Stimulus Leaves Bus Riders Stranded at the Station

A version of this story was originally published by New America Media.

By the time President Barack Obama announced today's end of the Cash for Clunkers program last Thursday, Americans had turned in more than 457,000 polluting cars and trucks for nearly $3 billion in government cash.

The program was "successful beyond anybody's imagination," Obama said. "And we're now slightly victims of success because the thing happened so quick, there was so much more demand than anybody expected, that dealers were overwhelmed with applications."

Cash for Clunkers, a part of President Obama's $787 billion stimulus package, provided rebates of up to $4,500 when people turned in their trucks and SUVs for fuel-efficient vehicles. The biggest clunker was the Ford Explorer, followed by the Ford F150 pickup and the Jeep Grand Cherokee. The top cars purchased were the Toyota Corolla, Honda Civic, and Ford Focus.

"This program has been a lifeline to the automobile industry, jump starting a major sector of the economy and putting people back to work," Transportation Secretary Roy LaHood said in a statement. "At the same time, we've been able to take old, polluting cars off the road and help consumers purchase fuel efficient vehicles."

But what about the millions of Americans who never owned a giant SUV to begin with? What about those of us who can't afford a car or who have simply been doing our part for the environment by not driving everywhere we go? What about those of us who use public transit to get around?

The short answer is that we get almost nothing. The Obama administration reports only $8 billion (or approximately 1 percent) of federal stimulus money is going to public transportation.

As a result, across the country, urban transit agencies serving tens of millions of people are cutting back rather than expanding service, raising fares to record levels when the economic crisis means their passengers can least afford it.

According to a new report titled "Stranded at the Station" by the non-profit organization Transportation for America, budget cuts have forced nearly 90 percent of our nation's transit agencies to either cut service or raise fares this year.

Phoenix and Las Vegas' transit agencies both raised cash fares by 40 percent, while San Francisco and Boston increased theirs by a third. Dallas' DART system and Seattle's King County Metro system are charging 17 percent more.

Meanwhile, service cuts have ranged from humorous to dangerous. In Atlanta, officials at MARTA considered canceling all Friday service before backing down under public pressure. In Chicago, local officials tried to stave off cuts with higher real estate transfer and sales taxes, but that still wasn't enough. So the CTA board transferred $128.6 million earmarked for station upgrades and new buses to its operating budget, making approximately 19 miles of Chicago's "L" under "slow zone" restrictions, which require trains to slow to as little as 15 miles per hour due to rusty tracks and rotting ties. (The CTA also raised fares by 13 percent).

What's so infuriating about this crisis - and the lack of national public attention to it - is that a far greater number of Americans depend on these transit systems than will ever benefit from Cash for Clunkers. Indeed, Chicago's CTA alone has more than 1 million riders every day, more than double the total number of Americans who's gotten government cash for their truck or SUV.

According to the American Public Transportation Association (APTA), a trade group of transit operators, more than 35 million Americans ride public transit every day. These Americans, who save the environment by riding the bus instead of buying a Prius, receive little from President Obama's $787 billion stimulus package because the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, like most federal funding of public transportation, specifically forbids the use of any money for operating expenses.

But there is some hope. Working with friendly law-makers, APTA has inserted a provision in a bill that funds the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan that would allow public transit agencies to use up to 10 percent of their stimulus money for operating purposes. The bill is expected to be voted on when Congress returns from its recess in September.

It's not a solution, but it's a start.

Comments

[MaryanneAZ]

As with every other issue, unless it is you who is affected, then the issue is unimportant. In Phoenix, where everything is so spread out that it takes almost 2 hours to go from the outskirts of the City to downtown by bus, the issue is critical. Interestingly, when the cuts were made, they were only made to routes that affected people of color, the disabled, the poor and the elderly. When I contacted the Phoenix City Council to ask them how they arrived at the decision to cut only those routes, they stonewalled me. They did, however, manage to send a copy of my email inquiry to my employer. My employer, of course, fired me for being nervy enough to question the City Council about how I might get to work in my wheelchair without the buses I needed running when I needed them to run. Now my problem is solved -- I am permanently stranded.

[WorkingClass]

The working poor depend on public transportation. That's why there is no interest in this thread.

[Aaror]

Do you like being stuck in traffic?
One bus takes 40 cars off the road in rush hour.
How much is that worth to you? For $10 a year the citizens of a city with a million residents can buy 40 new busses or pay the salaries of 480 bus drivers (or buy 35 busses and pay the salaries of the drivers to keep them all on the road in rush hour).
Busses pollute less.
Busses use less gas, which lowers gas prices.
Busses reduce wear and tear on roads, saving cities money in the long run and giving you fewer potholes.
Busses don't just help the people who ride them, they help everyone else on the road too.