iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Ben Greenfield

GET UPDATES FROM Ben Greenfield
 

Why Crunches Don't Work -- Plus 10 Ways to Flat Abs

Posted: 03/ 1/2012 6:25 am

Imagine your spine is a credit card. In the same way that repeatedly flexing and extending a credit card will eventually lead to wearing out of the plastic, repeatedly doing crunches can put damaging strain on your back.

Here's why:

Each of your spinal discs is only able to support a limited number of bending motions over the course of your lifetime before you get low back pain, a disc bulge or a disc herniation.

And since crunches involve lying on your back and repeatedly bending and extending your spinal credit card, they place excessive strain on the part of your low back that has the most nerves and is most prone to wear and tear.

Perhaps you've heard that if you pick a heavy object off the ground, and you don't want to hurt your spine, you should "Bend at the knees, and not at the back." But think about crunches this way: Anytime you do a crunch, you're bending at the back -- over and over and over again!

And that's not all: A crunch simply doesn't burn as many calories as necessary for you to get rid of any fat that is obscuring your stomach muscles -- so it's an inefficient way to get your gut looking good.

Ultimately, there are better ways to get a flat stomach. Here are my top 10 crunch alternatives that will avoid back pain and burn many more calories than crunches. For each exercise, choose a weight that allows you to do 10-15 repetitions and click on the exercise name for a demonstration.

Crunch Alternative #10 -- Cable Torso Twists
In a standing position with your feet firmly planted and knees slightly bent, hold a cable or elastic band at arm's length (keep your arms straight) and twist your body. To do this exercise properly, imagine your bellybutton pointing straight forward, then rotate your bellybutton approximately 30 degrees.

Crunch Alternative #9 -- Woodchopper
In a standing position, hold a dumbbell, medicine ball, elastic band or cable above your body and to the side of your shoulder, and diagonally rotate with extended arms from above your shoulder, down and across your body to the outside of your hips -- just as if you were holding an axe and chopping a block of wood. Also, try "reverse woodchoppers," which is the same motion in the opposite direction.

Crunch Alternative #8 - Front Planks
Get into a belly-down position with your elbows bent and your body supported by just your forearms and your toes. This is a popular position that you'll see in yoga and Pilates. From here, you can simply hold this plank position, or you can tap your feet or alternate between reaching with each arm.

Crunch Alternative #7 -- Side Planks
Get into a similar position as a front plank but support yourself on one arm, so that your bellybutton is turned to the side. You can simply hold this position, or you can also do more advanced exercises like raising a dumbbell with your non-supporting arm or rotations.

Crunch Alternative #6 -- Stability Ball Plank
If your forearms don't like the front plank position, the stability ball plank is a great option. Simply put your shins or toes up on a stability ball and support the rest of your body in a pushup position with your hands.

Crunch Alternative #5 -- Stability Ball Knee to Chest
After you've mastered the stability ball plank position, try pulling the ball closer to you by bending your knees to your chest, then extending your legs back into the starting position.

Crunch Alternative #4 -- Stability Ball Pike
For an even harder stability ball move, try pikes, in which you start in a stability ball plank position and then point your butt up towards the sky in a capital letter A position while keeping your legs as straight as possible.

Crunch Alternative #3 -- Bridges
As I wrote in "How to Get a Flat Stomach," when you exercise your abs, you also need to maintain your low back strength. You can do a low back strengthening bridge by lying on your back, then pushing your hips up towards the sky while keeping your feet flat on the ground. For more advanced variations, try a single leg bridge or a stability ball bridge.

Crunch Alternative #2 -- Medicine Ball Side Throws
These last two exercises are a bit more ballistic and athletic, but great for building abdominal strength. Grab a medicine ball, which is one of those small but very heavy balls you can find at the gym, and then find an area of the gym where you have a solid wall. Twist your body to one side and then twist back and throw the ball against the wall. Catch, then repeat. Once you've completed a series of throws for one side, face the other direction and complete another set of throws for the opposite side. These are very similar to cable torso twists, except you're throwing an object.

