iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Bob Deans

GET UPDATES FROM Bob Deans
 

Wind Energy a Lifeline for Drought-Stricken Farms

Posted: 08/29/2012 5:24 pm

The killing of Billy the Kid was still within living memory for some on the stark, wind-swept prairie outside Ft. Sumner, N.M., when Powhatan Carter's grandfather settled there to raise cattle in 1937.

Twelve years later, Pow was born there, where he runs the family cattle business his grandfather began.

After two years of drought, though, Carter's land is so dry that even the durable native grasses in his pasture are dying.

With little grazing land remaining, and the cost of feed sky high, Carter has sold about half of his 450 beef cattle, months before he normally would and at a poor price. Soon, he said, he'll have to sell more.

To rebuild his herd and restore the dead turf will take years, Carter said, adding to the strain of keeping his grandfather's homestead intact.

"It's just hard to keep the land in the family, because most people are land rich and cash poor," Carter said in a telephone interview. "An outside boost makes all the difference."

Fortunately for Carter, he gets such a boost, about $35,000 a year for the electricity produced from the seven wind turbines towering above a series of rocky bluffs at the edge of his pastureland.

Come rain or shine, the winds blow steady, the turbines spin, and the checks come in the mail. And, for Carter, the extra cash means one thing.

"Survival," he said, "able to stay home, where you've always lived."

Watch NRDC's Bob Deans talk about the future of wind power in America:

Welcome in any year, income from wind turbines has become an economic lifeline for thousands of farmers and ranchers like Carter across the country's vast heartland. With more than half the country searing in the worst drought in half a century, much of the nation's corn, wheat and grasslands parched to ruin and cattle ranchers struggling to feed or liquidate their herds, wind turbines are providing back-up income that is helping to keep family farms and ranches alive.

"It's truly a blessing for us," said Carter. "It's kind of like the sky falls with a little more rain."

Windmills have been part of the landscape of the American West for more than a century, harnessing the force of the wind off the plains to pump water from wells or generate electricity for homes long before power lines crisscrossed the country.

Thumbnail image for _DSC9827.jpg

Photo by Melanie Blanding

Modern wind turbines, of course, are much larger in scale, with generators the size of tractor-trailers perched atop steel towers typically 200 feet tall. The power they produce goes into the commercial electric grid, where wind turbines are beginning to make a significant contribution to the nation's energy supply.

Wind provided 4 percent of the nation's electricity during the first four months of this year, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration. By the year 2030, the U.S. Energy Department reports, they could produce 20 percent of the country's electricity, as much as nuclear power plants generate now.

More than 98 percent of wind turbines are located on farms, ranches and other private lands. And the industry pays out more than $400 million a year to property owners and local tax collectors, according to the Washington-based trade group, the American Wind Energy Association.

Those payments make up a growing part of a diversified revenue stream for more and more of the nation's farmers.

"It's there every year," said Joe Jury, a fourth-generation wheat and silage farmer on family land near west Kansas town of Ingalls. "It's there to use as you need it, when you need it, and, in years like this, to use it to make up for the crop income that doesn't come in."

The $18,000 Jury receives each year for the nine small wind turbines on his cropland is money he can count on in tough times, "kind of like a rainy day fund," he said.

"It helps cover variable costs, equipment costs and other fixed costs you might have," Jury said in a telephone interview. "It's just additional income that helps you when things are short."

A half hour west of Amarillo, Texas, new wind turbines are going up on the farm where Perry Kirkland raises wheat, sorghum and corn.

"It's definitely welcome revenue, and it couldn't come at a better time," said Kirkland. "It's been very stressful and difficult to make farming stand on its own the past two years because of the drought."

Seasoned farmers and ranchers don't expect an easy time of it earning their living off the land. The money they get from wind turbines, though, provides a bit of a cushion that, in some cases, enables them to continue a way of life they cherish.

"If it's not a lifesaver, it's certainly something that has allowed farmers and ranchers in this area to continue to do what they want to do," said AJ Swope, executive director of Class 4 Winds & Renewables, a non-profit trade association and advocacy organization in Amarillo.

