Huffpost Politics
THE BLOG

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors

Bob Hagan Headshot

Two Systems of Justice? Why No Arrest?

Posted: Updated:
Print

Do we have two different systems of justice -- one for the wealthy business person and another for the common folk? As the Ohio governor and business interests joined hands in this latest incident, and as the governor got his enforcers to overlook the violations, and as the poisonous brine seeped into our valley and flowed to other communities downstream, I got my answer.

Under Ohio law, the businessman had committed a felony. This incident recalls to my mind an arrest of six students and one Vietnam veteran in November, 2011. They were protesting the delivery of these same toxic chemicals at another place owned by the same businessman. Their concern focused on the injection well that they believed was causing earthquakes in our hometown. The earthquake took place a mere 1½ mile from my home. The governor, who has taken a sizeable amount of money from the gas and oil lobby, was ignoring their calls to shut the wells down until more environmental studies could take place.

No matter, these "outlaws" were arrested, thrown into jail overnight, booked for disorderly conduct and fined. Fast forward to now and you will see what I am seeing and what most of those good people in my town are seeing: a justice system skewed for the corporations and the apparently invisible person who did the crime. The college kids and Vietnam vet were thrown in jail for a misdemeanor while the businessman has not even been arrested. Hey, we know he certainly has the money to post bond and not suffer the fate of jail, but why has he not been arrested?

Here in the much exploited, underpaid and heavily abused valley (once dubbed "Steel Valley"), our old town of Youngstown, sitting in the middle of the rust belt, watches history keep repeating itself. We have watched it first-hand: arrogant corporations turning their backs on us and rolling their eyes. For one hundred fifty years the steel magnates socked it to us and our environment, treating the Mahoning River and the citizens of our community with contempt. Their money-making operations spewed toxic wastes, slag and chemicals from blast furnaces, open hearths, coke plants and finishing mills to pollute and poison water that once supported wildlife, fishing, boating and swimming.

Then they left town.

Today, the gas and oil businessmen have ambitiously stepped in to fill the vacuum and carry on the abusive tradition established by their industrialist forefathers.

On Feb 5, I learned from the front page of the (Youngstown) Vindicator that a businessman, who calls gas and oil drilling his occupation, found a better way to dispose of the byproduct of his business -- toxic brine. He simply found an open storm sewer on his property and reasoned, what the heck, it drains into the Mahoning River and once there it's not my problem.

This same businessman, who had been cited 120 times by the executive branch of our state government, had finally maxed out on the Ignore Button by dumping over 40 thousand gallons of toxic brine waste right into the river! This precious stream was beginning to repair itself after so many years of abusive treatment. Citizens in our community have spoken hopefully of our once-declared-dead river returning to its original luster when wildlife, fishing, boating and swimming were common fare.

The businessman in question, first distanced himself from any involvement, but after a whistle blower came forward, he admitted that he indeed had ordered his employees to dump the poison.

I am an elected official representing this district and as a member of the Ohio legislature, I can tell you that I and many of my colleagues take seriously the responsibility of providing important checks and balances of government. In this case we are alarmed and angry.

My visit to the dumping area coincided with the state's on-site inspection where the violations would be reviewed and covered by Ohio Department of Natural Resources employees. By covered I really mean covered-up. This injection well owner, brine hauler, and horizontal drilling person had been dumping for so long that no one knew exactly how to answer my questions. How were they protecting themselves at the site? How many thousands of gallons had been released into the Mahoning River? What kind of chemicals has been identified? As I write this firsthand account I am still waiting for the answers. Are the governor and his administration more concerned with protecting his ODNR employees and the gas and oil industry than he is in protecting the health and well-being of our citizens in Youngstown?