Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Alec Baldwin

GET UPDATES FROM Alec Baldwin
 

Can America Be Great Again?

Posted: 09/24/2012 11:14 pm

When I attended college, a long time ago, I studied the American Presidency. At George Washington University in 1976, the student government, the GWU Student Association, had reconvened after being disbanded by the school at the request of the CIA during the height of anti-Vietnam protests on campuses across the country. Or some such folklore. Everyone was politicized. Volunteering for Carter. Bussing out to D.C. suburbs to canvass for votes. We all wanted internships at law firms, government agencies, or on The Hill. (Why not all three?)

The most popular course in the poli-sci department was Stephen J .Wayne's "The American Presidency." Dr. Wayne, now of Georgetown University, lectured on James David Barber's The Presidential Character, Charles Beard's The Economic Interpretation of the Constitution and George Reedy's The Twilight of the Presidency. Wayne's classes were packed to the rafters and Wayne was a gifted speaker and educator who held his students spellbound, knowing that some percentage of them were dreaming of living a few blocks down Pennsylvania Avenue, to begin with.

George Reedy's book reportedly shook up his old boss, LBJ, with its assessments of the Presidency. One essayist I found explains why:

Reedy's general concern is quite simple. He believed darkness was falling on the office of the president because the modern presidency had become an institution that, by its nature, kept a president out of touch with the country he must lead and the real problems he must solve. The modern president, Reedy explained, is cut off from those who will tell him the truth, and surrounded instead by "yes men" who tell him only what he wants to hear.

As a one-time insider, Reedy found that the presidency had become a uniquely American monarchy, an institution never contemplated by our founders. There are few checks on the man (or perhaps in the future, woman) elected to this office, other than his (or her) own character. The office is, in effect, a stage -- a focal place that magnifies a president's strengths, and often ignores his weaknesses.

With good reason, Reedy is not at all certain that the checks and balances of the Constitution, along with the powers of the media, are sufficient to assure that the executive branch is really properly serving the American people. To a remarkable extent, he explains, the president can do what he wishes, independent of what the people want, and what is in their interest.

The writer is John Dean, former counsel to President Nixon.

Learning the cynical realities of America's evolving monarchical chief executives, their active-positive passions and passive-negative ennui made us all begin to wonder if we were plotting careers in politics at the wrong time. Carter won, but seemed incapable of throwing the necessary levers and switches of political power to advance his agenda. After Johnson, then Nixon, the American press was accustomed to a president with every golf club in his bag and the skill to use them. Carter, rightly or wrongly, was portrayed as a president with only a sand wedge and little passion for the game overall.

Reagan came along and told everyone to forget about Vietnam and Watergate. Shake off all of the horrific results of having gone halfway around the world, ignoring the advice of our colonialist uncles (who were the French to give us military advice, anyway?), and watch 55,000 Americans die, along with a good-sized chunk of our soul, for nothing. For absolutely nothing.

Reagan told us to let that go. America is great whether we do great things or not. And when we do terrible things, it's... well... different. We're different. So let's move on. And we did. We forgot about Vietnam. Bungled and lied our way through Iran-Contra. We made plans to undo the Russians in Afghanistan, to fight the Iraqis in Kuwait, to use the hunt for Saddam as a means to get the oil we needed. We found Saddam in a hole in the ground in the middle of nowhere. But we couldn't keep a cadre of known extremists with a bunch of box cutters from ruining the world as we know it.

Not even Ronald Reagan and all of his magical blarney could have erased the memory of 9/11 and how it has changed the United States and the perception of us around the world. And I hope that memory is never erased. Ever.

As the election approaches, many Americans, I am certain, are still struggling with the question of who they will vote for. Is Obama like Carter, a micro-managing school teacher who doesn't even carry a one wood, let alone hit the long drive? Is Romney like George Bush Sr., a white-glove, Wall Street handmaiden who wouldn't know a subway token from the buttons on a doorman's uniform?

What do we need? What do we need now? Do we need more of a political philosophy that goes into a place like Iraq and incinerates U.S. military karma, again, but leaves wounded soldiers to come home and struggle within the underfunded VA system? Do we spend trillions to kill and loot for oil, sending brave men and women to die, but put forth no energy policy that will free us from that hell, or at least the one we create for others? Do we look at education in this country and just shrug and say, "Well, that's it. Another thing that's for the rich. Like a house. Or a real retirement account."

