iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Bill Maher

Bill Maher

Posted: September 27, 2007 02:07 PM

New Rule: Stop Saying Iraq is Another Vietnam, it's Another Enron


Iraq is Enron, and President Bush is Ken Lay. He's fighting a war with phony accounting tricks. The Bush administration fudged the numbers to get us into Iraq, and cooked the books to keep us there. "The surge" is simply another in a long series of inflated stock quotes. This past weekend Marcel Marceau passed away at age 84. Doctors say he went quietly. Thus proving that evil thrives when good men stay silent. And just like with Enron, the good men and women who are blowing the whistle on Iraq contractor fraud are being vilified, fired, demoted, and those are the lucky ones.

Last Friday morning the Senate Democratic Policy Committee held a hearing entitled "The Mistreatment of Iraq Contracting Whistleblowers," just in time to make the Friday news dump. According to the committee more than $10 billion dollars in Iraq reconstruction and military support contracts is unaccounted for. In other words, for every six dollars spent in Iraq one dollar is in question. And folks, it's a war-zone, you're dealing with a culture known for its haggling skills, so you've got factor in a little skimming, but this is ridiculous. If you stole that much money from the Mafia you'd be dead.

Vicente Fox may have called President Bush a "windshield cowboy," but Bush has certainly turned Iraq into a wild, wild, west. And here's another one from the War in Iraq's this-is going-to-make-you-vomit file. Some Iraq contract whistleblowers have been vilified and fired, others have been detained by the US military and subjected to harsh interrogation techniques.

Donald Vance, a Navy veteran, was working for an Iraqi-owned outfit called the Shield Group Security Company. Vance said he witnessed Shield Group selling guns, land mines, and rocket-launchers to Iraqi insurgents, American soldiers, State Department workers, and Iraqi embassy and ministry workers. Vance described Shield Groups as "a Wal-Mart for guns." Vance reported this to the FBI, and instead of a pat on the back, he got 97 days at Camp Cropper, a military prison outside of Baghdad. In fact, Saddam's Hussein's old crib. Vance was placed in solitary confinement, subjected to head-banging music blaring from dawn to dusk, and interrogators screaming the same questions over and over again in his face.

Also testifying at the hearing along with Vance was Barry Godfrey, a former KBR employee (KBR+Halliburton=Cheney) who claimed that he was fired after complaining to his supervisors about fraudulent overcharges.

Also testifying was Bunnatine Greenhouse. Greenhouse is the former highest-ranking civilian contracting official at the Army Corps of Engineers, so I'll dispense with the "Greenhouse having gas" joke. But Greenhouse was removed from her position when she tried to crack down on "casual and clubby contracting practices" at the Army Corps of Engineers.

Also testifying was Robert Isakson who was a co-plaintiff in a "qui tam" lawsuit (a whistleblower lawsuit) against Custer Battles. No, "qui tam" is not that stuff that Chinese people do in the park, it's shorthand for the Latin Phrase "qui tam pro domino quam pro seipso," which dates back to 13th century England, and means, "He who is as much for the King as for himself." Today, a "qui tam" lawsuit is one brought under the False Claims Act by a private plaintiff on behalf of the Federal or State Government. Isakson won the first civil verdict for Iraq reconstruction fraud against Custer Battles. However, the verdict was overturned by the judge, who ruled that because the CPA was not part of the US government, the "qui tam" statute did not apply.

Meanwhile the Bush administration has not litigated a single case against a contractor alleged to have defrauded the US Government in Iraq. Apparently, like terrorism, this isn't a law enforcement issue either.

Bill Maher is the host of HBO's "Real Time with Bill Maher" which airs every Friday at 11PM.

 
 
  • Comments
  • 311
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (10 total)
12:42 PM on 10/08/2007
Bill,
You should see the slick 20 page catalogue the Marines just sent my 24 year old son. At OUR expense the "All IN A DAY'S WORK. THE UNITED STATES MARINE CORPS." has offered to send him a free "About the Corps" opportunity book and a free Marine Corps workout t-shirt. Just complete the postage paid detachable postcard with your name, address, phone, cell, e-mail, DOB,school attended and indicate what size t-shirt you want! s,m,l,xl,xxl. Oh and there is also another postcard inviting a friend to stand with you.What do you think that cost us?
Kenny2k
dabrat77
02:28 PM on 10/01/2007
Bill I am a fan of your show and if you read these responces, would you please invite Naomi Klein and John Cusack on your show. I think your viewers would like to hear what they have to say. Interesting piece by the way.
photo
Star2000dancer
Pay it forward, the movie..
10:57 PM on 10/01/2007
Bill, I say there would have been no 911 if Gore was in office. I would love to hear your response on that. I'd also like to hear a debate about it.
07:37 PM on 09/30/2007
Compared to the money Bush is "Enron-ing" from Iraq this is minor. When Ann Richards was governor of Texas, the people that she put on the Texas Insurance Board had no connection to any insurance company. Our insurance rates were very reasonable. When Prince George ran against her in the Gubernatorial race, Dubya and his homies started a "smear campaign" against Governor Richards. This resulted in her losing the election. He made sure that every person on the Insurance Board was replaced. Replaced with "Company People" from every major Insurance Corporation.

