More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Andy Stepanian

Andy Stepanian

Posted: March 4, 2011 02:21 PM

Bidder 70: Obedience Is Scarier Than Prison


Today all eyes are on our climate crisis and we have Tim DeChristopher to thank. I've been paying close attention to the landmark trial of Tim DeChristopher, the University of Utah student and environmental advocate accused of disrupting the Bureau of Land Management (BLM)'s illegal auction of parcels of undeveloped federal properties to natural gas and oil exploration. When I read the news at work that the jury had just received their instructions from the judge and would leave to deliberate the case against DeChristopher I got up from my desk walked to the bathroom, I locked the door, dropped to my knees, and began praying for him.

2011-03-04-timHP1.jpg

I had been in shoes like DeChristopher's once as a defendant in the SHAC7 trial. I felt some of what DeChristopher felt as the jury walked out of the courtroom; an overwhelming rush of emotions, an unmeasurable mixture of fear, pride, disgust, and anxiousness. Your mind begins to play out scenarios of what the jurors are thinking, saying to each other and how they will rule... will they weigh in only on the judge's instructions or will their hearts prohibit them from delivering a miscarriage of justice? These questions and the various outcomes dance in your mind, you sweat, you're pretty sure you can actually feel the weight of the world on your shoulders, and all you can do is wait. You may try to deal with the waiting quietly while some of your friends are protesting outside with placards with your name on them, others are blogging and tweeting updates and rallying support on the web, some pray, some cry, some yell, some sing.

When the verdict was returned yesterday at 4pm EST, the nation gasped. The Internet then jerked like a knee struck by a mallet, tweets saturated the web with court updates, info on climate change, and links to photos of the pristine parcels adjacent to Utah's Arches and Canyonlands National Parks that DeChristopher allegedly placed bids upon. What was, to some, mere campaigning rhetoric and well crafted sloganeering all of a sudden became a harsh reality. We were literally fighting for our futures, and Tim DeChristopher was one of our first voluntary casualties.

"I understand that prison is a very horrible place, but I have been scared for my future for a long time and I think the scariest thing that I see is staying on the path that we are on now. Obedience, to me, is far scarier then going to prison," - DeChristopher told the New York Times.

Some people doubt whether or not they can risk their own freedom to fight for what is right. I submit to you that most people don't plan to do so until the moment of action presents itself upon them and its only then they understand the fate they are about to choose. Such was the case for Tim DeChristopher. When he entered that BLM auction room he did not have a premeditated plan, he did not have a specific criminal intent, all he brought with him that day was his backpack filled with books from school and a dream of a peaceful, more sustainable future, for the earth and the human and non-human animals that share it. He was lead to a table with registration forms, handed a paddle with the number 70 on it and directed to the bidding room. Perhaps without even realizing it DeChristopher's confidence and creativity had placed him in a seat directly between the pristine Utah parcels slated for lease and the vampiric oilmen who sought them. ...He raised his paddle.

2011-03-04-TimHP2.jpg

This moment was more then a crossroads for DeChristopher personally, it was also a crossroads for the global movement of climate change activists, DeChristopher chose to act and his creative response put a bookmark in the history of unbridled industrialism and wanton disregard for the natural world. His selfless act of non-violent, creative, civil disobedience provided a refreshing break in the monotony of typical protests. His actions highlighted the power of a single individual to challenge injustice wherever we see it, whenever we see it, with whatever resources are available to us. Tim DeChristopher did more then challenge the illegal sale of BLM properties, he opened our eyes, he set a fire inside our hearts.

Tim has shown the power of civil disobedience to shine a light -- the government should be giving him a medal, not a sentence, and in time this will be recalled as a key early battle in the century's long fight for a livable climate.

Just in case the federal government thinks that it's intimidating people into silence with this kind of prosecution, think again. In fact, this is precisely the sort of event that reminds us just why we need a real, mass mobilization to stop the climate crisis. - Statement from Bill McKibben on 350.org

The guilty verdict levied against DeChristopher is only a victory for the prosecution if it creates a chilling effect on the activist community. The case against DeChristopher has indeed had the opposite effect, the activist community has been invigorated by this weeks events, by the outpouring of solidarity, and by the subsequent mainstreaming of the climate change narrative. DeChristopher and his supporters have shown us that together they are strong and the fire that Tim set in their hearts when he raised that paddle is a fire that is spreading. The following are Tim DeChristopher's words as he walked out of the courthouse yesterday.

