iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Alan Uke

GET UPDATES FROM Alan Uke
 

The High Cost of Cheap Imports

Posted: 06/20/2012 10:48 am

Don't get me wrong: We need international trade. It's good for business, it's good for foreign relations, and it's good for development in all sectors of the economy. Our current economic crisis is not the fault of international trade but of the fact that much of it is dangerously imbalanced. For every dollar Americans spend on Chinese goods, only $0.25 is returned. It doesn't take a math wiz to figure out that eventually we're going to be pretty short on cash. These kinds of trading partners cause the bulk of our massive trade deficit.

The United States built its early success on industrial excellence, but we've let that advantage slip. After the end of World War II, our manufacturing sector was the only one not in shambles. Other countries made it a national movement to lift themselves out of poverty by making things at home and purchasing their own goods. With our prosperous economy and strong manufacturing sector, we took America's prosperity for granted while these other nations plundered it. Things are now so bad that we now need our own national movement -- to make things at home and only buy from countries who buy from us.

"Made in the U.S.A." products still exist, and even more companies would have incentive to move operations back if consumers began to reward these companies with their purchases. A consumer movement aimed at buying American goods, or goods from balanced trade partners, could save our economy. But to do this, we need more accurate information about where things actually come from. We need a detailed country-of-origin label that tells us where products come from, in what percentages, and whether the U.S. has imbalanced trade ratios with those producing countries.

If you own an iPhone, it likely has the words "Made in China" somewhere on the product. But the iPhone is only put together in China. The majority of its components are made elsewhere: in Japan, Taiwan, Korea, Germany, and even the U.S.A. This kind of misinformation is why we need more accurate labeling.

We need to support each other with targeted purchasing choices. We don't need to only buy American (though it helps); we need to buy for America. That means preferring goods from countries we have balanced trade relationships with. Instead of Chinese goods (until they buy more from us), we should buy from other low-cost countries. The price point will likely be similar, but the effect will be hugely more beneficial to our job market because of the trade ratio we have with these countries. As mentioned earlier, with every purchase we make of Chinese goods, 75-percent more money flows out of the country than comes back from them. But of every dollar spent on Taiwanese goods, only 27 percent is not returned, and that figure is 22 percent for Korean goods. The difference is astounding, and this multiplier effect has a concrete impact on our economy and our domestic jobs.

If we don't have a lot of money to spend, we can still buy the things we need from the cheaper, import-laden superstores. But the things we want we should buy locally or domestically, because our money makes a real difference in the world.

The American Revolution was also about economic independence from a foreign power. Remember the Boston Tea Party? If everyone were to focus their attention on buying American products and avoiding imports from countries who shun our exports, we could make a real dent in this country's economic problems. And that's why I am calling on Congress to pass a resolution to make July 1 to 7 "Buy American Week." Americans need to know that the power to bring our country back is firmly in their hands.

To learn more information about Buying America Back, please visit buyingamericaback.org.

 
 
 
FOLLOW BUSINESS
Don't get me wrong: We need international trade. It's good for business, it's good for foreign relations, and it's good for development in all sectors of the economy. Our current economic crisis is no...
Don't get me wrong: We need international trade. It's good for business, it's good for foreign relations, and it's good for development in all sectors of the economy. Our current economic crisis is no...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 27
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bob Metcalfe
Caught at 1st. slip trying to cut
09:51 PM on 07/03/2012
But.. but... but.. This is communism :-).
08:56 AM on 06/25/2012
Nice article. What's also important is where the profits from the sale of these products go. There is so much money sitting off-shore avoiding the ridiculous tax rates in the USA.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Joseph Peeler
08:09 PM on 06/27/2012
Nice article? It was full of so much economic illiteracy that my head is hurting. The man thinks we have a money shortage? Money measures. If there is less of it, prices adjust downward. It doesn't mean there is less production. The same holds for increasing the money (medium of exchange.) It doesn't increase production. If anything it slows it down.

The author points out that the Chinese return .25 cents of every dollar spent by U.S. govt./consumers. This is a complete lack of understanding. Exports pay for imports and vice versa. If an American buys a Chinese good with a one dollar Federal Reserve note, that is a promise to repay. The currency is debt. It's worthless until it is used as a claim check to claim goods out of the economy.

The Chinese are sending us real wealth in exchange for some exports but it is mostly debt. The U.S. manufacturers so little that China wants. What does China do with the surplus dollars? It tends to recycle those dollars (which are a form of debt) into another kind of debt in U.S. Treasuries.

So: For many years Americans have been getting the real goods (wealth) while the Chinese have been getting mostly I.O.U.'s. And I am supposed to think that the U.S. is getting the raw end of the deal? Ha!

