iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
GET UPDATES FROM Bill Moyers
 
GET UPDATES FROM Michael Winship
 

WATCH: Both Parties Give Invisible Americans the Silent Treatment

Posted: 08/27/2012 11:24 am

It's just astonishing to us how long this campaign has gone on with no discussion of what's happening to poor people. Official Washington continues to see poverty with tunnel vision -- "out of sight, out of mind."

And we're not speaking just of Paul Ryan and his Draconian budget plan or Mitt Romney and their fellow Republicans. Tipping their hats to America's impoverished while themselves seeking handouts from billionaires and corporations is a bad habit that includes President Obama, who of all people should know better.


Remember: for three years in the 1980s he was a community organizer in Roseland, one of the worst, most poverty-stricken and despair-driven neighborhoods in Chicago. He called it "the best education I ever had." And when Obama left to go to Harvard Law School, author Paul Tough writes in the New York Times, he did so, "to gain the knowledge and resources that would allow him to eventually return and tackle the neighborhood's problems anew." There's a moving line in Dreams from My Father where Obama writes: "I would learn power's currency in all its intricacy and detail" and "bring it back like Promethean fire."

Oddly, though, for all his rhetorical skills, Obama hasn't made a single speech devoted to poverty since he moved into the White House.

Five years ago, he was one of the few politicians who would talk about it. Here he is in July 2007, speaking in Anacostia, one of the poorest parts of Washington, D.C.:

"The moral question about poverty in America -- How can a country like this allow it? -- has an easy answer: we can't. The political question that follows -- What do we do about it? -- has always been more difficult. But now that we're finally seeing the beginnings of an answer, this country has an obligation to keep trying."

Barack Obama the candidate said he wanted to spend billions on a nationwide program similar to Geoffrey Canada's Harlem Children Zone in New York City, widely praised for its focus on comprehensive child development. In the last three years, only $40 million have been spent with another $60 million scheduled for local community grants.

Obama's White House team insisted their intentions were good, but the depth of the economic meltdown passed along by their predecessors has kept them from doing more. And yes, billions have been spent on direct aid to families in the form of welfare, food stamps, housing vouchers and other payments. What's needed, as Paul Tough at the Times and others say, is a less scattershot, more comprehensive program that gets to the root of the problem, focusing on education and mentoring. Not easy to do when a disaffected middle class that votes says hey, what about us? -- and the wealthy one percent who lay out the fat campaign contributions simply say, so what?

Just a few days ago, The Chronicle of Philanthropy issued a report on charitable giving. Among its findings: "Rich people who live in neighborhoods with many other wealthy people give a smaller share of their incomes to charity than rich people who live in more economically diverse communities." Responding to that study, social psychologist Paul Piff told National Public Radio, "The more wealth you have, the more focused on your own self and your own needs you become, and the less attuned to the needs of other people you also become."

Those few who dedicate themselves to keeping the poor ever in sight realize how grave the situation really is. The Associated Press reports that "the number of Americans with incomes at or below 125 percent of the poverty level is expected to reach an all-time high of 66 million this year." A family of four earning 125 percent of the federal poverty level makes about $28,800 a year, according to government figures.

That number's important because 125 percent is the income limit to qualify for legal aid, but although that family may qualify for help, budgets for legal services have been slashed, too, and pro bono work at the big law firms has fallen victim to downsizing. So it's not surprising, the AP goes on to say, that there's a crisis in America's civil courts because people slammed by the financial meltdown -- overwhelmed by foreclosure, debt collection and bankruptcy cases -- can't afford legal representation and have to represent themselves, creating gridlock in our justice system -- and one more hammer blow for the poor.

We know, we know: It is written that, "The poor will always be with us." But when it comes to our "out of sight, out of mind" population of the poor, you have to think we can help reduce their number, ease the suffering, and speak out, with whatever means at hand, on their behalf and against those who would prefer they remain invisible. Speak out: that means you and me, and yes, Mr. President, you, too. You once told the big bankers on Wall Street that you were all that stood between them and the pitchforks of an angry public. How about telling the poor you will make sure our government stands between them and the cliff?

