More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Alison Rose Levy

Alison Rose Levy

Posted: February 17, 2011 07:57 AM

Following a time-honored tradition of democracy, two ordinary citizens head to Washington, D.C. today with a message for the President and Congress. Their message is simple: "Please keep our drinking water safe."

The two citizens, the actor Mark Ruffalo, nominated for an Oscar for his performance in The Kids Are All Right, and the documentary film-maker, Josh Fox, nominated for an Oscar for his film, Gasland, are holding a press conference, meeting with Congressional representatives, and screening the film, in an effort to safeguard the people's right to the life essential, safe drinking water. As detailed in Gasland, hundreds of news stories, state and federal government reports, and expert scientific analysis, this right can no longer be taken for granted, thanks to widespread water contamination by hundreds of proprietary chemicals used in hydraulic fracturing, (or fracking), a novel form of an old gas drilling practice. Fox and Ruffalo are calling for an immediate federal moratorium on drilling, permitting, and fracking until appropriate safety measures are in place.

2011-02-17-IMG_0360.jpg


Fox points out that, "Fracking has never been proven to be safe. Thousands of contamination cases, and testimonials across the country, point to a massive failure to protect water, air and human health."

In an open letter to Congress and the president, Fox alerts these leaders to

"the numerous dangers, hazards and injustices created by hydraulic fracturing for natural gas and urge(s) them to take immediate action to address" the "severe environmental, public health, and human and civil rights abuses that the deregulated Natural Gas Industry has wrought on the citizens of the United States as a result of the massive gas drilling campaign that has been ravaging the country over the past decade."

It all began with the Halliburton Loophole, inserted into the 2005 Energy bill by former vice-president Dick Cheney. That exempted the novel practice of horizontal hydraulic fracturing, which first introduced the use of over five hundred proprietary toxic chemicals from compliance with the Safe Drinking Water Act, the Clean Water Act, the Clean Air Act, and the Superfund Act.

Fox calls for an immediate end to these exemptions.

Five years ago, no one could have foreseen that the Gas Rush, with its ever-growing track record of hazards, spills, leaks, explosions, water and air contamination, and health dangers, would have strained the monitoring capacities of state governments, and over-ridden the rights of ordinary citizens to the extent now seen.

Calling for bi-partisan support, Fox calls for an end to federal subsidies, reporting that "fossil fuel industries receive three times the level of federal subsidies as compared to renewable energy sources," creating an "unfair advantage in the marketplace for fossil fuel drilling technologies," like fracking.

Based on the "dire crisis occurring across America," Fox recommends:

1. Expanding the planned EPA study to extend beyond 2011, to address issues of hazardous and cumulative emissions from gas drilling, and to be conducted by scientists without conflict of interest.

2. Conducting a five-year parallel health impact assessment in all of the most areas by an independent third party working alongside the EPA, either from an unbiased charitable foundation or an esteemed University.

3. Requiring EPA, and state and local departments of environmental protection/planning to oversee and issue permits for fracking

4. Managing immediate health and ecological crises in drilling areas to include:

  • The use of vapor recovery units to control emissions at existing well-sites, separators, refineries, compressor stations and condensate tanks
  • The provision of replacement water via municipal pipelines in areas where aquifers have been contaminated
  • The restoration of areas that have been industrialized with compressor stations, refineries and other gas drilling and refining machinery to a state appropriate for residential use.
  • The compensation for loss of property and physical injury to communities experiencing irreparable damage.

Fox further asks that the burden of proof for safety be shifted to the gas companies, requiring them and their associated industries to:

  • Publicly disclose chemical ingredients in all products used to drill and frack on well-by-well basis.
  • Tag each chemical product with a non-radioactive isotope to help track its possible migration into drinking water supplies.
  • Cover costs for independent baseline water testing for all chemicals used in drilling, prior to drilling.

