iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Bill Quigley

Bill Quigley

Posted: October 10, 2010 06:29 PM

"If it gets any worse," said Wilda, a homeless Haitian mother, "we're not going to survive." Mothers and grandmothers surrounding her nodded solemnly.

We are in a broiling "tent" with a group of women trying to raise their families in a public park. Around the back of the Haitian National Palace, the park hosts a regal statute of Alexandre Petion in its middle. It is now home to five thousand people displaced by the January 2010 earthquake.

Nine months after the quake, over a million people are still homeless in Haiti.

Haiti looks like the quake could have been last month. I visited Port au Prince shortly after the quake and much of the destruction then looks the same nine months later.

The Associated Press reports only two percent of the rubble has been removed and only 13,000 temporary shelters have been constructed. Not a single cent of the US aid pledged for rebuilding has arrived in Haiti. In the last few days the US pledged it would put up 10% of the billion dollars in reconstruction aid promised. Only 15 percent of the aid pledged by countries and organizations around the world has reached the country so far.

With other human rights advocates from CCR, MADRE, CUNY Law School, BAI and the Institute for Justice and Democracy in Haiti, I am huddled under faded gray tarps stamped US Aid. Blue tarps staked into the ground as walls. This is not even the hot season but the weather reports the heat index is 115.

The floor is bare dirt, soft from a recent rain. Our guide works with a vibrant grassroots women's organization, KOFAVIV, which is working with women in many camps, and she encourages residents to tell us their stories.

Anne has seven children. She would really love to have a tent. She and her family live on a small plot of dirt eight feet by eight feet. Sheets are tied to pieces of wood to keep out the sun. Plastic sheeting covers the ground. When it rains everything they have is soaked. She begs every day for food.

Therese has three children, 12, 11, and 9. She has lived in the camps since the quake. A few weeks ago when she went to get a bucket of water, some men grabbed her and raped her. Before the quake she worked as a street vendor but has no money to buy supplies to sell. She prays all day every day for help.

Caroline lived with her husband and three children in an apartment in downtown Port au Prince. The quake took her husband and left the rest of the family homeless. She was raped in the first camp she settled in. When she moved she was raped again and fought back with KOFAVIV. She and other women set up their own security with whistles and flashlights to protect each other. They push the police to arrest. Her life is now in danger because the rapists know who she is and she is vulnerable.

We hear from dozens of other mothers and grandmothers -- Alana, Beatrice, Celine, Marcie, Rene, Wilda and others. This is what they tell us.

There is no electricity at all in the camps. Some have lights on poles that work some of the time. Many have no lights at all.

There is no food. The children are terribly hungry. The food aid program was terminated in April and nothing took its place. The authorities cut off the food so people would leave the camps, but where is there to go?

Water is hard to find. For the people in Petion park, water is delivered by truck to a central site a block or two away in the middle of several camps. Thousands of people line up twice a day to get water before it runs out. In another camp we visited Sunday, Camp Kasim, there was no water at all for hundreds of families and none scheduled to be delivered until Monday at the earliest. Boys and girls surged around a pipe several blocks away trying to capture some water in Oxfam marked buckets.

People are coughing, sniffling, and their eyes watering. Quiet babies are the norm. Many have skin rashes and vaginal infections. There are several volunteer clinics but usually only the very sickest are seen because so many people need help. The biggest camps now have some toilets but not enough. Drainage is a big problem especially now during the rainy season.

Children cannot be kept in the suffocating tents. They play in the muddy paths. They would love to return to school but there is no money.

Security is a huge problem. Less than a dozen of the thousand plus camps have official security at night. During the day the police may come around or maybe the heavily armed MINUSTAH UN forces will patrol. But at night security forces vanish. With little or no light at night, tens of thousands of unguarded sheet structures and canvas walls offer thieves and gangs an inviting target. Violence against women and girls is widespread. Women who go to the latrines at night are attacked. Some women talk of carrying rape babies. Others will do anything for the crudest abortion. When they go to the police and ask them to investigate, officers demand money for gas. Even those who pay the police usually end up frustrated. There is a sense of impunity.

