iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Anav Silverman

GET UPDATES FROM Anav Silverman
 

Zionism Yesterday and Today

Posted: 03/ 2/2012 8:20 am

Working as an educator at Hebrew University High School for the past three years, I've had the privilege to teach the next generation of Jerusalem youth. Like any other job, there are good days and bad days, but occasionally there are also rewarding days. It is that rare day when you've imparted a lesson beyond the grammar rule in the English textbook that makes teaching a profession worth the minimal paychecks and sometimes obnoxious students.

I was fortunate to have experienced such a day about two weeks ago, when I took my class of 33 eighth grade students to Israel's national airport.

To clarify, I wasn't getting rid of the students and flying them out of the country.

The visit to the airport came in light of a class project about aliyah, the Hebrew term for the immigration of Jewish people to Israel, a phenomena that has spanned for centuries since the Babylonian and Roman exile of the Jewish people from the land over 2000 years ago. On that particular Tuesday, a group of 45 North American newcomers (olim) had arrived with the US organization Nefesh B'Nefesh on a free charter flight to begin their new lives in the Holy Land.

The return to Israel has always been a fundamental Jewish aspiration and a central theme in Jewish holidays, prayers and traditions, documented in the Psalms, biblical texts and liturgy by celebrated Jewish poets such as Rabbi Yehuda Halevi of Spain who wrote about the return to Zion in works dating back to the 11th century.

In the 13th and 19th centuries, the number of Jews returning to the land of Israel rose due to religious persecution across Europe, and partly because of expulsions from England in 1290, France in 1306, Spain in 1492, and Portugal in 1498. In the early 13th century, a group of 300 rabbis from England and France led their people to Israel because of religious beliefs and persecution. At the time of the Ottoman Empire's conquest of the land of Israel in 1517, Jews lived in Jerusalem, Nablus, Hebron, Safed and the Galilee. The Ottoman Turks allowed Jews fleeing from Spain to seek haven in Israel, with many making their homes in Safed and the Galilee.

The Jewish community in Israel continued to grow as pious Hasidic Jews in the late 18th century arrived in groups of thousands from across Eastern Europe, as well as Jews from North Africa and Central Asia, settling in four main cities: Hebron, Jerusalem, Tiberias and Safed. Jerusalem developed most quickly and by 1844 the Jews made up the largest community in the city.

With the emergence of the Zionist movement in the late 19th century, which derived its name from the word "Zion," the traditional synonym for Jerusalem and the Land of Israel, larger organized Jewish immigration began. The first wave in 1882 brought 35,000 Jews, who sought to escape the pogroms in Russia, as well as Yemenite Jews, most of whom settled in Jerusalem.

The Jewish communities continued to subsist even after the British defeated the Ottoman Turks in 1917 during WWI, after 400 years of Ottoman Turkish rule. However, by 1939, the British severely restricted Jewish immigration with the White Paper, which limited Jewish immigration to Israel to 75,000 people in a five-year period, against the backdrop of unbridled Nazi power and the Holocaust which was in the process of exterminating six million Jews in Europe. More than 100,000 Jews attempted to illegally enter Palestine by ship from 1937 to 1944, and almost all the ships were intercepted by the British. Half of these European Jews were arrested and held by the British in detention camps on the island of Cyprus. Subsequently, on July 15, 1945, when survivors from the Nazi concentration camp Buchenwald arrived to Haifa, they were arrested by the British. This form of illegal immigration, known as Aliyah Bet, continued until the founding of the state of Israel on May 14, 1948, after which the immigration of Jews to the Jewish state became officially legal.

Flash forward 64 years later and I watch my students wait excitedly for the new North American arrivals to come out to the reception area. They've prepared welcome signs both in English and Hebrew and are holding chocolates (some of which have been eaten) while waving Israeli flags.

The first couple to make their way out of the terminal happens to be the oldest couple to ever make aliyah in the history of Israel. Phillip and Dorothy Grossman, ages 95 and 93 respectively, smile and wave their mini-Israeli flags as they are wheeled out to be welcomed by their great-grandchildren, grandchildren and 33 Jerusalem students, singing and dancing.

2012-03-01-OldestCoupletoMakealiyah.jpg
Photo: Anav Silverman / The Grossmans from Baltimore arriving to Israel's Ben Gurion International Airport.

The Grossmans, who have been married for 71 years and made aliyah from Baltimore, Maryland, have three children; one already living in Israel, five grandchildren, 14 great-grandchildren and two great-great-grandchildren. Many members of the family, including three great-grandchildren, came to the airport to welcome the couple who will make their new home in Jerusalem.

Following the Grossmans, 43 other North Americans also received the same warm welcome from my Jerusalem students, including an airplane pilot and random tourists coming through.