"I don't think people who aren't in this industry understand how fiercely those ranchers hang on to that identity," said Scott White, oral historian with the National Ranching Heritage Center at Texas Tech University in Lubbock.

"They consider themselves caretakers of the land. But, when nature is destroying it, it kind of takes their feet out from under them," said White. "The turbines help, and what the money's mostly going for is repairing fences and barns and supplying feed to cattle."

Similar sentiments are being echoed across the American breadbasket, where the summer drought has meant hard times not just for ranchers and farmers, but for the tractor dealers, grain brokers, lumberyards, hardware stores and myriad other businesses that rise and fall on the fortunes of agriculture.

"If affects everything in rural America," said Jury. "It affects the whole economy. A year like this, everybody kind of goes into survival mode and pulls back. You're just struggling trying to stay afloat."

Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for _DSC9300.jpg

Photo by Melanie Blanding


Wind turbines are helping to diversify the rural economy, providing jobs that don't dry up in a drought. Nationwide, some 75,000 Americans make their living building and maintaining wind turbines. A good technician can earn $70,000 a year or more, solid income in most farming communities and attractive to younger people who want to make a living in the communities where they were raised.


"Our enrollment keeps growing," said Andrew Swift, director of the Texas Wind Energy Institute at Texas Tech. About 100 students are enrolled, he said, in the school's bachelors degree program in wind energy. "It's been big, and growing, and keeps us all hopping."


The graduates, some of whom don't see a bright future on the farm, are finding work on the turbines.


"When wind first came, there was a real breaking point around here in terms of the demographics," explained Greg Wortham, mayor of Sweetwater, Texas, a major wind energy hub. After a few tough years in the cotton business, a new generation was coming of age when farming's future looked bleak. "Wind came along at exactly the same time," Wortham said, providing good-paying jobs that helped keep young people in the area. "Wind," he said, "was crucial."


Wind turbines and the transmission lines they rely on have boosted the tax base in scores of rural communities that have been struggling for decades.


"It's an economic developer's dreamland," said Don Allred, judge and chief executive of the Texas panhandle county of Oldham.


A decade of wind development has increased his county's property tax base from $156 million to more than $500 million, he said. As a result, "We were able to give a 10 percent reduction in the taxes, while increasing our revenues by more than 12 percent," he said. "In a small county like ours, that's a tremendous amount."


As often happens when new technologies change the landscape in unfamiliar ways, wind turbines have favored those who are best positioned to take advantage of them, meaning, in large part, owners of large parcels with strong winds.


"Bankers down in Abilene call them their windinaires," said Swift.


For the most part, wind turbines aren't making farmers and ranchers rich. In hard times, though, the cash coming in from wind turbines just might make the difference between keeping the family ranch or farm, or having to find another way of life.


"It's nice to have it if you do need a new truck or something," said Carter, the New Mexico rancher. "But most people just need it to survive."

