More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Bob Burnett

Bob Burnett

Posted: October 1, 2010 09:21 AM

It's a familiar joke: A man falls off a forty-story building; as he passes the twentieth floor, a friend yells out the window, "How's it going?" and the faller screams, "So far, so good!" Now it's become the Republican campaign theme.

The United States is in free fall. The economy is stagnant and shedding good jobs. We've lost our edge in the global marketplace. The middle class is getting squeezed out, as the rich get richer and the poor poorer. We're stuck in an endless war in Afghanistan. Horrific problems, such as global climate change, are ignored. Millions of voters believe the good ship America has lost her way.

Meanwhile Republicans play blame games. Stoke the fires of polarization. Chant: "So far, so good. Let's shut down the government."

As the US heads into a critical midterm election, the US electorate is more polarized than at any time since the Vietnam War. And Republicans view this as an accomplishment rather than as a problem.

Attitudes about health care reform typify our political division. The latest Kaiser Foundation Tracking Poll indicates that while support for the bill is increasing -- 49 percent of respondents now have a favorable opinion of it versus 40 percent unfavorable -- the opposition has become more entrenched. 26 per cent feel the bill should be repealed "as soon as possible." (A Fox News poll shows that 44 percent favor repealing.)

There's a hardcore conservative minority that opposes everything the Obama Administration proposes: economic stimulus, action to spur employment, tax increases for billionaires, campaign finance reform, repeal of "don't ask, don't tell," cap and trade legislation to limit emissions, and on and on. They don't have any substantive counter proposals; they're united by hatred of Barack Obama.

Recently, the GOP released their Pledge to America. If these were not such serious times, the document might be dismissed as political humor, a parody of 1994's Republican Contract with America. Pledge is best understood as a baroque overture to the Tea Party movement that has its own Contract from America.

These conservative manifestos share three components: First, the belief that power has to be returned to the states, that much of what goes on in Washington is unconstitutional. (Conservatives believe that, because of the Tenth Amendment to the Constitution, many Federal laws are unconstitutional because they usurp power from states -- the so-called Tenther movement.) The second component is the desire to reign in government spending and cut taxes - although there are few serious proposals on how to do this other than defunding health care. And finally, conservatives propose to solve the energy crisis by removing all barriers to exploration of domestic reserves and operation of US power plants -- regardless of the environmental consequences or the fact that this won't solve the problem.

Neither the Pledge to America nor the Contract from America consider the United States' most pressing problems, how to: guarantee good jobs for working Americans, end the war in Afghanistan, ameliorate global climate change, and reduce the role of moneyed interests in American politics. These are "So far, so good" plans that ignore America's real problems and instead appeal to nativism.

Given that the conservative manifestos are not solutions oriented -- they're rants -- why are polarization politics working? Why does the enthusiasm gap favor conservatives?

An obvious answer is that it's easier to be against something rather than for it, particularly in the middle of a depression. Rank-and-file conservatives who were outraged by the election of Barack Obama have seized upon difficult economic times as an excuse to rail against all things Democratic.

But there are two other culprits. Every problem is someone's opportunity. And America's problems have presented conservative media with a terrific opportunity to expand their base. As Barack Obama's numbers have fallen, Glenn Beck and Rush Limbaugh's have risen.

But let's not forget the free-market capitalists, the power elite who were the real base of the George W. Bush era. Conservative powerbrokers like the Koch brothers have seized on inchoate populist anger, molded it into the Tea Party movement, and harnessed it for their avaricious purposes.

There are unusually high stakes in the November 2nd midterm election. It's about more than which Party will control the Senate and the House of Representatives, which Party will be seen as having momentum going into the 2012 Presidential election.

Conservatives want to shut down the Federal Government. Republican Senator Jim DeMint brags that his objective is paralyze the Senate in "complete gridlock."

Their plan seems to be working. The United States is in free fall and the radical Republican response is, "So far, so good. We want the government to crash."

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 736
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (10 total)
05:38 PM on 10/19/2010
I've read many of the preceding posts - all prediictable. The question, I think this article provokes, is which party (since we're married to parties) will best stop the polarization? As most posters here continue the blame-game with neverending proofs of their party's superiority, the most I can assume is that regardless of who wins in November, the polarization will continue and this conversation will not look any different in March as it does today.
12:35 PM on 10/11/2010
The Democrats are just as bad as the GOP. The GOP is honest about it but the Democrats say they care and say they understand but then make all the same compromises that the GOP wants and which keep making the same mistakes that created this mess.

This is NOT the time for compromisers. This is not the time for bailing out billionaires "for the greater good".

