More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Carl Pope

GET UPDATES FROM Carl Pope

Praise the Lord and Pass the Tenth Amendment

Posted: 09/15/11 07:12 PM ET

This seems to be Governor Rick Perry's basic approach to the unprecedented and catastrophic wildfires that are sweeping Texas, destroying thousands of homes, blackening tens of thousands of acres, and killing -- in a single week -- four people. Perry's approach to the drought and wildfire problem has been truly alarming, especially if you think he might actually be our next president.

Texas had a wildfire protection plan, one that called for adding "200 firefighters, creating rapid-response teams to quash small flare-ups, building advanced automated weather stations and establishing two training academies for wildfire crews." The Texas Forest Service proposed the plan -- it began seeking funding in 1999 -- and finally told lawmakers in 2008, "This is the final straw! Bigger fires call for bigger state resources!"

Neither Governor Perry nor the legislature responded. Former Republican Senator David Swinford, whose Panhandle district suffered devastating fires in an earlier drought, desperately tried to get more funding for the plan and for the state's volunteer fire departments. Swinford lost. "The dereliction of duty is the state not putting money in that program," he said. "I got tired of watching it."

But when drought came again, and Texas lost its first million acres to wildfire this spring, Perry acted. He proclaimed an official day of prayer for rain, declaring that "Texans have been strengthened, assured and lifted up through prayer; it seems right and fitting that the people of Texas should join together in prayer to humbly seek an end to this devastating drought and these dangerous wildfires..."

Prayer was not Perry's only response. On July 5, only a few months after he had publicly mused about the need for Texas to consider secession if the federal government didn't stop spending money, Perry asked President Obama for federal disaster relief -- which Obama promptly provided.

Perry didn't, and still hasn't, taken any kind of active role in dealing with either the drought or the fires; he's left everything up to overstretched state and local agencies, which he systematically starved of funding as governor, with occasional calls for help from Washington. Indeed, in July, after asking Obama for aid, Perry publicly shrugged his shoulders and once again turned the problem over to the divinity. "I think it's time for us to just hand it over to God and say, "God, you're going to have to fix this [...] I think it's time for us to use our wisdom and our influence and really put it in God's hands. That's what I'm going to do, and I hope you'll join me."

Of course, Perry disputes the idea that continuing to dump billions of tons of carbon pollutants into the atmosphere is increasing temperatures and exacerbating drought, so his unwillingness to try to take preventive action to curb extreme weather is at least ideologically consistent. But his passivity in the face of the need to prepare for, and respond to, fires and droughts -- wherever they come from -- is staggering even on the right. When running for president, Mike Huckabee once commented that even if God sends a flood, human beings have to put out the sand bags.

Perry may strut, but he's dangerously passive -- with a reckless willingness to attribute the fruits of this laziness to divine will.

During the siege of the Alamo, William Travis did everything he could to get reinforcements for his dangerously outnumbered troops. Perry reminds me not of the heroes of the Alamo -- Bowie, Crockett and Travis -- but of the ineffectual, passive provisional leaders of the Texas Republic who failed to send the help Travis needed -- as Travis said, "My bones shall reproach my country for her neglect."

 
 
 

Follow Carl Pope on Twitter: www.twitter.com/CarlPope

This seems to be Governor Rick Perry's basic approach to the unprecedented and catastrophic wildfires that are sweeping Texas, destroying thousands of homes, blackening tens of thousands of acres, and...
This seems to be Governor Rick Perry's basic approach to the unprecedented and catastrophic wildfires that are sweeping Texas, destroying thousands of homes, blackening tens of thousands of acres, and...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 36
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
FreeHat
Really?
08:30 PM on 09/16/2011
Carl Pope, you have just as much formal education in climatology as does Perry. Perry is shiet imo, so let glass houses be intact.
02:09 PM on 09/16/2011
It's interesting to watch the public witness the end result of conservative ideology in practice. In the conservative mind, things will always just "take care of themselves". Wheither its the economy, descrimination, natural disasters or the myriad of ongoing issues that confront the human race; conservatives are smug in the knowledge that these issues will just go away. The embarrasment always comes after the damage has been done and much of the human misery endured needlessly.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Katmandu01
12:14 PM on 09/16/2011
Ricky P has assured us that global warming is all based on "flawed science" and that we should all prey "to humbly seek an end to [the] devastatin­­­g drought" that is afflicting Texas". This might raise the question of which diety people are being called upon to prey to. I'm guessing he probably means the Judeo Christian diety, namely Jehovah. However, since a lot of real nasty stuff has gone down on his watch (two World Wars, the Holocaust, etc) it may be a good idea to check out a few other dieties. There is Allah but Homeland Security might have a problem there so he might recommend Ra or Vishnu. There is of course Zeus but then he might refer the worshipper to Demeter (agricultu­­­re), or Posidon (droughts are part of his portifio) or of course Apollo (sun) but it all gets very confusing with the these polytheist­­­ic systems. Finally he might recommend that everyone worship the Mayan gods since they're a little closer to home. Hunab Ku was the supreme god but he was pretty distant and impersonal so I might suggest Yum Caax since his portfolio, riches, husandry, fertility, growth, life, joy, good crops, etc pretty much covers it but then I remembered that the Mayans were big on human sacrifice and that would never do. However with all of the inmates that Texas has on death row perhaps this drought could be ended by ritually cutting out their hearts with a flint knife.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bill Duckworth
It is a DOOZY
11:36 AM on 09/16/2011
10th Amendment
providing that powers not granted to the federal government nor prohibited to the states by the Constitution are reserved, respectively, to the states or the people