 
FOLLOW GREEN
The killing of Billy the Kid was still within living memory for some on the stark, wind-swept prairie outside Ft. Sumner, N.M., when Powhatan Carter's grandfather settled there to raise cattle in 1937...
The killing of Billy the Kid was still within living memory for some on the stark, wind-swept prairie outside Ft. Sumner, N.M., when Powhatan Carter's grandfather settled there to raise cattle in 1937...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 29
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:54 AM on 09/04/2012
Survival for some -- illness and habitat destruction for others. How about in your next piece you illustrate the habitat destruction and impaired hydrology from the wind farms being built on New England's ridgelines. Or how about the illness and ruin from those who through no fault of their own have to suffer from the infrasound, flicker and lowered property values. Really - this reads like propaganda. In New England we are being asked to destroy intact ecosystems for a cause that would be better served by reducing the real culprits - transportation and heating oil. Next time we get a Tropical Storm Irene, I hope you're there to witness the destruction caused by blasting our ridgelines and putting parking-lots on them. Try watching from the bottom, where the floods blast through our infrastructure. And we get to pay for this destruction ourselves. BETTER IDEA: reduce our consumption and put tax dollars towards efficiency. If you're skeptical, watch the movie "Windfall" available for streaming on Netflix.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kent Otho Doering
Ex -Pat in Germany- "Why Burn Money"-Pro-Renewable
09:40 AM on 08/31/2012
There was one questions about Wildpoldsried posted to me I cannot answer, How many farms does the village have?. To be honest, I do not know because that is not listed on their home website. If you type in "Wildpoldsried" you will get a number of articles about it, some in English. The village solar co-op feeds solar power to the local utility at the higher feed-in tariff rates mandated by German law. The co-op wind turbine and manure methane re-capture fuel cell p.g.. is fed into the grid on a different tarif. Using the current technologies, the average manure methane recapture power output per German farm is 100 KWh, 24.7 / or it can be pressure stored, and used at night when the wind is not blowing.as base line back up.
Germany is exiting nuclear. A number of nuclear power plants have been shut down, and the rest go off grid by the end of 2022, about 25 GWh off or being taken off the grid. The massive build out of agrarian methane-recapture- will put at least 22 GWh on the grid in that period- literally "replacing nuke with poop power". And with double the amount of fuel cells as reserve, the gas can be stored on site..and SMART GRID coordinated called up when built out wind and solar slack as "fast ramp up power". -base line back up reserve - of over 50 KWh! ..
04:06 PM on 08/30/2012
Bob,

You mention "A good technician can earn $70,000 a year or more, solid income in most farming communities and attractive to younger people who want to make a living in the communities where they were raised." Where did you get that stat?
10:27 AM on 08/30/2012
The price of oil, coal and nuclear keep rising.

The price of wind and solar keep dropping.

Easy choice.
06:42 PM on 08/31/2012
I flew over those wind turbines in New Mexico. They weren't spinning. Easy choice.
04:46 PM on 09/19/2012
so i guess that means you would be dissapointed if solar panels dont produce power at night too? Get real, the wind doesnt always blow sherlock. Renewables have a place, they arent the only answer but they are proven. Plus a commercial size wind farm is not built if it isn't economically viable.
04:34 PM on 09/10/2012
Just whatever you do steer clear of Endurance Wind Power. We sunk our own money into one of their turbines three years ago with a promised five year return on our investment. It was no small investment. It was supposed to generate enough power to meet our need an eliminate our electric bill, this has not happened. In fact, in three years it hasn't even generated the energy it was supposed to generate annually.

Within the first two months it began developing issues, now three years later they continue to send parts to the local dealer and promise a fix that never comes. It has never worked for more that three months without a problem and has never performed even remotely up to expectation. They do not support their product, they do not support their local dealer, they do not make good on promises and are a slip-shd operation from every angle. I am sure there are good companies out there that produce a good product, but Endurance Wind Power is not one of them.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
alteredstory
Hold on to the center
10:26 AM on 08/30/2012
For perspective, the fossil fuel industries have received an accumulated $640 billion or so in federal aid over the last 100 years.
10:26 AM on 08/30/2012
Wind and solar are the future of energy production.