Fox asserts that

"if a chemical listed by the product manufacturers is found in a citizens private well or in a municipal water source, and is not found to be naturally occurring in the geology before drilling, both the product manufacturer and the drilling and extraction companies should have the burden to prove that contamination was not caused by the drilling company."


In addition, due to widespread reports of "illegal dumping and improper disposal/treatment" of vast amounts of toxic drilling waste, generated by fracking, Fox recommends that "Every drop of drilling waste, drilling fluids, produced water or drill cuttings should be identified by its contents, tracked and reported in trucks that carry hazardous waste placards and must have a detailed and outlined waste management program for disposal and/or treatment." To read the complete letter with all of Fox's recommendations, please go here.

Fox hopes that on their visit to Washington, they will persuade the President and legislators to "swiftly act in the public's interest to address this crisis."


Sign up for health and environmental news, and radio programs here.

 

Follow Alison Rose Levy on Twitter: www.twitter.com/AlisonRoseLevy

 
 
  • Comments
  • 40
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Alison Rose Levy
Connect the Dots www.healthjournalist.com
09:40 AM on 02/19/2011
For anyone interested in my coverage of the interconnection between personal health and our environment, please feel free to tune into my radio. You can see my free ezine which features radio announcements and actions at: http://tinyurl.com/6kqyf4g and sign up at: www.healthjournalistblog.com
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Alison Rose Levy
Connect the Dots www.healthjournalist.com
10:49 AM on 02/18/2011
With many people hoping that gas is a solution to our coal problem, I thought I would provide a summary of why that may be problematic on my current HP blog: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/alison-rose-levy/is-gas-the-solution-to-ou_b_825014.html
09:15 AM on 02/18/2011
There are company's out there that offer Water from Air technology also known as atmospheric water generators. These systems generate water that is 100% free of chlorine, fluoride, lead, recycled water, effluent and other toxic wastes. Most filtration systems remove all trace minerals from the water, thereby producing clean water. However there are systems that are specifically designed to retain the beneficial minerals that keep you healthy whilst removing impurities. So not only does an atmospheric water generator eliminate the need for plastic bottle the water generated with these dispensers costs in the neighborhood of 6 cents per gallon. http://www.koniafl.com
07:13 PM on 02/17/2011
Mr Fox and Mr Ruffalo are performing an excellent public service using their celebrity to draw attention to this most important issue. Hopefully more members of congress will join with Rep Hinchey to enact legislation that will protect our drinking water supplies from the risks associated w/ shale gas extraction
06:06 PM on 02/17/2011
The EID guy canceled on a chance to debunk "Gasland" at Mercyhurst College last night as soon as they found out someone from Pittsburgh was going to be there to defend it. This is a common practice with this industry. If they can have the whole stage, they will come, put up some opposition, they bail at the last minute.
Natural Gas may be a cleaner burning fuel, but the extraction of it as practiced today makes it the most serious threat to the environment we are facing. If they are so efficient and safe, why then do they insist on not being regulated by the Clean Air and Clean Water Acts? Maybe it could be done in a safe way but will they pay the cost. Just like the cost of the cement for the oil rigs in the Gulf, the cement casings on Fracking rigs are faulty. There have already been too many accidents, illegal dumpings of their toxic Frack water into rivers and streams and the air quality where they are operating, well i could go on and on. Here in PA unfortunately, we have proof of all of this with many more wells scheduled to start asap. We need to stop this now, before any more irreversible damage is done to our water, land, air and PEOPLE!
photo
K August
Research alecexposed
12:32 AM on 02/18/2011
From what I've read they are getting dangerously close to the Delaware River.......water that also supplies the 10's of millions living in New York City and the surrounding areas.