Can America be great again? Can it make the sacrifices necessary to right the ship after the Kafka-esque nightmare of Bush-Cheney? Four years isn't long enough to undo that amount of damage. I don't know if Obama can do it in eight. But I will tell you one thing: America will never be great again under a Romney administration. It will be great for rich people, while everyone else will be asked to dial down their expectations of what it means to be an American, again. Most will just shrug and comply.

I think Obama's aloofness or insouciance or whatever you want to call it is a man trying to stay cool in the pocket during a game when your offensive line isn't always giving it their all. I do not think that Obama is any more of a socialist than his predecessors. He used government to clean up a bigger mess, one made by government; a mess that was made by allowing rich people to use tax dollars to enrich themselves by bringing their "products" to market at a subsidized price. Subsidized by you and me.

In 2003, Robert Kennedy Jr. wrote this:

Corporate capitalists do not want free markets, they want dependable profits, and their surest route is to crush competition by controlling government. The rise of fascism across Europe in the 1930s offers many informative lessons on how corporate power can undermine a democracy. In Spain, Germany and Italy, industrialists allied themselves with right-wing leaders who used the provocation of terrorist attacks, continual wars, and invocations of patriotism and homeland security to tame the press, muzzle criticism by opponents and turn government over to corporate control. Those governments tapped industrial executives to run ministries and poured government money into corporate coffers with lucrative contracts to prosecute wars and build infrastructure. They encouraged friendly corporations to swallow media outlets, and they enriched the wealthiest classes, privatized the commons and pared down constitutional rights, creating short-term prosperity through pollution-based profits and constant wars.

Re-elect Barack Obama.

 
FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
When I attended college, a long time ago, I studied the American Presidency. At George Washington University in 1976, the student government, the GWU Student Association, had reconvened after being di...
When I attended college, a long time ago, I studied the American Presidency. At George Washington University in 1976, the student government, the GWU Student Association, had reconvened after being di...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 2,697
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (56 total)
01:54 AM on 11/02/2012
Alec,

I've been thinking about this Citizen United situation. Why not create a pac that makes ads advocating the wngnt position? What better way to confront people who might actually vote for Todd Akin than an over the top ad written by great comedy writers and performed by future Tina Feys that take their beliefs to the bad ending we will get if Todd Akins are elected. I would contribute to that pac.
12:59 PM on 10/05/2012
As I travel around the US. a lot, I still see great places like Yellowstone NP., The Grand Canyon and meet lovely people. Yes, Alec Baldwin is right when he points out some of our problems. Alec is also right about Romney and Ryan. I wonder if Romney or Ryan ever rode on the NY. subway system; rode a bus from NY city to Binghampton NY.; or took Amtrack from Boston to Washington, DC.?

If they did, they would see how easy it is for the common folk to travel first class!

President Obama should remain our President. I worked to get him elected in 2008 and I will work to get Obama/Biden elected again.

VOTE FOR OBAMA/BIDEN IN 1012. I AM.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:14 AM on 10/05/2012
yes, American can begreet again.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Matt Hotz
10:17 AM on 10/10/2012
Curious word that.
Etymology
From be- +‎ greet. Compare Dutch begroeten (“to salute, cheer, acclaim”), German begrüßen (“to welcome, appreciate, salute”).
[edit]Verb
begreet (third-person singular simple present begreets, present participle begreeting, simple past and past participle begreeted)
(transitive) To give or send greetings to; hail; salute; greet; acknowledge by greeting.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:06 PM on 09/30/2012
In a word, No.
Think small, be small.
Dream big, be big.
America's dreams and her "leaders" have gotten smaller over the last three decades, We have been told in essence that dreaming and then doing has become "too expensive." We've been sold four quarts of "less is more" in place of a natural American gallon of hope and dreams. Americans today spend more time "lowering their sights" and their expectations than any people or culture I have known over my lifetime. They have taken both greatness and happiness away from themselves by the drop and by the dram, until when it is needed most by themselves and the world, almost none remains, and an entire world has suffered for it. What the people of any nation own is not the scale of their greatness. It is what a Nation hopes that lifts their people and a world who admires them. America and her people are a rich Nation. All that is required as a "turnkey" is that our leadership ask of us, as it has before, to dream and to do, not only for ourselves in this day, but to leave as a legacy for our future the great things and great deeds that lift all mankind, thru all times.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Derek Ryter
10:36 PM on 09/30/2012
Well written, Alec.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
shetellutrue
10:25 PM on 09/30/2012
brilliant
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Traynor
Oh....nooo! Empty Biooo!
10:20 PM on 09/30/2012
It never stopped being great. You and Faux News just keep saying it and now you've convinced at least yourselves that it's true. Stay tuned, Alex. You're about to "wake the F%#€ up!"
10:14 PM on 09/30/2012
Let's stop worrying about 'being great'. We are. And there are many other nations that are great as well. But real greatness will come when all nations start getting along and abandon wars as a means of settling their disagreements.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GetRidOfWires
Science is not a liberal conspiracy.
10:14 PM on 09/30/2012
Somehow we have let capitalism overshadow democracy. Until and unless we reverse that priority, America will suffer.
10:12 PM on 09/30/2012
America's conception produced a great ideal, but the ideal was never realized. One major thing the country needs right now is to eliminate the current bi-partisan configuration.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MarkInEugene
A blasphemy a day keeps the deities away.
09:59 PM on 09/30/2012
Excellent commentary Alec!