There are an estimated 1,300 "camps" of homeless people in Haiti. Homeless people live literally everywhere. People are camped in the middle of many streets. Shanty structures are built right up to the edge of streets. Every park, every school yard, every parking lot appear to have people living under sheets or lean to tents.

The most fortunate families live in modest plastic tents. The newest tents are royal blue with red flags with yellow stars on them -- donated in the last week from China. Less fortunate families, and there are many of them, live under faded sheets stretched between wooden poles made from tree branches. Within the camps there are dirt paths -- some only inches wide. Tents and sheet shelters are side by side -- inches apart.

Evictions are starting. Churches are pushing people off their property. Schools which are reopening are turning off the water to the people camped in the ball fields. Some in authority are openly saying that people must be forced out the camps. But only 13,000 temporary structures have been built and they are far away from family, school, jobs and healthcare. There is no place to go.

The UN, which effectively runs Haiti with the Haitians and the US, holds meetings nearly every day to coordinate responses to dozens of issues like security, food, water, reconstruction, and gender violence. Human rights advocates in Port au Prince complain that no meetings are conducted in Kreyol, the language of the Haitian people.

Yet there is hope. The Haitian mothers and grandmothers we heard from are fighting for their lives. KOFAVIV and BAI and other grassroots human rights groups are speaking out, demonstrating, educating the people in the camps, and working together for social justice.

During a torrential downpour Saturday, dozens gathered on folding chairs under the front porch overhang of BAI to work on how to get the US, the UN, Haiti and the NGOs to do their jobs.

Together the people have a chance. As one woman who works against violence told us, "If there is one woman and one man, maybe the man will win. But if the woman uses whistles to alert other women and gets other women to show up, maybe the man will see he is going to lose and will run away."

Meanwhile, Wilda and a million other Haitians are slowly dying from starvation, illness, lack of security and neglect. Nine months after the quake.

By Bill Quigley. Bill is Legal Director of the Center for Constitutional Rights and a professor at Loyola University New Orleans College of Law. He has worked in Haiti for years with Bureau des Avocats Internationaux and the Institute for Justice and Democracy in Haiti. He wrote this article from Port au Prince with help from Laura Raymond and Sunita Patel. You can contact Bill at Quigley77@gmail.com

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 64
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
07:25 PM on 10/12/2010
6 Billion dollars a day on war and we can't deliver a cent of the 1.3 billion promised. There are no excuses for this kind of heartless neglect. I am an atheist but it occurs to me that every religion in the world tells us to care for the weak and the poor. There may come a time when we face a catastrophic event and need the help of others. I find myself more ashamed of my country every day.
10:19 AM on 10/12/2010
Bill Quigley stated that: The food aid program was terminated in April and nothing took its place.

It is incorrect to state that after the end of general food distributions, no programmes were put in place to provide help to the most vulnerable Haitians.

In line with the Government’s National Plan for Recovery and Development, the United Nations World Food Programme has restarted and expanded key programmes.

All pregnant, lactating women as well as children under 5 years old living in camps, in earthquake-affected areas and in areas with a large influx of displaced people, still benefit from blanket distributions of fortified food. A Government/UN/NGO study demonstrated that this approach – focusing on prevention and treatment- helped Haiti avoid a malnutrition crisis in the aftermath of the earthquake.

With its School Meals Programme, WFP plans to feed 1,1 million children daily in 2010-11 in schools located in all 10 departments of the country.

To help increase food security and stimulate the local economy, WFP has started Cash and Food for Work initiatives. Projects focusing on rubble removal and other tasks provide work for people living in camps and in areas directly affected by the earthquake.

Other projects are designed to contribute to long-term agricultural rehabilitation. Providing better food security and improved livelihoods to Haitians in rural areas creates opportunities for people to remain on their land and for those who have left to return.