As one student, Natalie related to me. "It was amazing to see with my own eyes that olim are continuing to come to Israel and make their home here." "I never realized that aliyah is still such a prevalent part of Israel today," added her classmate, Shelly.

For my students, this was an important day. The arrival of these new immigrants highlighted many important things, including the fact that Jews around the world continue to want to make their home in Israel -- no matter what their age or situation. The return to the Jewish homeland has always been a dream that has inspired the Jewish people for thousands of years. It is a dream that many continue to seek to make a reality, and for those that it is a reality, like the young generation of Israel today, it must never be taken for granted.

2012-03-02-ClassPictureatAirport.jpg
Photo: Elad Shlomo / Jerusalem eighth grade students greet new North Americans arrivals at airport.
 

Follow Anav Silverman on Twitter: www.twitter.com/SderotAlert

Working as an educator at Hebrew University High School for the past three years, I've had the privilege to teach the next generation of Jerusalem youth. Like any other job, there are good days and ba...
Working as an educator at Hebrew University High School for the past three years, I've had the privilege to teach the next generation of Jerusalem youth. Like any other job, there are good days and ba...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 114
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:34 PM on 03/03/2012
Beautiful story, Anav. I'm glad you posted a picture of the Grossmans too. Thank you.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CapSen
Empathy. The faculty to feel what the other feels.
12:53 PM on 03/03/2012
Seems part 1 of my story got lost. Dearie me. Shouldn't try to post long narratives. I'll try and reconstruct if anyone is interested.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CapSen
Empathy. The faculty to feel what the other feels.
11:49 AM on 03/03/2012
socialist leanings, I meant to say in 1
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CapSen
Empathy. The faculty to feel what the other feels.
11:48 AM on 03/03/2012
2 - From there on Zionism evolved to get inextricably and inconsistently mixed with religious bigotry. That is why Israel does not, and cannot have a Constitution. A secular republic with equal rights for all citizens is just plain irreconcilable with a 'national home' for a certain religious group.

Israel is schizophrenic in its basis, which is the cause of all later internal troubles.

Not to mention starting an imperialist colony on someone else's territory, and then justifying that with, that's really revolutionary, 2,000 year old religion-based claims. The fact that some people who just might be your forefathers lived somewhere in times immemorial does not justify conquering that territory.

I wonder how Americans would feel if any group of people would settle in, and take over NY state because they have a holy book telling them it's theirs! It's theirs! Red Eric, who actually 'discovered' America, would be the reason modern-day Icelanders could claim the whole of the US of A ;)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Galilee
I boycott products from Syria & Gaza dictatorships
01:45 PM on 03/03/2012
Why are you stealing land from the native Americans?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:32 AM on 03/05/2012
Native Americans are entitled to US citizenship.

Palestinians are evicted from their land by Israel, shot at and then turned into refugees while Israel steals their property. There is no similarity.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CapSen
Empathy. The faculty to feel what the other feels.
11:48 AM on 03/03/2012
1 - I started to read this article because of the title. However, the article does not treat the stated subject.

I can give a comprehensive outline: Zionism started out as a secular diaspora nationalist movement with leftist, or even socialist (kibbutz!) in reaction to the rise of the nationalist ideology in 19th century Europe. Nationalism departs from the mistaken, or rather trumped up notion that people speaking the same language or having the same religion should have a right to have a state, an own territory, to the exclusion of whoever else is living there. This calls for racial purity and the removal of the 'Other'.

In the jewish case the special, new feature was 'diaspora'. Zionism supposed that all these disparate, separate jewish communities all over the world, with different characteristics, form one 'nation'. However, there is no such thing as a 'nation' in the empirical world. It's an invention that does not bear any relation to reality. And even less so in this instance. France, where nationalism was invented, could call itself a 'nation' because there was a fixed long-time state with a relatively homogenous population. Well, they had to eradicate non-standard French in order to maintain that assertion.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CapSen
Empathy. The faculty to feel what the other feels.
11:33 AM on 03/03/2012
The author of this article is disingenuous in hiding the fact that the large majority of jews expelled from Europa found refuge in *muslim* lands, welcomed and protected by the islamic minority autonomy statute called 'millet' in the Ottoman Empire, that at the time comprised most muslim areas, from Algeria to Iran, and from Souther Russia to the Arab Peninsula.

While not comparable to modern ideas about equality, citizenship and minority rights, this was most certainly the most enlightened way of treating (christian and jewish) minorities of the time, esp. compared with European antisemitism.

Jews settling in the 'Israel area' were a small minority. This is why, for instance, up to this day there are jews living in Istanbul, Turkey speaking a medieval Spanish dialect, Latino.

