More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Bob Burnett

Bob Burnett

GET UPDATES FROM Bob Burnett
 

America After 9/11: Still Crazy After All These Years

Posted: 05/20/11 09:27 AM ET

The death of Osama bin Laden is an opportunity to reflect upon the deterioration of the United States since the attacks on September 11, 2001. We've entered into an endless state of war and our economy teeters on the brink of collapse. And, as a people, we've developed a distinctive derangement.

America's craziness developed in four stages over an eleven-month period: First, on November 7, 2000, there was a controversial presidential election. On December 9th the US Supreme Court intervened, and, as a result, George W. Bush became president. Bush had had an undistinguished business and political career and was the least qualified presidential candidate in eighty years.

Stage two: New presidents have a brief "honeymoon" period; Bush used his to advocate tax cuts so extreme many Republicans opposed them. The Economic Growth and Tax Relief Reconciliation Act of 2001 made sweeping changes to the IRS code: income tax rates, estate and gift tax exclusions, and retirement plan rules. (It lowered the top marginal rate -- the millionaires' bracket -- from 39.6 percent to 35 percent.) Although initially estimated to cost slightly more than $1 trillion, over time the impact of the act accelerated. In 2008, the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities estimated that, if continued until 2018, the Bush tax cuts would cost $4.4 trillion. They've profoundly changed the US economic landscape. Writing in the New York Review of Books, journalist Michael Tomasky compared these $4.4 trillion with the $4.3 trillion in cuts to government services in the "Ryan budget" adopted by House Republicans and observed, "'... all of this debate, all of this [so called] 'bravery,' is largely about paying for the Bush tax cuts.'"

Bush popularized a dysfunctional conservative belief that it is appropriate to enjoy government services without paying for them. The Federal government didn't shrink under Bush; it grew and began running mammoth yearly deficits.

Stage three: On September 11, 2001, the US was savaged by terrorist attacks planned by Osama bin Laden, the leader of Al Qaeda. Traumatized Americans looked to our president for leadership. Not surprisingly, considering his history of failure, Bush responded with a series of dreadful decisions.

In a 2004 interview bin Laden observed that, as a consequence of the 1980's war in Afghanistan, the Soviet Union had been forced into bankruptcy and "We are continuing this policy in bleeding America to the point of bankruptcy." Bragging, "[it has been] easy to provoke and bait this [Bush] administration," bin Laden stated, "Every dollar of al Qaeda [investment] defeated a million dollars [of US investment] besides the loss of a huge number of jobs... As for [the economic consequences of 9/11], it has reached record astronomical numbers estimated to total more than a trillion dollars." Bin Laden's primary objective was to bring down the American economy.

Despite intelligence warning of an imminent terrorist attack, George W. Bush didn't have a clue before 9/11 and, despite bin Laden's confession of why he attacked us, Bush didn't have a clue after 9/11. That's important to recognize, because while the May 2001 Bush tax cuts started the US down the slope to economic catastrophe, Bush's subsequent actions accelerated the calamity.

Stage four: On September 20, 2001, Bush spoke to Congress and the American people. Declaring, "Freedom itself is under attack," The president rallied the country to pursue a "war on terror."

Bush indicated that while the US security establishment would be deployed in a "war" on terrorists without a foreseeable end, average citizens had no role to play. "Americans are asking: What is expected of us? I ask you to live your lives, and hug your children... uphold the values of America." (Later, when asked what Americans could do, Bush responded they should go shopping or "go to Disneyland.") Notably, Bush did not suggest that his tax cuts for millionaires be revoked or that Americans, in general, make any sacrifice.

George W. Bush's failure to give average citizens a role to play was bad psychology, in general, as millions of Americans had been traumatized and having an assignment, however trivial, would have helped them heal. (In contrast, after the Pearl Harbor attacks, FDR enlisted all Americans in the war effort.) But the Bush "no sacrifice" policy disconnected average citizens from the conduct of the government; it ended the dream of "participatory democracy." And Bush's ill-conceived wars fractured the Federal budget, which ran huge deficits.

Bush's policies made no economic sense; the national debt doubled during his administration. Worse yet, they promoted a national schizophrenia: Bush preached, "government is the problem," while the Federal government ballooned in size and the average citizen grew increasingly uninvolved and anxious. Bush was deranged and over the course of his Administration he infected Americans with his craziness. A decade later, our dementia continues.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 62
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
04:56 AM on 05/23/2011
"Bush's policies made no economic sense; the national debt doubled during his administration. Worse yet, they promoted a national schizophrenia: Bush preached, "government is the problem," while the Federal government ballooned in size and the average citizen grew increasingly uninvolved and anxious. Bush was deranged and over the course of his Administration he infected Americans with his craziness. A decade later, our dementia continues."