"Everything that went on inside that building tried to convince me that I was alone, and that I was weak. They tried to convince me that I was like a little finger, out there on my own, that can easily be broken. And all of you out here were the reminder, for all of us, that I was... connected to a hand, with many fingers, that could unite as one fist. And that fist could not be broken by the power in there... All those authorities in there wanted me think like a finger. But our children are calling to us, to think like a fist."


Be a part of Tim's vision, please visit http://peacefuluprising.org

To get involved with the global movement to stop the climate crisis, please visit http://350.org.

Learn about government repression of environmentalists, please visit http://greenisthenewred.com.

To donate to the Tim DeChristopher legal defense fund, please visit http://bidder70.org.

 

Follow Andy Stepanian on Twitter: www.twitter.com/sparrowmedia

 
 
  • Comments
  • 22
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
09:21 AM on 03/08/2011
Your concerns and emotional reactions to the illegal actions of this protester do you little credit. There is really not the slightest reason to be unusually concerned about the future. In fact that future is arguably more promising now, and for more people in more countries, than it has ever been before. Try to imagine yourself seeing that - what would you do with yourself then? How would you seek to live and contribute to the big adventure?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Andy Stepanian
12:13 PM on 03/08/2011
An exponential increase in the extinction of species in the past 100 years, the stalling of north atlantic gyres, the acidification of mid-ocean surface waters with carbonic acid, bleaching of topsoils, food shortages, and rapid population growth are all things to be concerned about.

No one is trying to be chicken little, but unless people fight for their futures we and our children will inherit a damaged one.

Things can and will get better, yes, but things don't get better without work.
09:41 AM on 03/09/2011
I can give you an even longer list of things to be concerned about, Andy. Imagine the progress that might be made with them if the enormous diversion of energy and attention to the whimsical but doomladen fantasy that CO2 is a major influence on climate. At least 30 years have passed with this speculation taking centre stage for not only environmentalists, but also those concerned with the development of the poorest countries. A tragic distraction on a global scale.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Malcolm Hensley
Last of the Reagan Republicans
12:51 AM on 03/07/2011
On one side we have the NIMBY environmentalist, on the other side we have big energy!
The working poor is caught in the middle and has no chance! Someone save them!

Think about it; when a large corporation closes a manufacturing factory here who really gets hurt disproportionately more?

There are all kinds of economic theories including that old British Empire theory on Free Trade that the winners are the ones that get away with treating their environment and citizens/workers the worse win!

Let me give you an Economic Definition. The nations with the cheapest energy gets more jobs for its poor than the other nations!

Let me introduce you to another Theorem! The nations with the highest energy cost will imprison more of their minorities than nations with cheap energy! Nations with the lowest energy cost will raise their minorities out of poverty faster than nations with the highest energy cost!

People think education is the first rung out of poverty. That would be wrong! Education is the second rung out of poverty! The first rung since the start of the industrial revolution has been that entry level factory job!

NIMBY environmentalist think by raising our energy cost and going to Green Energy they will save the planet! All they did is transfer the pollution and jobs.

Now my NIMBY environmentalist friends explain to me, a working man, since Asia between 2000-2007 (that's prerecession) singlehandedly increased coal consumption over 50% planetwide, how this saves the Planet?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Andy Stepanian
04:47 PM on 03/07/2011
This is about total liberation, and total justice. Demanding an end to unsustainable futures, and in that space allowing for an economy to develop around alternatives. No one wants to cost others jobs, or divert them elsewhere, no one wants a racially disparate prison industrial complex.

Tim was not a NIMBY activist, he did not want oil and gas development anywhere. He just chose to act locally to affect global change.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Malcolm Hensley
Last of the Reagan Republicans
01:28 AM on 03/08/2011
First off thank you for replying to my post.

