iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Ann Brenoff

GET UPDATES FROM Ann Brenoff
 

The Video That Was A Dagger To A Working Mom's Heart

Posted: 06/21/2012 10:08 am

I've always been a working woman and my segue to becoming a working mom was easy. I never even considered an alternative. When my husband and I adopted our two children from China -- they were 5 and 4 years old at the time -- I took the barest minimum of unpaid family leave and returned to work.

It was a necessity, I told myself. A financial necessity and a personal one. We certainly needed my salary. And while I was absolutely ready to be a mother, I wasn't ready to give up the job that I loved dearly, the career success that I had painstakingly sought and achieved.

I felt confident that with a supportive spouse, I could do it all. I deposited my kids in preschool and went back to work. My husband became the stay-at-home parent who attended daytime school events, drove the kids to soccer practice and fixed them their after-school snacks. And with a few notable exceptions -- Dads are lousy hair braiders for ballet rehearsals -- everything was chugging along smoothly until I watched my son's 5th grade graduation video, a professionally produced 45-minute "documentary" made by one of the school dads.

The video showed me what I've been missing, which is everything.

The video completely captured my son's school experience from kindergarten through fifth grade. Beautifully set to music with happy, smiling kids in every frame, there was only one thing wrong: It was mostly all news to me.

While the other parents in the audience watched, hoping to catch a shot of their children, I was busy asking my husband things like, "When did he dress up like a penguin?" That happened in kindergarten when they were studying the Arctic, he told me. All I knew at the time was that I had to make sure he had a white shirt and black pants to wear to school that day. I don't think I ever knew what it was for.

I missed the school jogathon two years in a row. I missed the 2009 and 2010 school Halloween parades and the 2011 holiday concert. I have missed every Thanksgiving class party since second grade. I can't count how many colonial re-enactments, oral book reports, teacher appreciation days, computer class powerpoint presentations, art shows, annual makings of gingerbread houses, field trips, science projects, morning concerts and class plays that I've missed. It's fair to say many of them. I also haven't been a classroom volunteer since my now high school-aged daughter was in second grade; I relinquished my weekly 45 minutes in the classroom to a stay-at-home mom who could be counted on to show up more faithfully.

The events I did manage to attend each required scheduling acrobatics. Early work starts, late finishes, skipping lunch, calling in favors of colleagues to cover for me. I call them my deals with the devil: If you let me go watch my son play his cello, I promise to work at home until midnight and never ask again -- or at least not again this month. And so it's been for the six years of my son's academic life and the nine years of my daughter's.

Working moms, we are a hardy lot. We function on little sleep and begin our second fulltime job when the closing bell for the first one sounds. We hope that our bosses don't notice when we dash out the door abruptly to watch our sons pitch in Little League or when we need to meet the school bus. We live in a perpetual state of guilt: Guilty when we are work because we aren't with the kids, and guilty when we are with the kids instead of being at work.

Truth is, the school day and the work day collide and working parents miss stuff. We try our best -- and in our family's case, my husband was the constant attendee. We make up for what we miss the best we can; oral book reports, concerts and first-dives off the high board are taped so Mom can watch them after work. But let's face it: It's not the same as being there. Not for the kids and, as the 5th grade graduation video showed me, not for me.

Maybe this is how suburban dads felt in the 1950s and 1960s: They left for work in the early morning on the commuter train and came home long after the kids were fed and put to bed. They were the breadwinners and there was little time for anything else. Relationships with their kids were built on weekends and they frequently didn't even know the names of their children's teachers.

Maybe they got used to it. It's clear to me I haven't.