Like most homeowners, we attach the homeowners insurance to the mortgage payment. The year that Bush took office; our house payment increased by $750 per month. That's how much our homeowner's insurance had increased.
09:53 PM on 09/30/2007
I'm no Bush fan by any measure, but remember the same year you are talking about, with the election of Bush and the insurance hike, is the same year storm Arlene hit Texas. Coming from a Florida resident, let me tell you- any time a destructive weather storm hits your state- your insurance rates increase exponentially.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
shelleybear
01:10 PM on 10/01/2007
If the insurance companies ran their business properly, they would allow for destructive weather. Instead of investing beyond a sane amount.
In Florida, many insurance companies are cutting and running leaving retirees high and dry.
Why?
Because they milked the residents dry while the weather pattern was good, and then, like any good gambler, took the money and ran before the house turned against them.
10:08 PM on 09/30/2007
Well, its nice to know Bu$h was able to launch himself from Texas Governor to President after doing such a "great job," huh? Its amazing how the narrative can change to make a total failure of a businessman, "Lord Pissypants," look like a good choice for President by almost half of the people. Then, of course, ALMOST half is good enough to have the Corporate Supreme Court justices to select him as the WORST PRESIDENT EVER.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:22 PM on 09/30/2007
Thank you Mr. Maher,
With the lack of interest in American benchmarks for democracy, and the abundance of morons like me who have trouble conveying a thought, I respect people like you who get it and can.
11:14 AM on 09/30/2007
Awesome Bill!
We need to remember that when the Gop goes to war and it's biggest contributors make record profits, it's not a mistake its politics.
OF course, Chomsky said the same thing during Vietnam
11:08 AM on 09/30/2007
IT IS ALL A RUSE!!!
Americans are addicted to Oil; therefore they can condone the Invasion of Iraq, and consequently its pillaging.
THE NEO-CON OBJECTIVE:
TO LOOT THE US TREASURY.
Stealing and controlling Iraqi Oil is an added bonus.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
donnybrkgr
09:48 AM on 09/30/2007
My "Vomit File" is overloaded
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DonRoberto
11:44 AM on 09/30/2007
If we want to get America out of the war-for-profit boondoggle, let's take a page from the Republicans' "running government like a business" playbook. Let's get our Democratic Congress to immediately apply Sarbanes-Oxley to all government agencies and employees.
Make General Petraeus publicly sign off on the accuracy of his progress reports. Have the President scribble his SOX John Hancock to the next White House report on global warming. Make the OMB produce a full accounting of monies spent in and on Iraq (the REAL books, not the ones they keep to show to Congress) and have the director of the agency certify they are correct and complete by adding his own SOX signature.
Bottom line, if Mr. Maher's right --- and Iraq IS Enron --- SOX might finally be the cure.
09:53 PM on 09/30/2007
Bushco is selling American soldiers' lives for a war profit. He is paying an American life per about $250,000 each. He is selling the lives of our enlisted people like Judas sold Jesus for 30 pieces of silver. That made Judas rot in Hell for eternity, right? Or so the story goes. So why is Bush not a traitor for selling out his troops?

