iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Ben S. Cohen

Ben S. Cohen

Posted: June 18, 2010 02:41 PM

The Hezbo(ti)lla

What's Your Reaction:

Behind the rush to send further flotillas to the Gaza Strip, a power game between Islamists of various stripes is emerging. While Turkish, Palestinian, Iranian and Hezbollah flags have all been spotted at rallies and port side gatherings in support of the flotillistas, these scenes of apparent unity belie a more conflicted reality beneath.

Turkey's government, having cast itself as a kind of neo-Ottoman guardian of the Palestinians, is the object of much goodwill among Gazans. That has irked the Iranians, the principal sponsor of the Hamas regime, into a display of one-upmanship: Last week, Tehran announced that it was sending its own flotilla under the protection of the Iranian Navy -- a pledge it subsequently backed away from.

Not to be outdone, the Syrian dictator, Bashar al-Assad, seized on the recent flotilla clash to start beating the drums of war. In an interview with the BBC, Assad said that the Israeli raid on the Mavi Marmara had ruled out any prospects for peace in the near future. Such bellicosity suggests that Assad wants to claim the mantle of his late father, Hafez, as the "lion" of the region. As Syria both hosts the exiled Hamas leadership and has been the object of recent American overtures, Assad has at least two reasons to believe he can do so.

Amidst all this jockeying, there is another player, under-analyzed since the initial flotilla furor, but nonetheless critical to its outcome: the Lebanese terrorist movement, Hezbollah.

Like Hamas, Hezbollah is wedded to the idea of an unyielding war against the Jews ("if the Jews all gather in Israel, it will save us the trouble of going after them worldwide," Hezbollah leader Sheikh Hassan Nasrallah famously declared.) And like Hamas, it is also locked in struggle with a rival Arab leadership. For Hamas, it's the Palestinian Authority; for Hezbollah, the Lebanese state.

In legal and political terms, Hezbollah is an outlaw. The group is shunned by western states as an interlocutor, is militarily stronger now than in 2006, when the United Nations Security Council passed Resolution 1701 demanding that it disarm, and remains the most immediate threat to Lebanon's integrity. Just this week, a top Hezbollah financier was arrested in a region of Paraguay well-known for smuggling and organized crime. Craving both its weapons and international legitimacy, Hezbollah recognizes that there are times when a slice of political respectability can come in very useful.

The flotilla campaign has provided Hezbollah with an opportunity to show its "humanitarian" side and to align itself with Turkey. The wily Nasrallah understands that, for all the current tensions between Turkey and the west, Ankara is in a much better position to strengthen his hand within Lebanon than are either of Hezbollah's traditional backers, Iran and Syria. Hence Nasrallah's fulsome praise of the Turkish leadership, which has apparently resulted in an invitation from Prime Minister Erdogan for him to visit Turkey.

Even with his supporters chanting "O Allah, O Merciful One, watch over Erdogan," Nasrallah shows no sign of moderating. Nor has he lost any of his customary hubris (the opposition website Syria Truth quoted Nasrallah saying -- translation here -- that Turkey's "red flag" was "making decisions" based on Hezbollah's "yellow flag.") Hence his decision to back the new flotilla which is reportedly heading to Gaza from Lebanon.

This flotilla is being organized by Yasser Kashlak, a Palestinian businessman based in Lebanon. Kashlak is known for his ties to terror groups, having shared the platform at a January "pro-resistance" conference in Beirut with representatives of Hezbollah, the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, the Syrian Ba'ath Party and the Iranian Vice-President, Reza Mir Tajeddini. Kashlak insists that his flotilla is an independent initiative, but Al Manar, Hezbollah's broadcasting arm, disagrees, noting that the voyage was announced less than a day after Nasrallah appealed for more flotillas to head for Gaza. The assertion of no connection with Hezbollah is further undermined by the presence of Samar Hajj, the wife of a former Lebanese General jailed for his part in the assassination of Lebanese Prime Minister Rafiq Hariri.

