iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Brian Moody

GET UPDATES FROM Brian Moody
 

You Don't Need a Hybrid

Posted: 07/30/2012 2:57 pm

As a quick fix to over-consumption and excess carbon output, you may be drawn to a hybrid like the Honda Insight or the Kia Optima Hybrid. However, just because you want to use fewer resources and pollute less, you don't need a hybrid. In fact, there are plenty of great alternatives out there that sip fuel, cost less and provide a better driving experience than a hybrid.

For example, a Honda Civic EX is $21,445 including destination fee, while a similarly equipped Civic Hybrid costs just under $25,000. Granted, the hybrid version includes features like an upgraded audio system, LED taillights, turn signals built into the outside mirrors and a rear spoiler, but the extra money mainly pays for the Civic Hybrid's complex gas/electric powertrain.

When it comes to using less gas, the Civic Hybrid does a fair job, with an EPA estimate of 44 mpg for both city and highway driving. But the Civic EX does well, too, with an EPA estimate of 28 mpg in the city and 39 mpg on the highway. The estimated annual fuel cost for the non-hybrid Honda Civic is about $450 more than for the Civic Hybrid. At that rate, it would take about 10 years for the Hybrid's gas savings to cover its higher price.

Also, most hybrids can feel somewhat strange to drive. By definition, hybrids use a combination of two power sources. The transition between the gasoline engine and the electric motor is often noticeable. And the regenerative brakes on most hybrids can be grabby and overly sensitive, and they can be extra noisy as they capture lost energy and put it back into the batteries.

But there are plenty of cars that get great fuel economy without any of the inherent compromises of a hybrid. Here are just a few:

Ford essentially redefined what a small car could be with the Fiesta. Despite its base price of about $14,000, its interior is better than that of some more expensive cars. Ford's hands-free Sync system also makes it compelling. EPA estimates for a 2012 Ford Fiesta with a six-speed automatic transmission are 29 mpg in the city, 39 mpg on the highway. The available SFE package boosts highway mileage to an estimated 40 mpg.

The all-new Dodge Dart is a compact sedan with a base price of about $16,000. If you choose the right engine, the car is quick and a blast to drive hard. You can also get tons of great tech options. The Dart's available combination of a six-speed manual transmission and a turbocharged 1.4-liter engine earn it an EPA estimate of 27 mpg city and 39 mpg highway. Opt for the Aero version, and you're looking at 41 mpg on the highway.

Nissan's redesigned 2013 Altima is a decent-sized sedan with a top-notch interior, excellent handling and a sleek-looking body. It has a base price of $21,500 and gets an EPA fuel economy estimate of 27 mpg city, 38 mpg highway.

Volkswagen's Jetta TDI is priced at about $23,000. That might be a little on the high side if you're on a strict budget, but this car is worth every penny. The diesel engine makes the car feel powerful, and the Jetta has a look and feel that says premium sedan, not economy car. True, there are some hard plastic bits inside the Jetta, but overall, the interior is nicely done. The diesel engine nabs an EPA estimate of 32 mpg city and 42 mpg highway, and many people report even better fuel economy than those estimates.

And these are just a few examples. There are many more non-hybrids that get great fuel economy. For those who really want to cut down on consumption, you might want to consider getting a good used car -- no new manufacturing means that no new resources are consumed or pollution generated when you buy a used car.

If you really want to lessen your impact on the environment, but you still want all that a new car offers, resist the knee jerk reaction of buying a hybrid. At least check out some alternatives first. You may be surprised how little you have to spend and how much fun you can have behind the wheel of a car that's a real fuel sipper.

 
FOLLOW BUSINESS
As a quick fix to over-consumption and excess carbon output, you may be drawn to a hybrid like the Honda Insight or the Kia Optima Hybrid. However, just because you want to use fewer resources and pol...
As a quick fix to over-consumption and excess carbon output, you may be drawn to a hybrid like the Honda Insight or the Kia Optima Hybrid. However, just because you want to use fewer resources and pol...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 13
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
09:30 AM on 08/03/2012
You forgot to mention all of the cars in Europe that get 70-80 mpg and how the car companies refuse to sell them in the U.S.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Daniel Kauwe
i like stuff except when i do not
11:18 PM on 08/17/2012
i thought that was just a myth...lol
11:41 AM on 07/31/2012
i own an electric truck and an electric scooter and i love the feeling of freedom from the oil companies but, in context, the 15 largest container ships that ply our oceans everyday put out more pollution than all of the cars in the world combined... and there are 30,000 of them. funny that no one ever talks about that.
07:04 PM on 07/31/2012
On the contrary, people talk about that quite a lot.

