More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Bob Burnett

GET UPDATES FROM Bob Burnett
 

Obama's Tipping Point

Posted: 06/17/11 08:58 AM ET

This summer there's a lot at stake in Washington. The Congress and the White House are struggling over an agreement to extend the US debt limit before the August 2nd deadline. Meanwhile the economy has slowed and we may be sliding back into a recession, so a second stimulus is being debated. We're heading for a Tipping Point that will determine Obama's political future.

The notion of the Tipping Point was popularized in a bestseller by New Yorker staff writer Malcolm Gladwell. He defines the Tipping Point as "the moment of critical mass, the threshold, the boiling point," where a previously rare phenomenon becomes commonplace or where a social or political movement takes a new direction.

Recently in American politics we've seen a tipping point almost every year. In 2008, we saw two: first, Barack Obama snatched the Democratic nomination from Hillary Clinton -- the Obama nomination tipping point was probably his Philadelphia speech where he spoke about his pastor Jeremiah Wright and race. The other tipping point occurred during the second Presidential debate, where John McCain came across as senile, while Obama looked presidential.

In 2009, the tipping point came on February 19th when CNBC commentator, Rick Santelli, ranted about the government and threatened a reincarnation of the Boston Tea Party. Conservatives and Fox News commentators seized on this idea and the Tea Party movement was born, culminating in demonstrations, and Tea Party candidates being featured in the November 2010 mid-term elections, which caused Democrats to lose control of the House of Representatives.

Since the advent of the Tea Party, there hasn't been another tipping point in US politics but that hiatus will likely end in August. Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner has warned that the debt limit must be extended by August 2nd or the government will go into default. Democrats and Republicans agree this is a hard deadline, although some GOP Congressmen minimize the impact. The two Parties are attempting to negotiate an extension but, as of this writing, are miles apart. For Republicans, an essential element of any agreement would be reduction in entitlements, such as Medicare. For Democrats, an essential element would be the elimination of the Bush tax cuts for the rich.

As if this situation was not grim enough, the US economic recovery appears to be slowing and many experts fear we are sliding back into recession. On June 3rd the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported that only 54,000 jobs were added in May and unemployment remained unchanged at 9.1 percent. Consumer confidence has plummeted and approximately half of Americans believe the US is heading towards another Great Depression. The latest polling shows that Americans are far more concerned about employment and the economy (48 percent) than they are about the budget deficit (10 percent).

The conventional wisdom is that President Obama is in trouble because of unemployment, but the looming August crisis can be his opportunity. Guardian columnist Alex Slater observed that it's not simply "the economy stupid" but more generally about the direction of the US economy, "about hope." And hope is Obama's specialty.

There's every indication that Republicans do not have a clue about job creation and they are likely to refuse to raise the debt limit. If this happens it will both trigger a new depression and destroy the Republican Party.

Even the GOP comes to its senses and raises the debt limit, they do not have a realistic strategy to reemploy America. That's a huge opportunity for Obama, a potential Tipping Point.

Malcolm Gladwell writes that a Tipping Point requires three elements: "the Law of the Few, the Stickiness Factor, and the Power of Context." Tipping points require a few very influential people. In this case there is no one more influential than Barack Obama, who remains the most popular active US politician.

Gladwell observes that Tipping Points take advantage of unique windows of opportunity, context. In August we will have the context for a radical transformation of the economy.

Finally, a critical element of Tipping Points is stickiness, the ephemeral quality that "compels the phenomenon to "stick' in the minds of the public and influence their future behavior." Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal had stickiness.

One of Barack Obama's defining political characteristics is his ability to rise to the occasion with a powerful speech. We saw this when he burst onto the political scene with his keynote address at the 2004 Democratic convention. This January Americans were moved by his memorial address in Tucson. Once again, Obama needs to summon his oratorical skills and present his own "new deal."