Nobody's perfect, but there are plenty of candidates who aren't even shooting for that. They're in it for all the wrong reasons. That's the way I see Romney.

He wants the Presidency like he wants a new Yacht or success in an investment. He's done a 180 on so many issues over his political career that it's pretty hard to believe he's not an opportunist. I don't see a man who feels the pain and hope of his nation. He has not been able to inspire and motivate his own Party, but that's because he doesn't believe half of what they stand for.

President Obama has more of sincerity and I'm willing to bet on that for another 4 years rather than roll the dice and potentially get another tinkle down failure as Jim Hightower calls it.
09:54 PM on 09/30/2012
America will never be great again, unless we follow the economic model of Iceland.
10:07 PM on 09/30/2012
European economics, FTW!
photo
FTracy3
My micro-bio is as empty as the rest of my life.
09:54 PM on 09/30/2012
Lots of comments here from Obama supporters about "The US was never great."...might make a good Obama/Biden campaign slogan.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Matt Hotz
10:35 AM on 10/10/2012
America has been confused. That thing Peter Parker realized about responsibilities and power. The warning given by the ONE MAN who would know exactly what he was saying meant; being a five star supreme commander type, who was also a president with wholesome midwestern German work hard, be good bit in his ancestry. We, erm... forgot to heed. We listened to the other guys in the room. They, in turn gave us the Cold War, and Iraq, Viet Nam, and nearly every other bungled attempt at empire, and its unintended consequences when they backfire. Like Central America and 9/11. We also gave power to the progeny of Prescott Bush who would later went on to become a cia director, a vice president and a president. He got us into Iraq that first time, and his recovering alcoholic kid vowed to avenge something about a wrong doing and gave an American dream that imploded the economy with the foreclosure crisis.
America in compact awesome form has been a wonderful thing. Great, even. The Industrial complex part about it. Not so.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:46 PM on 09/30/2012
Robert Kennedy thought he was writing about Europe but was looking into the US future under the GOP thumb. The Republicans have calculated that they do not need to be a "big tent" and embrace any group other than the wealthiest ten percent or less among us because they made the proverbial 'deal with the devil':

The moneyed investor class that is the actual owner of the GOP brand have 'bet the farm' that religious fundamentalism cuts across all other demographics to an extent sufficent to get them the votes of the "one issue" "values voters" and put them in power and keep them there. The GOP ownership actually loves the issue of abortion as much as their "follower class" religiuos zealots profess to loathe it.

For a consumer driven economy such as ours to be successful, the majority employee class must be successful enough to have purchase power beyond the necessities of life. In this regard, today's GOP 'bites off the hands that feed it' -- they've created a massive and ever-increasing wealth divide from which our economy will never recover under Republican rule.

Recommended read: "How the GOP Became the Party of the Rich", Rolling Stone, NOV 2011.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rkemani
09:43 PM on 09/30/2012
Of course America can continue to be great (notj great again). With right policies. Even the CEO of Bain Capital in an interview with Fareed Zakaria implied that Obama might do ok in the second term. I do hope he pulls up his socks.