Their emissions in ports, for example, have been a subject of hot debates because they contribute so significantly to local air pollution in those port cities.

And much if not most of the impetus for buying domestic/buying local campaigns has been to avoid the carbon footprints and pollution required to ship goods or foods by ocean vessels. That's why folks are encouraged to consume locally raised fruit, for example, when it is in season rather than out-of-season stuff that's sailed in from Chile.
photo
ILoveFiction
That's unbelievable!
10:20 AM on 07/31/2012
You don't need a stable climate.

Please try not to do too much to ensure we have a decent future.

Like that?
nothingchanges
too soon old, too late smart
09:30 AM on 07/31/2012
The 1984 Civic coupe was EPA rated at 67 MPG highway, 51 MPG city.

I guess automotive engineers "forgot" how to make fuel efficient cars?

IMPO...........Americans drive what's most "profitable" for the manufacturers to produce. Not what is best for our future, or our economy.

Properly geared and powered, I see no reason from an engineering standpoint that we couldn't be offered vehicles that get 80 MPG without hybrid technology.

Too bad we won't be offered them.
09:45 PM on 07/30/2012
You Don't Need a Hybrid ? All people who are in a wheelchair need this. And If I was BILL GATES everyone who was trapped to a wheelchair would get one for free !!!!!!!!!
http://www.rockethub.com/projects/9512-kenguru-joystick-model
http://www.kenguru.com/
The CEO, Stacy Zoern, raised money to bring this company to the U.S. from Hungary, quit her job practicing law, and is doing everything in her power to get the Kenguru on the market to change lives! She is personally tired of being dependent on other people all the time and looks forward to a time when she can independently get to work, go to the movies, get to the doctor, and meet her friends out! But Stacy is also still waiting, because she uses a power chair and needs the "joystick" driven Kenguru for power chair users. The current funding will allow us to finish the design of this model that people are waiting for all over the world! Our engineers are on standby! If we raise more than our goal, we can start building them as well! Well we are AMERICANS LETS BUILD OUR SELF UP AND SUPPORT THIS WONDERFUL WOMAN WITH HER DREAM !!!!. DO ALL CEO' UNDERSTAND THAT THIS IS WHAT PEOPLE NEED . A WAY FOR ALL TO BE BE INDEPENDENT.
08:01 PM on 07/30/2012
Excellent article. And if you power that Jetta TDI with a biodiesel blend, it's far superior to a hybrid.
07:08 PM on 07/31/2012
Except not in all cases.

As you surely know, not all biodiesel is being produced from waste that would otherwise go into landfills.

An unfortunate amount is being produced from foodstocks that need to go to hungry mouths. On land that needs to produce food, not biodiesel. And its production requires considerable amounts of water, fertilizer, and pesticides that cannot be sustainably used to produce automotive fuel.

These are complex issues, and generalizations are death to complex issues.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
MSROADKILL612
love auto biographys. any appS to write mine?
07:35 PM on 07/30/2012
should have said = if u family has a stable of cars
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
MSROADKILL612
love auto biographys. any appS to write mine?
07:33 PM on 07/30/2012
no comments - seems odd

The absolute total bargain for some is the cng civic

Pill at home for $1.40~ pge

a filling station is $2~ tho hard to find, & u ride in the fast lane on the freeway

~45mpg

very clean & maintenance free (clean fuel)

US NEEDS A NETWORK OF FILLING STATIONS

If your family has a a carpool, u need one of these in it for most journeys
11:47 AM on 07/31/2012
the epa has issued a report stating the estimates of the natural gas reserves in the ground have been over estimated ( by the gas drilling companies) by 80%. all of the money being made now in the gas biz is with buying and selling land leases.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
MSROADKILL612
love auto biographys. any appS to write mine?
06:21 PM on 07/31/2012
I didnt say i approve of fracking - i dont - still lottsa gas if dont use it for power gen