Indeed, he was and it does...that's why I say let the GOP win on not raising the debt ceiling. The only way to break out of this dementia is to let them inflict pain on the very people that created them and support them, the rich.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
roninroshi
Oni ni Kanabo (鬼に金棒 )
03:36 PM on 05/22/2011
So elegantly written..."George W. Bush became president. Bush had had an undistinguished business and political career and was the least qualified presidential candidate in eighty years"... Shurb's POTUS election victories will confound basic common sense and morality for a millennia or more.
06:11 AM on 05/23/2011
Yet, we look at the crop of "wannabe's" and what has improved???? I would never vote "R" and this is why...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
beckpod1
12:59 PM on 05/22/2011
Homeland Security is an expensive joke...that only made things worse...I say you are either with people how have real facts and tell the truth...or you are with the liars.....
iflew
Dyno Remediator
12:21 PM on 05/22/2011
Remember how Bush told people to provide their own retirement? From personal experience I was aware of people including myself who went out and dumped money into financial instruments, 401, SEPs Roths Conv. IRA, Annuities etc. Guess what? after all those years the money is about the same number of dollars as what got put into the "Market". At the same time the purchasing power of the money declined. Medical costs up 8%/Year. Insurance 33%/Year for some years. Money put into investments like stocks, no dividends. My money paid to account manager compensation large on small accounts, small on large accounts, bonuses large on large accounts.

CEO compensation infinite. People who invested had it taken. That's how the unfettered private sector can be trusted.

During the backward market time a manager called his elderly widow client and told her since her account had dropped below $800,000 he would have to raise his management fee, so send more money. She said, "You lost it, you find it!".
iflew
Dyno Remediator
12:06 PM on 05/22/2011
Lowest tax on the wealthy in 60 years.

I think some republicans were unhappy the world didn't end on May 21st, 2011. Since the world didn't end they might have to pay taxes for all of 2011. They would rather ruin the economy and beggar their neighbor than pay tax. It follows they would prefer the world end than pay tax.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
pjwrites
05:13 AM on 05/22/2011
Bush was on the side of the terrorists, obviously.
Karma2U
Blessed are the Peacemakers
11:50 PM on 05/22/2011
I don't believe he was on the side of the terrorists - but he did allow the bin laden family to fly out of the country on 911 when all other air traffic was grounded. He also by his own admission dropped the ball on looking for OBL, after all, he made a spectacle of noting that his mission was accomplished.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rtx47
12:36 AM on 05/22/2011
Problems and Solutions in OUR HANDS.

Seeds of our decline were planted over four decades and before. These seeds are planted today, while we ignore results of what was sowed.

Today, half the marriages end in divorce; 60% babies are born to unwed mothers. About 50% children drop-out of school (70% in major cities); and additional 25% drop-out of college before graduation. These are results after spending billions on school and undergraduate education.

Senior citizens die in hospitals and nursing homes (raising health-care costs); because children refuse to care for them at home in their dying days. Between, end-of-life care and treating preventable illness we spend one Trillion per year; which is added to cost of goods and services.

Leaders in both parties and all levels of govt., various sectors of business, finance, industry, education, media, health-care, are only interested in their selfish well-being; while robbing society and country of billions of dollars in assets. Corporate CEO's are not interested in shareholder value. They want their annual compensation and bonus.

We have to stop the hype and self-glorification. Let's start accepting facts and speaking the truth. Spin has gotten us no where. We live high on the hog; with expectations that "sky's the limit" and we are a rich country. Last three decades should teach us that throwing money at an issue does not solve it. Often it makes the problem worse.

"We cannot eat our cake and have it too!"
missprissanna
the weight of the news nearly broke my back
05:18 AM on 05/23/2011
I find it very troubling to blame children who "refuse" to care for the elderly in their dieing days???....exactly how do you manage to care for grandparents or parents when you are working several jobs just trying to make ends meet, at the same time you are trying to help your children and grandchildren? Many of us boomers have helped care for our grandparents and parents....I suppose we're expected to be super people or something.

The majority of us AREN'T living high on the hog....
07:13 AM on 05/21/2011
You're right Bob, but since most Americans still think America is Numero Uno, despite all evidence to the contrary, decline is inevitable. To combat a problem you have to recognize that you have a problem. (You can quote me on that).
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nancy Hirabayashi
Liberal and proud of it!
09:47 PM on 05/20/2011
In two pages, with conciseness and accuracy, you summarized the bloody-awful decade wherein the Supreme Court appointed a "president," the American public was told to go shopping, the rich were rewarded for -- well, being rich, and witless old guys in funny hats surpassed rationality in public discourse. What would attendees at the Constitutional Convention have said, as they forged their painful but necessary compromises? Thank you for this excellent essay...what do we do now?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rtx47
12:49 AM on 05/22/2011
The take home message is the govt should balance the budget.
The last several decades has made it a pattern for the President and Congress to dole out money with no complusion to pay-as-you-go and make the difficult choices that leaders (elected or otherwise) are charged to undertake.

