With tiresome predictability, the Iranian tyrant Mahmoud Ahmadinejad is again in New York for the United Nations General Assembly. And again, he is performing to type. Rambling, inchoate speeches about the decline of capitalism, facile equations of the Iran's judicial system with that of the United States, ranting about Israel -- of course! -- and a televised sit down with Charlie Rose. And Larry King.
As my colleague Kenneth Bandler argued in a recent op-ed, "no broadcast media outlet is obligated to give Ahmadinejad a platform. Some may argue about the need to protect free speech, but that's definitely not the issue. It's about the Iranian leader taking advantage of our open society to propagandize."
It's hard to believe that producers and anchors don't know that already, nor that they haven't watched their colleagues wrestle with Ahmadinejad's elasticity in the past. Really, why bother any more?
I am not suggesting that Ahmadinejad be ignored. But to indulge him in this way serves no purpose other than reinforcing his sense of immunity, at just the time that his clerical rivals are once more scheming to bring him down.
Far better to remind Ahmadinejad that the world is watching. For those in New York, there are protests - like this one outside the UN, or this one, outside the Hilton hotel where he is staying, and doubtless more besides. After all, there are plenty of reasons to protest -- most immediately the sentencing of human rights defender Shiva Nazar Ahari to six years of incarceration, just days after the regime extorted $500,000 from her family to bail her out of prison.
To protest is to recognize the futility of dialogue with Ahmadinejad, a man who, when it comes to lying, enviably blends classical totalitarianism with postmodern spin. As an interview subject, he should be left to the sort of useful idiot who thinks that a show on Ahmadinejad's mouthpiece, Press TV, is a mark of celebrity -- serious journalists need not, and should not, follow there. They would be better off investigating why a regime media outlet like Press TV is widely, and preposterously, regarded as a legitimate broadcaster.
They might find that part of the answer lies in the marketing. Press TV has quite snazzy graphics and music inflected with soul and jazz. It even waged an advertising campaign on the red double-decker buses of London -- which is its main international operating base -- using the frankly Orwellian slogan, "24/7. News. Truth."
Truth, in this case, means alternately demonizing and marginalizing the protests of the democracy movement in Iran. It means ignoring the power struggles plaguing the Iranian regime, like that between Ahmadinejad and parliament speaker Ali Larijani -- a rivalry so bitter that not even their shared enthusiasm for Holocaust denial can heal it. Above all, it means fabricating stories. Here's the JHate blog with a venerable example:
Press TV has repeated its allegation that Israelis kidnap non-Jews and harvest their organs for use as "spare parts." In a story about real allegations that some Israelis purchase kidneys on the black market in South Africa, Press TV adds that "another report" describes an Israeli plot to "kidnap children and harvest their organs." Press TV continues: "According to the report, some 25,000 Ukrainian children had been brought into Israel over the past two years to be used by Israeli medical centers for their 'spare parts.' The Israeli military is also accused of stealing the organs of Palestinian prisoners." Press TV has made this heinous allegation at least three other times.
Of course they have. This same allegation of blood libel has been around for hundreds of years -- and as Ahmadinejad himself might tell you, the old tunes are the best.
But my patience has run out. I don't want to know what Ahmadinejad had for breakfast this morning. I want to know why governments which have banned terror broadcasters like Al Manar and Al Aqsa continue to tolerate the presence of Press TV on the airwaves. And I want to know when they are going to shut it down.
Follow Ben S. Cohen on Twitter: www.twitter.com/ZWord
Ahmadinejad calls Israel's Netanyahu a 'skilled killer'
Iran's Ahmadinejad Harks Back To Koran, Cold War To Turn Tables On The West
Ahmadinejad's Media Blitz Unfolds as Young Activists Receive Harsh Sentences
Context. there are two famous soviet newspapers: Izvestiya ( news) and Pravda ( truth).
Joke: There's never nay izvestiya in Pravda, and never any pravda in Izvestiya.
