More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Alex Catarinella

GET UPDATES FROM Alex Catarinella
 

Britney's Beautiful Jonas Åkerlund-Directed Breakdown

Posted: 02/18/11 08:00 PM ET

A little after 9:55 p.m. EST Thursday, my Twitter news-feed flash-flooded into a sea of foreign (to those living in Medieval Times... ) hash-tags like #HIAM, #HIAMVideoPremiere, #FemmeFatale. Which could only mean, the one and only Britney Spears (oops!) did it again. After 14 tepid, smoke-and-fog teasers, the highly-hyped Jonas Åkerlund-directed music video for her hard-thumping club banger of a single "Hold It Against Me" finally premiered.

I've so far refused to read full-length reviews, because the general consensus via Twitter caused me perpetual eye-rolling. Example: Mr. Perez Hilton/gaga-for-Gaga fan tweeted to "Britney" his disappointment regarding her lack of dancing. As per usual, fans remain trapped in a pre-Britney buzz-cut, "Best of... " music video collection replete with red catsuits, school-girl garb collection and frenetic pelvic thrusting dance routines -- a time wherein the pop princess was seemingly on top of the world. Um, let's not forget that she was also 18 and giggling while claiming she'd be a virgin until marriage in Pepsi-sponsored press conferences. Times have changed.

What I'm trying to say is, at 29, "Hold It Against Me" very well may be Britney's most personal, mature and greatest work of art yet. Yes, you read it right. A-R-T (sans the ludicrous product placement). The video kicks off with a meteor racing towards earth. The explosion is Britney, showing off her midriff to a slew of flashing cameras and dancing on a lit sound-stage surrounded by half-naked, writhing male dancers. Typical Britney. But then the chorus starts and Britney, in a flowing wedding dress, is hauntingly elevated into the air with surrounding futuristic screens basically playing, yep, a "Best of... " Britney video collection. With her golden locks and caked-on makeup, this is a return to the old, squeaky-clean Britney. This is how fans wish to remember her pre-babies/divorce/rehab: our beautiful and perfect pop princess, celestial, flying free and on top of the world and looking down on little ol' us. But I can't help but notice Britney's sad, soulful eyes, her subtext screaming to the cameras, "I'm not a Slave 4 U, I won't gimme you more, I'm no longer a girl, but I'm a woman with real life issues who sometimes tours the world and breaks records. You want a piece of me? Take your best shot. Here I am."

Other up-to-interpretation scenes reveal a Britney surrounded by a wreath of microphones (she's always gotta be "on!", the microphones are her shadow), and Britney battling (in fancy stilettos) a look-a-like. But there's no winner (she's her only competition, the only one standing in her way is herself a la Black Swan). She eventually comes "back to life" on stage for the confetti-exploding, choreographed closing scene celebration, which presents a return to old-school Britney (Look, she's dancing in a cute Britney outfit! She fell and got back up! Another "comeback"!)

But the most moving part of the entire five minutes comes during the dub-step breakdown, in which neon paint shoots from Brit Brit's finger tips, covering the screens projecting her immaculate, former self and drenching her pristine white wedding dress. Uh oh! Britney is going "crazy" again and her kingdom of followers (in this case, the probably Terence Koh-inspired identical figures without eyes who struggle aimlessly under her billowing dress) have lost, and are lost, without their Queen.

So, this is why I have no problem with the lack of hard-hitting choreography in this music video. The video, to me, quite complexly represents something quite simple. Although uber-fans (okay, or just me) playfully refer to her as Godney, she's oh-so-human. The once picture-perfect pop star has returned and is offering fans the new, worn-and-torn, and yes, stronger than yesterday Britney.

A recap. She lands on earth, it explodes. She flies in the air like an angel with her mega-fans dancing blindingly underneath her. She can't always handle the pressure of living up to her greatest hits constantly following her and the world wanting a piece of her. She battles herself, falls down, gets back up, and we all watch in anticipation and obsession while switching on the record button. But everything's gonna be okay. Because she's Britney, bitch, a Southern gal with big dreams who stole and broke the world's heart. She needn't give an elaborate explanation for this video. It is what it is: Britney at her most authentic, the sometimes frappuccino guzzling (and a bit hay-zay) pop icon. Take it or leave it. But don't hold it against her.