Vomit. Vomit. Vomit.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MissingAmerica
09:47 AM on 09/30/2007
This is so right on. Both schemes to dupe American citizens out of massive amounts of dollars and impose massive debt on its innocent victims. Enron went into the billions, Bush is into the trillions and still on a roll with, according to the latest news, a mind to invade Iran now. Yup, the only thing stopping the Bush machine is that we had Congress to protect us from Enron, but Bush has Congress to protect him from us. This leaves us no one to protect us from Bush and his giant Congressional GOP stone wall machine. It's a shame we can't get these issues so we can impeach this administration and replace it with decent American leadership.
05:52 PM on 09/30/2007
Yes ask the UN to levy charges against this administration for War Crimes. Then perhaps Mr. Reid and Ms. Pelosi may reconsider (along with the rest of the co-conspirators in acts against the Constitution) to RETUN OUR RIGHT TO IMPEACH THE EMPEROR and his little Dog W too.
05:31 AM on 09/30/2007
Thank God we have true Americans like Bill Maher to counter GOP cowards and "suck-asses"
like Rush "I like to mix Viagra with vicadin" Limbaugh, and Bill "Can I get a MotherF***n Ice Tea" O'Reilly.
Professor73
Constitutionalist
10:29 AM on 09/30/2007
I am a 1973 Marine and couldn't disagree with you more.
photo
kcgeezer
Blue guy in a red state.
10:38 PM on 09/30/2007
I'm a 1973 vet too and you sir must have your head firmly up your ass. If you think that the GOP in its present form is worth defending or that its media shills are honorable you are misguided or have a terminal case of stupidity. This is a war that should never have been fought. We left Afghanistan to let junior show up his old man and now Bin Laden is thumbing his nose at us.
02:27 AM on 09/30/2007
There were only 2 reasons for the Iraq expedition:
1) Loot the US Treasury.
2) George can call himself a "war president" going into the 2004 election cycle.
03:02 PM on 09/29/2007
Excellent point!

The privitization of the federal government has reached stunning depths. But we were warned. The following order was issued 1 month, 6 days after Inauguration. Though the group was to focus on ways to shift responsibility from federal to state or local authorities, I believe that it was a cover to find ways to shift the responsibility from the feds to the private sector. Edited for length, the original is here: http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2001/02/20010226-13.html.

February 26, 2001

MEMORANDUM FOR THE HEADS OF EXECUTIVE DEPARTMENTS AND AGENCIES

SUBJECT: Interagency Working Group on Federalism

The Working Group shall comprise the following officials (or an appropriate designee thereof):

1. Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy
2. Director, Domestic Policy Council
3. Secretary of the Treasury
4. Attorney General
5-14. Secretaries of the Interior, Agriculture, Commerce, Labor, Health & Human Services, Housing & Urban Development, Transportation, Energy, Education, Veterans Affairs
15. Director of the Office of Management and Budget
16. Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency
17. Counsel to the President
18-20. Assistants to the President for Economic Policy, Office of Faith-Based and Community Initiatives, and Chief of Staff to the Vice President
21. Deputy Assistant to the President for Intergovernmental Affairs and such other as the President may designate.

The functions are:

A. Identify initiatives that promote principles of Federalism, such as:

1. Federal endeavors which may more appropriately be carried out by State or local authorities;
2. Opportunities for flexible funding streams, regulatory waivers, and other opportunities that increase State and local flexibility, innovation, and accountability;
3. Measures for improving Federal responsiveness to State and local concerns; and
4. Enforcement of rules, orders, and procedures that advance Federalism.

B. Draft a new Executive Order on Federalism, which will require departments and agencies in the executive branch to adhere to principles of Federalism;
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
janvoght
lover of Life...
02:13 PM on 09/29/2007
In other words, this blatently illegal, unconstitutional activity will be allowed by the powers that presently be...so, if you don't want to wind up spending a couple of uncomfortable years in some torturous archaic prison, or the like...go with the flow and at worst you too can profit? Not quite the material or character great civilizations were built on, but it smells like reality.
02:03 PM on 09/29/2007
Bill does great stuff. I watched him struggle for answers on mortgage and stock issue with " The Money Honey" from CNBC last night. I would like to think that my work covers much of the questions he wisely asked and no one else asks on mainstream TV. The lack of serious and balanced discussion of the macro economiy and finance costs everday America billions a week. I am also here on HuffPo and just thought I would shamelessly plug myself:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/max-fraad-wolff/lets-be-honest-it-doesn_b_66350.html
09:54 AM on 09/29/2007
If the media had spent as much time getting into the war as they spend getting out we would not be in this mess. However the media does not give a damn they win either way because their interest is in the money only and not the interest of the country's welfare. They have no morals either like the leaders. And they also can still sleep at night watching thoses few suckers who give their life and limbs while they take the cash and run.
02:04 PM on 09/29/2007
Bill does great stuff. I watched him struggle for answers on mortgage and stock issue with " The Money Honey" from CNBC last night. I would like to think that my work covers much of the questions he wisely asked and no one else asks on mainstream TV. The lack of serious and balanced discussion of the macro economiy and finance costs everday America billions a week. I am also here on HuffPo and just thought I would shamelessly plug myself:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/max-fraad-wolff/lets-be-honest-it-doesn_b_66350.html