iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Amanda Chatel

GET UPDATES FROM Amanda Chatel
 

I Gave Up Being a Maid of Honor for Fashion Week

Posted: 08/21/2012 2:12 am

I have never been fortunate enough to just be a guest at a wedding. I'm always in the wedding party and more often than not, I'm the maid of honor. For some reason I have that "maid of honor" appeal, or maybe, and far more realistically, the majority of my close friends just don't have sisters who can fill that role.

When Holly asked me to be her maid of honor, I was hesitant. Yes, we had been friends since 4th grade, but it was also a friendship that had been very on-again off-again over the years depending on how caught up she was with whatever fella she was dating at the time. I was also already lined up to be my sister's maid of honor that summer, as well as another friend's, so it just seemed to be too much. And honestly, I loathe being maid of honor. I'd rather find myself at the gynecologist with my legs in stirrups for an entire day than deal with all the drama that comes with such a "prestigious" part of a wedding.

Since I knew Holly was going to be asking me, I had already, long before her actual request, thought about whether or not this was a road I'd want to go down with her. Even before she officially asked, two of her other friends had already thrown fits and cried because they knew that they were going to be just bridesmaids. It was a scene to which I really did not want to be privy.

But our history as friends, although fair weather at times, won out and I agreed to fill the position with a teeth-gritted smile.

Being in New York City let me off the hook with a lot of things when it came to planning the shower and bachelorette party. The two women who had already all but threatened suicide over my appointment of maid of honor were more than happy to organize the necessary events leading up to the weddings since they were all in New Hampshire. They were practically throwing each other under a bus over who would decide on the colors for the shower and who would get 60 percent of the credit for the damn thing. From a few states away, I just watched all the arguing unfold via email and considered myself grateful that all I had to do was show up, smile, and yet my "crown" was still in tact.

Then something wonderful happened.

I got a job in the fashion world. Although my original dream was to move to the city to write, answering phones at a fashion-related company was far more glamorous than doing the same at a doctor's office while I pursued my writing on the side. A few weeks into my new job I realized there was one glitch in this new-found fancy job that had me in daily contact with some of the most famous designers in the world: I would have to choose between Holly's wedding and Fashion Week. Her wedding happened to fall on the Saturday of September's Mercedes Benz Fashion Week.

Although I was never explicitly told that my job was on the line if I took off the weekend and the days leading up to it, the notion was implied. This was before the recession so if I had to quit, having only been there for a few months, I probably would have found something else, but the problem was that it was Fashion Week in New York City. I was about to attend an event that I had been reading about my entire life; I was about to meet designers over whom I had swooned since I first picked up a Vogue. I was about to fulfill some sort of dream, and it was that dream that won over being at Holly's wedding that September day. As she walked down the aisle, I was at Bryant Park in a far-from-designer dress with my boss, playing pretend.

Holly did not understand when I told her my decision. She let loose about how I had been an "absent" maid of honor from the beginning and anyone else would "kill" to have been in my place at her upcoming wedding. While I did not disagree with her, I did think about how many more people would have killed to be in place at Fashion Week that year.

Again our friendship went into off mode, as I knew it would. When she got pregnant on her honeymoon, it went back into on mode, and then off mode again a year later when she couldn't understand why I didn't want to spend Christmas with her new family. Apparently, she had forgotten that I had my own family with whom to spend the day.

I realize now that my decision was selfish. If I were a really good friend I would have been there. I would have altered my entire summer to be at her beck and call, as many maids of honor do, but it's just not me. I'm a far too selfish person to be a maid of honor, but yet that doesn't stop people from continuing to ask me to be one.

I do not regret my choice to bail on Holly's wedding. Had it been my sister, this story would have ended differently: I would not have known what Fashion Week looks and feels like. But now that I do and had that experience, I know in my heart that I made the right choice for me. I moved to New York City for many reasons, and being part of a glitziness that you can't find in many corners of the world is one of those many reasons.

 
FOLLOW WOMEN
I have never been fortunate enough to just be a guest at a wedding. I'm always in the wedding party and more often than not, I'm the maid of honor. For some reason I have that "maid of honor" appeal, ...
I have never been fortunate enough to just be a guest at a wedding. I'm always in the wedding party and more often than not, I'm the maid of honor. For some reason I have that "maid of honor" appeal, ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 243
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (10 total)
01:07 PM on 09/04/2012
So - being a friend also means being honest. If you didn't want to do it - you should have said no. If people keep asking you to become their MoH in the future - and you hate that role - be a true friend (or acquaintance as the case may be) - and just say no. You can explain that you are flattered to be asked - but that you just aren't good at that role - end of story. I don't understand bridezillas or maid-of-honor-zillas...People need to get over themselves. A wedding is about the lifetime commitment and promise of the two people involved - everything else is just not important.
photo
rockymtnleather
The right is consistently wrong.
06:31 PM on 08/25/2012
Too bad so sad for Holly! If I had been in Amanda's Maid of Honor shoes ... I wouldn't have given up Fashion Week even if it WAS my sisters wedding. She would have had to understand ... as I'm sure she would have.
11:27 AM on 08/24/2012
What does this have to do with anything? Who cares what a crappy friend you are! Is this the confession blog? Were you required to write a story from your life?

Overall, an example of poor writing.

Example A: "I moved to New York City for many reasons, and being part of a glitziness that you can't find in many corners of the world is one of those many reasons." This is called being redundant. You used "many reasons" twice in the same sentence. Please go back to high school to work on your writing.
photo
rockymtnleather
The right is consistently wrong.
06:34 PM on 08/25/2012
Sounds like Holly is the crappy friend to me. She's the one who turns the friendship on and off as she pleases. Besides, Amanda wasn't being redundant ... she was illustrating but ONE of the many reasons out of the many reasons that she moved to New York in the first place.

