iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Bill Schneider

GET UPDATES FROM Bill Schneider

President Obama the Warrior

Posted: 09/26/11 01:33 PM ET

President Obama the problem-solver is turning into President Obama the warrior. It just might save him.

Politics is the enemy of problem-solving. That's common knowledge. Why can't the country deal with the national debt? Politics. Why can't we do something about climate change? Politics.

We see more evidence of it every day. Why is the country on the brink of another government shutdown? Politics. Why can't we get disaster relief to people who desperately need it? Politics. President Obama told a rally this month in Richmond that the American Jobs Act could pass if Republicans "set politics aside for a moment to deal with America's problems."

Set politics aside? Not on your life. House Speaker John Boehner made that clear when he said, "Tax increases... are off the table." Obama's response a few days later: "I will not support -- I will not support -- any plan that puts all the burden for closing our deficit on ordinary Americans." In other words, "Go ahead -- make my day."

President Obama is by nature a problem-solver. That hasn't changed. The president's two big speeches this month were aimed at solving the nation's two big problems -- jobs and debt. He insists on a "balanced" solution that cuts government spending ("but not... with spending cuts that would hamper growth") and also raises taxes on the wealthy ("We can't just cut our way out of this hole").

Problem-solving is cool, rational, and technocratic. It sees issues as problems to be solved, not fundamental conflicts of interests and values. But politics is not just about problem-solving. Politics is also about causes and values that stir the blood: "us" versus "them."

Republicans have become totally committed to that ideological style of politics. Problem-solving is secondary. Every issue is a battle between "us" and "them."

The minute President Obama called for higher taxes on the wealthy, Republicans denounced him for "class warfare." A spokesman for the conservative American Crossroads political action committee told Politico, "The president is explicitly driving a wedge between Americans. That's not leadership, that's borderline demagoguery."

The president's response? "That's not class warfare. I'm not attacking anybody. It's simple math." What could be more bloodless than math? Math is problem-solving.

It will probably be impossible for President Obama to make deals with Republicans to pass his jobs plan or his debt-reduction plan. That's fine with many Democrats, who believe that every time Obama makes a deal with Republicans, he gets rolled.

The jobs problem and the debt problem are not likely to be solved in the next year. Which means that any attempt by President Obama to run for re-election as a problem-solver is likely to fail. So what can he do?

He can do what he did in 2008: stir the blood. Run as the passionate leader of a cause. In 2008, it was "hope" and "change." This time, it's "fairness."

President Obama mentioned "fairness" 11 times when he introduced his debt reduction plan: "Anyone who has signed some pledge to protect every single tax loophole so long as they live, they should be called out. They should have to defend that unfairness."

"Fairness" gets Democrats' juices flowing. But it doesn't always work.

In 1984, it was a flop for Walter Mondale -- who also promised to raise taxes. Mondale's error was timing. The "fairness" theme paid off for Democrats in the 1982 midterm. That year, unemployment peaked at 10.8%. When the economy is bad, middle-class people are receptive to the argument that there's something wrong with the system. They say, "People like me are hard-working and have the right values and we still can't make it. It isn't fair."

In 1984, however, it was "morning in America." When the economy is good, middle-class Americans say, "I'm doing O.K. and so are people like me. If there are some people who still can't make it, it must be their own fault." The fairness issue falls flat.

Right now, it's not "morning in America." It looks a lot more like 1982 than 1984. "When everybody went up, it was a lot harder to make [the fairness] argument," Sen. Charles Schumer told the Washington Post. Now another recession seems imminent. "I think the time is ripe again," Schumer said. "I think the president sensed that."

President Obama can run for re-election on two messages. Why are our problems not solved? Because Republicans put politics first. They refused to compromise. The other is "my values are better than their values." Fairness trumps smaller government. After all, solid majorities of Americans support raising taxes on the wealthy.