WATCH:

 

Follow Alex Catarinella on Twitter: www.twitter.com/ACatinheat

 
 
  • Comments
  • 28
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
07:47 PM on 02/23/2011
I like Britney. She has a great voice, she is fun to watch, her tunes are catchy. In her personal life Britney has been stellar considering that there are many struggling people who don't have to share it with the world. Britney looks great, I enjoyed her Hold it Against Me video. I see Britney as a very strong woman. Perfect? Well, none of us are.
11:29 AM on 02/23/2011
The whole, "Everybody Dance" thing in a music video was old even when Janet Jackson was doing it. If Perez hilton is complaining about not having it, then perhaps he ias about 3 decades older than he claims.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dovelove
Laissez les bons temps rouler.
12:18 AM on 02/23/2011
I haven't seen real choreography from Britney in a long time. Why are some surprised about the lack of dancing?
08:55 PM on 02/22/2011
That ultra huge dress concept? Ripped off from Grace Jones' Slave to the Rhythm.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vy3fsj-aGWw
07:53 PM on 02/22/2011
This was the director's video, not her's. People give her far too much credit, but she does keep a lot of people employed to do the work for her.
06:25 PM on 02/22/2011
I would have enjoyed an "artistic" video telling of Britney's rise and fall, but this wasn't it. Or, at least, I couldn't get passed all the product placement to tell if it was. She made a dated, crowded, boring, hot mess of a video just to pad her bank account, and you fell for it. She's laughing all the way to the bank.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Wintersoldier7020
04:17 PM on 02/22/2011
Britney spears needs a hardcore trainer to whip her back into shape...she's a dancer. Ever since that humiliating VMA performance, she hasn't had confidence, it's understandable, but she needs to snap out of it if she's serious about making a comeback. All I saw in "Hold It Against Me" was hesitation, in her video "Stronger" she was on top of her game mentally and physically.
wetcoastm
Free Speech As Dictated By Our Sponsors
04:00 PM on 02/22/2011
I am sorry I tried to watch the whole video because I thought the review was interesting. Urgh it is the same junk that you see constantly in the last ten years. No actual music, just regurgitated electronic sounds about doing someone with the same pout, I could not even make it through the whole video. I think this is why some people have said there is a disconnect in the popular music genre right now. The people who freaked out when Arcade Fire won the best album Grammy might like this stuff but I will go back to looking for interesting real musicians on Youtube.
03:46 PM on 02/22/2011
Stupid video.

I feel like I have two black eyes from being repeatedly punched in the face with clumsy visual metaphors. This video looked like it was directed by a first year film student with a Hollywood budget.

Britney hasn't been relevant since she went crazy, and this proves it.
02:29 PM on 02/22/2011
excellent review. a well-written and thorough interpretation of her latest video.

i agree with the writer's sentiment. britney's 'take me as i am' approach to just about everything is what makes us want more. yea, we could have all lived without the (awkward) product placement, but can anyone really blame one of the most closely followed artists in the biz for cashing in? especially now that the music video is a dying art. i'd find it hard to believe she gives a flying frito about what product she's holding.

i'm not the biggest britney fan on earth, but i love the realness of this video. she doesn't actually seem to care, and that's fascinating to me. her life doesn't belong to her. of course she's jaded. the woman is writing and performing pop sings, not pretending to have some righteous cause. if that's what you're looking for, you're listening to the wrong music. focusing your energy in this direction is futile. the song is called 'hold it against me' for christ's sake.

all in all, she's the best at what she does. i don't know a lot about her as an artist. the point is, i don't need to. she's a mess and she probably had no say in this video whatsoever. and it doesn't matter because everyone is obsessed with her. britney is laughing all the way to the bank. a true american icon in every sense.

it's art reflecting life. but maybe through a funhouse mirror.
01:55 PM on 02/22/2011
Frankly this makes me pretty happy - historically Britney's first release off her album has historically been the song I find to be the weakest on said album - like "me against the music" from In the Zone and "Gimme More" from Blackout and I hated "Womanizer" but loved Circus. Generally I love the rest of her albums so if this ( which I don't think is her best but is hella better than the last three first releases") is what she's leading with - if she stays true to my experience of her that means I've got a great album coming up to work out to : )
01:31 PM on 02/22/2011
Thanks for explaining the video. You don't see videos anymore that portray the song the way you think they will. I was expecting Britney and a hot guy chasing each other around. I did enjoy the white dress splattered with paint! I am a "forever" fan and wish her only the best. You can not fabricate her charisma!!!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
vaf112675
Read my comments. You'll know me by them.
12:06 PM on 02/22/2011
I respectfully disagree with your review. Whatever art was in this video was sadly swallowed up by all the damn product placements.

Also, quite frankly, not one of her best videos. Doesn't even hold a candle to the one where she fakes a suicide.
11:27 AM on 02/22/2011
both the video and the song are so dated! i expected more, she is 29 not 59. it just smacks of 'look at me I am sooo edgy', but with absolutely nothing to back it up. gaga did product placement in a clever way, this just looks like the shopping channel. rubbish!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OtayPanky
You're welcome
11:09 AM on 02/22/2011
Dude! That was priceless!