 

Follow Ann Brenoff on Twitter: www.twitter.com/AnnBrenoff

FOLLOW PARENTS
I've always been a working woman and my segue to becoming a working mom was easy. I never even considered an alternative. When my husband and I adopted our two children from China -- they were 5 and 4...
I've always been a working woman and my segue to becoming a working mom was easy. I never even considered an alternative. When my husband and I adopted our two children from China -- they were 5 and 4...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 697
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (16 total)
08:44 AM on 07/12/2012
It is great that the author's husband was able to take care of the kids. So many families don't have that option. I think she is doing a great job of pointing out what a great privilege her husband has to be the primary caregiver. The stereotypical stay-at-home parent who is bored and frazzled and can't wait to get back to her/his career is sad. Being a stay-at-home parent is a worthy profession (and can be fun with the right support) and the more MEN who feel empowered to do this job, the better off we will all be.
10:21 PM on 07/01/2012
Thank a lot, Brenoff, for setting working women back. My husband is a stay at home Dad, and he too gets to see/attend all the things that I don't get to do, but I at least know what's going on. I pay attention when there is a school event, even if I can't attend. And my husband sends pics of the event to me at work, even if I can't attend (which is quite often). Why were/are you so inattentive or distracted as to what was/is going on with your kids every day? I may not be able to be there for every event, but I get as much info as I can whether it's the pics, or getting details from my husband or asking my kids about the events. say, at our family dinner that night. The way I look at it, if it's not me staying at home with my kids, the next best person is my husband, their father. Your article sounds like if you work, you miss everything, and in reality, it's NOT like that, unless that is what you choose.
09:03 PM on 06/30/2012
What a heartfelt and assessment of the life of a working parent. I have been lucky to work from home and attend many school functions, but I coach women who are not as lucky as I am. They (like you) love their jobs and are great at doing their jobs - it seems to me that no matter the choice, there are some missed experiences and to deny that is true just makes it worse. Being honest about the realities and celebrating all that is working in our lives is the best combo. Thanks for sharing your experience. Jamee Tenzer, shesarealmother.com
10:17 PM on 06/25/2012
When I was pregnant with our 2nd son (who is now 6 months old, the other kid is 6.5 years old) my husband was working a physically demanding night shift job with a 2 hour daily commute. We struggled with whether I would go back to work after my 3 month maternity leave was up. I was working full time before the baby was born. We decided that I would go back part-time, and it was honestly the best decision we could have made. I truly feel like I have a perfect work/life balance, and my employer is so flexible that if I need to come in late or leave early it's not an issue.

I was a stay-at-home mom when my now 6.5 year old was a baby, and I didn't enjoy it. I wasn't organized enough to get him out of the house to play groups and parks, I felt guilty all the time for not contributing to the household finances, I felt isolated, and was just bored most of the time. That situation was not beneficial to either one of us. I know a lot of women don't have the same choice, and we all have different wants and needs for our families- but I highly recommend considering a part-time schedule for women struggling with the decision on whether or not to return to work.
08:24 PM on 06/25/2012
I think this article if very unfair to working women. Not all working women miss out on their childrens school activites like this mom. I am a working mother of 3 and I have never missed a play, an award ceremony, field trip, baseball practice or baseball game. My children come first. I use my vacation time for such days. It is all about balance and choices. I choose my children each time. Just because I work to contribute to my family does not mean I will miss the important things.
04:15 PM on 06/25/2012
If you have to work then you have to work. If you have the luxury of staying at home, then good for you.

But for those people who have to work in order to feed, clothe and shelter themselves and their children (not for lots of foreign holidays and expensive cars - but to LIVE) stop beating yourself up about what can't be and make sure that the time you CAN spend with them is quality time.