What will the Obama campaign sound like? Like President Obama in Cincinnati last week: "I'm a warrior for the middle class! I'm happy to fight for the middle class! I'm happy to fight for working people, because the only warfare I've seen is the battle against the middle class over the last 10 or 15 years!"

Fighting isn't problem-solving. It's politics. Sometimes good politics.

 

Follow Bill Schneider on Twitter: www.twitter.com/BillSchneiderDC

President Obama the problem-solver is turning into President Obama the warrior. It just might save him. Politics is the enemy of problem-solving. That's common knowledge. Why can't the country deal w...
President Obama the problem-solver is turning into President Obama the warrior. It just might save him. Politics is the enemy of problem-solving. That's common knowledge. Why can't the country deal w...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 74
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mcartri
11:21 PM on 09/26/2011
I collect Social Security and am on Medicare. I will only vote for Democrats next year. Why? Read the first sentence again.
photo
Hiphopcrates
Kicking the money lenders out of the Temple
08:41 PM on 09/26/2011
At this rate, maybe the warrior will emerge in 2016 when he publishes his memoirs.
Sergeant
Dress Right
08:38 PM on 09/26/2011
"President Obama is by nature a problem-solver. That hasn't changed." I disagree. He is a community organizer. A mediator. They are neutrals and don't take a side. His entire presidency has been a study of mediation. Problem is, the presidency demands hard decisions and taking a side, sticking to it and ramming it through ignoring the screams of dissent. Early on it was clear that he did not have the desire or ability to fight for what he believed in. Either that or he did not believe in anything very much. He seemed to be moving from one talking point to another.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
everything news
I have no bio.
11:42 PM on 09/26/2011
Probably because he was a Constitutional Lawyer he believed that working together with both sides was a fair way of running the government and that eventually they could find some compromises. . He never predicted how terrible this bunch of Republicans would be and how they would use blackmail all the time to get what they wanted regardless of how it would affect the country.No one had everhy seen anything like that. Maybe he has finally seen the light and realizes that they are just against him, not discounting the fact that he is not a white President.
The T-Party has exibited clearly that fact.
02:01 AM on 09/27/2011
I think you were right on, that he didn't believe in anything very much. When asked by a potential campaign manager for the '08 election, why he wanted to be president and what he wanted to accomplish, he had no answer.

He had not thought about it before, so could not answer the question. The potential manager left the meeting, declining to work with someone who seemed to be running for ego instead of the US.
-from the book "Game Change"
08:19 PM on 09/26/2011
Let's hope Obama is energized to use this and similar themes. The article states Obama can use two themes- Republicans are playing politics and values like fairness. I think he has a couple other choices, too. Couldn't say what they are...

But he has to stop pandering to cynical Republican politicians! If he stays a gentleman who expects Republicans to change, he will lose. If he drops his illusions and fights, he has a great chance to win.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mcartri
11:23 PM on 09/26/2011
He needs to clobber the GOP for being the party that wants to kill Medicare. That's how he wins Florida for sure.
07:52 PM on 09/26/2011
Sorry Bill, as much as you may wish the deux ex machina for Barack Obama, he is beyond repair.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:38 PM on 09/26/2011
Et tu Bill Schneider? It will take infinitely more than empty rhetoric and posturing to save this presidency. The Republicans continue to obstruct everything the president wants and the people will want results not explanations for failure in 2012, but Obama had his chance with the strongest progressive House and a solid Senate majority which he completely squandered with his asinine belief that the Republicans were not bringing real guns to his repeated rubber knife fights.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
everything news
I have no bio.
11:55 PM on 09/26/2011
The first two years he had to do lots of work to save us from a depression that was left for him by the previous administration. There was no surplus money , there was zero money. The 2 wars had not been paid for left for the new administration (on purpose) deregulated the banks so they could do whatever they wanted and so caused the housing demise.. He bailed out the auto industry because it is our bread and butter, which ended up repaying the loans with interest He has produced 2-1/2 million jobs, he strategized and won the capture of OSAMA BEN LADIN this country's number one enemy, which other presidents tried and failed to do.
I don't think you can call all that asenine. How much can a man do with so much opposition from the other side? We need to give him four more years and then talk.
06:57 PM on 09/26/2011
Obama,the first Nobel Peace Prize laureate warrior- the baton holder of the Cheney-Obama wars.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:53 PM on 09/26/2011
Ain't it funny how Barack found us common folks when we needed him and he needed us. Serendipity strikes again. "I'm a warrior for the middle class", a brother indeed. Heck, "the only warfare I've seen is the battle against the middle class for the last 10 or 15 years!" Yeehah! My president thinks I'm worth an explanation point, hooray!