Crunch Alternative #1 -- Medicine Ball Slams
I've saved the best exercise for last. Hold the medicine ball overhead, then slam it into the ground as hard as you can, while keeping your abs tight and breathing out. This exercise is also a fantastic stress-reliever.

Now that you know 10 ways to avoid crunches, you'll never have to strain your credit card again -- and that's good advice for the one in your wallet, too.

Ben Greenfield is a fitness and triathlon expert and host of the Get-Fit Guy podcast on the Quick and Dirty Tips network. His book, "Get-Fit Guy's Guide to Achieving Your Ideal Body -- A Workout Plan for Your Unique Shape," will be published by St. Martin's Press in May 2012.

For more by Ben Greenfield, click here.

For more on fitness and exercise, click here.

 

Follow Ben Greenfield on Twitter: www.twitter.com/GetFitGuy

Imagine your spine is a credit card. In the same way that repeatedly flexing and extending a credit card will eventually lead to wearing out of the plastic, repeatedly doing crunches can put damaging ...
Imagine your spine is a credit card. In the same way that repeatedly flexing and extending a credit card will eventually lead to wearing out of the plastic, repeatedly doing crunches can put damaging ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 48
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jgarma
02:05 PM on 03/05/2012
Agree that all these alternatives to crunches are better for toning the abs, and that's because they each utilize more muscles than do simple crunches.

The more muscles you employ to do an exercise, the more muscle you develop, the more calories you use and the more your metabolism gets amped up.

The bottom line for producing strong abs is to work the core, as these alt. exercises do. But to blast away the fat that covers the abs, you need to do more than work the core. Need to work the entire body, particularly the largest muscles -- legs, glutes, back, best -- by employing compound exercises.

Compound exercises are those that work several muscle groups simultaneously, like the Olympic "clean and jerk" (lifting a weight from off the floor to overhead). Such exercise boosts human growth hormone production in the body, burn fat and increase metabolism.

Check out "How To Boost Your Human Growth Hormone in 20 Minutes!" http://wp.me/pA04z-UZ
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cyrus Trance
America is not a theocracy.
08:52 PM on 03/04/2012
"Each of your spinal discs is only able to support a limited number of bending motions over the course of your lifetime before you get low back pain, a disc bulge or a disc herniation."

Discs lose hydration over time and as you age they can form small tears in the annulus fibrosus. There are no studies that show this is because a disc has a set number of movements.

"And since crunches involve lying on your back and repeatedly bending and extending your spinal credit card, they place excessive strain on the part of your low back that has the most nerves and is most prone to wear and tear."

Then you better never do yoga or pre workout stretching.

BTW, people who do regular exercise have healthier spines.

"Perhaps you've heard that if you pick a heavy object off the ground, and you don't want to hurt your spine, you should "Bend at the knees, and not at the back."

Because extremely heavy weights can cause the spine to go into forced flexion putting more stress on the posterior longitudinal ligament. The PLL is weaker posterior to the discs and heavy weights can induce a bulge. Conversely, doing crunches strengthens muscles without putting excessive strain on the PLL.

If you have a spinal injury chances are your physical therapist will put you on a exercise program that includes flexion of the spine.

You do not know what you are talking about.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:40 PM on 03/04/2012
Since the initial premise regarding the back is incorrect, who can say if the rest of the advice has any validity.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kahunacook
Takin' my time, choosin' my lines
05:31 PM on 03/02/2012
While I have used most of the "alternative" exercises listed above I still do crunches. The initial premise proposed here based on the spine having a set number of "bends" allocated to it is flawed. One could easily take that theory and apply it to the exercises recommended above. What makes bending any more limited than rotations? Stability ball knee to chest - the theory implies that we have a finite number of knee bends allotted. Spines, like knees and elbows, evolved to give us our range of motion, unlike the credit card, which is not made to bend.
08:34 PM on 03/02/2012
Mirf empowering the brain. Every ailment, has a micros coping beginning, imagine how small, that is, therefore; it is easy , by gently increasing blood circulation, to prevent pileup, thus preventing
the beginning of any sickness, It would be a million times easier to cure oneself then blowing of a goose feather from your arm, why, because e micro is several millions, times lighter. easy to do.
09:48 AM on 03/02/2012
Without scientific citations for the proposition, here we are again told that we have a finite and apparently specific number of repetitions of some normal function during our lifetimes and if we use them up, we are out of them. Some were claiming the same nonsense with heartbeats a while back, something like we are assigned only so many in life and if we use them up early through aerobic exercise, we die.