If the Mavi Marmara saga didn't prove it already, Hezbollah's planned foray into Mediterranean waters demonstrates that the flotilla movement is about many things, but humanitarian aid isn't one of them. Israel's decision to further ease the blockade of Gaza will therefore make little difference. The goal here is to assault Israel with more tenacity than one's rivals. Should that mean dispatching a few martyrs along the way, then so be it.

 

Follow Ben S. Cohen on Twitter: www.twitter.com/ZWord

Behind the rush to send further flotillas to the Gaza Strip, a power game between Islamists of various stripes is emerging. While Turkish, Palestinian, Iranian and Hezbollah flags have all been spotte...
Behind the rush to send further flotillas to the Gaza Strip, a power game between Islamists of various stripes is emerging. While Turkish, Palestinian, Iranian and Hezbollah flags have all been spotte...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 545
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
EnMasse
11:54 PM on 06/21/2010
Photographs of the actual women who will be on the "Mariam" flotilla: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/sharmine-narwani/the-day-us-jewish-groups_b_618849.html
01:02 AM on 06/22/2010
It shows clearly that Mariam(Saint Mary) flotilla carry women from all religious background to carry humanitarian help to Gaza!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GeorgieMark
Cogito Ergo Sum
10:43 AM on 06/21/2010
It is completely besides the point if the flotilla's organisers base motives were something completely different than showing the world how deplorable the situation is in Gaza

The point is that the situation in Gaza is deplorable and nothing else really matters.
02:40 AM on 06/22/2010
Your right - the question now is, how can the world make sure that on the one hand the people of Gaza get more imports via Israel, less oppression and murderings from Hamas and still maintain Israels security concerns. It's a tough balance to strike.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ralph Boyd
Look, . . right behind you!
05:25 AM on 06/21/2010
The term "Terrorist" like beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

Hezbollah may have begun, (like Netanyahu's Likud Party descended from the Irgun through the Herut party) as a terrorist organization, but Hezbollah really is Lebanon now. Israel isn't afraid of Hezbollah suicide bombers, Israel is afraid of Hezbollah ballistic missiles aimed at Tel Aviv. Like the US and Russia it may be a balance of terror, but it's not terrorism.

Same with Turkey. Israel isn't afraid of terrorists from Turkey, Israel is afraid that if she tries to take on Hezbollah with another invasion of Lebanon, her Air Force will get jumped by the very large NATO standards Turkish Air Force. Deterrence by its very nature can be terrifying, but it's not terrorism.

With Syria Israel isn't afraid of Syrian Terrorists, she's afraid that as Syrian upgraded her ballistic missiles to the new solid fuel variety she gave all her older liquid fueled ballistic missiles to Hezbollah. She's also afraid that as Syria keeps sending massive amounts of the newest anti tank and antiaircraft missiles into Lebanon that a Israeli invasion of Lebanon would be prohibitively costly in men and equipment. Israel is also afraid that with Syria's new Russian Air Defense Systems she won't be able to do anything about it. Once again that's deterrence not terrorism.

Right now Gaza and Hamas are just a distraction, for everyone a little geopolitical slight of hand. The real situation is up North.
11:35 PM on 06/20/2010
To those who say all Muslims are terrorists or that Islam is a religion of religious violence; and excerpt from a translation of the Koran:

You shall have your religion and I shall have my religion.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lbsaltzman
Permaculture and Sustainability
12:07 AM on 06/21/2010
There are many passages in the Qu'ran that show great tolerance and compassion.
12:45 AM on 06/21/2010
Ah, for once I agree with you lot. Pity the Hamas is the anti-thesis of those wise words, much like Hizbulla. They are freaks to the proper interpretation of Islam, and as a matter of fact the "Sheikh" Yassin of the Hamas was often ridiculed by Al-Azhar's teachers many a time for his falsification and politicization of Islam. As for Hizbulla, most Sunni Muslims will tell you they are infidels.
01:09 AM on 06/21/2010
Do not take it personally.