In August, the US will come to a critical political moment. Whether we use this to go forward with a just economy or continue our descent into plutocracy will depend upon President Obama. For better or for worse it is his Tipping Point.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 229
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jcaunter
Profile: schizoid, INTJ, IQ145
10:03 PM on 06/19/2011
You missed a tipping point: when Obama's tool, Ben Bernanke announced QE2 in Jackson Hole. When that happened the US committed itself to full currency destruction. All the Democratic Party elites and their Wall Street masters have been planning for the destruction event to take place after November 2012, but now for various reasons it looks like we will see it while Obama has a good while left in office.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NAMI
Je juge , donc je suis
05:06 PM on 06/22/2011
JCAUNTER

hey would you mind clarifying FULL CURRENCY destruction ?
also , Bernanke is a REpublican so are most of Wall St. CEO and big shots.
miloiki
sweet as can be
09:03 PM on 06/19/2011
"One of Barack Obama's defining political characteristics is his ability to rise to the occasion with a powerful speech."

Alas, that is all he is good for...making speeches.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mistinguette Grandison
No. Corporations are NOT people
09:19 PM on 06/19/2011
He's better than that, and making speeches are a huge part of the job anyway. Communication is greatly important.
photo
CapitalismIsCancer
We live under fascism. RIP America.
12:34 PM on 06/19/2011
The murderous bankers on Wallstreet ran-up a $12 trillion debt to pad their corporate-commie pockets and their Tea Party henchmen want working class Americans to pay the bill.

This is the clear, factual reality the corporate media lies about and covers up.
photo
CapitalismIsCancer
We live under fascism. RIP America.
12:23 PM on 06/19/2011
Obama is a Reaganist, he said so himself.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TxAnna
12:21 PM on 06/19/2011
We may be coming to an opportunity for a tipping point, but it's really facile to think that if the President could just deliver one of those oratorial zingers he does so well that he'll finally become the progressive president We the People hoped we'd elected in 2008. He hasn't been that guy to date and I don't hold any hope that he will magically transform into that guy - even if the opportunity smacks him in the face. Didn't we already have these moments of opportunity - in the health care/health insurance reform process, at the time that the Bush tax cuts were supposed to expire, and now at a time when he should be talking about jobs and instead is being led into a dialogue about how much of the social safety net he'll agree to cut?
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Chris1962
NYC
11:56 AM on 06/19/2011
>>>The conventional wisdom is that President Obama is in trouble because of unemployment, but the looming August crisis can be his opportunity. Guardian columnist Alex Slater observed that it's not simply "the economy stupid" but more generally about the direction of the US economy, "about hope." And hope is Obama's specialty.>>>

Really? http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-503544_162-20027090-503544.html BS is Obama's specialty.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:31 PM on 06/19/2011
Say something with substance; I dare you.
09:46 PM on 06/19/2011
People who hate the president simply "because" don't deal in substance.
05:56 PM on 06/18/2011
"I predict future happiness for Americans if they can prevent the government from wasting the labors of the people"
Thomas Jefferson
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:32 PM on 06/19/2011
Revise "government" to "plutocracy of sociopaths" and the quote makes sense today.
03:22 PM on 06/18/2011
What's up with people foaming at the mouth to demand additional taxes on the rich? Those people earned their money and have a right to keep what they can. Instead of getting so work up about BTC (which by the way, did expire and was only revived by a Dem controlled senate and WH agreeing to it), why not ask Congress to do away with silly deductions and common acct. tricks to avoid taxes. No matter what the rate is, so long as there's way out, the rich could afford the best lawyers and accountants so they don't pay. Hence all this vitriol is misguided. Keep the rates, close the loopholes and place additional firewalls against tax mitigation (as avoidance is illegal).
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TRex86
Enjoying life in West Ohio
06:26 PM on 06/18/2011
You're half right. Do away with exemptions and tax preferences. It's absurd that the richest 400 Americans pay a 16% tax rate when the middle class pays more than twice that. Because the federal corporate income tax collects a pittance I would do away with it but require corporations to become pass-throughs, distributing their retained earnings (less working capital) as fully taxed dividends. If corporations started paying those juicy 6+ percent dividends the stock market would take off. Likewise, capital gains should be taxed as ordinary income, but I wouldn't tax the earnings on savings (dividends or interest).

