'Justice for Vieques': Resolutions Passed by Both Houses of Puerto Rican Legislature

The United Nations and both houses of the Puerto Rican Legislature have now passed resolutions supporting the people of Vieques in their struggle with disease, contamination and neglect from the United States Navy's 60-year bombardment of the island.

When will the Obama Administration follow through on Obama's campaign promise to clean up the island and provide justice for the Vieques residents sickened by the Navy's actions?

The people of Vieques are experiencing an ongoing health crisis created by the U.S. Navy, which left behind a toxic brew of chemicals and heavy metals, including depleted uranium, napalm, mercury, arsenic, and lead from bombing and other military training activities. Residents of Vieques suffer from abnormally high rates of cancer, birth defects and other serious diseases. Scientific studies show this stems from their contaminated environment.

The U.S. government's ongoing neglect of the cleanup and health effects afflicting the people of Vieques have generated overwhelming public outrage in Puerto Rico and beyond. Groups which have called on the government to provide a just remedy for Vieques include the United Nations; the Congressional Hispanic Caucus (CHC); the League of United Latin American Cities (LULAC); the National Association of Latino Elected and Appointed Officials (NALEO); the National Council of La Raza (NCLR); the American Values Network and others.

The Senate of Puerto Rico passed a resolution on June 19, 2009 calling on President Obama to:

"recognize the extraordinary contributions and sacrifices made by the residents of Vieques to the preservation of our national security over a period covering more than six decades." The resolution further states that "it would be in the best interests of the United States of America to address the losses and ongoing medical and economic needs of the U.S. citizens on Vieques, which could be resulting from the U.S. Navy's long bombardment and contamination of the island" and suggests that "the fastest, fairest, and most efficient way to correct the injustice and health crisis is for the U.S. Government to resolve the claims pending in the US District Court in San Juan as well as those pending for the Municipality of Vieques before the Secretary of Navy." [unofficial translation, PDF]

A similar resolution passed the Puerto Rican House of Representatives a week later on June 25, 2009 [PDF]. And a resolution reaffirmed last month by a special committee of the United Nations:

"Urges the Government of the United States, in line with the need to guarantee the Puerto Rican people their legitimate right to self-determination and the protection of their human rights, to complete the return of occupied land and installations on Vieques Island and in Ceiba to the people of Puerto Rico; respect fundamental human rights, such as the right to health and economic development; and expedite and cover the costs of the process of cleaning up and decontaminating the impact areas previously used in military exercises through means that do not continue to aggravate the serious consequences of its military activity for the health of the inhabitants of Vieques Island and the environment." [PDF]

During his campaign for President, Barack Obama promised the people of Puerto Rico in a February 2008 letter that his administration would:

"actively work with the Department of Defense... to achieve an environmentally acceptable clean-up of the former U.S. Navy lands in Vieques, Puerto Rico. We will closely monitor the health of the people of Vieques and promote appropriate remedies to health conditions caused by military activities conducted by the U.S. Navy on Vieques."

Instead of following through on his campaign promise to help Vieques, President Obama has not yet acted, and - perhaps emboldened by silence from the White House - the Justice Department has pursued a defense of "sovereign immunity" to protect the Navy and deny justice to the people of Vieques.

Hiding behind an archaic principle derived from the Middle Ages when, ostensibly ordained of God, "the King could do no wrong," is hardly the change that the people of Vieques expected from the Obama Administration. While there may be legitimate uses of national security arguments in defending the military's actions in other instances, the U.S. Navy's abhorrent conduct in Vieques does not merit such forgiveness.

Over 7,000 Vieques residents who are plaintiffs in an ongoing mass tort action have documented multiple failures by the Navy to comply with specific, mandatory environmental regulations. They also cite the Navy's failure to warn the people of Vieques of the harmful effects of toxins released into the island's air, water and soil.