The battle against the middle class began a long time ago. More recently we could start "With the bridge to 21st century." and the real estate meltdown. Yup, Clinton, Mr. Working Class Democrat, said YES, YES, YES, to Wall St and no money down. Monica?


What'd President Change do? He rehired the same think tank that said Wall Street and Las Vegas is good. And now he wants us to believe that he's been on the same side as Joe Public all along the watchtower. You get the President you pay for.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
No More Spin
Check your facts or I will.
08:13 PM on 09/26/2011
Curious how you conveniently neglected to include the presidencies of Bush Jr., Bush Sr. and, of course the quintessential figurehead whose presidency allowed for so much of the corporate influence in politics today, Reagan. The battle against the middle class goes back further than 15 years; 1980 is a fairly good starting point.
Sergeant
Dress Right
09:01 PM on 09/26/2011
Hey, he is just a regular guy who hires commun*sts until they are discovered [Van Jones] and was on a first name basis with people who had been on the FBI 10 most wanted list [Bill Ayers]. Other than that, just another guy.
05:57 PM on 09/26/2011
Obama's Latest Gaffe: Jews and Janitors

There’s long been more than a sneaking suspicion that President Barack Hussein Obama is a dyed-in-the-wool anti-Semite although there’s no doubt he is more prone to gaffes than even George W. Bush. His closet anti-Semitism may have met his “gaffery” over the weekend at the Congressional Black Caucus awards in Washington.

Quickly scrubbed from the official transcript of Obama’s speech advocating class warfare–technically, he was addressing what he called a growing disparity of wealth in the United States–the president mixed up Jews and janitors before he realized his Freudian slip but he had already been caught by the tale of the (video)tape.

I guess it’s easy to confuse the two. After all, both words begin with a “J.”

Not that much of the mainstream media will make mention of Obama’s “Jews janitors” flub; they’re still more interested in Bush gaffes.

The Jewish vote is, of course, critical to his re-election, not as critical as the black, union, and homosexual votes but very significant nonetheless. He needs money from all of them to hit his goal of a billion dollar campaign chest.

Blacks, unionists, and gays are guaranteed supporters but those Jewish backers have been slip, slip, slipping away in view of the administration’s policies on the Mideast and his kowtowing to Arab potentates and catering to Muslim interests at home. The last thing he needed . . .
(Read more at http://www.genelalor.com/blog1/?p=5558)
05:24 PM on 09/26/2011
The hope and change were based on half truths just to get elected your fairness is just another construct all to fool people all just to maintain the status quo and the ruling class

Example

1. Guantanamo Still open for business
2.Corporate business needs to pay their taxes Could you say GE then hires the Preseident
3.Stop special Interests and how Washington does business yet he hires Trumka
4.Iraq and Afghanistan We are still there
5.Stop the political rancor The president talks with a croaked tongue
6. America needs to stop U.S imperialism May I say Libya
7.stop president Bushes illegal wire taps uhhhh We are still doing it
8. Stop Rendition According to the Pentagram its still justified
9.Sen. Obama "Stop tax increase during a recession"
10 Last but not least Obama Care which is unconstitutional
Sergeant
Dress Right
09:07 PM on 09/26/2011
1. And he extended the Bush tax cuts, now the Obama tax cuts while railing against the rich.
2. Then he supported the invasion of Libya as a regime change. Something he criticized Bush for.
3. He tanked the EPA attempts this year.