This is a time to end pretty much every policy of the past 30 years: NAFTA, free trade with slave labor China. H-1b, open borders, US involvement in state building around the world. It all has to end.
MarkInTexas
Moderate is the new liberal.
12:58 PM on 10/13/2010
You know, we possibly may come from opposite sides of the political spectrum, but there's nothing in your post here I can disagree with.
03:25 PM on 10/07/2010
Obama, Biden and Rahm have all engaged in polarization efforts against their base too.
Obama is advancing the corporatist agenda against the wishes of Democrats... offshore and onshore drilling expanded, taxpayer dollars for nuclear, no accountability for war contractors, Wall Street or conservative Supreme Court activism... continued subsidies for oil and gas that dwarf his "green" spending... Social Security under attack by "experts" Obama coddles despite ideological hostility... entrenching corporate interests in health care... wars continue while claiming to end them... targeted assasinations with innocents being killed... economic warfare against Iran for exercising legal rights we agreed to... tolerating war crimes by an ally... continued rights and privacy intrusion... and on and on.

Sorry, but this left/right post is based on a faulty premise just as divorced from reality as the GOP.

I get the motivation to advance party politics, but...
photo
Left of Right
Want to default your country? Default your job!
04:57 PM on 10/05/2010
Excellent article, Mr. Burnett! I fan you!

I think another reason why we are in free fall, in addition to finding it easier to be against than for, is the compelling attraction to fear. And the fear is everywhere--the extreme right-wing AM Radio programs, the Becks, Hannity's, and O'Reilly's, the tea-party
rebel-rouser's like Palin, and the cowardice, misinformation, corporate-protecting rhetoric from them all and from those in office and those running for.

I believe that is why Fox and AM Stations have such high ratings, and why these candidates are drawing crowds and votes; people are drawn to fear. It is the emotion and adrenalin of it, I believe. Like turning out to watch a train wreck. They are being told where to lay blame for their troubles. The lies and misinform gives people a target. All they have to hear is where to point the finger of blame and "we will fix it," and they are drawn into a psychological euphoria of hope. It is a type of mass hysteria.

The problem is, they are not checking their sources. As you say, the voters are going the easy route. Unfortunately, they are being deceived and they are voting away their rights.
03:27 PM on 10/04/2010
"As the US heads into a critical midterm election, the US electorate is more polarized than at any time since the Vietnam War. And Republicans view this as an accomplishment rather than as a problem."

It IS a well-deserved accomplishment.

There is a misnomer that only Democrats tax and spend. The FFACT is that Republicans borrow and spend equally as bad. Think about this FFACT: There are NO fiscal conservatives in the Democratic party. There are very few fiscal conservatives in the Republican party. That means that both parties tax, borrow, and spend our children’s money at will.

This also means words that are used to imply some sort of “middle ground†between Republicans and Democrats like â€bipartisanâ€, “moderateâ€, “middleâ€, “centristâ€, or â€independentâ€, are more accurately describing the different degrees of “willingness to move towards Socialismâ€. In other words, if you find “middle ground†it never means a step towards conservatism.

This use of these terms also presents itself when liberals use words like “obstructionistâ€, “gridlock†and phrases like â€we need to come together†to imply that conservatives are taking an objectionable stand. They use these terms knowing that the “compromise†or “common ground†will ultimately be a conservative capitulation resulting in a liberal resolution that moves our country closer to Socialism.

Children should watch for these terms knowing that when used, a liberal is demanding that a conservative move his position towards socialism. Get the FFACTS about spending our children's money at http://theffacts.com/.
photo
68Namvet
Sioux, French, German, Jew, American mutt
08:08 PM on 10/04/2010
So does that mean any move by a democrat toward conservatism is moving our country towards Fascism?

And if there are "NO fiscal conservatives in the Democratic party" how do you explain Clinton's record of reducing the size of government, reducing discretionary spending and operating from and turning over a budget surplus?

And why is doing nothing except spending money for unneeded wars and going deeper in debt for tax breaks for the wealthy a "well-deserved accomplishment".

Just wondering.
01:10 PM on 10/05/2010
1. How are “individual responsibility†and “less government control†a move toward Fascism?

2. Clinton was definitely a fiscal-liberal but also a populist in that he discarded his big-government plans to insure his re-election. He reluctantly compromised with conservatives, in selling his political soul, and that slowed the move towards socialism.