Can people even image what a disaster that would be if these chemicals made their way into the water supply of millions of an area like NYC? In some places people have been told to not even wash their clothes in the toxic water......so what do they do about water to bathe in?
07:45 AM on 02/18/2011
The setbacks in the Draft regulations from the Delaware River Basin Commision require a
measly 500 foot setback from the Delaware River and it tributaries. The Delaware supplies the potable water for 10% of the American population, 15 million people.
Below is a link to the latest Action Alert from Catskill Citizens for Safe Energy,
catskillcitizens.org.
Within the Action Alert there are links to the proposed DRBC regs, talking points to help folks
write common sense comments on the regs and the information to submitt comments.

http://org2.democracyinaction.org/o/5952/blastContent.jsp?email_blast_KEY=1152382&t=

Help us out, we need all hands on deck!
05:11 PM on 02/17/2011
Thank you Josh and Mark!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:36 PM on 02/17/2011
It is a naive to think that we can switch entirely to renewables immediately. I'd like to say it's possible, but it’s not. We need to take positive steps towards energy independence and cleaner energy. That is exactly what natural gas does. There seems to be a lot of information out there challenging the claims in Gasland. Natural gas can be developed safely. We should make sure responsible development is a priority, and we should take advantage of what natural gas can do for our country today.
04:18 PM on 02/17/2011
The "information out there" challenging the claims in "Gasland" has been provided and paid for by the industry. The fact is that these companies are not using safe practices, because they want to get the gas out of the ground as cheaply as possible, so their profit margins are greater. Read this, if you don't believe me: http://www.facebook.com/gaslandmovie#!/note.php?note_id=10150134345436499&id=1104813031
04:21 PM on 02/17/2011
Hi Emily ,
Here is some information for you.
Regarding Renewables:Two scientists from Stanford University and the University of California report in two parts, links below, that the world could eliminate fossil fuel use and rely entirely on clean, renewable energy in as little as twenty years. The recipe for sustainability? Fifty percent wind, 40 percent solar, 4 percent geothermal, 4 percent hydroelectric, and 2 percent wave power.

http://www.stanford.edu/group/efmh/jacobson/Articles/I/JDEnPolicyPt1.pdf Part 1
http://www.stanford.edu/group/efmh/jacobson/Articles/I/DJEnPolicyPt2.pdf Part 2

Of course we can only move to clean, sustainable energy if and when governments stop propping up the fossil fuel industry with taxpayer money. In 2009, dirty-energy companies received a whopping $309 billion dollars in government subsidies!

In his State of the Union address, President Obama called on Congress to eliminate "the billions in taxpayer dollars we currently give to oil companies." Our new Congress claims it wants to slash spending-let it begin by defunding destructive corporate welfare.

Josh Fox affirms Gasland. The truth is the movie is factual, this should scare you me and the rest of us into action. Action to protect our health our communities and our country.
http://catskillcitizens.org/learnmore/Affirming-GASLAND.PDF