"The new world order" wants submission from everybody.

There is almost no resistance in the world and everybody in exchange for little bread has sold out their moral values.

The main problem of "The new world order" with Islam is that Islam does not allow submission for anybody but God!

For a peace to happens both parties should keep the peace.

For war to break out only one aggressor is enough.

Even you has fallen for the propaganda. Islam has not attacked western countries!

Western countries are attacking Muslim countries!

The next target is Iran!

Watch other alternative media until the propaganda wear off from your brain!

http://www.presstv.ir/llnw/
03:14 AM on 06/21/2010
Of course you conveniently forget the wars Arabs waged against Israel one time after the other until they realized it'd be much more efficient to pay for Palestinian terrorist groups to attack Israel from the territories. So far, it has been working. Israel is losing the propaganda war miserably.
11:27 PM on 06/20/2010
Boycott Israel now. If you are not in a position to march with a banner then look for other ways. Be selective when shopping in a supermarket, don't buy anything with made in Israel on it. But be careful they have been known to to put false labels on their goods. Avoid banks who have big holdings in Israel. We saw it work against Apartheid South Africa.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lbsaltzman
Permaculture and Sustainability
12:02 AM on 06/21/2010
Absolutely right! Boycott Israel until they both stop the siege of Gaza and end both the occupation of the West Bank and the theft of West Bank land.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:11 AM on 06/21/2010
Boycott, Divest, and Sanction

http://www.bdsmovement.net/
01:04 AM on 06/21/2010
You know what? I'm not actually against it. One caveat though: increase it to include all violators of human rights. Thus please add to the list:
Yugoslavia (Federal Republic)
North Korea
Indonesia
Algeria
Libya
Colombia
Egypt
Israel
China
Iran
Congo (Democratic Republic)
Sudan
Iraq
Burma
Turkey
Mexico
Congo (Republic)
Venezuela
Syria
Saudi Arabia
Rwanda
Pakistan
Bahrain
Sri Lanka
Philippines
Peru
South Korea
India
Cambodia
Cameroon
Nepal
Yemen
Brazil
Burundi
Cuba
Morocco
United States Of America
Uganda
Angola
Uzbekistan
Russian Republic
Croatia
Togo
Tunisia
Chad
Lebanon
Lesotho
Senegal
Nicaragua
Jordan

Won't do it? They you are discriminating against Israel. Israel is the Jewish state and discrimination against Jews is called Anti Semitism.
10:04 PM on 06/20/2010
Yes, and yes. The world wants to break an illegal siege of a people who deserve a state of their own. Israel has a state defined by the 1967 borders as most people know. So, Israel needs to stay in their backyard, clean its own house and let the Palestinians be and then, maybe we'll have some peace in the area. The desire to gain more and more territory will lead to disater for all. And besides 100% security, an impossibility, what does Israel really want?
03:18 AM on 06/21/2010
"And most people know". That's the point. When Hamas also knows, then there will be no boycott. Let me remind you that Israel withdrew from Gaza and demanded only that Hamas renounced violence and accepted Israel's existence in order to start peace talks. Hamas, as we all know, answered with thousands of rockets.
04:39 PM on 06/21/2010
Israel withdrew from Gaza because it was too expensive for them to steal land in the west bank and in Gaza and protect both with the Occupational forces. It wasnt done out of the goodness of Ariel "the butcher" Sharon's heart
07:54 AM on 06/21/2010
Believe it or not all they want is peace. Peace and no more. No more land, no more rockets, no more terrorists. Is that a fair deal??
08:51 AM on 06/21/2010
Another new recruit! Who is "they"?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:59 PM on 06/20/2010
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OkXDev2wXVA&feature=channel

Another Turkish crew member less senior speaking of bars that were intact initially but when he got to them they were cut in preparation for hostilities.
07:24 PM on 06/20/2010
You try to convince the whole world that any type of resistance against Israel inhuman acts is connected to terrorism!

