iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Bernard-Henri Lévy

Bernard-Henri Lévy

Posted: November 3, 2010 02:23 PM

And so Iran is backing down. The Islamic Republic does it in its own way, tortuously, but it is backing down. And that is what is evident in two stands made public this morning, after the new stay of execution accorded Sakineh under the pressure of public opinion and of the chancelleries.

The first comes from the Iranian Minister of Foreign Affairs, Manouchehr Mottaki, telling his French counterpart Bernard Kouchner that "the authorities of justice had not pronounced the final verdict in the affair concerning Sakineh Ashtiani" -- a discreet, to say the least, way of making one (temporarily) forget the letter addressed by the Supreme Court of Tehran to the application of sentences office of Tabriz prison instructing that the young woman be executed as rapidly as possible.

And the second, from M. Mehmanparast, spokesman for the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, reported by the Isna press agency, regrets that the Westerners have the "insolence" to transform "the case of Sakineh Mohammadi Ashtiani, who has committed crimes and is guilty of betrayal, an affair of human rights". What insolence, indeed, M. Mehmanparast insists, to have made of "her case a symbol of the liberty of women" and to "use a simple case (the criminal law case) as a means of pressure against Iran".

Ah, what a lovely way to express things. And how elegantly put the ire of the Iranian government. Fortunate "insolence", in any event! Happy mobilization that has transformed Sakineh's face into a global icon, a symbol, and thus put off, for the time being, the date of her expected death!

For me, of course, the struggle continues. It continues even more than ever. For a stay of execution is not a pardon. And, lamentably, execution of the sentence can still occur, and at any moment. We must keep up the pressure. There must be increasingly more citizens--signing, for example, the petition of La Règle du Jeu-who express their solidarity with the young woman unjustly condemned and, of course, with her son, Sajjad.

Let's not give in.

Let's continue to be "insolent".

Bernard-Henri Lévy

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 31
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
TexasDem0
USMC Vietnam vet,Veteran for Peace
03:21 PM on 11/04/2010
Thank you Bernard-Henri Lévy for keeping this in the public's view.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NTT
Fighting rants with facts
10:33 AM on 11/04/2010
Yes, we did succeed (for the time being!) in obtaining a de-facto stay of execution for Ms. Ashtiani. We did not save this Iranian man http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-11559750 from having his hand lopped off for stealing chocolate.

And how many others are there, in places like Iran, Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, UAE, Kuwait, Yemen, etc. etc.? How many are killed, maimed, or otherwise horribly punished for breaking medieval "laws"? And these are only the "judicial" victims. How many are "honor" killed, beaten, tortured, mutilated, imprisoned in their own houses, forcibly married, oppressed, enslaved, etc. by their own families, villages, societies -- due to abysmal primitivism and backwardness?

If WE do not act in their defense, WHO will?
10:41 PM on 11/04/2010
NTT - neither dide you save the hundreds if thousands of people living in American prisons and jails. America has more prisoners than any other country in the world at any time in history. One man was in on the three times and you're out because he stole batteries. American justice. He would have had the same sentence if he had stolen a chocolate bar. You choose - lose a hand and be free or live out your life in an overcrowded prison but have both your hands to work for a corporation's answering service if your lucky,.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NTT
Fighting rants with facts
08:03 PM on 11/05/2010
What a phony rendition of reality! I don't know who is more guilty: the barbarians who apply these medieval "punishments", or you people who justify them??
08:23 PM on 11/03/2010
"And so Iran is backing down. The Islamic Republic does it in its own way, tortuously, but it is backing down."

This is becoming a joke, you guys make up stories, then it turns out to be all made up and then you claim Iran is backing down. The demonizing of Iran by the international war mongers if wasn't so criminal it would be funny. No matter what one thinks of Ahmadinejad, he has nothing to do with the case of this woman who killed her husband and is in jail for it. Even if Ahmadinejad wanted to release her he wouldn't be able to do.
08:04 PM on 11/03/2010
The last time France guillotined a man was in 1977. I wonder if you protested that execution with the same force as this one. I mean all executions are babaaric and counterproductive but did you protest that last one in France. Or any of the other ones around the world? Is one country worse than another when it comes to execution. Is Bernard Levy the one who decides this is okay or not worth talking about but that one is an outrage?
04:56 AM on 11/04/2010
You do realize that it is 2010 now? Capital punishment was abolished in France almost 30 years ago.
08:46 AM on 11/04/2010
mp146 - I do realize it is 2010. I wonder if America does. I think the last execution I read about was recently. It was in America The woman (it was a woman) was mentally challenged. I don't think this blogger threw a hissy fit over that execution or the many others which occur in America. But if you want to think it is okay for France, an advanced nation, to guillotine people until the late 1970's or that America use such horrific methods of execution as the gas chamber or electrocution feel free. I can assure you that wherever the death penalty occurs it is expensive, counter productive and barbaric. And, though it may not interest you, many innocent people die. But the guy who did it walks free.
08:56 PM on 11/04/2010
We cry out at human rights abuses to nations that do not follow washington's orders but it is perfectly fine for Egypt, Pakistan, Indonesia, Columbia and Saudi Arabia and others who are brutal dictatorships to go on abusing their own population.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Carol Gebert
05:34 PM on 11/03/2010
Thanks for the news.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
persianadvocate
04:15 PM on 11/03/2010
Dear Fellow Huff Posters:

I would like to bring your attention to an important news story for which there is a complete MEDIA BLACKOUT. Shahrzad Mir-Qolikhan, a young Iranian national, was arrested in the US in December 2007, and now complains that she was lured to the US as a means to get to her ex-husband, then kidnapped, held ransom for him, and brutally tortured and abused in US Federal Prisons. She reported this in a telephone interview with PressTV. Her ex-husband, Mahmoud Seif, had allegedly tried to export night-vision goggles to Iran from Austria. The story can be found here: http://www.presstv.ir/detail/149384.html

This is a verifiable story! She is being held in FEDERAL Prison and she can be located and interviewed, but there is a media blackout! Please HuffingtonPost, research and investigate this. For my fellow HUff Posters, please promote this information to whoever will listen. One person's humanity is not any less because she is Iranian, Iraqi, Israeli, or otherwise. She has two daughters, young, who are very worried and are asking Obama, formally, to allow them to see her. Please tell everyone you know about this and overcome the media silence!!!
photo
karim banned
A fool's mind is at the mercy of his tongue and a
06:55 PM on 11/03/2010
This is her interview with Iran's media over the phone in English.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CbfxwDcTe3k&feature=player_embedded#!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
persianadvocate
07:14 PM on 11/03/2010
thanks for that!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
No War With Iran
06:20 AM on 11/05/2010
Okay, I'll believe that there is a media blackout on this woman's situation, but why when I google her husband's name, I still come up empty handed as far as any non Iran state owned news websites? The pieces don't fit.
03:20 PM on 11/03/2010
This is good news. But even if Sakineh were pardoned, given safe passage out of the country, a government pension and a villa on the Riviera, the anti-Iran squads would find some other pretext to demonize, isolate, or otherwise cast the nation of Iran and its leaders in the worst possible light. This is done with the obvious purpose of using women's rights as a pretext to mask the real intention of the propagandists- get the political left on board the neo-con bandwagon for further isolation leading to war against Iran. Selective, even false propaganda is effective- it worked wonders leading up to Gulf War I, when many members of congress openly wept when that Kuwaiti "nurse" (actually the Kuwaiti ambassador's daughter) tearfully and with trembling voice told her audience about the Iraqi soldier's ripping babies from their incubators and leaving them on the floor to die- and it was all a propaganda stunt, arranged by the advertising firm of Hill and Knowlton! Yet it persuaded enough members of congress to approve going to war, a war whose consequences the world is still suffering acutely 20 years on.

While not implying in any way that Sakineh's case is mere propaganda, I think that there has to be some sense of moral consistency and universality, which would condemn all such injustices.

Compare this woman's fate to that of the handicapped woman in Virginia. With regards to these two cases, which nation has shown more forebearance or humanity?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:36 PM on 11/03/2010
humanity and wars are mutually exclusive words

i wonder what they will show to the gullible citizen when it's time to justify going to war against Pakistan, Yemen, Eurasia, Oceania and .....
photo
OliverTwist
Contrarian advocate for truth and justice
06:39 PM on 11/03/2010
I think I remember that leaked documents indicate that the CIA intended to leverage propaganda about women in Iran as a means to mobilize support in Europe for an attack against Iran.

Of course, this would be less easily done if Iran had a more western social and legal system.
02:52 PM on 11/03/2010
This is torturous. One day they stay the order, the next they want to proceed. Don't want to imagine what it must be like for this woman. The stress itself might do her in. :\
photo
karim banned
A fool's mind is at the mercy of his tongue and a
06:57 PM on 11/03/2010
Western media do this intentionally to keep this case alive.
07:50 PM on 11/03/2010
Western media was going to stone her for adultery? I thought that was an idea from the enlightened people who run IRI judiciary.
09:51 PM on 11/04/2010
It seems they want to keep Shakineh alive..