We all need more safe, clean alternative energy.
10:22 AM on 08/30/2012
Now that we have this cute article on how landowners benefit from the turbines, why not one on how landowners and communities benefit from oil and gas extraction. $35K is pocket change compared to what oil and gas can pump into a community and state.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rucio
07:42 AM on 08/30/2012
Crumbs. For the $5,000 per turbine that Powhatan Carter is promised per year, the developer is promised about $1 million over 10 years of tax breaks. The wind industry claim that they pay out more than $400 million a year to landowners and local tax collectors neglects the fact that it receives well over $5 billion a year from federal taxpayers, including the very landowners it's "enriching".
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rucio
09:03 PM on 08/30/2012
I miscalculated. The developer gets almost $2 million from taxpayers over 10 years. And that's per turbine. And the one's on Powhatan Carter's land are relatively small compared to today's models, designed to extract even more public money for the developer's profits.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
vetxcl
02:16 AM on 08/31/2012
No link, no proof , no fact.
10:33 AM on 08/31/2012
The typical return from the Production Tax Credit is based on performance, that is for every Megawatt hour of energy sold to the grid, they get 22 dollars. These turbines in New Mexico were 1.5 Megawatt rated, average about 1/4 of that day in and day out, so in a year , each turbine makes 1.5 MW ( .25 * 8760 hours )= 3,285 Megawatt hours , at 22 $ each that is $72,270, since the tax credit lasts 10 years, then that is $722,700 for each turbine, and remember it is a TAX CREDIT, it goes to waste if the owner is NOT MAKING MONEY and PAYING TAXES!!, then they can reduce their tax using this credit, but only if they OWES TAXES!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kent Otho Doering
Ex -Pat in Germany- "Why Burn Money"-Pro-Renewable
04:59 AM on 08/30/2012
Hi, its the old ey-pat vet Green Freak from Germany again on Wildpoldsried:
We talked about wind, solar, and manure methane recapture letting Wildpoldsried generate 2.5 times more power than it uses. Currently, septic tank, manure methane recapture p.g. and heat is installed at about 2.5 % of Germany´s farms. It will be built out because methane has "greenhouse warming effect" 25 times higher than co². With Fuel cells -and Stirling heat recapture p.g. driven generators. average farm output will be 150 KWh,, not including wind and solar
Built out to encompass all 200.000 farms by 2025- that means 30 GWh on the Germa grid from septic tank-manure methane recapture p.g. - the equivalent of 30 nuclear power plants. - or 120 big coal burning plants. It is a solid back up baseline power source for backing up wind and solar p.g.. Solar, wind, and methane recapture are the three technologies being applied in EEC agrarian region renewable energy build outs. .In Germany, agrarian farm p.g. based on those three will be generating - well over 53.000 MWh -by 2025- 17% of the coutry´s total energy needs. (from Nuke to Poop power) German goals are off nuke by the end of 2022, and off fossil p.g. and heat-hot water by the end of 2025. Agrarian region wind, solar, and septic tank- manure methane recapture will contribute a lot towards reducing greenhouse gas emissions and cutting global warming.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
vetxcl
02:20 AM on 08/31/2012
Nice to hear that Germans aren't afraid of using newer technology like Republicans in this country are. Good to hear that they're using wind energy and not just solar energy, as the German reputation is here in the States.

Keep up the good work.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rucio
11:07 AM on 08/31/2012
Karl Rove was a featured speaker at this year's American Wind Energy Association conference. George W. Bush was keynote speaker 2 years ago. Bush and his pal Kenneth Lay of Enron are the reason Texas is the country's leader in wind energy and were instrumental in establishing the federal package of subsidies that make it so profitable. Most big energy companies are totally into wind, because it provides easy greenwashing as well as substantial tax avoidance. The current CEO of the AWEA, Denise Bode, a longtime operative for petroleum and natural gas, was on Dick Cheney's infamous energy panel.
07:11 PM on 08/31/2012
30 nuclear power plants would produce 30 GW-years (assuming 1,000 MWe). That's about 9,000 times greater than the 30 GWh you've attributed to septic methane.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kent Otho Doering
Ex -Pat in Germany- "Why Burn Money"-Pro-Renewable
03:23 AM on 08/30/2012
Great- the ex-pat in Germany - knows how agrarian wind programs in wind rich areas can boost farmers incomes.

Most German farms are too small to independently put up wind... But, villages band together, and do wind assessments as to where to best position the wind towers on their respective lands. (villages here are such that the farmhouses are clustered in a village while the fields are spread around them.)

In Wildpoldsried Bavaria, farmers joied a co-op, and pitched in together to build thier own wind tuirbie grid around the village- feeding into the local grid. They also took advantage of German solar subsidies- and feed in tariffs for solar as well... and every farmhouse- has solar voltaic and solar heat as well. The farms also have septic tank and manure methane recapture systems- which power fuel cells for heat and hot water and power-- with additional power coming from heat difference Striling motors driving generators. The village produces 2.5 times more power than it uses.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Unitynow8
Liberal World Citizen
07:34 AM on 08/30/2012
Makes my German heart proud
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
vetxcl
02:20 AM on 08/31/2012
faved again.