3. Wars are never “unneededâ€. Wars can be fought with stupidity, costing way too much money, but they always serve a purpose. That is, people around the world hate the United States, and envy its rich people, just the way you do. However, unlike you, the people around the world that hate us are very dangerous and must be stopped. They can’t be reasoned with, they must be stopped. So, I agree with you that the war has been way too costly, especially in human life, but let’s be clear that freedom is never free.

Regarding tax breaks for the wealthy, who is this wealthy and what do they do with their money? Unless they stick it in their pillow they are spending or investing it which means more jobs. You just think that the government taking this money is the right penalty for someone who succeeds. You miss the crucial fact that wealth creates wealth. That is, for every rich person there is hundreds if not thousands of other wealthy people because of the rich person’s efforts.

Class envy not good: http://theffacts.com/2010/09/10/ffact-class-envy-gives-liberalisim-the-perfect-villain/
photo
68Namvet
Sioux, French, German, Jew, American mutt
02:47 PM on 10/04/2010
It amuses me when conservatives want to blame the economic problems on Obama. Truthfully, he is responsible for continuing the war folly of bush - costing us unnecessary $billions - and the stimulus was far too small to correct the problems.

Simple analagy - the republicans (bush, republican Senate and House) drove the economic bus down the mountain ($600 billion drug bill to protect big pharmaceuticals, $1.4 trillion tax cuts primarily benefitting the wealthy, $1 trillion unfunded unnecessay war in Iraq) to the edge of a cliff. Quickly they (bush) threw a life line (TARP) to the drivers (Wall St. & wealthy) and hauled them to safety. They left the bus and passengers (main street middle class) hanging on the side of the cliff. Obama sent a small tow truck (stimulus) to hold the bus from falling further down the cliff - but, it was too small to pull the bus back up the mountain. What was needed was a large crane to move the bus. What the now safe drivers (republicans) are asking for is to cut the ropes to the tow truck, take the money spent for the tow truck and give it to the drivers (retain the bush tax cuts) and then they can buy a new bus and can start driving it again.

Incredible!
photo
68Namvet
Sioux, French, German, Jew, American mutt
02:28 PM on 10/04/2010
You seem to forget that this is no longer the "land of the free and home of the brave" but, rather, has become the land of the easily frightened and home of the chronically stupid! People no longer pay attention to facts or reality - but base their opinions and their votes on misplaced beliefs and faith.

Ask a "conservative" (republican) if they stand for smaller government, less deficit spending and increased personal liberty and they will undoubtedly scream "Of Course"! Yet, of the last five administrations, only Clinton's actually reduced the size of government (by both numbers of employees and discretionary spending). Of the last twelve administrations, only three (Reagan, Bush 1 and Bush 2) increased deficit spending and the national debt as a % of GDP. And from warrantless wiretaps to "gay marriage", suspension of habeus corpus to requiring immigration papers of anyone appearing Hispanic and wanting to amend the Constitution, or (god forbid) building a (shudder) Mosque - Liberty has become "freedom to be just like me", period!

Likewise, "liberals" (democrats) don't see the hypocrisy of appointing a tax dodger to be Secretary of the Treasury, don't get promises of transparency given way to secret meetings to gut major health care and financial reform bills, or continuing the unnecessary Iraq war, rendition, Guantanamo, expanding Afghanistan, and on and on.