The whole buy American thing is nonsense because of the law of comparative advantage to trade and shrinking the division of labor.
08:24 AM on 06/28/2012
The US has created a problem for itself through its large trade deficit and China has benefited greatly. But this will converge to a Mexican standoff where China needs the US to export to and the US needs China to subsidize its economy. It is in the interests of both countries to maintain the value of the US dollar because one country prints and the other holds. This will end one day when China drops the US dollar as an international currency. This will be gradual and won't happen until the Chinese economy is greater than that of the US. Then its so long US economy.
photo
cyclone70
When one facepalm isn't enough
01:25 PM on 06/22/2012
Unfortunetly there a moves afoot in the WTO and the C of C to eliminate or further obscure product origin labeling

it would them be impossible to be an informed consumer if you have no idea where your products are coming from. Many places already use the obfuscating label of "distributed by" rather than "Made in"

of course in addition to the potentially poisonous, defective or counterfeit goods that is very likely with imported goods, you have little or no recourse to pursue these foreign interests legally if you are harmed by one of their products - as people who bought defective chinese tires, and those whose pets were poisoned found out

We need stronger and stricter country of origin labeling, not less
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Roosevelt Democrat
06:55 PM on 06/21/2012
Many people truly believe it was labor cost that cost the U.S. 35+% of our manufacturing jobs!

People really think it was labor cost that forced Solyndra, Evergreen Solar, SpectraWatt, Solar Millenium and Solon in these highly automated manufacturing plants to shut down!

Why?

Why does no one remember their history class and realize the planet always had cheap labor call them serfs, slaves, coolies ...etc...

The industrial revolution had to wait for cheap reliable energy! Watch this graph from the EIA and learn:

http://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.cfm?id=4390

and the cost not even mentioned in this article!

Over 2/3's of our mercury pollution now blows in from China!

http://discovermagazine.com/2011/apr/18-made-in-china-our-toxic-imported-air-pollution

People were so upset a couple of weeks ago because tuna had a measurable increase in radiation!

The increased mercury in tuna will kill you long before the radiation!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Roosevelt Democrat
03:36 PM on 06/21/2012
I'll give you cost of cheap imports.

The loss of National Security!

An example: Our soldiers camouflage uniforms use the pattern to blend into the background these same uniforms require a dye that have special IR characteristics that is no longer manufactured in the U.S. we get most of these dyes from China none of these dyes are manufactured in the Western Hemisphere! Most other dyes subjected to IR light tend to glow in the dark.

Say for what ever reason in a time of crisis China no longer wants to sell these special dyes to the U.S.; do we send our Soldiers and Marines to fight in glow in the dark uniforms?

The only practical solution is to require 10% of everything sold in the U.S. be made, mined, drilled, or grown in the U.S. Because going in times of crisis from 10% to 100% of are needs is hard but possible. Going from 0% is nearly impossible because the brain trust and infrastructure is no longer there.

Any bought politician that fights this brand them as a national security hazard!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
koos458
The Weather is Aways Nicer in Coos Bay
11:58 AM on 06/21/2012
Our biggest export has been our economy.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Roosevelt Democrat
06:38 PM on 06/21/2012
And the sad thing is both President Clinton & President Bush used reductions in our capita gains to pay for the new factories in fast developing nations. President Clinton cut capita gains 8% and President Bush another 5.8% after President Clinton signed NAFTA and gave Permanent Normalized Trade Status for China and President Bush signed CAFTA!

See before these Trade agreements the money was locked in here in the U.S. because what's the point in building a new factory in a fast developing nation if because of tariffs your products are noncompetitive?

Remember it's capita gains Warren Buffet worries about and it's income taxes his Dentist and Secretary worry about!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Aesops
Appearances often are deceiving
03:04 AM on 06/24/2012
Few seem to grasp the distinction in tax sources and the effect. That being said, Uncle Warren is a massive corporate shill.
photo
janmB
loves life
11:46 AM on 06/21/2012
Trying to find out where your meds are manfactured....is a challenge. There is no address on the internet & I don't need a street address just to know it's made in the USA. But I did find a list where b/p meds are made and it includes China--Pakistan and India. Now Afghanistan is going to make prescription drugs ( in addition to growing poppies lol )
Dubbed a "secondary market." regulators say ....some have put fake, stolen or adulterated products into the nation's drug supply.
During the 1980s and 1990s, the law was used to prosecute not only the military-industrial complex, but the medical-industrial complex, as well. Pharmaceutical companies, private hospital chains and nursing homes have paid out billions of dollars in penalties.
Courts have repeatedly narrowed the scope of False Claims Act suits starting with year 2000.
Don't we just LOVE deregulation.....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Roosevelt Democrat
06:41 PM on 06/21/2012
I was told by a dear friend from India the only thing pure in India are the virgins!

"Never trust any product without checking it first! You get what you inspect from Asia not what you expect!" he said.

