iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Adam Goldberg

GET UPDATES FROM Adam Goldberg
 

Some (Unfocused) Thoughts on Girls

Posted: 12/27/2012 5:04 pm

So I decided to put some words down about the HBO show "Girls." I'm going to assume that anybody who is reading this has seen the show. And since I have no idea what I'm about to write, I'm just going to spit some stuff out and you can take the ride with me.

Thought 1:

I'm pretty sure I'm in love with Lena Dunham. Well, either I'm in love with her or I'm in love with her character, Hannah. I didn't know who Lena Dunham was until a few years ago when I was living in Los Angeles and a friend gave me a screener ("screener" is a fancy Hollywood term for a DVD) of Dunham's movie "Tiny Furniture." It's always more interesting to me to watch tiny (yep, I incorporated the word "tiny" into the description of this movie) movies rather than it is to watch "Iron Man 8." The movie was a delight. Once the credits rolled on this cinematic art exhibit, my life was enriched for the better. In addition, I'd been introduced via a brightly lit LCD screen to a new creative and cultural force. Her name is Lena Dunham. And she is making art. Funny, touching, honest, relatable art. Huge turn-on. Plus, she's a woman, and I'm a man who is attracted to women, so she's got a lot going for her from my point of view. From what I understand (or made up in my own mind), Hannah is supposed to be a rough, fictional approximation of Dunham. I've seen a few short minutes of Dunham on talk shows, and I've read some of her tweets. I think that gives me enough of a basis to justify my love for this particular girl.

Hi, Lena.

Thought 2:

I was just talking to some of the wonderful women over at HuffPost Style about the show. That conversation is actually what inspired me to write this. They, as 20-something females, have a much more specific relationship than me to the events that transpire on "Girls." Because they're girls.

Well, I'm a boy/guy/man. And one thing I kept hearing was that the character of Adam (portrayed by Adam Driver) was an "asshole." (Side note: I love that many of the characters on the show are addressed by the first names of the real people who play them. I'd imagine this makes the performances on the show flow much more authentically from the actors. I'd feel strange if someone referred to me as Steve.) (One more side note: My name is Adam.)

I'm not so sure Adam is an asshole. He's just an oddball, much like many of us out here in the real world, who has a series of (mostly sexual) interactions with Hannah. He's broken and self-absorbed just like Hannah (and many of us). Is he an asshole because he sent Hannah a picture of his penis and then said it wasn't meant for her? Is he an asshole because he doesn't contact Hannah for long periods of time, but then when he does, he acts like nothing happened? Doesn't that just mean that he has his own life? Is Hannah supposed to feel guilty when she's at brunch with the other girls and she's not talking about or communicating with Adam? She has her own life too. When Adam and Hannah do see each other, they have fun, they have sex (whether the sex is good or bad is for Hannah and Adam to decide), they communicate, and I think he genuinely cares for her. Once they officially become GF and BF, he really does commit himself to her.

The "Girls" / "Sex And The City" comparisons are all over the place. In fact, the show makes self-conscious reference to that bygone HBO hit early in the series. Shoshanna (aka Zosia Mamet) is a BIG fan of this show. She has a poster of the movie on her wall. I had a "Back To The Future" poster on my wall for many years, but I digress. These girls, whether consciously or unconsciously, are living in the post-"Sex And The City" world. The "Girls" world is a new world. And it's a world where Lena Dunham is the driving creative force behind the fictional representations. Lena Dunham is living in the post "SATC" world too. We all are. I'm not sure what "Sex And The City" and its impact have to do with what I'm saying here, but the point I AM trying to make is that the GIRLS are the focus of "Girls." The guys are certainly interesting. But we experience less of their lives than we do the girls of "Girls." I think Dunham is perfectly capable of writing interesting men, though when I first watched the show I thought of Adam as sort of an alien. He didn't seem real to me. But I recently rewatched the first season of "Girls" and realized that we were just watching his character unfold in a slower way than the female characters. We get a smaller glimpse into his equally complex life (and the equally complex lives of the other "Guys"). But let's not jump to conclusions and call Adam (or me) an asshole. If you could only see in him what Hannah and I see, maybe you'd understand.

