More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Arlene M. Roberts

Arlene M. Roberts

Posted: May 14, 2010 04:55 PM

Dishonorable Discharge: Stop the Deportation of U.S. War Veterans

What's Your Reaction:

There is no greater sacrifice than putting your life on the line for your country - even when it's your adopted homeland. So why are there so many non-citizen war veterans being deported after giving years of service in multiple wars?

Citizenship is not a prerequisite for military service, and there is little distinction as legal permanent residents (green card holders) engage in combat alongside citizens. Upon re-entry into the United States, legal permanent residents follow the same procedures as citizens, and are not inspected by immigration officials. But according to Banished Veterans, there are approximately 2,000 to 3,000 non-citizen veterans facing deportation.

Rohan Coombs is one such non-citizen veteran. Born in Jamaica, West Indies, Mr. Coombs came to the United States at the age of thirteen as a legal permanent resident. Some time after graduation from high school, Mr. Coombs enlisted in the Marine Corps and was given assurances from his recruiter that he would be on the path to citizenship. Mr. Coombs gave six years of service to the Marine Corps, from 1987 to 1993, and was deployed during the Persian Gulf War. Upon his return, however, he suffered from Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) and began using marijuana. Subsequently, he was charged with possession of marijuana for sale and sentenced to prison. Three months into his sentence, Mr. Coombs signed a plea agreement on the advice of his counsel, in the hopes of reducing his sentence to eight months, but was totally unaware of the deportation consequences. Now Mr. Coombs sits in El Centro, a detention facility operated by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) in San Diego, California as he awaits deportation to Jamaica, even though he has resided in the United States for almost thirty years.

Mr. Coombs' attorney, Craig Shagin, has filed an appeal on his behalf. According to Mr. Shagin, "There is something in American law known as a non-citizen national, and it's our position that veterans--that is, anybody who serves in the United States military--from the moment they take the oath of allegiance, is in fact a non-citizen national. The reason for that is that when they go overseas in uniform, they are in fact treated under both American law, international law, and the law of war as American nationals. That is, they're putting on the emblem and the insignia of the United States. "

Non-citizen veterans like Mr. Coombs need treatment for their disabilities, not a ticket out of the country.

 

Follow Arlene M. Roberts on Twitter: www.twitter.com/arlenemroberts

 
 
  • Comments
  • 4
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
spytheweb
11:37 PM on 05/16/2010
If you serve in the military and are not a US citizen, you're just a hired gun. The fact that this guy has been in the US for almost 30 years yet did nothing to become a US citizen shows just how much he wanted to become a citizen.

There are many illegals here that have been in the US for 10, 20 years yet still can not speak english. They do not want to become US citizens, they just want to live and work here and take advantage of the system. These illegals think once they cross the border that they are in fact US citizens.

My wife is from Korea. She can speak, read and write english and she wanted to become a US citizen, and she did. She had to be interviewed, take a test and Oath of Allegiance to the United States of America. Besides a security and medical clearances. This is the law.

It's bad news that veterans are being deported. My advice to anyone who comes here and is thinking about staying, start thinking about what you have to do to become a citizen and don't put it on the backburner thinking it will take care of itself.
04:44 PM on 05/24/2010
There are many people in Mr. Coombs' situation. He should not suffer such an unjust result for actions that were unfortunate actions on his part.
11:15 PM on 05/30/2010
What is more "unjust"? That this man was illegal and was informed that he was legal, because he joined the military -- and that there are people out there, using this as a tool toward amnesty -- or that this man, after being discharged from the military for whatever reason, decided to become involved in the drug trade, smuggling 1,600 pounds (1 1/4 tons) of marijuana over the border, using his PTSD as a lame excuse to get involved in drugs? If that was the case, every one of our soldiers would have gotten involved with drugs, but instead, there are the strong and there are the weak. The weak will make the wrong choices and blame those choices on anyone other than themselves, whereas the strong are survivors and overcome whatever adversity or unfortunate situations may come upon them.
11:09 PM on 05/30/2010
For one, you cannot serve in the military unless you are a citizen of the U.S., unless you are a foreign spy or something of that nature. My husband was a recruiter and has stated that all official documentation is required in order to enlist, including a person's birth certificate, high school transcript / GED, Driver's License / State I.D. and a background check is done.