The top 1% would not be harmed by jacking up their tax bracket five percent or so. They actually got the benefit of money borrowed from social security to cover the true deficit the last 30 years. They need to start paying it back. When (if) the economy heats up our federal budget should be as follows: revenues = current expenditures + amortization of the debt and unfunded liabilities of the entitlements. Are we grown up enough to do that?
photo
CapitalismIsCancer
We live under fascism. RIP America.
12:30 PM on 06/19/2011
They got rich on the backs of the working class who paid the tabs on these endless wars for resources and slave labor.

It's their turn to pay some back.....unless they want 280 million Americans tempted to strap on bombs.
11:54 AM on 06/20/2011
Yes Capitalism is EVIL. Lets all become socialists!!!! Maybe we can even be like Greece!!!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
innerpuppie
The truth is an absolute defense...
09:27 AM on 06/18/2011
Obama won't have a critical tipping point unless it included more money for the rich and powerful so their newfound cash could 'trickle down' to benefit the poor and middle class (yeah, right). He won't have any tipping point or epiphany - he isn't that creative. All he knows how to do is to bend over for the GOP and to hand out concessions to special interests like they were Halloween candy.
07:22 AM on 06/18/2011
These "tipping points" are petty ones that history will not remember. The biggest mistaken decisions are the ones that future historians will see more clearly than we can right now.

The two parties represent the same class interests. It wouldn't "make a difference" if they approved the election of a talking dog, our slide into history's trash can will not stop or even slow down. We passed that particular "tipping point" quite a while ago.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
John Ison
Marketing and Merchandising Expert
08:24 AM on 06/18/2011
this implies that there is no difference - which is just plain false - the GOP drove us into the situation we're in right now - that is a fact - another fact is they have no clue or no desire to solve our problems other than to suggest we double down on Reagan's failed trickle down philisophy. Gov does have a role in our nation and can do many things that we as individuals cannot - despite the rantings of the tea baggers and their ilk. But the GOP's "starve the beast" program has made every effort to destroy hope for a strong middle class in this country. There is a difference in the parties and saying there isn't is just another sell out to GOP bumper sticker philosophy.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
innerpuppie
The truth is an absolute defense...
09:30 AM on 06/18/2011
Yes, there is a difference in the parties; however, what we have in office at the present time is nothing more than a Republican in a Democrat's clothing. Obama has done more for the rich and business and the war machine as any Republican president of the recent past.

Differences in parties exist but in order to see what a Democrat could do in the WH we have to elect one first.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Opinionated Lady
Buy American - Bring industry home
08:26 AM on 06/19/2011
While I hate to admit it, the lines between the parties are increasingly blurred. In hindsight, the Rs have been ably assisted by the Ds starting with the elimination of Glass-Steagal, and advocacy for fair trade agreements - read that NAFTA. The President's current focus on debt reduction instead of jobs and his failure to speak out in defense of what used to be traditional D values offers some proof of this position.
Mike Rock
Right wingers, prepare to lose debate.
07:01 AM on 06/18/2011
If they don't tax the super rich this time, it's time for REVOLUTION.
01:32 AM on 06/18/2011
President Obama should let it happen, no matter how painful, and crucify the Republican party for a generation. Please do not cave Mr. President!
07:05 AM on 06/18/2011
Its shame your a American!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
John Ison
Marketing and Merchandising Expert
08:29 AM on 06/18/2011
the shame is that the GOP and their Tea Bag friends would do anything - including damaging the entire worlds economy to take power. And of course to insure Obama is blamed for their destruction of the American middle class. The fools are heading in a downward spiral of immorality all the while singing their hymns and clutching their misinterpreted bibles.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mistinguette Grandison
No. Corporations are NOT people
09:20 PM on 06/19/2011
So agree. He should point that out that this is what happens to a country when you put your political interests Over the people.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NAMI
Je juge , donc je suis
10:22 PM on 06/17/2011
WHEN a STATE CUTS ............it means CUTS JOBS.

where are the JOBS???? GOPers ?