In the end, shale gas cannot and will not be extracted safely. Learn more at catskillcitizens.org. Type in a few key words, start with radioactivity, uranium, contamination, toulene, cancer, earthquakes...
03:21 PM on 02/17/2011
Gas drilling is not about America like Gas Companies are saying. If so why are Chesapeake and other companies selling the Marcellus leases and holdings to Norway,China, and other countries.The drilling is all about profit and the gas will be sold to the highest bidder.There already is a plan to installed a major pipeline down to NYC to ship it abroad.Besides this, gas drilling is turning our countryside into an industrial waste zone.The movie GASLAND only tells some of the destruction and lying that is going on.Come tour N.E.Bradford county,Pa.and see for yourself,and this is only one area of the country that is being destroyed !
02:38 PM on 02/17/2011
Thank you so much to Josh and Mark for taking the truth to Congress. The power of corporations has become so enormous that they are usually able to control the message and suppress the truth -- particularly about industrial harms. It is essential that our representatives represent the people over corporate greed.
01:44 PM on 02/17/2011
Josh Fox is wrong about one thing only. We do not have a moratorium on gas-drilling in New York State. We have a stay of execution -- an extended comment period for gas drilling regulations. This is all the more reason that Mr. Fox's call for a nationwide moratorium on fracking is needed NOW! There is an on-going movement to take back our power from the tyranny of corporations. Mr. Fox's call is a much needed and, I hope, curative shot in the arm. THANK YOU JOSH FOX! End the chemical warfare Halliburton and others are conducting on unsuspecting and unarmed Americans! tw
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Alison Rose Levy
Connect the Dots www.healthjournalist.com
02:09 PM on 02/17/2011
Thanks, Teresa for that clarification. And thanks also for mentioning Halliburton because the Halliburton loophole was so named because Halliburton is the company that produces the cement casings used in the fracking process. These are of course subject to damage and human error, as we have seen in the Gulf Oil spill incident.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:08 PM on 02/17/2011
Hear Hear ... fan'd and fav'd
01:41 PM on 02/17/2011
Even the industry is realizing that their messaging is not working with the public. It is in everyone's best interest to strengthen regulation, monitoring and enforcement. The influence of this powerful industry with the politicians has destroyed the trust of the public. It is in the best interest of everyone to get regulations in place to protect our water and public health.
Interesting article is posted about the industry and their message not resignating with the public.
http://fuelfix.com/blog/2011/02/16/fracking-message-isnt-working-says-industry-exec/#comment-13873
02:05 PM on 02/17/2011
We have everything on the line with respect to the proposed gas drilling and the catastrophes that will follow if fracking is allowed - we need a Moratorium Now. lLet's make New York state the first state to ban this horrific practice. Every day, do something, send an email to your rep, write Governor Cuomo; every single voice matters and together we can do the seemingly impossible - holding back this toxic tide so that we can enjoy our water, our land, our air. Upstate New York will become an industrial wasteland, we cannot let this happen..
01:18 PM on 02/17/2011
Mr. Fox is completely accurate to be drawing attention to this industry. It's not just hydraulic fracturing we need to be concerned about - it's gas drilling in general. In NY state, there is no effective reporting mechanism for residents whose water wells have been tainted, even from conventional drilling. The DEC doesn't track that. The Departments of Health get the complaints, and they have gotten them, but they don't have a system of aggregating that data either. And then the burden of proof is left to residents, against all of the paid industry lawyers and scientists, to prove that the industry caused the harm. Well casing failures on vertical wells allow gas migration into water wells. And I know of a farmer whose water went bad after the seismic testing by Chesapeake occurred on his property - that's probably not from the gas in the shale, but gas higher up that was shifted and mobilized by the disturbance of the seismic testing. Can he prove it was the seismic testing? Probably not... and now he can't farm. The reality is, this industry is devastating communities with little to no accountability, and the problems they cause can't be fixed. Gasland may not get every detail completely 100% accurate - we're all still learning as we go - but it's depiction of the impact on people and communities from this industry is spot-on. The industry takes the profits and the people are left with the bills - for health care, road
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Alison Rose Levy
Connect the Dots www.healthjournalist.com
01:59 PM on 02/17/2011
Due to budget cuts in these areas, and allocations in other areas, the agencies protecting public health and the environment have been gutted, and their regulations trimmed . Right now, another Huffington post covers Newt Gingrich's call to dismantle the EPA: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/02/10/newt-gingrich-cpac-speech_n_821507.html
Moves like these, past and present, leave people exposed to industries' heedless stampede to their next quarter's earning goals. Fox calls for the burden of proof to be transferred to the gas industry where it belongs. (You can read his detailed account of how to do that at www.healthjournalistblog.com) In that, Fox proposes that non-radioactive isotopes be used as tracers.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:24 PM on 02/17/2011
... And the revolving doors between government and the industry they're supposed to be regulating. Every major industry has this on-going scenario ... Former secretary of banking, Hank Paulson is ex CEO of Goldman Sachs, food and chemical industry has Monsanto people throughout governmental offices - look at Secretary of Agriculture Tom Vilsack - former Monsanto executive. He's just pushed through GMO alfalfa ... when are we as a society going to put up the big stop sign - like the citizens of Egypt just did - and say NO MORE gaming of our industry/government - banks, oil companies, ...