But the government is now using the "sovereign immunity" defense to claim that:

"there was no specific and mandatory provision requiring any warning to citizens of Vieques regarding environmental hazards, and any warning would have required balancing competing concerns of secrecy and safety, national security and public health." [pg 21 of PDF]

The Justice Department even has the gall to suggest in a recent court document that:

"With respect to any warning, the Navy would have had to balance its military and national security needs against any perceived benefits to public health and safety in light of the risks and burdens of a warning program and the great public anxiety warnings could create." [pg 23 of PDF]

Yes, you read that correctly. In the government's twisted logic, warning people about the impending bombing that will contaminate their air, water, soil and bodies could harm them more than the toxic contaminants themselves.

How thoughtful. Viequenses now suffering from cancer and birth defects must feel grateful to the government for saving them from the anxiety of being warned about their exposure beforehand.

President Obama must quickly intervene in this matter and ensure that the people of Vieques are not denied their day in court. They have sacrificed greatly for our nation and deserve swift justice, attention to their health problems, and a thorough cleanup of their island.

It's time to deliver on that promise, Mr. President.

Follow Brendan DeMelle on Twitter: www.twitter.com/bdemelle

Comments

[Rhotel1]

There is no depleted uranium hazard at Vieques. The little that was accidentally fired there was removed from the ground years ago. Are the rest of the claims just as bogus as the DU claim? Douglas Lind Rokke falsely claimed to have inside knowledge of the accidental DU firing in an e-mail to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission. Look up key words Rokke and Vieques in NRC's www.nrc.gov Electronic Reading Room in ADAMS. You will find that the NRC thoroughly tested the island and that the Navy removed every one of the 25mm DU penetrators that was mistakenly fired at the range. Activists should tell the truth and relate facts, not just tell any lie that gets attention. The writer shows that they are a lazy researcher by throwing DU into the mix .

The facts - two Marine Harrier aircraft accidentally were loaded with DU instead of training rounds and fired 263 25mm DU penetrator rounds at a target on Vieques on February 19, 1999. No other DU rounds were ever fired at Vieques. Navy scientific team recovered 57 equivalent penetrators a month after this incident. The 2000 NRC scientific investigation team found no evidence of contamination beyond the immediate holes in the ground made by the penetrators and no possibility of contamination of the civilian population after making hundreds of test borings and samplings. In excess of 100 pages of reports at the NRC public website further explain naturally occuring radiation and the basic science in considerable detail.

[Brendan DeMelle - Huffpost Blogger]

Thanks for your comment Rhotel1. The facts contradict your claim that "the Navy removed every one of the 25mm DU penetrators," as you even acknowledged in your reply. The Navy says it 'mistakenly' fired 263 DU rounds (in violation of their license), and yet they only recovered 57 of those rounds, as you mention. That's hardly "every one" of the DU rounds that the Navy admitted firing on Vieques.

Interested readers can read the Navy documents themselves, confirming that the Navy only recovered a fraction of the depleted uranium rounds fired on Vieques . See page 2 [PDF]: http://www.mediafire.com/?iyydjyuln3z

Also see:
http://www.wise-uranium.org/dissti.html#VIEQUES
"The U.S. Navy notified the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) on March 5, 1999, of an event involving depleted uranium (DU) ammunition. The survey work plan indicates that during a training exercise on February 19, 1999, two U.S. Marine Corps aircraft expended 263 DU rounds at the Vieques Island, Puerto Rico, North Convoy Site. The Navy indicated that a team of Navy health physicists was deployed between March 10 and 19, 1999, and recovered 57 DU rounds. Only a portion of the site was investigated at that time because of unexploded conventional ordinance and dense vegetation. The Navy plans to recover all detectable DU penetrators and conduct a final status survey."

While these documents indicate that the Navy "plans to recover" the remaining depleted uranium, there has never been public confirmation that this happened.

[Florentine]

It's reprehensible for Obama's Justice Department to hide behind the "sovereign immunity" claim. I voted for Obama with the expectation that he would fulfill his promise to the people of Vieques and am utterly disappointed that he has yet to institute new policies based on what's RIGHT, not what's easy, cheap or convenient.

I believed in your change, Obama. Now it's time to bring it.