Moyers & Company airs weekly on public television. Explore more at BillMoyers.com

This post is part of the HuffPost Shadow Conventions 2012, a series spotlighting three issues that are not being discussed at the national GOP and Democratic conventions: The Drug War, Poverty in America, and Money in Politics.

HuffPost Live will be taking a comprehensive look at the persistence of poverty in America August 29th and September 5th from 12-4 pm ET and 6-10 pm ET. Click here to check it out -- and join the conversation.

 
 
 

Follow Bill Moyers on Twitter: www.twitter.com/BillMoyers

FOLLOW POLITICS
It's just astonishing to us how long this campaign has gone on with no discussion of what's happening to poor people. Official Washington continues to see poverty with tunnel vision -- "out of sight, ...
It's just astonishing to us how long this campaign has gone on with no discussion of what's happening to poor people. Official Washington continues to see poverty with tunnel vision -- "out of sight, ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 50
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
08:22 AM on 08/30/2012
Bill you're thoughtful and right. Obama while better than the Republicans has ignored the poor because he is subjected to such intense pressure by Corporate america that has a much louder voice. The only reason I believe Obama can sleep at night is that he distance's himself from the poor by knowing he didn't create the problem. He's locked into a struggle with Congress that he can't win. Americans have voted Tea party representatives into office and we all suffer.