If you make time for your children whenever you can they will keep that with them and remember that you worked - for them, why else would you work?
03:05 PM on 06/25/2012
I think you should take solace in the fact that your hard work made your children's school experience so wonderful. Children seldom recognize the full extent of the sacrifice their parents make for them before they themselves become parents. You are the chef, your children the dinners who feast from your bounty.
02:53 PM on 06/25/2012
Here is my take on this! Both women and men need to stop feeling guilty about putting their children in childcare or staying at home. From this whole conversation I hear people contemplating the fact their kids will be upset for missing a ball game or that the parents feel guilty they missed an event. Only the lucky five percent of the world does not have to work! The rest of the 95 percent must! In a time when there is child labor not only in the developing world, but also in the US, people need to be thankful that they can provide for their children. Fifty to 100 years ago, most kids were running the streets in the US, because parents worked. Were parents scared? Yes, but they weren't complaining about what they missed rather they explained to their kids what was going on. Most kids understood. Later as adults, these very same kids respected their parents for their sacrifices. Therefore, SAHM and working parents, stop giving each other the finger and start respecting each other. I'm tired of both sides BS! If parents can't raise their children to see reason and be respect people, then they failed a major milestone! Remember the older generation had famine, wars and depression! We are in the land of milk and honey! Stop gripping about it!
01:35 PM on 06/25/2012
I was a single mom that chose to work my butt off to provide for my children....that is the biggest regret that I have. My children did not get enough of my time, babysitters were undependable, daycare was too costly, and my children did not have the supervision that they needed. I was so tired and spent when I got home there just wasnt enough of me to go around. My children are grown now. My 25 year old works and insists that his wife stay home with their 7 month old. My 23 year old is expecting her first and is wrestling with whether or not to just work part time. I found that working interfered in my marriage as well. Currently I am not working for the first time in a long time and I love it. Not only do I have time for my children, but also my husband and my grandchildren as well. I am going to go back to school. There are many times when I do things with my family now...that I stop and think...if I was working I wouldnt be able to be doing this right now. The problem with money is ....the more you make ...the more you spend and the more things tend to cost you. Life is about memories....not money. Time is something that can never be replaced.
12:31 PM on 06/25/2012
Every family has to do what they feel is right for their family. If one parent feels guilty, maybe something can be worked out to change this. I was with my kids at home & didn't miss a single thing....I am blessed. My husband on the other hand, now that the boys are 21 & 25, knows what he missed. But all along, I kept reminding him they weren't getting any younger, but he kept being a workholic...he now has to live with that guilt.
11:27 AM on 06/25/2012
I overheard an expenctant mother saying yesterday - I think my prents will take care of the baby when it's born...I'm going back to work. Farming out your kids and dropping them off at an insitution (daycare) isnt being a parent,I wouldnt have kids then. We do without a lot but I dont want to miss being a PARENT! i understand there are some situations, but the majority is selfish parents that jsut farm the kids out to daycare or someone else to keep up with the Joneses.
11:55 AM on 06/25/2012
Guilty as charged! (drop my son off to daycare and run away). Oh but they still call me when he's sick or got hurt or needs something. Because I'm the PARENT. Gag.
12:27 PM on 06/25/2012
Sick hurt or needs something? Only if it's urgent, plenty of boo boos and upset tummies or "gag" needs of that child go untended to everyday.......so the kids are left to fend for themselves so they are taught self reliance, one of the reasons teenagers need so damn much attention that they go to strangers to get it, on the internet or in their community.....a predators dream!
09:09 PM on 06/25/2012
some people have to work not just to keep up with the Joneses. you can consider yourself lucky that you were able to stay home and have your husband support you. But some of us have to contribute to the household. I never miss a play, field trip or sporting event ever. You can choose to take time off from work to be part of these things instead of missing them like the writer in this article. You should stop being so critical and realize everyone has to do what is best for their family. Daycare is not an institution but can be a learning loving place where kids can build friendships. why are mothers constantly bashing each other instead of supporting each other?Being a mom is the rewarding experience filled with guilt no matter if you work or not work. We should all be there to support each other with encouragement instead of making ignorant statements.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bethanese
I may argue with stupid, but not with crazy.
11:05 AM on 06/25/2012
And the war continues. Either way people are going to stick up for their own choices. It gets us nowhere. How about doing the best you can with what you have and setting a good example for your child whether you choose to stay at home or go to work? I really feel for those who don't have a choice; those who want to stay at home but need to work, or those who want to work but can't. If you did your part on the "nurture" end of "nature vs. nurture," then you can only hope that your child will understand that you did what was best for your family when he/she is old enough to make his/her own choices. I appreciate everything my mother did for me, regardless of whether she was a SAHM or a working mom. I still appreciate the things she does for me now that I have a child of my own. And it has nothing to do whether or not she was home during the day.
12:36 PM on 06/25/2012
Sorry, but its hard to sit back and say nothing when society is becoming "the Lord of the Flies"....where kids are left to raise themselves, and learn through the media how to act..oh the horror! It's very simple, you want kids? RAISE THEM! I am all for women in the workplace, just not mothers of minor children.
01:29 PM on 06/25/2012
Hey austinKID, the father was a stay-at-home in this article. Don't put the ENTIRE weight of child-rearing on women. I see nothing wrong with either parent working and the other staying at home regardless of whether they are male or female.
01:39 PM on 06/25/2012
I am a woman and I agree 100%. Mothers of minor children should be at home and the fathers of those children should be working like real men to support the women being able to be at home. The greatest gift a man can give to a child is to show respect for their mother.
10:32 AM on 06/25/2012
I had to return to work when my youngest was 3, because I became a single mom. They are now 7 & 12. Last week was my girls' final week of school. On Monday I pick up my girls from the sitter and my youngest is whinny and mad. After trying to ignore her bad attitude for about an hour I finally asked, Why are you in such a bad mood? Did something happen? Well I got an answer .... "It's all your fault mom. You were the ONLY parent that didn't come today. Your ALWAYS the only parent that doesn't come!" It was true and hurtful but she's right. I couldn't be there because I have to work, I am the ONLY income to support the household. It still doesn't make it right. Even though I pay for my children I rely on someone else to raise my children, help mold them into the person they will become. Why have we allowed society to dictate that we only have to PAY for them, not actually raise them?