Look, Aparthid South Africa until her final days insisted that Nelson Mandela is a terrorist! How much that propaganda had helped Aparthid in South Africa?

The propaganda will not help apartheid in Israel either, and Israel know it in the heart the she does not have!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:44 PM on 06/20/2010
Not at all. I'm a supporter of Sayyad, peaceful resistance.

See, unlike you, I realize that violence doesn't work. I'm not a warmonger and support civilized behavior. When people act civilized, they show the world that they are serious, they are taken seriously. Thus my support for Sayyad and peaceful resistance.

Try it, you'll live a longer healthier calmer life. :)
07:37 PM on 06/20/2010
Good as much as you expected them to accept their deaths at the hands of the pirates many of them chose to fight their invaders. Its just a shame they were very easy on them. They should have thrown the pirates overboard.
03:21 AM on 06/21/2010
By pirates you mean the Islamists who publicly declared the intention of breaking a military siege and when approached by naval forces, attacked them. Right?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:54 PM on 06/20/2010
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1I6XL2pzguE&feature=channel

The Captain of the Marmara speaking of the preparation for violence!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:50 PM on 06/20/2010
While in Israeli custody........wow, great testimony. Let's hear what he has to say when he is free of the real/implied threat of harm or prolonged custody.
03:22 AM on 06/21/2010
If you accuse somebody of something, prove it.
He was interviewed by a thinktank, but of course, you will always find an excuse.
07:35 AM on 06/21/2010
Yes Hanoum, you note "in custody" - for what exactly? The rest of the world calls it kidnapping. I have seen him interviewed since, and he was laughing at the Israeli "evidence" saying they rounded up all the knives in three canteens, and broke into the eight fire stations to produce the axes in their pictures. He also said he would be honoured to sail any future ships.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:06 PM on 06/20/2010
http://www.haaretz.com/news/diplomacy-defense/hamas-official-palestinians-should-fire-at-israel-from-west-bank-1.297245

"Hamas official: Palestinians should fire at Israel from West Bank

Asked whether rocket fire against Israel should be limited to launches originating in Gaza, Zahar told the East Jerusalem newspaper Al Quds that the fact that "such launches should happen in the West Bank as well [as Gaza] is inevitable."

Zahar criticized the Ramallah-based Palestinian Authority for fighting the "resistance," saying that it was not Hamas that took over Gaza, but in fact President Mahmoud Abbas's Fatah movement that had seized the power in the West Bank, aided by the Israeli "occupation."

Abbas, according to Zahar, got "one big zero" out of the international community, adding that Arab states had severed ties with Hamas in order to avoid conflict with the United States and to "save their heads."

The Hamas leader also stressed that Hamas would never change its policy, even if it won the next elections, saying that the solution lies in "resistance."

"If we had been interested in forfeiting our rights, I would have been in Washington by now," Zahar told Al Quds. "
01:18 PM on 06/20/2010
Remind me again how two wrongs make a right.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:25 PM on 06/20/2010
Silly me, what was I thinking, I forgot that it's okay for hamas to advocate barbarism.

Will keep that in mind for future reference.
01:25 PM on 06/20/2010
I'm also curious as to how Hamas proclaiming violence against Israel makes international charity workers terrorists.
03:25 PM on 06/20/2010
PLO is afraid to allow an election in west bank, since HAMAZ would most definitely wins it!

Remember PLO was also a terrorist organization before it sold out some of Palestinian rights to Israel in Camp David and Oslo!

Despite that PLO had given away many of Palestinians' rights to Israel, she refused to accept a peace agreement!

Israel has never shown that she can make the right decision from a position of strength!

The violence in Israel and Palestine is the responsibility of West, specially US for not putting sanctions and pressure on Israel to follow international laws and treaties.