I will say it one more time. There needs to be a change in the way American banks do business. I am a firm believer that the American credit score system is corrupt. Since there is no debtor's prison's in America, banks and credit card companies lobbied for a punitive system of punishment that continues to rob the poor and the middle class. If mortgages in American were structured differently, allowing people to pay down there houses quicker, without having to pay the interest first everyone would benefit. There needs to be a law stating that everyone, regardless of credit score, is entitled to a 4 percent interest rate on there primary resident, that everyone can also refinance at this fixed rate. The banks need to be broken in two, commercial and investment banks need to be separate. Nothing else will fix the system.
07:27 AM on 08/30/2012
5. Obama has failed to respond to the increased costs of energy, food, et al. necessities already slamming the fixed income elderly, disabled, low income poor...failing to even change the assistance eligibility and failing to change the part-time income allowance/costs of working levels of the disabled to work program and senior on retirement part time income so that the poorest are being slammed with increased costs and penalized by Obama's failure/management of federal programs to cause them to lose assistance !
6. It's very nice what Michelle does to improve school feeding quality and availability; however, that does not excuse the President failing to assist the poor and low income who are not schoolchildren !
Obama has Executive Powers to fix/change Federal Programs/Federal Funding Management/Federal Policies...and he has failed to use those powers to help the poor/low income.
It is time for Obama to get on the tv and start telling the poor, the low income, the elderly, the disabled, the poor students, precisely what he is going to do for them the very next morning after he gets elected...and it's time for the poor to get out and vote...proving that money issn't everything in the USA.
07:21 AM on 08/30/2012
3. FEDERAL ASSISTANCE programs/funding MUST be held in the Federal coffers and administrated/managed by FEDERAL agency department staff so that ALL eligible citizens are EQUALLY assisted with the federal programs/funding no matter which state they live in. Currently, and worse under Ryan/Romney, states take the federal funds and disappear them into their state treasury coffers, arbitrarily handing out maundy coins to the poor, or not, regardless of the degree of the individual need...a basic violation of the Us Constitution "ALL CITIZENS ARE EQUAL, EQUALLY ENTITLED TO GOVERNMENT SUPPORTS, TREATMENT, ETC...."
4. YES, Obama has failed miserably to redress the deplorable conditions of the poor, failing to reverse the GOP's bastardizations of original JFK/LBJ programsin addition to the sta
tes skimming off the federal funds given to states to fund federal programs assistance for the poor.
06:47 AM on 08/30/2012
People really need to get out and vote in Nov. This is a very important election. Don't pay a lot of attention to the polls. We can't let the republican win in Nov. If they win there will be people living in the streets. They will be living in their cars and tents. There will be a Civil War. The republican party only cares about the filthy rich fat cats. They talk about less government. Well don't tell me what I can or can't do with my body.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:51 AM on 08/30/2012
As a progressive myself I can identify with what Moyers says. Between my two 30 something children both with serious medical issues I can't help any others. I would if I could. But my focus now is on my own family.
07:36 AM on 08/30/2012
So...have you written your US Congress AND President Obama telling them that 1. you need MORE assistance to help raise your family healthfully or they will suffer terrible deprivations, and 2. have you told your GOP neighbors to 'go fly a kite in another country' because they do not have the right to kill off your family by eliminating federal assistance programs funding to satisfy their deficit cutting plots to kill off the poor/needy by deprivations...just like hiter/nazis did 1930's-1945 until US WWII vets killed them off/subjugated them ? No patriotic US WWII vet can possibly vote for Romney/Ryan...unless they have a bad case of memory loss/dementia....
01:48 AM on 08/30/2012
Moyers uses the quote "The poor will always be with us." That's an alleged remark of Jesus' in the Bible. A statement from a guy who lived 2,000 years ago in a country, Judea, that had no social welfare arrangements for the poor, sick, or crippled. Even the Romans provided basic supplies of grain and bread for the poor. So we accept this quote, like a broken record played to blind sheep, taking comfort from the statement of a guy who lived in a place and time with no safety nets for those in need? That's just STUPID.
We're supposedly a smart species. Apparently we're not smart ENOUGH to manage two simple things: peace and prosperity. "The poor will always be with us" is evidence of amoral tunnel-vision of all the pampered white guys in ivory towers, of politicians who spend more on their hair care products than most poor people spend on their monthly groceries. There is no excuse for this lame attitude for a supposedly "smart" species. We can land on the Moon but not manage to eliminate poverty for the entire globe? Uh-huh. If you believe that, I've got a bridge in Brooklyn to sell you. Poverty is 14 karat proof of our lack of intelligence and compassion. No wonder politicians don't talk about it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kalidescopemind
My glass is 1/4 full '(
06:00 AM on 08/30/2012
No it is not. Quote the bible. Its a snarky comment from a too-rich old lady, who is justifying her "I'm not going to do anything about it" attitude.
07:50 AM on 08/30/2012