How you can distort a picture without lying. By not telling the whole truth.

Arabs and muslims are generally viewed as antisemitic these days, where muslims and jews have been living peacefully side by side for 5 centuries. The trouble only started after the establisment of Israel.

How many people here know this, or care to know? And if so, why do they not care? Because prejudice feels better?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:39 PM on 03/03/2012
The author of this comment is disingenuous in hiding the fact that the large majority of Jews who found refuge in *Muslim* lands were later persecuted, expelled and their properties withheld.
photo
GilGamish
Exposing the charlatans
06:16 PM on 03/03/2012
"The trouble only started after the establisment of Israel."

Really so the ethnic cleansing of Jews from Hebron in the 1920's wasn't trouble ? And you accuse others of hiding facts? Or maybe you just don't know the facts yourself. Which is it?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
analyse this
Everything is temporary anyway
08:18 AM on 03/03/2012
So Jews from all over the world own the land but people who live in it do not?

People who have a claim 2000 years old is more valid than claims of 60 years old?

It seems the world is always being asked to suspend logic and reason for Israel. Wow.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Nwo2012
Sue me, I boycott products from the settlements
11:28 AM on 03/03/2012
Indeed
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CapSen
Empathy. The faculty to feel what the other feels.
12:54 PM on 03/03/2012
Yeps. They have a special status. Don't ask me why. Or do ask :)
02:40 AM on 03/03/2012
Good to see your people were able to realise their dream. Now spare a thought for the Palestinians who also hope to return to their homeland.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lbsaltzman
Permaculture and Sustainability
12:09 AM on 03/03/2012
It is a shame the the return to the "Jewish Homeland" involved ethnically cleansing the indigenous Palestinians whose ancestry stretched back to pre-Christian times in the region.
08:57 AM on 03/03/2012
You really should re-read your history and lose the brain toxins. Most Palestinians can trace their lineage in Israel to the last 100 years of the Ottoman Empire.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Nwo2012
Sue me, I boycott products from the settlements
11:29 AM on 03/03/2012
israel didn't exist 100 years ago
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CapSen
Empathy. The faculty to feel what the other feels.
11:52 AM on 03/03/2012
You're not adressing the comment. In any case, 100 years is before 1948.

But I get tired and bored refuting Hasbara lies all the time.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
noiz001
10:10 PM on 03/02/2012
What a wonderful story. The joy of the new olim being greeted by your students and the joy of the students to realize that so many people still hold the dream of making aliyah to their home.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CapSen
Empathy. The faculty to feel what the other feels.
12:02 PM on 03/03/2012
And the joy of oppressing 3 million people living in misery because of an ill-advised invasion and establishment of a Western colony, and treating 1.5 million as second class citizens.
08:57 PM on 03/02/2012
I thought of a practical solution to the palestinians and israelies , NO two state solution
BUT ONE STATE for both . democratic , with one simple exception . THE PRIME MINISTER AND THE DEFENCE MINISTER MUST ALWAYS BE JEWISH , The rest of the future governments will be picked by the Kenesset whose members are selected by all the residents of the new state . What do you think ?.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
svasol
Environment means we are all in this together
10:34 AM on 03/05/2012
C'mon- Democracy is so inconvenient.
07:08 PM on 03/02/2012
My cousin is named Aliyah, which is strange since we are not Jewish. By the way the "Zionist narrative" doesn't really help the argument about jews being native to the area since over 3 million jews have immigrated to Israel and had kids to make the current population 5 million.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Domingo Cardoza
USARMY Ret. _Unabowed America-Firster
06:44 PM on 03/02/2012
That's a well written story of the field trip for the kids of her class. The question is, where would she take the Arab citizens of Israel kids to make them feel patriotic about Israel. Is a rhetorical question, just pointing out that for the olim to come, room had to be made.
05:52 PM on 03/02/2012
Interesting statistics on the new arrivals. How about contrasting them with the figures relating to ones who have thrown in the towel and are leaving. There is a reason why very few immigrants give up the citizenship and passports of their birth countries.
01:57 AM on 03/03/2012
No immigrant would reject own citizenship voluntarily. It does not make sense. Citizenship is a very valuable thing to own.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
trader14
05:16 PM on 03/02/2012
Palestine = Jordan
Go Home already your Islamic brothers are waiting. Israel is for the Jews. Time to move on.
The arabs attacked the Jews and the jews won and Arabs lost..... get used to Israel being a Sovereign Jewish State in the Mideast
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Nwo2012
Sue me, I boycott products from the settlements
11:30 AM on 03/03/2012
Ethnic cleansing millions of Palestinians from their own land wont solve a single one of israels problems.