iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Andy Ostroy

GET UPDATES FROM Andy Ostroy
 

The Most Outrageous Aspect of the Trayvon Martin Case

Posted: 05/21/2012 9:37 am


So now we know, through evidence released by prosecutors this past week, that George Zimmerman, the 28-year-old superhero-wannabe who shot and killed unarmed 17-year-old Trayvon Martin in Sanford, Fla,, on February 26th, had wounds on his head and a broken nose. And as expected, ignorant racists nationwide rushed forward with disingenuous cries of "See!?... that proves the kid had attacked him!" But Zimmerman's wounds suggest one thing: that Trayvon fought like an animal to save his life.

Ever since this story hit the press I've been mortified about how Trayvon has been vilified as the aggressor when all evidence points to him being the one who desperately needed to exercise his state's Draconian 'Stand Your Ground' law. For the life of me I don't understand why the media has not explored this angle more than it has. The simple fact remains here: that a grown man with a gun, safe in his locked car, against the implicit instruction of a 911 police operator, left that car to pursue, confront and kill a child (yes, racists, under the age of eighteen one is legally considered a child) who was holding nothing more than a bag of Skittles and an iced tea.

What exactly does 'stand your ground' mean if not to fight like an animal to save your life when you believe it's being threatened with deadly force? Why does the fact that Zimmerman suffered wounds serve as evidence that Trayvon initiated the scuffle? To the contrary, Zimmerman's wounds reinforce that the kid bravely came at his attacker with everything he had. That after screaming for help seventeen times in a desolate area he fought furiously to save himself from being shot dead...something he unfortunately failed to do. Why is no one talking about how it was Trayvon who 'stood his ground?' Why does it seem that this law is only being discussed as it applies to Zimmerman?

As for Zimmerman's claim of self-defense? Bullshit. That defense went out the window the second he stepped from his locked car with a loaded semi-automatic weapon.

 

Follow Andy Ostroy on Twitter: www.twitter.com/AndyOstroy

FOLLOW POLITICS
So now we know, through evidence released by prosecutors this past week, that George Zimmerman, the 28-year...
So now we know, through evidence released by prosecutors this past week, that George Zimmerman, the 28-year...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 1,587
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (8 total)
11:36 AM on 07/19/2012
Agreed this is a beautiful article and this cases isn't seen in this aspect at all. Hopefully you enlighten a couple of people!
07:56 AM on 07/18/2012
GZ, in his race to catch TM, slipped and fell, causing wounds to his head. GZ placed those wounds on TM attack on him to prove a SYG defense. It's not 'rocket science' to use lies that no one can prove did not happen. The jury will be filled w/people, who will only go along with what can be proven. GZ will go free, like OJ. The whole case will be determined by the jury. Trials are about proof.
photo
southingtonian
"I'm a Capricorn and you can't make me do sh*t.."
09:00 PM on 07/08/2012
"The simple fact remains here: that a grown man with a gun, safe in his locked car, against the implicit instruction of a 911 police operator, left that car to pursue, confront and kill a child who was holding nothing more than a bag of Skittles and an iced tea."
Succinct summation, give it to the prosecutor.
photo
nawseeya
"the only thing more terrifying than mother nature
08:44 PM on 06/26/2012
this is ridiculous everything you are saying is wrong. did you even look at the evidence?be objective, man, instead of being part of the problem.@@
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
cjus2473
Few men have virtue to resist the highest bidder
01:08 PM on 07/16/2012
and hopefully the money you sent this man will be used on his defense versus paying mastercard as he was doing...nothing says arrogant as the person who thinks they have this in the bag...