Second thank you for admitting we instead of entry level factory jobs have set up a racially disparate prison industrial complex. Most of my environmentalist friends when confronted with the fact that higher energy cost has helped shaped our racially disparate prison system try and deny it!

I've broken down the basic cost of dirty fossil fuel energy and have come to the conclusion you can't compete in a free trade environment with green energy!

Anyone who says they can is either delusional or mathematically challenged!

I think it is time to steal some of the poor working Tea Party members away with Environmental taxes and tariffs on products sold here based on their environmental footprint! Include things like sustainability, manufacturing emissions footprint, and transportation emissions footprint.

These encourage local manufacturing! Tell me does it really make sense to grow cotton in California, ship it to Asia to be made into shirts and shipped back to California and across the country?
02:53 AM on 03/06/2011
Wow. What a good, noble man. Thank you, Andy, for so eloquently highlighting his courage. Is it people like him and you who inspire us all to do and be more.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Andy Stepanian
04:48 AM on 03/06/2011
Thanks so much Rory! There is so much that all of us can do, and Tim has lead by a great example. Please tell everyone about http://350.org and http://peacefuluprising.org
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Margery Kempe
Raised by wolves. Phd in
04:32 PM on 03/05/2011
Why is this story not on the front page? Come on Huffies! This one is BIG.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Andy Stepanian
06:01 PM on 03/05/2011
Thanks Margery!

Send them an email. I am thankful they let this story go up intact. If any story goes on the front page I hope it is the Bill McKibbon article.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/bill-mckibben/tim-dechristopher-taking_b_831163.html
02:00 AM on 03/05/2011
It's time for all of us to reread Naomi Wolf's Blueprint ( http://www.huffingtonpost.com/naomi-wolf/ten-steps-to-close-down-a_b_46695.html ) because the conviction of DeChristopher was another blow to democracy. They are coming fast now. The noose is tightening. It's time to get to work!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Andy Stepanian
10:02 AM on 03/05/2011
Naomi Wolf has some amazing critiques, I would suggest people who are interested check out this link. Similarly, you should also check out Will Potter's work over at http://greenisthenewred.com
08:24 PM on 03/04/2011
Beautifully written essay, Andy. Most people still do not even know Tim's story. So Keep on writing!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Andy Stepanian
10:00 AM on 03/05/2011
You should write an article for Newsday! Can we get together one day soon? I'd love to come by and say whats up too!
05:31 PM on 03/04/2011
Typical American justice, one version for the rich and powerful bereft of decency and conscience who appear to get away with murder and recklessly sabotage the economy, people's jobs and future and one for the small guy who is just trying to protect our public lands from despicable abuse.
Not one person has gone to prison after achieving what Al-Queda could only dream about.Not one head rolls when financial institutions, bankers and speculators screw over the system with total disregard for the damage they caused.They even get rewarded with a bailout so they can still pursue their lavish lifestyles.
One man who unselfishly tries to disrupt these corrupt,manipulating and greedy corporate monsters from desecrating our precious lands gets sent to prison purely for pissing them off.This country's standards of justice are very quickly going down the drain and the chance of a healthy American future is looking very grim.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Andy Stepanian
09:59 AM on 03/05/2011
People like DeChristopher help to redefine justice and help keep democracy in check. I would not loose hope when fighting for justice, just expect to get your hands dirty as we go through these changes.
03:55 PM on 03/04/2011
Love this, we need to bring the power back to the people to save the environment, animals, children s future. Let's get this viral all across the US!!!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Andy Stepanian
09:56 AM on 03/05/2011
Thanks Dominique!

Agreed, lets try to make this issue viral!
Genders
Love, Tolerance, Enlightenment
03:49 PM on 03/04/2011
All he had to do, was to create a company and a web site to raise money from investors to pay for the bid. Other companies have done that.
10:02 PM on 03/04/2011
He did just that. They had (after much asking) the money together to make the initial payment, and their payment was refused. THAT little bit of information was left out of the trial, because the judge felt it would "confuse" the jury.
Genders
Love, Tolerance, Enlightenment
02:04 AM on 03/05/2011
Wow, do you have link?