If west Isolate Israel and Hamaz sees a goodwill from the west in form of humanitarian help to Palestinian they will stop the violence and engage in political resistance. For the first step US can stop sending 3 billion a year military help to Israel and send a smal portion of it as humanitarian help to Gaza!

West has sold HAMAZ as an irrational terrorist organization to western people.

Sooner or later west has to accept HAMAZ as representative of Palestinians, since at least for now PLO has lost its legitimacy to represent Palestinians both in Gaza and West Bank!
04:27 PM on 06/20/2010
"Israel has never shown that she can make the right decision from a position of strength!" - explain he Oslo accord, the peace treaty with Jordan, the withdrawal from Lebanon, from Gaza and peace with Egypt.

Hamas's charter clearly states incroporates thsi Holy Quran quote:

"The Day of Judgement will not come about until Moslems fight the Jews (killing the Jews), when the Jew will hide behind stones and trees. The stones and trees will say O Moslems, O Abdulla, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him. Only the Gharkad tree, (evidently a certain kind of tree) would not do that because it is one of the trees of the Jews."

Why anyone would support such an organisation which states genocide against Jews as a prime objective is beyond me.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lbsaltzman
Permaculture and Sustainability
01:02 PM on 06/20/2010
Here is a typical story of what the Palestinians endure as reported by Palestinian academic Mazin Qumsiyeh.

"Israeli occupation forces today in Beit Jala engaged in beatings, burning of
fields, and attacking peaceful demonstrators, bystanders, and reporters. Two
young Palestinians: Mohammed Masalma and Thaer Mahmoud were injured after
severe beatings with hands and clubs (they were both near their homes and
not participating in the demonstration). Several demonstrators were also
roughed-up. Occupation enforcers also attacked six reporters and prevented
them from doing their job of covering the event: Yousef Shahin (Palmedia),
AbdelHafith Hashlamon (European News Aghency), Nasser AlShayukhi (associated
Press), Mamon Wazwaz (APA), Musa AlShaer (France Press), and Najeh Hashlamon
(ABA). The Israeli occupation forces (thugs) also aimed their gas canisters
at dry fields managing to set a fire that engulfed an olive grove
(fortunately, the Palestinian fire department quick response saved most of
the field and the nearby homes). The apartheid forces also aimed tear gas
at far away homes in Beit Jala to senda message of fear to the local
population. And Israeli Occupation ‘intelligence’ Officer Fadi came and
then tagged us and as we were trying to leave in my car mocked us and call
out my name with his loud speaker. Video of much of the action at
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ktDUzjnxapY"

Mazin Qumsiyeh, PhD

http://www.qumsiyeh.org
Professor, Bethlehem and Birzeit Universities
Chairman of the Board, Palestinian Center for Rapprochement Between People,
http://www.pcr.ps
04:28 PM on 06/20/2010
So simple question - if life is so bad for these poor people, why doesn't their leadership sign a peace deal?
05:40 PM on 06/20/2010
If Israel's so scared of "terrorists" why doesn't their leadership sign a peace deal?
07:46 PM on 06/20/2010
Israel has been offered a peace deal. They want to steal more land. Meshal has already offered 10 yrs of peace in exchange for Israel leaving and going back to 67 lines. Once in 2006 and again two weeks ago it was reiterated. Israel does not want peace, they want the land.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Fein
Either everybody counts or nobody does.
10:56 AM on 06/20/2010
LOL

If apologists can't be factual, at least be clever so that we can laugh at you even more!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Albert Amato
10:13 AM on 06/20/2010
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IbCGeKuyc_c&feature=player_embedded
German public television views Turkey's flotilla as violent radicals......shocker!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:30 AM on 06/20/2010
Albert thank you for that, an eye opener. Prompted me to start digging information about the so called BPP movement. Had no clue.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
EnMasse
08:51 PM on 06/21/2010
That makes two of you.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:32 AM on 06/20/2010
As if German Public TV was an objective source on anything concerning Israel. Israeli media would be more objective than anything you can expect from the Germans - so far.