I am a conservative and I am the first to admit these are not the acts of a progressive. I didn't even agree when they were the acts of a conservative. We should not be in a war unless there is a threat or actually an attack on the US [Afghanistan...not Iraq]. If you are going to be a change agent then stand up and have the b*lls to do it. He could have been a historic president. Instead, he is just business as usual but without the competence.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lgillooly
05:18 PM on 09/26/2011
Obama can do a lot, but not without the help of other Democrats. Where are they?
Also, the GOP is no longer a political party. They are owned completely by big industries. Those same industries control a lot of our media. 90 percent of our AM airwaves consist of right wing lobbyists that call themselves talk show hosts.
There has been barely any coverage of the protesters on Wall St, but if a dozen Tea partiers do ANYTHING it is all over the news. When tens of thousands protested in Wisconsin wehardley heard about it. Whoever controls the message will control our future.
07:17 PM on 09/26/2011
Where are the Democrats? They were last seen running away from the white house as fast as they could. Self preservation took over...
Sergeant
Dress Right
09:09 PM on 09/26/2011
Well, someone voted in the election in NY 9 and it wasn't corporations. And someone voted in November 2010 and it wasn't just the CEO of GE.

The election of 2012, if things don't get better, will be an historic election.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lgillooly
01:54 PM on 09/27/2011
That is my point. If Americans believe the President is a socialist, Marxist anti American with Muslim ties and possibly not even born here OF Course they will vote against someone like that. Unfortunately smears, lies and propaganda are allowed in our media.One of the worst is Rush Limbaugh and he is on hundreds of channels every day across the country. Any GOP er that has ever disagreed with him has had to crawl back and apologize. Sadly, this corporate lobbyist disguised as a talk show host is the defacto leader of the GOP.
photo
BillZBubb
Cogito ergo sum. Cogito.
05:16 PM on 09/26/2011
Yeah, Obama the warrior until he gets re-elected--then its back to Obama the appeaser.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Schalaine
We are women. We vote.
06:53 PM on 09/26/2011
Why would he? He can't run for another term. With the right Congress, the next four years could be good. Elizabeth Warren is just the beginning.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:40 PM on 09/26/2011
If he hadn't led us in the wrong Bush too! trajectory for the last 4 years, one could have hope that you are right. Unfortunately, it is more like self-delusion than accuracy to say that Obama will lead us anywhere.
Sergeant
Dress Right
09:10 PM on 09/26/2011
Elizabeth Warren is just one person and even if elected do you think she will get the podium instead of Harry Reid?
04:53 PM on 09/26/2011
Obama should have been fighting when he first took office. When you "negotiate" you end up taking the weak position. The GOP does not negotiate. They demand! Do this or else we shut down the government.
It is time to fight for the people of the USA. I mean the real live people not the corporate "people". It is time to get rid of the Billions of dollars buying the politicians.
It is time to cut all the politicians benefits, pay, and retirement! Make them use the same system the rest of us use.
It is time to refuse to pay any more for a meal than a normal business person get for taking a person to lunch.
It is time to STOP all this nonsense and start doing your job.
04:40 PM on 09/26/2011
Sure, Bill. This is gonna get Obama just as far as it did that other "Happy Warrior", Hubert Humphrey. Don't remember him? Well, that's why.
04:32 PM on 09/26/2011
A good Problem solver always would be a warrior or warrior. If one believes in hope of solving two major problems which US facing can be averted with fair political policies with gr8 understanding of prescribed solutions by Mr. president Obama . Why do one doesn't understands that cooperation is a good polity when there is a conflict of ideas of polity .. hope let be cooperation of peace prevail to solve present existing issues in US.God bless all .........