Preamble Constitution
"establish justice" and "provide for the general welfare"

Declaration of Independence
unalienable rights to LIFE, Liberty and the Persuit of Happines
02:15 PM on 09/16/2011
"Or the people". ....How about we just skip the middle man career boss hogs at the state and local level and give that remaining power directly to the people. If the feds can be taken to court over Tenth Amendment issues -so can the State and Local governments. What goes around comes around.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bill Duckworth
It is a DOOZY
07:09 PM on 09/16/2011
You might be right, if we put voting for Policy we can shed the Representative form of government. And vote policy

Like, NO WAR, NO DRONES, NO TAX CUTS for the rich, etc.

There was a time when your locl officals could work for you with Washington. Now the both pretty much are Self Motivated for themselves and the Stock Traders.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BlairCase
11:33 AM on 09/16/2011
The Brastrop fire is the worst in Texas history in terms of houses burned, not in the number of acres burned. More and more urban workers are building homes in unicorporated rural areas to avoid paying municipal taxes. Unlike farmers and ranchers, they don't clear the land for agricultural use. Instead, they allow trees and brush to grow right up to their homes. This is nice, but it increase fire danger. Many of the residents in unincorporated rural areas are unwilling to tax themselves to pay for adequate fire protection.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BlairCase
11:10 AM on 09/16/2011
Drought has affected Texas and the Southwest for thousands of years, with some prehistoric droughts lasting for many decades. The current drought will be comparable to the 1930s and 1950s drought only if it last for mutliple years. Wildfires will consume more and more Texas homes as long as long as residents who work in cities contrinue the trend of building "country homes" in unincorporated rural areas. Unlike farmers and rachers, they don't clear the land but allow the trees and brush grow to the edge of their houses, greatly increasing the fire danger. At the same time, they are unwilling to tax themselves to pay for fire departments. Texas leaders ordered Travis to abandon the Alamo because it was located away from the colonists' population center and had no strategic importance. The Alamo defenders probably expected the Mexican army to ignore the mission in San Antonio and advance along the Gulf Course.
Gperky
Born with a Plan
11:05 AM on 09/16/2011
I think Pope is somewhat biased for Obama and against Perry. His comments border on lies.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
chriss0114
the meanderings of a madman
11:39 AM on 09/16/2011
I noticed you pointed out none--because there are none

truth and facts do have a "liberal" bias

but then, Obama is not a liberal anyway
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cyberfringe
When the going gets weird, the weird turn pro.
10:34 AM on 09/16/2011
Persistent drought increases over the American southwest (per climate change modeling) will make living in the region increasingly difficult and dangerous. Between fires and desiccation, plant life will diminish, and dust bowl conditions (already present) will increase. The desert sands will remobilize. In 50 years or so the American southwest could look very much like the Arabian desert. Scientific opinion is divided on whether this future can be avoided or not; much depends on rapid and thorough international response to reduce carbon emissions (I am not hopeful). Federal funds for disaster relief help people in the short term but do nothing to secure the future. The efficacy of prayer is surely questionable. Politicians like Perry (he is not alone) seem unable to understand that we need leadership that has Plan A, Plan B, and Plan C because this is a REALLY tough problem not only for the millions of people who live there now, but for our children and grandchildren who will inherit this mess.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Katmandu01
10:52 AM on 09/16/2011
We don't inherit the earth from our ancestors, we borrow it from our children.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BlairCase
11:21 AM on 09/16/2011
The Chihuahuan Desert haa been advancing northeast across Texas for thousand of years. The desert doesn't need tro "remobilize." It has never stopped moving north. The Chihuahuan Desert is a "mountain shadow" desert that gets little rain becausse of the Rocky Moutains. Greenhouse gases may be speeding up the process, but not by much. The portion of West Texas that is now "semi-desert will gradually become desert. East Texas, which gets moisture from the Gulf of Mexico, will remain green. Southeast Texas is heavily forested and some of it resembles the Lousiana bayou country.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:12 AM on 09/16/2011
So Texas has unprecedented wild fires this year and have to request federal $ for disaster relief because they didn't plan enough $ to handle the natural disaster. What about every state that is in the path of hurricanes on east coast? Should all those Governors have money stock piled, not used, sitting in a fund, just in case they get hit by a hurricane? After all... they know that the hurricanes can happen. Your also trying to blame climate change for a wild fire. Wild fires have been happening here long before industry. It's a natural process that actually promotes new growth, etc.
photo
abbienormal
What hump?
09:35 AM on 09/16/2011
Wild fires in Texas this year have been the worst on record.