One of many reasons why staunch Israel supporter Merkel has no more public support.
photo
Wozzeck
Pearl Bay, Australia
10:49 AM on 06/20/2010
PBS and NPR are consistently biased towards Israel.
Omission and simple lack of coverage are their primary tools, but disinformation is also used.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:11 AM on 06/20/2010
The first thing every German Chancellor does on the day they take their post is pledge allegence to Israel. This is what Merkle had to do. Go back and read her inaguration speech. It is just the way it is.

But this this will make things interesting in Germany:

"In a move so loaded with historical symbolism I fear their ship will capsize, an organisation of German Jews plan to send an aid ship to break the Israeli blockade of Gaza. The descendents of the first victims of Hitler’s genocide are going to the aid of Muslim Arabs - the sworn enemy of post-war Jewry - in defiance of Israel, the Jewish state, created phoenix-like from the fires of the Holocaust. Phew! – the mind boggles.

Indeed, German Jewish Voice claims it has been inundated with (40) requests to join its adventure and, though they may represent the more far-flung shores of Jewish criticism of Israel, they are part of a process now redefining the Jewish Diaspora’s relationship with the State of Israel."

http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/juliankossoff/100043826/german-jews-to-join-new-gaza-aid-flotilla/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
muck-raker
give me liberty or give me death
07:11 AM on 06/20/2010
Since Israel's 1948 creation, Canada, like America, has been a loyal ally, not an "honest broker" on the Israeli/Palestinian conflict, then or now, and the reason outspoken professors like University of Ottawa's Denis Rancourt got fired, despite his stature, tenure, and heroic commitment human rights and democratic values, ones neither Canada or America champion, uphold or defend.

No wonder that Prime Minister Stephen Harper called on New Democratic Party (NDP) MP Libby Davies to resign as her party's deputy leader for saying Israel's occupation is the longest in the world, then adding: "People are suffering. I've been to the West Bank and Gaza twice so I've seen for myself what's going on."

In response, Harper said:

"Mr. Speaker, this is a fundamental denial of Israel's right to exist." That and more from others in parliament, the way US politicians defend the most outrageous Israeli crimes, denouncing their victims as terrorists.

It's why champions of human rights can't rest, nor should they ever compromise on right v. wrong issues, especially when it comes to Israel or its Washington paymaster/partner. The rest of this article follows

http://www.rense.com/general91/eas.htm
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
muck-raker
give me liberty or give me death
06:31 AM on 06/20/2010
Here is Flotilla survivor telling in his own words that people around him were shot dead by israeli gunman firing from the heliocopters...nuff said.

http://www.gilad.co.uk/writings/paul-larudee-account-of-my-capture-and-imprisonment-as-part.html
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
muck-raker
give me liberty or give me death
06:25 AM on 06/20/2010
Here is a personal accounting of American citizen captured on Flotilla aid ship. He was beaten many times, CHAINED and thrown into cell, refused counsel and telephone....If this is how Israel treated Rachel Corrie and other Americans they can not be our friend.
http://www.gilad.co.uk/writings/paul-larudee-account-of-my-capture-and-imprisonment-as-part.html
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Fein
Either everybody counts or nobody does.
11:00 AM on 06/20/2010
Our Zionist fanboy politicians have no problem selling us out to the AIPAC lobby like they did to the
USS Liberty victims. But the Turks are another matter entirely.
05:33 PM on 06/20/2010
He was released after 24 hours - get over it. 24 hours after lynching IDF soldiers during a maritime policing operation. If anyone tired pulling that stunt on any other navy in the world, the entire flotilla would have scuttled.
05:48 PM on 06/20/2010
Lynching IDF soldiers? That seems somewhat difficult to believe considering there were no reports of nooses on the ship, and all the IDF commandos came out alive.