Also, he doesn't wear a shirt. I know I'm not the first person to point it out, but I'm pointing it out. That is something about him. Most of the time he doesn't wear a shirt. He is much more fit than me, and much less hairy than me. So I'd probably go shirtless most of the time if I were him too. I have a secret dream of having women watch me shirtless on "Girls" season 4 and saying "that Adam Two character is so cute. I wish I knew him in real life." Well you can tweet at me after you're done reading this. I'm a real person. Adam on the show isn't.

Well, Adam Driver is a real person, but I don't much about him. I'm sure he's nice though.

Thought 3:

I like "Girls." A lot. It's a glimpse into a world that I perpetually want to know more about. The world of girls. I love these girls. I love that the world of art and entertainment is broadening by the day and that someone who I feel is a valid "voice of my generation" is sharing stories of interest on "Girls." The other day I told my parents that they should watch "Girls" because it would give them a unique look at my generation. I don't particularly want to tell my parents about all my adventures and sexual escapades over the phone or over FaceTime (getting a FaceTime reference in here shows just how much our world has changed in just a few years, and it shows how I'm a member of the "Girls" generation). They can just watch "Girls" instead and draw their own conclusions/be horrified/laugh/cry/react however they want. That's what's great about TV and movies. They shape our ideas about the culture we live in.

It's odd to watch the show "Girls" and feel like it's fiction, and yet in a way it's somewhat of a glimpse into my own life. Maybe I'm Adam from "Girls" in some ways. And maybe I'm Hannah. Maybe I'm ALL OF THESE CHARACTERS. Who knows. But I live in New York, I'm young, I'm uncertain of where my life adventure is headed, I'm looking for love, I'm looking for sex, and I'm looking for meaning.

It's a "Girls" world. I'm just living in it.

WATCH A TRAILER FOR "GIRLS" SEASON 2 BELOW (via HBO):

 

Follow Adam Goldberg on Twitter: www.twitter.com/ajgoldberg

FOLLOW TV
So I decided to put some words down about the HBO show "Girls." I'm going to assume that anybody who is reading this has seen the show. And since I have no idea what I'm about to write, I'm just going...
So I decided to put some words down about the HBO show "Girls." I'm going to assume that anybody who is reading this has seen the show. And since I have no idea what I'm about to write, I'm just going...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 202
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
01:23 PM on 01/02/2013
Was this written by a 12-year old?

Or by Lena Dunham?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mochaview
My micro-bio approves boycotting corporations
07:02 PM on 01/01/2013
My new show is going to be about the girls/guys who get gentrified out of the places they enjoy now with flashbacks of what happened to the folks that seemingly just disappeared into thin air. Then the second part will be about how they come to gentrify the next area and meet up with what's left of the people they pushed out in the first place. The third part will be about how they fall apart when unearned skin privilege no longer brings them power.
Party hard, be frivolous, pretend like you stand on the right side of things for now The days of reckoning and major change are near. Many in the world you'd never, ever blog about who made NY a unique place but are being pushed out so that "Girls" can have a place to be besides the suburbs are going to establish ourselves on terra firma away from these islands that the waters will overtake. You hipster gentrifiers may not be able to just take the suburbs back because the ones forced out won't let you! Now THAT's an interesting show at least for us anyway
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TheSarge
Armed Crawdad BodyGuard
06:19 PM on 12/31/2012
The author wouldn't survive a minute within my circles, but I have to admit I also like the show.
11:00 PM on 12/30/2012
I really enjoyed this article, it really pointed out the things that make Girls a unique look at another generation. Lena Dunham is a fantastic writer and she has really created something special with this show. A coworker at DISH introduced me to it early on, and having never watched Sex and the City, I was never inclined to compare the two. I was still initially very hesitant to watch it, but after seeing a couple episodes I was totally hooked. I am anxious to see the new season, and I am glad that I don’t risk missing episodes with my DISH Hopper. I love that I can set it to automatically record entire seasons of my favorite shows, the 2.000 hours of recording space is more than enough room. I can understand why some people don’t enjoy this show, but personally, it something I can’t miss. It may not portray every persons experience as a 20 year-old, but it definitely draws attention to a new era of girl’s experiences in a big city.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OKF
Coffee Engineer
12:16 PM on 12/30/2012
Adam Goldberg = beta nerd
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:18 AM on 12/30/2012
I was thinking of Female Zen in this this TV ???___?