And, no. States in the Northeast don't need to stockpile funds to deal with hurricanes, but their governors are not so foolish as to reduce the number of first responders.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
newworldman777
What would our future 7th generation think of us?
09:42 AM on 09/16/2011
Wildfires are indeed a natural phenomenon. But the severity of the current drought in Texas is beyond the norm, indicative of the very climate change that the Republican front-runners like Perry are denying. And even during seasons of normal rainfall, Western states like Texas experience seasonal wildfires that clear the land of underbrush and allow new growth, like you said. The problem is that our burgeoning population is steadily expanding out into rural areas where these fires have traditionally burned with little detriment to humans. Consequently, these fires are drastically affecting human life throughout the West, including Texas, and people like Perry should have the intellectual wherewithal to understand this and prepare for it accordingly. Sadly, Perry has failed miserably to meet this challenge. This speaks volumes about Perry's inability to dissect problems in a thoughtful fashion and address them with even a shred of common sense. He would undoubtedly be a horrid president.
02:25 PM on 09/16/2011
Heaven forbid that disaster trust funds be established. We don't need to financially prepare for disasters because they never happen. Excuse me- Dancing with the Stars is on.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
babybuda
Tolling for the outcast....
06:27 AM on 09/16/2011
Depraved indifference ... The hypocrisy is mind boggling this is appalling!
photo
IsotelusMaximus
Ole boy raised on shotguns.
12:57 AM on 09/16/2011
What happened to wildfires before there were religion, firefighters and the federal government?

"Perry didn't, and still hasn't, taken any kind of active role in dealing with either the drought or the fires;"

Sir, do you honestly believe that if we all drive Fiat's that there wouldn't be wildfires? Plus, I thought folks like the Sierra Club would like the benefits to the forests from wildfires; but this article is not about the environment, it is a cheap political op-ed and a weak slam on "religious" people.
photo
abbienormal
What hump?
09:36 AM on 09/16/2011
It is an article about Perry, who was elected to lead, refusing to actually do his job.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
newworldman777
What would our future 7th generation think of us?
09:54 AM on 09/16/2011
I am sure that the Sierra Club would gladly let the fires burn naturally. The problem is, during the past decade or so, swarms of people have fled the urban areas and moved into the wilderness areas throughout the Western states, including Texas. Consequently, these fires can no longer be allowed to burn themselves out, due to the sheer number of homes and businesses sitting in the paths of these fires in what was once wilderness. For Perry to ignore the changing landscape (with over-development in wilderness areas), and the unprecedented drought, and simply "pray to God" to solve these wildfire problems is, simply put, quite disturbing.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Malcolm Hensley
Last of the Reagan Republicans
09:37 PM on 09/15/2011
Hasn't the Supreme Court using the Interstate Commerce Clause made null and void the 10th amendment?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FLECKENSTEIN44
Pointing out the hypocrisy of the Left and Right
10:23 PM on 09/15/2011
umm no....the only way to do that is to call a constitutional convention and have the states repeal the 10th amendment. Which wont happen considering that would be the states giving up any powers that they have left after the federal government, power hungry and control freaks as they are decided to take over everything that weren't enumerated powers to them. And i think the interpretation of the commerce clause is super over stretched. in no way did the founding Fathers mean that the feds could regulate what goes inside our bodies and hat is sold in a state's border

The 1-th amendment also wasn't solved during the civil war. Heck even secession wasn't as their is still no law today saying states cant secede. Which i find quite odd tbh that the north wouldnt of passed that law.

But Republicans and democrats rather they like it or not the 10th amendment is still apart of the Constitution and needs to be upheld.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Malcolm Hensley
Last of the Reagan Republicans
11:22 PM on 09/15/2011
I agree 100% with your statement, "And i think the interpreta­tion of the commerce clause is super over stretched"! My point was the Supreme Court does not share our point of view!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
chriss0114
the meanderings of a madman
11:42 AM on 09/16/2011
the Supremacy Clause overrides the tenth as the tenth only applied to the leftovers--the 14th fully overrides the tenth and SCOTUS has hels so in numerous cases
photo
Scholastica8
PEOPLE MATTER!
07:01 PM on 09/15/2011
In reality, leaders such as Perry who first refuse to recognize the cause of a problem, then refuse or even hamper the ability to deal with the consequences, are more like Pontus Pilate, who washed his hands of the whole issue of Jesus Christ.... and more or less said, "Not my fault... on your heads," Oh, well, God's Will. It makes one wonder whom God is testing, the victims of the fires or Gov. Perry.
photo
IsotelusMaximus
Ole boy raised on shotguns.
01:03 AM on 09/16/2011
I haven't heard a leader deny the fact that lightning and people intentionally started these fires. Can you provide any link supporting your statement?
photo
abbienormal
What hump?
09:38 AM on 09/16/2011
No one knows what started most of the fires. Most public statements from state and local authorities that I have heard say that the state is such a tinder box that anything could have done it.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
newworldman777
What would our future 7th generation think of us?
09:58 AM on 09/16/2011
Does it really matter how the fires started? If arsonists started them all, then how are they going to be stopped in the future? This could be the new strategy of al-Qaeda...who the heck knows? The point is, the fires are there and are a real threat to the people who live in the fire-prone areas.