I'm not a Tea Party supporter; yet in many respects, TP has done this country a favor.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Querent
I just had to say that.
01:40 AM on 05/22/2011
It's amazing that you can look at all the symptomology and have NO CONCEPT of what's causing the disease.
06:14 AM on 05/23/2011
This isn't a tax problem, it's a revenue problem...there isn't enough revenue!!! Balancing the budget involves revenue...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thecreeksedge
09:23 PM on 05/20/2011
The commentary is pretty much on target, especially in terms of what has happened to the national psyche. We have truly turned into a country of nut cases, raving and raving about broad generalities that might have some basis in fact, but then allowing no real discussion about how we got in this mess and how we can get out. To deny that the Bush Tax Cuts and other policies ballooned the deficit is just nuts. To excuse the war policies regarding Iraq is to deny history. Bush and his Administration chose to initiate that war without significant justification and bullied anyone who opposed them with accusations of disloyalty. The war costs were "off the books," they didn't acknowledge their impact on the deficit. The prescription drug plan was not paid for. The economic meltdown occurred on his watch and the bailouts were launched with no intention of restraining the reckless practices of the financial industry. The real harm is that we are so divided as a nation that there is little reasonable chance of effective actions to turn this thing around. Bush succeeded somewhat as Governor of Texas because Democrats worked with him. Republicans have decided o obstruct every initiative of the Obama Presidency for purely political reasons. There is no question about the enormous harm this generation of the GREEDY ORNERY POLLUTERS (GOP) are doing to America.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Timothy Beauchamp
blogger and activist
03:37 PM on 05/30/2011
I was JUST getting ready to say the same thing ABOUT IRAQ. Iraq can NOT be glossed over.
05:51 PM on 05/20/2011
Start with disbanding the failure that is called TSA.
04:50 PM on 05/20/2011
Thank you for the excellent commentary Mr. Burnett.
01:17 PM on 05/20/2011
[quote]For liberty as we know cannot long survive in a country that is on a war footing or near war footing. Permanent crisis justifies permanent control by the agencies of the central government.[close]

– Aldous Huxley 1952 in Brave New World Revisited.
01:55 PM on 05/20/2011
How many AR 15's you own?
09:05 PM on 05/20/2011
Since he appears not to be a citizen of a largely deranged country, probably a lot fewer than yourself.
12:52 PM on 05/20/2011
Among the inaccuracies: Bush was a very successful governor of Texas, reelected with virtually no opposition. While the Supreme Court ended the Florida Supreme Court's political decision to conduct a skewed and fragmented recount, Bush won the election, as all subsequent studies have confirmed. We had no real forwarning of the 9/11 attack-- just the sort of general caustions received every day amidst a noise of intelligence--with difficulites "connecting the dots" substantially increased by things like the Church Committee mandates. After seven good economic years, the collapse of 2007 was brought on primarily by housing mortgage speculation, much of which was facilitated by Fannie Mae and Freddy Mac and, indirectly, their friends Barney Frank and Chris Dodd.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JDShipley
I drink coffee, therefore I am.
02:26 PM on 05/20/2011
More appropriately by largely unregulated securities speculation. Most subprime lending, the gunpowder to the housing crisis, occurred outside of Fannie and Freddie's reaches. Fannie and Freddie were late to the game; their size multiplying the problem, not causing it. Frank and Dodd are no more culpable than many others with lobbying and financial ties to the banking industry and Wall Street. If any sigular cause, look to the Fed's decision under Greenspan to ignore standing regulations that required ALL lenders to ensure the borrower's capacity to repay the loans. And, perhaps citing OBL as #1 is "noise" to you but it should not have been to the incoming Bush administration just as the outgoing Clinton administration should have paid more heed than launching a couple of Tomahawk missles. While reasonable to concede the outcome of the election, the SOTUS decision halted process that might have laid this issue to rest.
03:44 PM on 05/20/2011
On the Supreme Court thing, the Supreme Court stepped in when the Florida Supreme Court, along party lines, reversed the lower court whose Democrat judge had ruled for Bush. The Florida Supreme Court then made up its own nonstatutory procedure in which some counties would be recounted and some not. Democrats actually gave every appearance of trying to steal the election. On the OBL info, we knew he was bad, and we were warned often that he might try to do something. I'm sure there were a thousand similar warnings about 1000 othe bad guys too. I do agree with you that if Clinton had taken stronger action responding to earlier Al Qaeda attacks, OBL might not have felt he could hit the US with impunity.
allamericanboy
One of the original nattering nabobs.
02:43 PM on 05/20/2011
You have received some very bad information. I started to counter each statement but decided, if one holds these views to begin with, one is not easily swayed by facts or reality.
03:35 PM on 05/20/2011
The guy writing this article is provideing a lot of misinformation.
12:51 PM on 05/20/2011
Nice anti-Bush rant. Now, have you got any useful ideas to write about?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ProgressiveVoice
05:51 PM on 06/25/2011
If you can't understand how Bush put us on the path to where we are today - in a nutshell, Bush took a surplus budget and turned it into a national debt double what it was when he took office - then it is unlikely you would recognize a useful idea if it reached out and slapped you.