More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
BJ Gallagher

GET UPDATES FROM BJ Gallagher

Tithing: Sharing God's Abundance

Posted: 05/23/11 06:30 PM ET

Several years ago I was having a difficult time financially. Business was slow, I had some big medical bills and I'd not been as careful with my money as I needed to be. It was November, and I didn't know how I was going to make it through the end of the year, so I called my friend Anna to ask her advice. She had a good head for money.

I tearfully explained my predicament. She listened quietly. She was kind and sympathetic, completely understanding. She did not judge or scold. "You want my advice?" she asked, when I had finished telling her my sad story.

"Well, sure," I replied, "that's why I called you."

"Tithe," she said simply.

I couldn't believe my ears. "You don't understand," I objected. "I just told you: I don't have any money coming in, I've got all these bills piled up, and I don't know how I'm going to meet the mortgage next month. I can't tithe -- I have nothing to tithe with!"

"Well, you asked my advice, and I'm giving it to you," she said matter-of-factly. "All I have to share with you is my own experience. If you start to tithe, you shift your relationship with God. It is an act of faith in which you essentially say, 'I know I will be taken care of, so I can give this money back to God.' It works for me and it works for lots of other people I know, too."

I knew in my heart of hearts that Anna was right. Tithing was something I had wanted to do for a long time, but I was afraid -- afraid I would not have enough money to meet my needs, afraid to give away 10 percent of my income, afraid of financial insecurity. I had heard other people talk about tithing in the past, and being a spiritual person, I liked the idea -- but my fear always got the better of me.

"Here's what I'd suggest," Anna continued, "Why don't you call Naomi and ask her what her experience has been with tithing. Call Steve too, and see what he has to say. Then decide if it's right for you."

I thanked Anna for her advice, and immediately dialed Naomi's number. She was more than happy to tell me about her experience with tithing. She had been in similar financial straits a few years earlier, and Anna had given her the same advice she'd given me. Reluctantly, Naomi agreed to do it. She started by tithing to a 12-step community of which she was a member, because Anna had instructed her to "give to the spiritual community that nurtures you." Naomi took a check to the office of this 12-step program every time she got paid (she was self-employed in the real estate business). "The first time I tithed," Naomi told me, "I sold a $400,000 house the very next week! I made a great commission. I'm sure it was a direct result of my tithing."

After a while, Anna suggested that Naomi start tithing to her local synagogue, since she had been born and raised Jewish. "I'm not going to do that," Naomi protested. "I lost my faith years ago, and I'm not going to give them any money." Anna nudged Naomi, "Just try it. Do it a few times. See what happens." So the next time Naomi received got paid, she drove to the synagogue and gave them a check. Before long, the rabbi invited her to come to a special event at the synagogue. She went. She met a few people she liked, and she started going to more events. Her heart began softening toward the Jewish faith she had rejected, and over time she gradually felt more and more a part of this community. Finally, Naomi became an official member of the temple.

About this time, her young nephew turned 13 and it was time for him to have his bar mitzvah. She knew that her sister didn't have much money, so Naomi offered to pay for the bar mitzvah. Naomi had been estranged from her sister, but she loved her nephew very much, and she wanted to do this for him. Over the months of planning the ceremony and the party, Naomi and her sister gradually worked through their differences and were reconciled. The bar mitzvah was a wonderful day for the whole family.

In short, Naomi's commitment to tithe 10 percent of whatever she earned transformed her life. Tithing did more than put her on sound financial ground; it brought her back to her Jewish faith, it strengthened the bond between her and her nephew and it reunited her with her sister. She was living a life of miracles.

If I had any doubt about the efficacy of tithing, it disappeared in listening to Naomi's story. Tithing means acknowledging that no matter how little one has, there are always other people who are worse off. Tithing means saying to God, "I trust that You will provide for me, and I am willing to give back 10 percent to do Your work in the world." Tithing lifts the burden of fear from my heart and replaces it with trust. Tithing to a spiritual organization that gives me spiritual sustenance is the best way of saying thanks for all that I have received.

I once heard Jack Canfield (co-author of the "Chicken Soup for the Soul" series) talk about tithing and its role in his life. He said, "Both my co-author and I have been tithing for many years and we think it's an important part of our business success. But I have to tell you, it was a lot easier to write those checks when they were smaller. It's kind of hard these days to write tithing checks for $100,000, or more!" I laughed when he said that. Now, there's a problem I'd love to have!

I've been tithing for several years now, ever since the phone conversations I had with Anna and Naomi. I don't sell real estate, and I haven't had the success of "Chicken Soup" authors, but my finances have stabilized somewhat and the peace of mind I feel is priceless.

Tithing shifted my relationship to God from one of a fearful child pleading for God's protection to one of a willing partner with God in doing His work in the world. Most important, tithing gives me freedom from want and freedom from fear.

BJ Gallagher's new book is "If God Is Your Co-Pilot, Switch Seats" (Hampton Roads).

 

Follow BJ Gallagher on Twitter: www.twitter.com/BJ_Gallagher

 
 
  • Comments
  • 17
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
Dave24
Without God, life is everything.
04:55 PM on 05/24/2011
Invest in science programs and charities directly rather than donate through a religious institution. When the dioceses in California, Boston, etc. settled their abuse scandals for millions of dollars in order not to go to trial, where do you think all that money came from?