HA i know you want to CUT JOBS so UNEMPLOYMENT Rate goes Up and OBAMA becomes a ONE term Prez !!!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
trusk
01:43 PM on 06/18/2011
We need private sector jobs. Gov employees do not bring money into the coffers, they take money out. We need State employees as well as Federal Government employees, but we don't need to have more than we need.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NAMI
Je juge , donc je suis
01:05 PM on 06/19/2011
trusk
I agree with what you say

BUT private sectors ie Big and Small BIZ know that there is no DEMAND (consumer driven economy is gone with the wind )so they do not want to create JOBS...........ALSO Most Business people LOVE TAX CUTs and Are aiming to bring back GOPer rulers .........so they get the BUSH tax cuts to become PERMANENT and also ....... Establish the PERMANENT REPUBLICAN MAJORITY ................ie and WILL become a ONE PARTY SYSTEM.........which is A TOTALITARIAN system
and if you listen to the Speeches and how they plan to keep the HOUSE and GET the SENATE and the PRESIDENCY you will understand their intent.

SO OBVIOUSLY they will NOT LIFT a FINGER to help OBAMA ie the AMERICAN ECONOMY until AFTER the 2012 .

Other thing i noticed is that the number of private sector jobs created in MAY was really 83,000 .................and because the GOV fired 29,000 people , the total
so INSTEAD of USING the 83,000 .......the all the MEDIA minused and said 54,000............................so you sould be satified that GOV fired 29,000 people!!!!!!!!!!!
10:20 PM on 06/17/2011
The self-serving and incompetence of Obama knows no end. The President his knowledge and abilities from the very beginning and capitualated to the status quo all the way down the line, particularly on the financial system, banking, the suicidal glogalist surge in the economy, and the Pentagon's foreign policy,the latter being the President's fourth branch of government. Obama depends on the rich and powerful to empower himself because he is not his own person. The Democratic Party is going to lose big in 2012 unless they replace Obama.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
trusk
01:45 PM on 06/18/2011
I agree with you. It's funny that Hillary wanted to be Prez so bad and now says she has no interest. I believe she could defeat Obama and any of the Republican candidates right now. I myself am a Republican, so I am happy she does not want to run.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NAMI
Je juge , donc je suis
02:46 PM on 06/19/2011
pedrnales

As if Obama had set up that system !!! No one person can dismantle that system.
SO, Stop blaming Obama in that BLANKET manner that you do.because you lose credibility

Only the Progressives have some LEGITIMATE criticism of Obama ...........and even those do not take into consideration the CONTEXT. which is THE Biggest FINANCIAL Crisis/crash of the last 70 years since the Great DEPRESSION.

This is a NEW NORMAL , so none of the OLD Normal cliches will or should this time.!!
Obama will be just the better the alternative in 2012, both for US and for the USA internationally.
photo
Fez
Ignorance is no excuse for the law.
09:28 PM on 06/17/2011
Where is it written that Americans are entitled to the highest standard of living and that this standard will always get better for each succeeding generation? There are consequences for decades of deluded economic policy in which "growth," the strategy of a cancer cell, has run this country into the ground. It's juvenile to believe that banks can plunder with impunity and transfer their risks to the public as they collect the returns. The reckoning is here and our standard of living will decline as surely as the sun sets in the west.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Romeover
Civilization is for weaklings.
10:17 PM on 06/17/2011
Why should the standard of living increase? Because productivity is increasing.

Where is it written that the increased wealth due to the increase in productivity should go to the one percent of the population that is already obscenely wealthy?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NAMI
Je juge , donc je suis
02:54 PM on 06/19/2011
romeover

bery well said..........BRavo why should only the super rich expect Eternal Prosperity ? and the others year over year poverty.?
This is totally untenable..................this is not FAIR and Democratic American any more.