Stephanie Tremblay
World Food Programme
Haiti
10:16 PM on 10/11/2010
Forgot to mention in previous post that these are HAITIAN artisans in Jacmel, Croix-des-Bouquets, and Cité Soleil, Haiti ~
10:14 PM on 10/11/2010
There is one social enterprise up and running -- artisans selling Fair Trade goods through Macy's, providing employment for 350 artisans and secondary employment for 178. It's not a cure-all, but it certainly helps. If we purchase, more will be ordered and thus more employed .... http://bit.ly/9M5XpN
01:10 PM on 10/11/2010
I am an orthopedic surgeon who has done relief work in Haiti. The devestation and suffering there is unbelievable. There is a critical need for much more aid. There is also a problem that is almost taboo to talk about. Unfortunately too many of the Hatian people are sitting around waiting for someone else to save them. Trash and rubble is everywhere. The Hatian people need to find the resolve to start cleaning up themselves. The tent cities abounding in Haiti will be permanent unless the Hatian people go to work themeselves to clean up and rebuild. They still need our prayers and a renewed outpouring of aid. They also need to accept the hard truth that for the most part , the rest of the world has moved on and they need to as well.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
trouble4
Independent
09:02 PM on 10/11/2010
I'll agree with your statement. I was there a nurse a few months back, and I couldn't understand why the Haitians had not taken any initiative to provide for themselves. Why not move to a safer area, use materials in the rubble to build a temporary shelter, grow a garden to feed their families.

The conditions are horrendous, but no one seems to be doing anything to make it better for their families, they seem to be waiting for someone to do the work for them.
03:05 AM on 10/12/2010
that is absolutely ridiculous! i too went to haiti and was fortunate enough to meet with several grassroots organizations and activists in port au prince, petionville and cite soliel who are actively doing work to better themselves and their communities. and of course there's rubble everywhere because there is no heavy machinery! how are ppl supposed to remove the huge amounts of rubble with no heavy machinery? and many haitians have moved to other areas but soon have absentee landlords or ppl claiming to be landlords and displace, beat, rape or attempt to exploit those living on the land. and with the elections coming up, many ppl have been pushed out of their camps in order to be silenced and to avoid demonstrations by lavalas supporters. what we need to do is stand in solidarity with the ppl of haiti and question our own governments support of the upcoming elections in haiti which exclude the lavalas party. the party which the overwhelming majority of haitians identify with.
11:31 AM on 10/11/2010
I'd like to see armed groups of women doing security for themselves. After a few of the coward attackers were found the others might not be so bold. It sounds lawless by the author, but i wonder, why dont the people with homes support those without? Why bother opening a school if everyone is homeless and afraid to leave their tents? The popolation of Haiti is 9.7 million according to HuffPo, so aprox. 80% of the population doesnt do anything for the other 20%? Sounds about right...
lastpost
see biography
10:46 AM on 10/11/2010
“Nine months after the quake, over a million people are still homeless in Haiti”.
I saw on Russian TV, that their army had devised (revived from WW2 actually) “armaments” made from inflatable structures. Designed to reflect radar, and give an enemy a false impression. That their forces were far more extensively equipped that was the actual case. A slight redesign, and such devices could be turned into instant homes. Just press “inflate”, and step back smartly.

“only two percent of the rubble has been removed”
“Not a single cent of the US aid pledged for rebuilding has arrived”
A skilled labor force without jobs, and a job without a skilled labor force. If only there was some way of putting the two together. Hummmm…How about sending out some American temporary “migrant” labor, and getting the job done?

“Her life is now in danger because the rapists know who she is and she is vulnerable”.
Then make it clear that she is part of a large group of numerous other women. Who, if preyed on by anyone, will take it upon themselves to render justice. From the levelling-shadow of night, if need be.