That is: "You Me and What to DO!?!"

I say to the man writing this, never try to figure women out, you well go nuts! Better to accept the differences without peeling the skin off the apple! You well be wiser for it today and alive for it tomorrow if you listen!

The writer says this:??

"Well, I'm a boy/guy/man" State of Confusion man, get a hold of that fast! Why! Classic 20, 30 something females well chew you down: Here it is:

Boy, no date
guy, no date
man = gets a date, 90%

I find it it amusing that each generation thinks it invented sex and some how it all has changed!

Honestly, no free spirits in these shows or any one really going deep - standard run at the game, as the TV is the guide to life!
09:03 AM on 12/30/2012
Well that cleared everything up.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:12 PM on 12/30/2012
Your metric for clarity?!
09:55 PM on 12/29/2012
This article is just terrible.
09:31 PM on 12/29/2012
I think "Girls" is a deconstructed "Sex and the City". If you remove all of the glamorous artiface of SATC, the Manolos, the designer accessories, you end up with "Girls", and it often isn't pretty. Still funny, though.
03:23 PM on 12/31/2012
The main difference is Girls is funny.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mjredder
03:32 PM on 12/28/2012
For the record, some people can appreciate Lena Dunham AND eagerly anticipate 'Iron Man 8'. (Yes, he is in fact an iron man, not Tony Ironman. Oh the difference a space can make...)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Trilby
Like candy for dinner.
12:33 PM on 12/28/2012
Thanks, Adam. Like you, I love the show and Lena and the girls. I don't get all the weird quibbles and complaints. I think it's genius and very entertaining. Can't wait for Season 2.
botazefa
Sounds like Bodhisattva
12:26 PM on 12/28/2012
I love Girls, too. I'm also 40-something, and am struck by how self-absorbed and safe 20 somethings are portrayed compared to my generation.

We had cocaine and HIV. They have iPhones and narcissism. Not better or worse, but decidedly different.
10:17 AM on 12/28/2012
I am actually shocked by the comments on this article... I have seen the entire first season of girls and enjoyed it. I am a 20-something who has graduated with a Bachelors degree and cannot move out of my home because of my inability to find a job that could pay my rent (I live in the NYC area where the average studio is $1,000 and where every apartment building wants at least a 40,000/yr salary for the past 2 years). I have been to Greenpoint and Williamsburg and understand the appeal of these neighborhoods, young 20-30-somethings living ON THEIR OWN! Plus, like the show portrays, there are many people like Hannah who do have their parents pay for everything--but this is the reality of many post-grads who do not live at home. I believe there are differences in generations, and this show and its creator should not be judged for showing (some exaggerated) reality.
09:34 AM on 12/28/2012
Happy-ness is when you stop competing w others, and start sharing and teaching sex to your gf's and her younger sister(s) and all her gf's of legal age or with parental consent. If you don't make the memories you wont have them in the future to reflect on, and regret hurts far more than loneliness.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Trilby
Like candy for dinner.
12:28 PM on 12/28/2012
Wait, what?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:10 AM on 12/30/2012
Love the loop of loops!
08:18 AM on 12/28/2012
So you are in love with either Lena Durham or her character, Hannah. And I am assuming you are in your twenties or thirties. Your object of desire is a girl, who throws a fit when her parents refuse to support her anymore, in New York no less, who not only will not convey to her sexual partner what her wants or needs are in bed but will allow herself to be degraded to someone else's will, making their desires a 1000 times more important than her own. Well good luck with
that and if this show is what fully captures the 20's generation and you all are proud of that-good luck to us all.
09:58 AM on 12/28/2012
Were you really all that confident with yourself as a young woman?
10:58 AM on 12/28/2012
"I am assuming...."

an awful lot.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
cplKlyde
08:17 AM on 12/28/2012
As my 21 year old daughter put it: "As realistic as 'The Hills'."