I've got a completely flat abdomen. And I do no crunches and none of the recommended exercises. Or any other "exercises". Deer and mountain lions have fit abdomens and they don't perform exercise routines either. They simply eat the foods and engage in activity for which they evolved. Works for humans, too. Works for me. A paleo or primal type diet with whole foods such as grassfed meats, fish, lots of vegetables, some fruit, nuts, no wheat, no dairy. Activity similar to that of my ancestors tens of thousands of years ago, trekking over hills and valleys and rough ground, carrying things, hunting-type activities.
06:26 AM on 03/02/2012
I use the moves above, but I have had even more success with kettlebell routines and sprints. Both provide the benefit of fat-burning while engaging the entire core. Adding those two things to my routine finally brought out my abs.
http://lessonsfromtheendofamarriage.com
05:29 AM on 03/02/2012
Planks hurt your back at best, I'll be sticking with crunches, sit-ups, and others that don't involve the ones noted here.
02:07 PM on 03/06/2012
Planks only hurt your back if you don't have core stability and decent spinal alignment.

That being said, the original premise is incorrect. Doing tons of crunches every day is harmful, but not because the back is flexing over and over. It's more due to the fact that the local stability muscles, the transverse abdominis and the multifidus, are being weakened by disuse. There really isn't a way to "work" those muscles except to stand and feel pre-motion muscles. They're "stability" muscles for a reason.
01:51 AM on 03/02/2012
Great post. These are exercises that will shred your abs. Thrown in some hanging leg lifts and swiss ball or barbell rollouts and you're there. Anyone who doubts these exercises should try doing a plank for 90 seconds..
noahmarder
Exposing the regressive lies, one by one
12:04 AM on 03/02/2012
None of these exercises will flatten abs. Losing excess fat will.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:43 PM on 03/04/2012
Most accurate post here. The listed exercises may indeed bring more definition to the abs. but only losing the fat will "flatten" them.
09:52 PM on 03/01/2012
Crunches are a way more efficient exercise for your abs than most of the exercises he recommends and there is definitely no preset number of times we can bend are spines before our backs start to hurt, quality over quantity, dude. Then he recommends a few exercises that involve bending your spine just as much as you would with a crunch performed properly. We all know the old expression about opinions.
photo
robear6987
oops ! did i offend you , my bad .
05:23 PM on 03/01/2012
pics would have been more descriptive and useable.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
King7David
Hoo Yah!!!!!!!
12:27 AM on 03/02/2012
I was thinking the same thing.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Economike
05:18 PM on 03/01/2012
I'm 50 and have been doing crunches since I was a teenager. I have noticed no adverse effects on my back or otherwise and they are effective for flattening the stomach.
This comment has been removed.
05:03 PM on 03/01/2012
I would like to the medical/scientific evidence that your spine only has a "limited" number of bends over your lifetime before you develop back pain, etc.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dcnashinsc
07:48 PM on 03/01/2012
I am not a doctor but I think it makes sense. I don't believe there is a certain number but there is probably a range. Like tensile strength for metals. You can bend a piece of metal so many times untile it becomes as weak as a piece of paper and you can tear it. The joints have a limit. It isn't a definite number because it depends on how well you take care of yourself and how you lift heavy loads. Everything wears out at some point.
09:15 AM on 03/02/2012
I don't buy the argument either. Crunches stay on my menu. Along with lots of other stuff.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Eric Gardner
Hoping humans evolve again...
04:52 PM on 03/01/2012
Really questionable advice and theory from a "expert". I don't see any credentials that make him an expert. Actually one of the exercises could exacerbate shoulder injuries or create them. (rotator cuff)