Our infrastructure is crumbling, our schools are failing, our roads are full of potholes, our healthcare/insurance system is legalized extortion ... these are not left or right or party issues ... these are issues in our society. Coming together in peaceful unity is what will make change.
photo
K August
Research alecexposed
12:48 AM on 02/18/2011
It's not just little communities......many are worried that if the Delaware River gets contaminated that millions will be left without safe water. Millions in NYC and the surrounding areas all get their water from that river. The hundreds of toxic chemicals they use can't be filtered out.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Alison Rose Levy
Connect the Dots www.healthjournalist.com
01:15 PM on 02/17/2011
The gas industries' critique of Gasland, sent to the Academy of Motion Arts and Sciences to protest its nomination for the Oscar, was orchestrated by a group called, Energy in Depth, profiled today in fellow blogger's Brendan Demelle's current blog: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/brendan-demelle/gasland-attack-group-ener_b_824396.html
01:23 PM on 02/17/2011
Remember, Energy in Depth attacks anyone who questions their absolute authority and veracity. Will be interesting to see if they deny (as usual) and insist that they are only mom-and-pop biz-supported...or could it be they'll be silent on the matter.
12:54 PM on 02/17/2011
For their crimes against the people of earth, and the United States I propose that former President Bush and Vice President Cheney be investigated, tried and convicted for the massive contamination of air and water. That the natural gas companies themselves fork over every dollar they've made in profit to start cleaning this mess up. ANGA I do not believe you are telling the truth. There is NO WAY to SAFELY EXTRACT ANY FOSSIL FUEL, GAS,OIL, COAL. THEY ARE ALL POLLUANTS! AS Americans we need to file a class action lawsuit against the government and gas companies for breaking the 1975 treaty as outlined by Former President Nixon.
photo
K August
Research alecexposed
12:52 AM on 02/18/2011
That's not all they should be investigated for. A few more months and it will have been 10 years.
10 years of evidence is ready....... they knew and used it to their advantage so they could talk us into illegal wars.
12:27 PM on 02/17/2011
Take immediate ACTION by SIGNing this: http://action.workingfamiliesparty.org/p/dia/action/public/?action_KEY=3271 to BAN Fracking in New York: This is our land. We have to take the power back and not let our true resources be fracked on the way there. Fossil Fuels are old news. The time has come for all of us to live sustainably again, we depend on our water and soil, not oil. This is an act of desperation, not reason. Water = Life.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Alison Rose Levy
Connect the Dots www.healthjournalist.com
12:38 PM on 02/17/2011
You make a good point that there's a lot of talk about living sustainably-- but It's not just about moving to the country and growing your own vegetables. Many environmentalists with whom I speak feel that fracking is a turnkey issue because if we allow government and business to hold hands and invest in fossil fuels rather than renewables, we will be both putting off for another generation the new forms of energy we need, and poisoning our water besides.
12:59 PM on 02/17/2011
Right you are, and it all comes down to that. As Josh Fox wrote in his Statement to Obama & Congress: "....2. END TO FEDERAL SUBSIDIES FOR FRACKING. Fossil Fuel Industries receive three times the level of Federal Subsidies as compared to Renewable Energy Sources. This creates an unfair advantage in the marketplace for fossil fuel drilling technologies such as Hydraulic Fracturing, which undercut truly green forms of energy...." I'm a musician New York City, I'm from a small town upstate NY. There is no way I can go grow my food and live off the land right now. I'm dependent on what the world makes available to me cheaply & instantly. It certainly isn't renewable energy yet, but it will be and it could be tomorrow. The goal here is to spread this kind of thinking, for me.
photo
K August
Research alecexposed
12:55 AM on 02/18/2011
"and poisoning our water" ...and it will remain poisoned for hundreds of years. ...long after the gas is gone.