he will need about 4 million for his defense...so pony up
photo
nawseeya
"the only thing more terrifying than mother nature
08:59 PM on 07/17/2012
if he pays his cards out of it then so be it . the reason he is getting donations is because all these death threats and  false accusations are rendering it impossible for him to work. last time i looked, mastercard bills get paid by one's take home pay of which he is prevented from earning.
12:38 PM on 06/08/2012
The overall issue is one that applies to any person innocently and peacefully walking home after a short errand where you had interacted peacefully with a store owner: somehow you end up dead. Then, some say that you are at fault even though you were not acting criminally and it was you who was made afraid by the unidentified stranger who initiated intrusion into your safety space because he was angry at what you looked like and more importantly because he was emboldened to “initiate” by being armed with a gun. However, your reaction options to the stranger’s intrusion were, unknown to you, radically reduced because the stranger carried a concealed gun. The stranger’s failure to self identify and to reveal he was armed caused you to feel the situation was threatening but that it was an even match. And so there you are - blamed for your own death and only a bag of candy and an iced tea to show for it all.
08:47 PM on 06/11/2012
Wow. Well said. Mahalo!
12:17 AM on 06/08/2012
Zimmerman's injurys were a result of his own aggressive actions! Trayvon was walking home in the dark, with his hood up ( it was raining ) eating candy!!!! If I was pursued by a stranger at night I would be frightened and if I was approached I would fight for my life!!! Trayvon may have injured Zimmerman but he was also yelling for help at the same time!! I am a 61 year old white woman who wears hoodies also ! ( with the hood up! Shock!!!! ) If Zimmerman had stalked me in the same manner I would have reacted exactly as Trayvon did!! God Bless his young soul!!
08:46 AM on 05/30/2012
For example just look at the guy that just ate the face of that man. They suspect he was using the highly addictive synthetic drug called bath salts. Bath salts have mephadrone in them. Abusing mephadrone & abusing amphetamine's have pretty much the same side effect's. And this crap is being sold right over the counter & has devestating effect's to people that continue using it. They build up a tolerance to it & take more & more of it to be able to get the effect's from it. Eventually it causes very psychotic behavior. A lot of people including young adult's are able to walk right into a convenience store & purchase it.
photo
OdinsEye
Korean-Latino cop and retired military combat vet
02:59 PM on 05/31/2012
And this has what to do with what?
photo
pciorlandosales
have come to chew bubble gum and kick ash
05:59 PM on 06/04/2012
Sorry to inform you but mephadrone has been a schedule 1 drug in Florida for over a year now. You have not been able to buy/possess it for over a year over any counter. It is highly unlikely that bath salts where used in the Miami attack.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jordan2
Constitution...See:The Originalist Perspective
09:25 PM on 05/29/2012
http://blogs.chicagotribune.com/news_columnists_ezorn/2012/05/does-talk-left-get-the-zimmermanmartin-case-right.html

Two different scenarios at the link. One is from talkleft.

The other is a video with good visuals and commentary.

Looks like even the liberals are saying the evidence supports George's account. You can link to other sites at talkleft.

Here is a good review of the evidence except for the iced tea. I think it was actually watermelon juice cocktail.

http://www.talkleft.com/story/2012/5/27/41053/5361

We do not know if there will be a trial yet. This is an eye opener about ours SGY law. Remember that it was passed by 100 percent of the Democrats in our Senate.

http://www.southfloridacriminallawyersblog.com/2012/04/why-trayvon-martins-case-may-not-go-to-a-jury.html
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
cjus2473
Few men have virtue to resist the highest bidder
12:12 PM on 07/16/2012
Here is a good review of the evidence except for the iced tea. I think it was actually watermelon juice cocktail.

only racists would make this comment...please contribute to george...but please stop this inflammatory rhetoric...a child is dead...a grown man, if he felt this kid was dangerous, deliberately put himself in harm's way...we do know there will be a trial...unless you think making someone post 1 mil bail is just an exercise in seeing if the state of florida has good bookkeeping practices...

your using the south florida criminal lawyers' blog is not a good argument...you are comparing someone who actually committed a crime being killed by someone who used the stand your group...as far as i know it, walking home with a hoodie, candy and ice tea is not a crime in the u.s.

you keep saying that dems are in favor of this or that...do you think we live in a country where a jury is made up of political figures???? the jury should consist of a wide diverse group of people...and let's see how many agree that had their child left their home to purchase some junk food, wore a hoodie because it was raining, deserved to be gun downed by an adult who can't managed to actually become a police officer so he pretends he is one...
photo
siciliabel
Inside of a dog it's too dark to read.
04:36 PM on 05/29/2012
I just finished reading some of the comments generated by your blog. It seems that many of those commenting here have lost sight of the fact that a young man lost his life. He must have been terribly frightened, and as it turns out his fear was justified. For him, it ended up just about as badly as it could have. It seems many of the responders here have a great deal invested in "proving" that Trayvon Martin got what he "deserved". What he deserved was to grow up and live his life. His wardrobe choice or decision to defend himself shouldn't be subject to debate. He was a child, a beloved child.
03:09 AM on 05/30/2012
choice to defend himself? Talk about misinformed bias.

If he threw teh first punch he was not defending himself.
Being followed is NoT illegal. Having a gun is not illegal.

Defending your self form legal actions that are not harming your. IF he attacked first then Z was defending himself and not Martin.

