deedrdo]

i thought david's performance was awful. smug. heartless. and he ruined the ending.

i am a fan of his but not with this song.

[heretical_eggs]

He "grew up in musical theatre," but he balks like some amateur when Andrew Lloyd Webber tries to coach him? This guy has no emotion. It felt like he was just trying to use the song like a vehicle to show off his voice rather than put his voice into the song. This song demands emotional as well as vocal ability. This guy has the voice. He may get the emotion later. Regardless, this is the first I've seen of American Idol in years. I continue to be unimpressed, and I will not regret its passing from television.

[beekeeper]

I agree.... he is kind of smug

[Manni]

Carly the fat porky just shouted. She has an ugly facial expression to boot!

I can't stand her.

[beekeeper]

Dont be an azzz. She is not a fat porker. It is oxygen pirates such as yourself that saturate this world with negative energy and ignorance. Get a life.

[Daniel8168]

"oxygen pirates"

I LOVE IT! Great line!

I'm officially stealing that line. You can sue me for plagiarism later. =)

[SharonB]

Please post a picture of yourself so that we can tell you what we think of your looks.
That post was just rude. She is in no way fat. What the hell is wrong with you?
If you do not like her singing that is one thing, but the rest of your post makes you soung about 14.

[auramac]

Shikeze and Carly dazzled with joyous performances- vocally (just listen) not so hot. Cook did hit that one note that surprised me and, in fact, blew my mind. Young David was very good, but who cares? Brooke had been complimented the first time she asked to start over, now she's trashed. Listen to her studio version of this song as well as last week's ("Hero") and tell me she can't sing or doesn't sound fantastic on record. She needs a good coach and the rifht material. Jason should go- one-dimensionally stoned.

[kellygrrrl]

huh? "Shikeze" was voted off weeks ago.

[SharonB]

I know what ya mean, Kelly... this one leaves me scratchin' my head, too.

[Charity]

has no one here seen/heard michael crawford's version, which cook attempted to duplicate and failed miserably at? cook even affected a faux english accent and completely ruined the final note - going for on high instead of keeping it low where it belonged. just a train wreck though admittedly not as bad as jason and brooke, both of whom are so far out of their league on that stage that it has ceased to be amusing.

[blueraven]

Beg pardon? Low where it belongs? Crawford sings the last one high.