Iranian official and semi-official publications like PRessTV are not any better, actually worse if you add the religious dogma and National Inquirer-like news items.
President Ahmadinejad wields almost no power. He's a figurehead spokesman for the Iranian regime. Not even the entire regime. Since Ahmadinejad has no executive powers, it is irrational for any high level Western politician to attempt a dialogue with him.
Perhaps assistant to Under-Secretary of State may meet with President Ahmadinejad as equals wielding same amount of political oomph.
Iran is a theocracy controlled mainly by those outside of the elective process.
Unfortunately, ( for Iran) those who control Iranian foreign policies, Supreme Leader and a few military figures hide in the shadow, outside of the glare of TV cameras. If fact, Supreme Leader of Iran only meets with Muslims. I think he made an exception only to meet with Russian President once.
A meeting between Supreme Leader of Iran and, say, State Sec. Clinton may be productive in bridging some of the differences between the two sides.
and this: "To protest is to recognize the futility of dialogue with Ahmadinejad, a man who, when it comes to lying, enviably blends classical totalitarianism with postmodern spin. "
if I substitute bibi . . the sense of the sentence remains the same . . . . stop with the israeli propaganda . . . . stop trying to block people from thinking . . and making up their own minds . . . you are both predictable and laughable
United States Navy test of one of its 'earthquake weapons' which was to be used against Iran, went 'horribly wrong' and caused the catastrophic quake in the Caribbean,"
An unconfirmed report from a non-existent source pitching the most preposterous nonsense.
Bravo PressTV!
http://edition.presstv.ir/detail/116834.html
The media, as a matter of morals, often act as accessory to many a crime even if their actions don’t rise to an actionable level. An accessory must have knowledge that a crime is being, or will be committed and then aide or abet in any way. In many Countries, Germany being an example, Holocaust denial is a “crime”. In the United States the first amendment goes much further in protecting hate speech than other countries. However, just because something is legal does not make it moral.
The Jewish tradition goes very far in recognizing the power of words to do harm. The Rabbis admonished concerning the harm that simple gossip may cause even when the gossip was true. As to slander which is an actionable offense it was said “Whenever a person speaks slander it is as though he denied the existence of God…Slander slays three persons – the slanderer, the person to whom it is said, and the person of whom it is spoken”(Arachin 15b)
Is it asking to much for the media to show moral restraint. These interviews are are enemy propaganda, hate speech, incitement and slander.
As to “Press TV” their actions are a crime. The organization should be shut down.
We got your first message loud and clear, censorship is freedom.
What is you next Orwellian statement? war is peace?
http://www.haaretz.com/news/diplomacy-defense/report-israeli-suspected-of-running-ukraine-organ-trafficking-ring-1.306470
Swedish Aftonbladet:
http://desertpeace.wordpress.com/2009/08/24/israeli-organ-harvesting-still-headline-news-in-sweden/
How about CBS News:
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2010/04/07/world/main6372147.shtml
Israeli connection to International Organ trafficking:
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2010/09/16/world/main6872055.shtml?tag=contentMain;contentBody
Israeli government connection:
http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0YUG/is_2_14/ai_n17208591/
Also CBS channel 9 in louisiana:
http://www.wafb.com/Global/story.asp?S=13164079
There are just too many news about illegal organ trafficking and arrests of Israelis (even seven arrested in NY) to say Press TV is the only station that is reporting on this.
Is anyone surprised?
what a miserable joke you are.
"but that's definitely not the issue. It's about the Iranian leader taking advantage of our open society to propagandize"
the whole idea behind free speech is to be able to create an open platform where ideas are heard and discussed by all. since the concept is one that has practicality at its roots, without the actualization of this idea, the idea itself becomes pointless.
also, if your "open society" needs suppression of certain ideas to "protect it's people" from the evil thoughts of ahmadinejad, perhaps it's your-own-dumb-selves that you should point the finger at.