A 17 year old "child" can be violent and can kill. Esecially one that might have been banging Z head into the ground.
photo
siciliabel
Inside of a dog it's too dark to read.
11:50 AM on 05/30/2012
Your speculation is just that:  speculation.  What isn't in doubt is that when your age is 17,  the word child needn't be enclosed in quotation marks, he is much loved, and he didn't instigate this incident.  The rest can be left to the courts to determine.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
cjus2473
Few men have virtue to resist the highest bidder
12:15 PM on 07/16/2012
wow...i hope you contacted the police department with your eyewitness account...you saw this kid throw the first punch? mind boggling...

banging z head into the ground...another eyewitness account....

you're going to be busy testifying at the trial...hopefully you will be the first called...'cause george will need you...witness 9 appears to be contradicting your statements...
09:48 AM on 05/30/2012
Citing the statement of his girlfriend Dee Dee, with whom he was talking immediately prior to the shooting, Martin indicated he would not run despite Dee Dee's urging. That doesn't sound like he was very "frightened" to me.
photo
siciliabel
Inside of a dog it's too dark to read.
01:18 PM on 05/30/2012
That's probably the first time since the beginning of dating that a guy tried to sound cool and capable to his girlfriend.  Your fact-finding is sub-par, to say the least.
04:54 PM on 06/10/2012
Well,i wouldnt tell my GIRLFRIEND i was running from some chubby creep.
To me,it was murder. HE CALLED THE AUTHORITIES.His job was done.
08:25 AM on 05/29/2012
Zimmerman wouldn't have ended up clear down that sidewalk behind those home's if he would have turned around after his short run. He had to have kept looking to end up that far from his truck. If Trayvon took off running & ran from in front of those homes around to the back why would Trayvon state on the phone to Dee Dee that Zimmerman was following him. There is NO way that Zimmerman had the time to get down the 1 sidewalk, make a right hand turn & go all the way down that other sidewalk in the short period that he was running. NOT BUYING IT!!!!!!!
09:53 AM on 05/30/2012
Zimmerman wasn't "clear down that sidewalk" as you allege. The shooting took place less than 60 yards from Zimmerman's vehicle, directly behind the the building in front of which Zimmerman parked. Yet, it was over 100 yards to Martin's temporary residence. The call lasted over two minutes beyond the point where Zimmerman ceased running, as evidenced by the sounds on the recording, more than enough time for Martin to arrive at his home. Yet he didn't. Why?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ebeth Martine
12:10 PM on 06/08/2012
Zimmerman got out of his car after being asked by the dispatcher which way TM was headed!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Big6domino
06:07 PM on 05/28/2012
Self defense claims are only applicable to unavoidable situation. Those in which a victim does not have the time or opportunity to a) call the police b) find safety in their home or car c) retreat . We know that Zimmerman had the time to do all three and did in fact call the police who advised him to stand down. His criminal behavior begins when he decides to disobey the directive of the dispatcher. All of this but for one man and his asinine decisions COULD HAVE BEEN AVOIDED.
11:54 PM on 05/28/2012
"Self defense claims are only applicable to unavoidable situation.Those in which a victim does not have the time or opportunity to a) call the police b) find safety in their home or car c) retreat .We know that Zimmerman had the time to do all three and did in fact call the police who advised him to stand down."

False. Read the law.

"His criminal behavior begins when he decides to disobey the directive of the dispatcher."

False. First, there was no directive from the dispatcher. There was an advisement. Second, the dispatcher is not a law enforcement officer, and has no authority to issue directives. Third, there is no evidence to support the notion that Zimmerman did not heed the dispatcher's advisement.

"All of this but for one man and his asinine decisions COULD HAVE BEEN AVOIDED."

Speculation.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dino139
07:00 PM on 05/29/2012
It's "speculation" to say if Zimmerman had stayed in his car Trayvon Martin would be alive today? Seems perfectly obvious to me.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
jsgaetano
Legum servi sumus ut liberi esse possimus
09:05 PM on 05/29/2012
What speculation? Was someone forcing Zimmerman to continue stalking an unarmed kid who did nothing more than "walking while black"?
photo
pciorlandosales
have come to chew bubble gum and kick ash
06:09 PM on 06/04/2012
Yeah I guess when your pinned to the ground being wailed on until you have two black eyes, a broken nose, a gash in the head and a concussion leave's you lots of options. lol Really?
05:17 PM on 06/10/2012
This whole thing about 210 pound,police officer slapping george, being thrashed by the stringbean 158 pound kid is getting old.
I dont know and,cant understand how folks can condone the killing of an unarmed child,by a supposed adult who has a concealed carry license.