Sorry but I blame mom's like the one above that thinks it's better to have money, stuff, and social standings than to actually WORK as a mom and raise their kids. Sure you can PAY for them but WHY do you have them? To show off their pictures while your at the office? To help your own social status and look what i got? Obviously you didn't want to actually raise them.
10:47 AM on 06/25/2012
Spare me. The world at large will shape your kids, whether you like it or not.
02:07 PM on 06/25/2012
you are right, everything your children come into contact with will shape who they will become.  But your not there to help them navigate through it!  You offer NO emotional support or navigation because your at work. You are willingly allowing culture, that you are out of tune with because your at work, to shape your children. No concern what they are learning or doing? You wouldn't WANT to know these things??? You don't mind paying for them but you do mind having to take out the time to actually DO something for or with them?  So whatever they see or do just let chance and circumstance have it's will ..... BUT NO WAY would you let you finical security and work status fall to circumstance!!!
11:24 AM on 06/25/2012
well said.
08:49 AM on 06/25/2012
I know it's difficult, but try not to internalize the guilt. I'm a young mother and I'm still deciding whether I will continue with a career or take a few years off/freelance while they're young. The same people who make statements about selfish working mothers are the ones who will turn around and judge women who stayed home and were thrown under the bus in a divorce. Things aren't as simple as they once were.
12:29 PM on 06/25/2012
Well said. It's not always a matter of selfishness. For me, it's school loans I still have, and my husband and I just purchased a home. We are planning to start a family very soon, and he inparticular isn't comfortable with me staying at home just yet. We're hoping that will be possible once the kids are in school so I can be home for them after school and take them to activities and supervise their homework, etc. We figure, better to be 'more' there for them when they hit school years and need more guidanice as they get older. It's not ideal, but financially, it's what makes sense for us.
12:38 PM on 06/25/2012
It is not impossible to be a full time mother.
02:35 PM on 06/25/2012
^^It's not desired in every case, nor should it be. Everyone is an individual, remember.
07:28 AM on 06/25/2012
I have missed out on things also because I worked for some companies/people that would not let me take off time from work, especially one who made comments all the time about me being 5 minutes late coming in in the morning or coming back from lunch which was 1/2 hour. Where the heck can you go in a half hour time. I finally stopped taking lunch so I wouldn't hear anything. I work for a great person now that doesn't watch the clock.