Or, just listen to this wise philosopher:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MeSSwKffj9o
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
BJ Gallagher
03:10 PM on 05/29/2011
Dave - I'm not Catholic and I'd never presume to tell anyone where to tithe or which organizations they want to support. I am appalled by the Catholic sex abuse scandals. But I also don't think that horrible actions by a few invalidate the good work of the many. The church has built schools, hospitals, orphanages, homeless shelters, universities, and has provided food, comfort, and shelter for many many people over the course of its history. If Catholics choose to tithe to their church, I respect their decision.
11:31 AM on 05/24/2011
I liked the article because it describes results of tithing that are unrelated to monetary rewards received back from God. And I know the Bible does promise that God will shower blessings on those who tithe. But I would like to suggest the greatest benefit of tithing is simply learning to trust God and experiencing the faithfulness of God. The second benefit is the ministry to neighbor that is a result of tithing.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
BJ Gallagher
03:13 PM on 05/29/2011
I agree. I didn't know anything about tithing until I started talking to my friends and asking them about their experiences. And they all said the same thing: "We don't give in order to get. We give because we believe that it's all God's money anyway, and we're just giving back in order to help others. Any benefit we receive is a bonus ... the real payoff is in living our faith."
10:52 AM on 05/24/2011
So if you tithe and nothing good happens, would mean what? To link tithing and doing well mentally, financially or otherwise is simply ridiculous.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
BJ Gallagher
03:16 PM on 05/29/2011
How do you KNOW that nothing good happened? Tithing is not a tit-for-tat kind of thing. It's just that in the case I cited, Naomi DID see what happened ... and what happened was not what she expected.
researcher
researcher
03:48 AM on 05/24/2011
"Both my co-author and I have been tithing for many years and we think it's an important part of our business success"

this america is what religion has come down to in america. tithing for business success.

got to love that religious mentality. the lack of understanding of spiritual laws and what all the great prophets have taught has given in to materialism.

are there any christians out there that can see the selfishness in this tithing for business success. just one christian, please just one. :-(

has capitalism warped our minds to this degree; we think giving money to a church gives us success in life?

atheists are made not born with this kind of religious mentality.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CMB1969
raging moderate
09:19 AM on 05/24/2011
It isn't about "success in life" as defined strictly by a higher cash flow--it is about developing a lack of attachment to money. In quite a few cases, that does, somewhat paradoxically, lead to abundance further own (usually by developing the psychological traits that lead to better financial planning and "wealth building", not by short term income spikes), but the real goal is financial peace of mind regardless of current circumstances.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
BJ Gallagher
03:20 PM on 05/29/2011
Thank you. You said it perfectly. Tithing is putting my money where my mouth is. It's easy to say, "I believe God takes care of me and I am always provided for." But it's a lot of harder for many people to actually LIVE those words. Tithing is simply one way of walking our talk.
01:28 PM on 05/24/2011
I don't think the point of Mr. Canfield's quote was that he tithed so his business would be successful. He was stating that a successful business has been a blessing of his and his co-author's tithing. You can still see his faith in tithing as he still tithes. Tithing doesn't make business sense. Giving away ten percent of your profit is ridiculous in a business sense when success or failure can be measured in tenths of a percent. I don't believe tithing in itself gives anybody success. But giving the first ten percent of your earnings to God shows you have put your faith in Him to provide for you, and that is where God will bless my finances. I have tithed my entire working life, not because I thought I would be blessed with a multi-million dollar book deal, but because I had faith that God could do more with 90% of my money than I could do with 100%. And I believe I have been blessed by never going without a house, food, and clothing, and never having to worry that I will be without that.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
BJ Gallagher
03:23 PM on 05/29/2011
That's correct. Canfield was tithing long before he was a wealthy author. He was tithing way back in the days when he was a school teacher. And I'm sure he would still continue to tithe if his book empire fell apart. Tithing is a spiritual practice. And those of us who choose this form of spiritual practice do so because we like how we feel and we enjoy the peace of mind that comes from following a spiritual path. Tithing is a way of giving back a small bit of what we have so generously been given.
07:48 PM on 05/23/2011
A wonderful article that highlights what religion is all about. Peace with self and others. Thanks for sharing. I recall a gentleman whose wife and daughter attended services religiously but his shadow never darkened the chapel doorway. One day visiting his home, he pulled me aside and said, "if anyone ever needs encouragement paying tithing, send them to me." I was surprised. I did not know he prayed, let alone paid tithing. We all benefit when we share with each other and with our Maker.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
BJ Gallagher
11:36 PM on 05/23/2011
Great story, which also illustrates the importance of giving quietly and anonymously. Giving isn't about "look at me, how generous I am" ... it's about giving gratefully and humbly. Thanks for your comments.
11:12 AM on 05/24/2011
Thanks and agreed.
06:21 PM on 05/23/2011
Reconciling with an estranged relative is not a miracle, and it doesn't require giving money to a religious organization.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
BJ Gallagher
11:39 PM on 05/23/2011
For some people, family reconciliation may not be a miracle, but for Naomi it was. And you're right, family healing is not contingent on donating money to church or synagogue, but what Naomi's story illustrates is that tithing often has totally unexpected benefits ... benefits that one would never expect.
12:40 AM on 05/24/2011
The problem I see here is that words have meaning, and you can't just take one word (in this case "miracle") and apply it to whatever situation you want. A miracle is supposed to be a supernatural intervention that defies natural law. A woman making up with her sister, no matter how strained the relationship, falls way short of that.

Naomi's story illustrates that one time tithing had unexpected benefits. It's not a demonstration of anything beyond itself. The reason you hear about how often tithing works is because nobody is going to talk about when it didn't work. There is a major confirmation bias at work there.