“Together the people have a chance”.
But more importantly. Isn’t the media justified in concentrating on who will be the next VP?
10:42 AM on 10/11/2010
These facts are so harrowing and disquieting.Not only do the families have little or no food and water, but the women are being so degraded to nothing by men who abuse their physical power and rape and molest them. How terrible the human race can be.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MoreFreedom
09:27 AM on 10/11/2010
What are the people doing to help themselves? Are they rebuilding their homes? What is preventing them from producing goods and services? The reality is the Haitian government exists to exploit the people. It's lack of freedom is what causes the poverty. Government's purpose is to protect our liberties - but the reality in most of the world, is that those who govern, use their power to enrich themselves at the expense of their citizens. Government is evil unless it is restricted to just ensuring our liberties. When it goes beyond that, it takes our liberties for the benefits of a few. Haiti is a good example of government used for evil purposes.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Margie Kronewitter
08:37 AM on 10/11/2010
Where is the follow through from Bush/Clinton (I did see Clinton recently talking about Haiti, but haven't seen Bush ONCE). How much air time did our Cable News stations fill. Where's AC 360 who was the BEST at covering the earthquake. The U.S. should help Haiti & Cuba, because they are our neighbors. Sponsor Cuban doctors in Haiti... AND WHO IS THE REPUBLICAN WITH THE HOLD ON THE AID $$ ?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ClarcKing
Citizen
08:31 AM on 10/11/2010
There is an evil population reduction policy administered by the UN, NGOs, etc. The story in this post is a manifestation of the reality, that the people of Haiti are under an radical economic and population contraction policy and it is brutal.
photo
guveqzero
Inventor and Innovator
08:00 AM on 10/11/2010
Do you know why the aid has failed? Because we just feed people and expect them to rise from the ashes. But, they need fishing boats, fish farms, animal farms, all types of farms, not just handouts. The problem is what people consider as aid. First step, separate foodlines from aid centers. Foodlines alone will do nothing but prolong misery.

It's also time to replace the uneducated volunteers with teachers, but not US teachers. The US educational system is flawed, it's teachers are unprepared for this kind of work. I would recommend Europeans, they are much more in tune with working through social problems. Not perfect, but at least they understand a problem exists.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MoreFreedom
09:29 AM on 10/11/2010
Providing temporary food to the slaves of a government, doesn't remove them from slavery, nor does it ensure they will have food in the future. The people of a country are responsible to ensure they don't become slaves to their government masters. Haiti has tremendous disparity between the rich and the poor, the rich being those in the ruling class. Haiti is not a free country.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
granto2
05:03 AM on 10/11/2010
this should be the lead story on every news channel, every news report, every night until there is no choice left but to get very, very busy doing instead of talking. every american who donated should be asking their elected representatives to make it known where the money is. shameful and tragic. deeply disturbing on so many levels. thank you for the facts.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
starmanx
beam me up, Scotty
03:52 AM on 10/11/2010
One wonders where all the money went! Isn't there a way to track it? This is unbelievable and attempts must be made to rectify this mess. Shame!
02:01 AM on 10/11/2010
9 months in the middle of the rubble of a major city and all folks can come up with is a donated tarp?
Clear out some of the rubble and stack it to form a few walls. A million homeless huddled around waiting for someone else to care for them, they will still want charity 50 years from now. If they were told that no foreign help would come, would they possibly pick up a few rocks a day and clear the rubble in the next 9 months?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Margie Kronewitter
08:44 AM on 10/11/2010
sick and starving people deserve help, especially when so much money was donated. u r heartless. this is a typical Conservative comment. read the history of Haiti. they all deserve so much, starting with giving back from the Colonialists who exploited them. (French, US, etc.)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MoreFreedom
09:32 AM on 10/11/2010
The question is what happened to the donated money. Much of it went to government agents in Haiti, as aid often does in unfree countries. The only way for Haitians to get out of poverty/slavery, is for them to overthrow their corrupt government, and ensure they have a limited government that only ensures their liberty. Then they will be free to produce for themselves, instead of having to give it to their government masters.