Indeed...JFK/RFK/LBJ built federal assistance programs to uplift the poor and low income Us Citizens...and the GOP have bastardized those programs by raising the eligibility bars and EVEN SUBSTANTIALLY CHANGING THE PROGRAMS BY ELIMINATING PEOPLE FOR WHOM THE PROGRAMS WERE DESIGNED and ALSO ELIMINATING THE ORIGINAL SERVICES...Individual GOP-controlled state seven take the federal programs moneys and depsoit those moneys into their state coffers to fund their GOP programs which benefit the wealthiest in their state by redirecting the funds to things which benefit their wealthiest ...which is a serious federal law violation and warrants prosecution for Fraud ...but Obama has failed to nail the thieving con-artist fraudsters just because they are GOP politicians in control of states with the dumbest people in the USA...GOP voters. Anyone with two brain cells in the USA knows that US businesses are embarking on a 20-year strategy of using only part-time employees to eliminate costs of benefits. Rick Waggoner former detroit auto ceo, repeatedly told the presidents clinton, bush, and obama that the federal government needed to take responsibility for the supports such benefits once provided to the low income/lower middle income workers as well as the poor because businesses could no longer afford such benefits/benefits management. Not even Obama listened.Romney/Ryan plot to eliminate federal funding for such programs prove they're out of touch with US Business !
photo
Transit
"Hunger is the best pickle"
01:23 AM on 08/30/2012
It's simple. Republicans across the country have changed the voting laws so the poor are left out in the cold come election time. Without a vote the politicians have no need to address the poor. What a neat fix to the pesky poverty problem.
07:53 AM on 08/30/2012
...there was the arab spring uprising against such evil dictators....and Thank God, we still have the Us Constitution right to bear arms in the event the government subverts the US Constitution...
06:04 PM on 08/29/2012
as much as i am tempted to focus on the circuses, oops, conventions with the deluge of paid political advertising and commentary, i am skipping the "and now ladies and gentlemen, focus your eyes above the center ring attraction for the most astoun......" for the time being. instead, i am rereading tom friedman's ' Hot, Flat and Crowded ' and highlighting and index tabbing many of the subjects discussed. it is becoming more and more disheartening that intelligent dialogue on the looming problems this country and planet faces are overshadowed. by personalities, the blame game, the error of good/bad, black/white, right/wrong, heaven for me/hell for you, you view things from my perspective but i won't view things from yours nonsense.
07:56 AM on 08/30/2012
Please do the simple math: add up the costs of the two political campaigns including the circuses and tell me, can corporate america afford to pay daown the US national deficit to get the country back into the green ?/!! Any moneys available to increase the minimum national wage to $10.36 per cost-of-living-adjusted 1968 minimum wage.... ?/!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Grogger
Nothing is guarded more fiercely than unfair gain
05:19 PM on 08/29/2012
Here's an ugly truth, and NEITHER party will admit it. You simply can't have poverty without also having opulence, no one can get that wealthy without taking from others. It is that simple.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kalidescopemind
My glass is 1/4 full '(
06:02 AM on 08/30/2012
True. It is the hoarders that creat want.
08:02 AM on 08/30/2012
once upon a time in america...among the original 13 colonies, there were laws against Usury, there were regulations of banking and finance to prevent gauging the individual person, there were trade tarriffs to prevent american businesses from going abroad for cheap labor then importing goods which should have been made by americans/jobs...there were federal standards which were enforced to protect americans from dangerous food, from dangerous/defective products and fraudulent services. However, the states west of the Mississippi, not part of the original 13 colonies, don't want any of such federal nanny state governance, they prefer the law of the jungle, winner takes all, win by any means, rule by monied elite...in other words, they are running a sedition campaign to institutionally subvert the US Constitution which is High Treason punishable by death .... or, they can just secede and start their own dictatorship.
03:56 PM on 08/29/2012
I have immense respect for Bill Moyers, but if Pres. Obama were to follow the path Moyers is advocating, Obama would join the club of Jimmy Carter, Walter Mondale and Mike Dukakis and go back to being a law professor. The Democratic Party cannot become the party of the poor in an era when the middle class is fighting for its very life. The corporate aristocracy of the Republican Party knows this and has exploited it for decades.
12:10 AM on 08/30/2012
And just which direction do you think the middle class is moving in, a quick hint; it ain't up.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kalidescopemind
My glass is 1/4 full '(
06:08 AM on 08/30/2012
You notice how R&R won't talk specifics? They are already accising the President of creating a welfare state. Why should we talk about it? You can bet he will do more for income inequality than Romney. First, there is an election to win.
08:07 AM on 08/30/2012
Newsflash to the working middle class...they have been duped by the delusion they are mied rich and can afford to pay for their own supports, needs etc just as the wealthiest do. Are you telling me that their raided 401K's, their job insecurity, their mortgage-crises have failed to make them understand they are NOT the monied rich elite and will not benefit from GOP policies ? /!! If so, they are the dumbest people in the world...because the rest of the world looks on, watching all of this, wondering why the american working middle class keeps voting against their own self-intersts in favor of some delusion of grandeur and richness ... !!
02:59 PM on 08/29/2012
Right now its all about votes, so you can not take much stock in what is being said. Being someone that voted for Obama's change that never came, i am disapointed at the mud slinging the Democrats are doing instead of coming up with solutions to americas problems (which they have had 4 yrs to do). Do not know much about Romney, but he has already came up with his solutions to some of our most pressing issues. I do believe that Obama's mud slinging will be a big negative in his election this time around and the poll are already showing it!
12:12 AM on 08/30/2012
Nice cover for 'blame the other guy for what mine is doing.'
It has not mattered what the man has proposed as the GOP has just one answer "NO!"
02:50 PM on 08/30/2012
You are right with the GOP saying no - the question is can we take another 4 yrs with the same results?
12:46 AM on 08/30/2012
I love your sarcasm!
02:51 PM on 08/30/2012
That's all I have left for politics!
01:43 PM on 08/29/2012
True to form, Mr. Moyers, you have spoken truth to power. One of the few recognizable figures in the media willing to do so.