Whatever the elections bring, this country is in deep trouble.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Devaron Namsaar
10:52 AM on 10/04/2010
Just watching the parade of politicians trying to cut off each others head is amusing. Once upon a time politicians performed real jobs, like representing the people who elected them, and issues that were real to the people in their state or neighborhood. Now all these people (politicians) think about is themselves... "Got to get re-elected"... got to keep those "Contributions" (aka bribes) coming in... got to think about my future... blah, blah, blah....
A more sick group of bastards have not been assembled on this earth since the days of Rome (just before the fall of Rome).... come to think f it, I believe I hear Nero playing again!
I did figure out how to save billions of our tax dollars... and cut out 90% of all pork from the budget. Just disband the entire GOP... send the party of NO home forever. Just tell them No thanks, we don't need you or want you any further... Your dis-service is no longer needed!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Willie12345
09:36 AM on 10/04/2010
Bobby, Bobby, Bobby.......after the Democrats completely cut the Republicans out of any serious discussions while they held a super majority..........and now to talk about polarization created by the Republicans is unbelievable.
dtlewis
No micro-bio for you!
10:55 AM on 10/04/2010
Blatant falsehood there Willie. That the Repugs have nothing to offer in the way of solutions to the issues before the American people may be ripe for perversion by those on the right it does not alter the fundamental reality that conservative economic policies have over the past thirty years proven only disastrously detrimental to all Americans in possession of little or no capital. There is absolutely nothing the cons have to offer that can be reasonably expected to improve the lot to those who have gained only increased suffering and economic dislocation as a direct result of Republican party and conservative tax, trade and domestic economic policies. Fraud is about all you have to offer so if you want your party's input to be taken seriously as a reasonable policy contribution, put forward policies that have demonstrated a high probability of success at redirecting commerce in such a way as to actually improve the prospects of those not favored by existing law and holdover conservative economic policy.
considerthis
I try my best
11:31 AM on 10/04/2010
Where have you been Billy Boy Billy Boy?
09:59 PM on 10/03/2010
We do live in the land of extreme freedoms, including the freedom to poop on one's own head and then lie about how great it makes you feel and how great the smell is. We have the freedom to show off how ignorant or stupid we are. And every once in a while, probably more than most of us would like, stupidity reigns and the proudness shines bright, not even able to be dimmed by the stench. The thing is, we all have to live through it and ultimately clean up the mess, only to allow them another go at it. There seems to always be another generation of nincompoots emerging that believes a good story, even though it's been proven a lie a hundred times.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Chris Long
06:37 AM on 10/04/2010
ObiaMan, What is that on your head ?
10:36 AM on 10/07/2010
Must be poop. The good thing is, my nose doesn't work all that good and I ain't gotta look at it, so, it don't really bother me. But if you were really wondering, it looks like I must have had my hair pulled back pretty tight into my pony tail the day I took that picture. But, I can assure you, if it is poop on my head, someone else put it there. I've actually had a magnificent life. I just happen to love and work hard for the working class, the real people, those constantly getting ripped by the ultra rich and their businesses. And they do it through the republican party. Always have.
07:48 PM on 10/03/2010
I would venture to say most TeaBagger/Repugs have no idea how much trouble America will be in if they get their way. They don't get how expensive shuting down the government will be - aren't they the ones who worry about the deficeit? They don't get that they risk losing their precious social security and medicare. They don't get the Republicans want everything to get WORSE, not better - all to push their political agenda. If the Repugs have their way, we will be moving toward a caste system - the ruling, wealthy class and everyone else would be surfs.
photo
Left of Right
Want to default your country? Default your job!
05:01 PM on 10/05/2010
Yes! F&F!
01:19 AM on 10/16/2010
What makes you so sure that we are not already there? Seems like most of the poverty-level "working poor" have already entered serfdom. We are already living in an oligarchy, we are just calling it something else so we, as a nation, don't have to face the fact that the last 20 years of politicization have, effectively, destroyed our voting system. With the blessing of the Supreme Court, "corporate interests" are now the rulers of the US.
photo
abbienormal
What hump?
06:38 AM on 10/03/2010
The difference between conservatives like ron46032 and the rest of us is how we feel that we should live together as a community. Most of us want our fellow Americans to do well. We don't want to see each other without food, housing, jobs, or education. We believe that we will survive as a better nation if we take care of each other and we believe in fairness. Heck, experiments show that even dogs believe in fairness.

The Conservatives consider their neighbors to be people that they try not to hit driving to work in the morning. Oh, unless that person gets raped. Then they care a lot about what happens to that person and her body. Oh, and unless that person wants to marry someone of their own gender. Or unless a person happens to be gay and wants to become a teacher. The list is endless.

Basically, as I can surmise from their policies, Conservatives want to be isolated from their fellow Americans unless those fellow Americans are different from them. Then they want complete control over their fellow citizens.
04:10 AM on 10/03/2010
It's not a Contract FROM America...It's a Contract ON America.
04:09 AM on 10/03/2010
Can this also serve as a wake-up call for the Left. You may also not agree with everything the Democrats have done (or not done) but if this turns into an "I won't vote so I can show them" moment, please just realize what you will get as a result. This is what Biden meant when he said to stop whining - it was not to stop the constructive criticism and to try to move Obama in more progressive direction, it was to stop and think about the consequences now, in this electoral season.
photo
Left of Right
Want to default your country? Default your job!
05:04 PM on 10/05/2010
So true! It is time to fight so we may hold our ground and continue forward. If any listless democrat is going to with hold their vote, it is the same as giving the vote to the other side.

Fanned & fanned!
12:33 AM on 10/03/2010
ron46032, I can NOT for the life of me believe that anyone would think it is okay to shut down the government, are you NUTS? What about the elderly that get SS or Medicare? I am so sick of this crap. All I can say is that if the Republicans and the Tea Party gets the majority, America is screwed.
photo
Left of Right
Want to default your country? Default your job!
05:04 PM on 10/05/2010
Thank you! F&F!