Indiana's Marriage Amendment to Make a Comeback?

01/03/2009 05:12 am ET | Updated May 25, 2011

Could Indiana's constitutional amendment to ban same-sex marriage and civil unions make a comeback after all? While I wrote yesterday that the marriage amendment's chances were slim according to the Indianapolis Star, WIBC radio has a different story to report. The radio station says that the amendment will be back, but in a modified version to try and stymie activist's arguments against the ban.

Opponents in 2007 argued the proposal would have unintended consequences, such as making it impossible to file domestic violence charges involving unmarried heterosexual couples. Supporters disagreed, but with the amendment starting from scratch, Marion Representative Eric Turner says he's tweaked the wording to answer those objections.

Turner says the new version is modeled on amendments in other states which have stood up to similar scrutiny.

Turner notes about half of House Democrats voted for the amendment in 2005, and says he expects some Democrats to file their own version of an amendment this year. He says he hopes they'll be able to persuade [House Speaker Pat] Bauer to allow a hearing.

Will the amendment return? I'd imagine the rightwingers in the Statehouse will attempt to push an amendment to try and distract from the ruin our state economy is in. With all of the problems our state has - unemployment, brain drain, a poor economy and a national recession - I can't imagine Speaker Bauer wasting any time with yet another hearing on gay marriages that haven't happened. As the Speaker was quoted in the Star article:

"I've been asking people to show me that the current law has been broken, and they haven't showed me yet. I want to see the couples that were illegally married."

Speaker Bauer was instrumental to the defeat of the amendment in last year's session of the General Assembly. Barring some last minute trick by Republicans, I feel comfortable about any introduced legislation's fate.

Still, it's worth remembering that the Indiana Democratic Party paid for an anti-gay campaign mailer in the last election. The DNC, National Stonewall Democrats, and the Indiana Stonewall Democrats all condemned the mailing, but the state party refused to comment to reporters or acknowledge any complaints by activists.

Speaker Bauer was not involved in the anti-gay campaign ad.

(Crossposted at Bilerico Project)