Not saying you condone the murdering of children by armed men.
But you seem to be laying all of this at the feet of the child who was murdered in cold blood !
KARMA,will take care of the partys involved in this tragedy.He could walk away totally free and,clear. But,some how,some way things will be made right.That is just universal law.
I would hope that as he was hollering for help and,fighting for his life,that the child did get in a blow or two against his assassin.
04:07 AM on 06/11/2012
No, I won't be picking Orlando Sales thank you very much. As for Insano's supposed injuries. Trayvon stood his ground. I love the twisted logic that Trayvon had no reason to fear for his life....holey crap, how can anyone even attempt that argument. Oh, crap, in case you don't get it, HE DID HAVE REASON TO FEAR FOR HIS LIFE!! HE IS DEAD!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaliTLC
The GOP is a MORIBUND Party
04:26 PM on 05/28/2012
Finally - THANK YOU Andy.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Loubro2
Cool Lou
09:31 PM on 05/28/2012
F&F
09:46 AM on 05/28/2012
At the beginning i thought perhap's that Trayvon may have used his tea can to defend himself but the picture that was released of the can show's no damage or blood on the side of the can showing. However I see in the evidence where they have swabbed blood sample's from the flashlight. This may have been used to cause Zimmerman's injuries. I also just realized that they took cheek swab's from Zimmerman which could possibly be used to detect how much Adderall he had in his system. There is quite a bit of these document's blacked over so that mean's that is evidence that we are not seeing.
11:25 AM on 05/28/2012
"However I see in the evidence where they have swabbed blood sample's from the flashlight"

I am curious as to what difference you think it makes. Hitting someone over the head with a Maglite can kill you too. It killed Malice Green.

So it would have beens self-defense either way. Anything that hits your head hard enough to make it bleed can kill you.

But it doesn't matter anyway, because it was the sidewalk. You might as well just admit it now.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
jsgaetano
Legum servi sumus ut liberi esse possimus
09:07 PM on 05/29/2012
There's no "self defense". Martin was "standing his ground", as the two authors of Florida's SYG law have stated several times already.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
cjus2473
Few men have virtue to resist the highest bidder
12:43 PM on 07/16/2012
where the heck are you getting your information - geraldo? they took no drug swab of mr. zimmerman - they took it of mr. martin....mr. zimmerman had the flashlight - not mr. martin

please get your facts correct
01:35 PM on 07/16/2012
I know all that. Look how long ago I made those posts. Way before all the info came out. GAUD!!!
06:56 AM on 05/28/2012
I see there is no mention of him taking Adderall in the fire department EMT record's. Why did he fail to
tell them he was taking this medication? They probably would have made him go to the hospital to be
drug tested that's why. I see they listed paresthesia on the report. Paresthesia is a side effect of
amphetamine abuse.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jordan2
Constitution...See:The Originalist Perspective
09:30 PM on 05/29/2012
I can find no Florida statute that would have allowed them to test him without reasonable cause.
03:16 AM on 05/30/2012
adderall will have nothing to due in court. IT jsut smoke and mirrors by bias M supporters simply becasue the case is falling apart and was only brought up because of mob pressure(angry villagers with pitch forks and torches, basically.)
08:15 AM on 05/30/2012
There is no reason I can think of if a person is on 3 prescription drug's why they would omitt telling them 1 of those drug's unless they were trying to hide the fact that they were abusing a drug that is often abused. A drug that is associated with paranoia, aggressive & hostile behavior & hallucinations when abused. I would think that killing someone would be probable cause for them to test him. But like I said the police do have mouth swab's & they could still be or maybe already have been tested for his drug useage. And I am sure that since they have been aware of him taking these drug's since it all came out after the killing that they are probably looking in to it.
12:20 PM on 05/27/2012
When Mr. Sooner was representing Zimmerman he stated that he was going to use" Shaken Baby Syndrome" as his defense. I wonder did Zimmerman confide in Mr. Sooner that he was taking Adderall?
Ampetamine is a component of Adderall. It is used to treat people with tramatic brain injuries which would coincide with Shaken Baby Syndrome. Has there been something wrong with Zimmerman since he was a baby? Was this disclosed in his information to apply for a Concealed Carry Permit? Is this a reason why his father has alway's come to his defense when he has gotten in trouble with the law?
06:45 PM on 05/28/2012
"Is this a reason why his father has alway's (sic) come to his defense when he has gotten in trouble with the law?"

What father wouldn't come to his son's defense, especially when in need? You obviously need a hobby.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
blessed457100902
Smooth Christian married man. Frank honest and dir
08:50 PM on 05/28/2012
What hypocrisy of the lowest rank order by you an others in here. Now you want to quote Dershowitz when I bet during the OJ trail you called him every name in the book didn't you? Like you used "liberal" but you really want to say something else but you can't! I read the affidavit and stand by my words!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
blessed457100902
Smooth Christian married man. Frank honest and dir
08:50 PM on 05/28/2012
Did TM run inside that complex the very first time he visited his Dad? Did he call 911 the very first time he visited his dad?Since he didn't run in there who in the heck is GZ to run him out of there by killing him? I don't give a rats behind how long TM had to do this and do that GZ had the exact amount of time TM had to keep his vigilante cop wannabe behind in his vehicle he chose not to and he goes to prison to rot!
04:39 AM on 06/11/2012
Wow. That one is news to me.