Over the passed few days I have been re-watching HBO's "The Wire." One of its major themes is the faceless nature of our nation's poor, specifically in our inner-cities. David Simon went out on a limb to do the right thing by drawing attention to this seemingly intractable issue.

Over the course of the series various characters struggle with their consciences over the drug trade, and their role in it, or in stopping it. There are career-oriented police officers like Lt. Daniels who has to choose between climbing up the ladder in the "Company" and doing what is best for his investigation, over the long run. In the first season, Daniels reaches a crossroads. He comes to a point where his conscience is at odds with his ambition. He has to make a decision between doing the right thing for his city and doing what is best for his career. In a moving scene he takes on the power structure of the police department. He chooses his conscience. He chooses the right thing. Obama, unfortunately has thus far chosen his career. Hopefully he'll be given another term and have another chance to live up to the ideals that he aspired to in Chicago.
iridium53
Semper Fi
12:46 PM on 08/29/2012
Nobody speaks of the poor, the hungry.

Nobody speaks of the War in Afghanistan - we still have people fighting there.

Nobody speaks of foreign policy - apparently because Romney doesn't have any knowledge on that subject.

The point is to talk only to the self-interest of the swing voters in a few swing counties in a few swing states.

A discussion of issues is now irrelevant.

A discussion of plans and hopes is irrelevant.

Proof of lack of corruption (taxes) and trustworthiness is irrelevant.

The only thing that matters is appealing to a small number of voters that, so far, have not paid attention and have a decision-making problem.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Rebecca Juro
Journalist, Blogger, Talk Radio Host
11:27 AM on 08/29/2012
The truth is that this is nothing new for Obama or the Democratic Party. As early as November '07, Obama was campaigning on protecting LGBTs from discrimination in the workplace by saying he supported passage of the Employment Non-Discrimination Act (ENDA) and would use the weight of his administration for fight for its passage, as evidenced here: http://www.bilerico.com/2007/11/a_call_for_full_equality.php

However, Obama has done nothing of the sort. Even with full control of the federal government during the 111th Congress ENDA didn't even get a vote.

The truth is that the Obama campaign assumes we'll be there for them because Romney would be a disaster, so they make no effort to be there for us when we need them.

Most telling example: In 2008, Barney Frank said (paraphrasing)"Get us 15 additional Democratic members of the House and we'll get ENDA passed next session." They got 22, full control of Congress and the White House, and ENDA didn't even get a vote. Now Nancy Pelosi is saying (paraphrasing)"Get us 25 new Democratic members and we'll get ENDA passed.".

What's next? Will we be sitting here without rights four years from now with Democrats telling us "Get us 50 new members and we'll get ENDA passed."? How much longer do we as Americans allow this bigoted shell game with our civil rights to go on before we finally stand up and say enough?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:48 AM on 08/29/2012
This list of promises broken by this administration is so long, its too heartbreaking and maddening to bother to enumerate. Even as someone who was never taken in by the obama hope and change marketing machine, I still cant bear to think about it too much.
How people were taken in so easily is truly a testament to the mind numbing brain washing effect of the MSM. If anyone had watched Obama during the confirmation hearings of Condoleeza Rice as Sec of State and Robert Alito as Justice, no one would have been too surprised by this administrations fails and tendency to immediately capitulate even before its challenged..
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Randy M Still
read Still Life on amazon.com
03:27 PM on 08/29/2012
I hear you, but LGBT did nothing but complain the early years of this presidency and Obama DID come thru, in a bigger way than any previous president, need I remind you. Of course oppressed people always want full rights, but lets not lose sight of the progress thats been made, and who helped in that struggle. Obama.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ecceme
Be afraid!
10:33 AM on 08/29/2012
Bill Moyers for presidential therapist!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Randy M Still
read Still Life on amazon.com
03:28 PM on 08/29/2012
We need him to run for president.