Wise words.
photo
janmB
loves life
06:25 AM on 06/22/2012
There is nothing one can trust anymore. This was covered in a 60 Minutes piece some months ago. They knowingly prepared a variety of dangerous pills (contained lead, arsenic, etc), identified them as "health" pills (with fake content list), and sent them off to some labs for a PAID analysis using a fake company name. All were FDA approved labs (ouch). Some labs did the work (identified the actual pill contents), some obviously lied (reported pills contained what the fake list said--within parameters. No problems found ).
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MassWG
11:27 AM on 06/21/2012
Good sentiment and good intentions, but a voluntary "buy American" push is too little, too late. Those sentiments first started decades ago when everything was made in Japan and Korea and Taiwan. Now it's China, and the trade deficit is worse than ever.

A true solution has to somehow evolve from recognizing the true origins of the problem: the establishment of the dollar as global reserve currency and the subsequent de-linking of the dollar from gold. This has allowed for the undue credit expansion (and related public and private debt) that suckers us into financing our consumption by borrowing rather than by producing.

Global trade imbalances are the natural and unavoidable result of a global monetary system that no longer has gold as a natural balancing mechanism. Even if we work to somehow fix those imbalances, we are still in for a tough ride. If we don't fix them, we are in for an even tougher ride, because they will ultimately fix themselves in a catastrophic way.

http://www.firstprinciplesjournal.com/articles.aspx?article=1792
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Joseph LeCompte
The USA isnt broke.It was robbed.
11:25 AM on 06/21/2012
Most of your food and toiletries are made here. There is almost nothing essential that you cant Buy American.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:41 AM on 06/21/2012
Much of the pharmaceutical ingredients ingredients used in OTC drugs come from China:

http://www.manufacturingnews.com/news/10/0518/chinadrugs.html
You Don't Know Where Your Drugs Come From And Neither Does The FDA; U.S.Imports 90 Percent Of Its Antibiotics (And Vitamin A) From China

"...The United States needs two tons of heparin per month. Seventy percent of that is sourced from China, says the study. Tainted Chinese heparin (made from pig intestines and used as a blood thinner) supplied to Baxter International caused the death of 81 Americans in early 2008..."
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:08 PM on 06/21/2012
http://www.ourfuture.org/blog-entry/2010031222/last-flatware-factory-us-close
Last Flatware Factory In U.S. To Close | OurFuture.org

"There's only one flatware factory left in the US, a former Oneida plant bought by Sherrill Manufacturing. In spite of the fact that there's a brisk market in flatware in the US, and that the facility is highly productive and state-of-the-art, the plant will be closed and 80 workers laid off.

Earlier this month, the news came out that the Obama administration was going to close the office that reports on jobs lost due to globalization, so that it will be much, much harder to check any claims about whether trade was a net cost or benefit to the American worker. While writing about it, I was watching Modern Marvels: Chrome, and they profiled this plant, the last domestic flatware maker, telling viewers..."
11:14 AM on 06/21/2012
From an overall, benefiting the nation perspective, would it be good for the U.S. to focus on bringing back a manufacturing economy at a time when AI systems are becoming advanced and cheaper to where most of these jobs would probably be automated in the near future?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:35 AM on 06/21/2012
"Made in USA" and "Made in China" labels may soon be replaced by:

"Made in the World" labels

http://www.manufacturingnews.com/news/11/0930/madeintheworld.html
European Technocrat­s May Soon Deprive Americans Of Knowing Where Everything They Buy Is Made

"The World Trade Organizati­on, the OECD, the Internatio­nal Chamber of Commerce and the European Commission are moving aggressive­ly to eliminate "Country of Origin" labeling, claiming that it does not reflect the current structure of global trade. The Europe-bas­ed organizati­ons instead want to adopt a "Made in the World" logo for all products on the grounds that global supply chains have rendered country of origin labeling inaccurate and obsolete.

The intent of the proposal is to reduce public pressure on politician­s for protection­ist trade policies..­."

More at:

http://www.wto.org/english/res_e/statis_e/miwi_e/miwi_e.htm
WTO | Made in the World
photo
OMEGA MAN
A wise man learns from the mistakes of others.
09:36 AM on 06/21/2012
You can’t off shore all the jobs, and then expect to sell back into a healthy market.

Employee = Consumer
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:00 AM on 06/21/2012
Population of India: 1.2 billion
Population of China: 1.5 billion
Population of U.S. 300 million
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:50 AM on 06/21/2012
Great article!

People should thing about this every time they visit Wal-Mart in search of "cheap" merchandise.
Not only Wal-Mart, but every other business selling imported goods.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
J T K
Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
04:27 PM on 06/20/2012
Especially when we have so little spending money that just isn't feasible. People always want the best product at the lowest price and while there may very well be long term advantages for myself and everyone else, I can tell you that I'll choose to keep that extra money in my pocket rather than pay one cent more for a possible advantage later. I know the money I have to use, not the money I may get from this.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
usa241
03:58 PM on 06/20/2012
I support this 100%. Keep up the good work Alan!