Sounds like you need to use some Preparation H and get over yourself.
12:27 AM on 08/24/2012
Not only is she a crappy friend, and selfish as she claims, she is also ungrateful and dishonest.

She writes "I have never been fortunate enough to just be a guest at a wedding. I'm always in the wedding party. For some reason I have that "maid of honor" appeal". Maybe she should have followed that with, because everybody wants me and I am so popular and cool. (I call that ungrateful).

Then writes "I'm a far too selfish person to be a maid of honor, but yet that doesn't stop people from continuing to ask me to be one." Again, another way for her to say, I am clever enough to know who I really am, but seems I have fooled everyone and they really want me anyway. I am just way too popular. (Again, ungrateful).

Then to end it with "I do not regret my choice to bail on Holly's wedding". Bail? I think using this word and this sentence shows she has little remorse. Everything in the story, was I, I, I. Me, me, me, nothing showing any fondness towards Holly. I can't believe she has any friends with this level of arrogance. She has a lot to learn.
12:13 AM on 08/24/2012
Your entire written piece paints you as selfish.
photo
madeye1
I cahoot with no one.
11:26 PM on 08/23/2012
I gotta hand it to you, Amanda. If I had pulled a stunt like that, no way would I publicize it. Also hope your ex-friend is not the vengeful type.
09:23 PM on 08/23/2012
You caused someone stress on a day and at a time that was probably very important to them and you're proud of it ... lovely.
I would question why you feel the need to write about it now and in a public forum. To make a buck?One more "dig" to a person you label a friend and her other bridesmaids? You don't think you did enough damage by saying yes instead of no thank you in the first place? The need to point out to them that you "made it" in NY? Jealousy?
I can't help thinking that if you were truely happy with your choices and life you would be more gracious about water under the bridge instead of bragging about being selfish and inconsiderate.
12:08 AM on 08/24/2012
I didn't think highly of this person either, but at least she admitted she was selfish I guess. She definitely caused her more stress then needed.

It would have been better if women would start to realize it's actually nicer to be honest then to play fake nice. When she knew initially she wasn't that into it, she should have told her friend from the start that she is honored but couldn't do the job justice and that she had too many other obligations.

So not only was she selfish, she was dishonest, she needed to add that too. People need to get in touch with their feelings!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
b4pangea
Insert clever micro-bio here
11:32 PM on 08/24/2012
It all just comes across as so self-congratulatory- “Guess what, I’ve had a self-realization moment! I now get that I acted selfishly, because I’m selfish! And I’m okay with that! And bonus points for being so honest about my flaws and embracing them! Yay me!”

Her attitude toward her friend appears totally smug, superior and remorseless. At least, that's how it came across in this piece.
08:38 PM on 08/23/2012
All she has to do is say, I am honored, but I can't; she considers herself selfish, then why can't she just say no? Her sister's wedding was the most important; that's her sister.
08:34 PM on 08/23/2012
If you didn't want to be in the wedding, you should have declined. Since you didn't, you should have stuck to your commitment, no matter if your friendship was on and off over the years. I'm not one for big weddings, but I wouldn't bail out on a bride like you did. Isn't there a Fashion Week every year? You could have gone to next years, and I'm sure it would be just as exciting as this years. Shame of you!
08:26 PM on 08/23/2012
I would be a lot more sympathetic if this woman had cared about being maid of honor in the first place. She didn't want the job and was thrilled to get out of it. Why say yes in the first place. And she keeps saying she's selfish like it's a badge of honor or something.
12:11 AM on 08/24/2012
Totally agree, and then to know you are taking the job from two people whose heart was in the right place? Seriously..
07:54 PM on 08/23/2012
The true concept of marriage is a beautiful thing. But expensive, high stress weddings are a huge waste.
08:13 PM on 08/23/2012
Weddings are good for two things free booze at the reception and hooking up with
hot single brides maids for after wedding sex.
10:41 PM on 08/23/2012
true...true...true
07:49 PM on 08/23/2012
I told my fiance to not be a maid of honor to her friend that was going to make her do all the planning and stuff on top of that told her that no one else was invited and it hurt their mutual friends feelings. I just flat out told her I respect you to much your not a door mat and told her friends to not worry about her shes ran over too many people and we all called her and my fiance told her no. If this lady was under the same stress its best she not went too.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kepowell5
07:39 PM on 08/23/2012
Wow.. you are one really crappy friend. The worst. I can't believe she couldn't see that in you. You don't even like your friend! Wierd wierd wierd. Whats wrong with saying No I can't I'm in two other weddings this summer; its just impossible. Oh well, you know what you were doing.. so you deserve all the bad comments you're getting here. Toodles!
08:40 PM on 08/23/2012
exactly, all she had to do was say no!!!
12:12 AM on 08/24/2012
Exactly a crappy friend, no wonder they have been off and on friends for years! She didn't really care about her friend.
photo
pokerstarz
Do not allow the eye to fool the mind
07:30 PM on 08/23/2012
honey, you made the right choice. there's a reason you two are on again/off again friends. move on. neither of you is that committed to the friendship. it seems to be one of convenience.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mzladysmiling
Loves God, Family, & Country
07:12 PM on 08/23/2012
it's the me, me, me, mentality....
what's in it for me and what can I get out of it....
and hopefully won't have to give anything back...
it's a sad world we live in..... siggghhhh