NYR More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Carol Hoenig

GET UPDATES FROM Carol Hoenig

Where Will Books Find Their Champion?

Posted: 02/23/11 01:01 PM ET

Seventeen years ago about this time I was part of a staff of about 100 that helped open a Borders Books & Music store on Long Island. The energy was palpable, especially since we were there when the newly-built shelves were empty and it was our job to fill them by unpacking the hundreds of shipped boxes with just-published books and those that had been around for a long time, sometimes with a limited audience. The music being stocked was also a huge mix of new releases, along with the more eclectic. It was a time that bode well for both the publishing and music industries.

Back then, before a Borders employee was hired, we were to take an intensive test to assess our knowledge about the products we'd be selling. In other words, was this just going to be a job or did we have a passion for those goods? I have clear memories of the excitement I felt whenever I walked into that store, one filled to capacity, wondering what new book I'd come across that day and simply must own. Staff could not just point to a section, directing a customer to where the book should be, but had to walk the customer to the section, find the book and hand it to them. Sometimes it was like searching for a needle in a haystack, but the jubilation that abounded when the book was found was cause for celebration -- not to mention a sale.

Nothing seemed amiss when a couple of years later I transferred to help open the Park Avenue Borders in Manhattan where an entire floor was dedicated to music. Those were the days, my friend. We thought they'd never end. By then, I was a Community Relations Coordinator and then a National Event Specialist, my office in that Park Avenue store. Often, in order to take a break from my desk, I'd walk the sales floor and watch all those people browsing, searching for something they didn't know existed. At the time, there were rumblings in the industry about electronic books, but few seemed to think they would take hold. And they didn't. Not then, anyway. But what was happening was that the music sections were diminishing and then those eclectic book titles had to be special ordered. Yes, the corporate office made a lot of missteps, as so many of us witnessed at the store level, but we were forced to ride the wave until it was our department that was cut.

In 2005, it was the end of my career with the bookstore. I missed the days of being able to see what new titles were being shelved and recommending books to customers wanting something to read, but not sure what -- then those same customers returning because they appreciated the previous suggestion. Sure, Amazon has the "If you liked this, you'll like this" on their site, but Amazon doesn't know that perhaps the prior purchase had been a gift and nothing one would read themselves. In other words, there is no way to discuss just what one is in the mood for and the capability to browse, leaf through and make a decision after acquainting oneself with the book. However, with the announcement of more bookstores closing almost on a daily basis, it doesn't matter because that time seems to have reached its conclusion and both stores I helped open are part of the group to be closed.

One thing is certain though, we writers will still write and musicians will still perform, but will we be like that tree that falls in the forest when no one is around? In other words, I wonder who will champion these books?

 

Follow Carol Hoenig on Twitter: www.twitter.com/AuthorsGuide

Seventeen years ago about this time I was part of a staff of about 100 that helped open a Borders Books & Music store on Long Island. The energy was palpable, especially since we were there when the n...
Seventeen years ago about this time I was part of a staff of about 100 that helped open a Borders Books & Music store on Long Island. The energy was palpable, especially since we were there when the n...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 13
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
05:01 PM on 02/24/2011
It's true. Amazon does not have a smell of the book store and silence of the similar minded people walking the aisles. World is changing. Libraries do exist and maybe some sort of contemporary book-store-library has a chance, especially if it sells the coffee and tea.
12:59 PM on 03/05/2011
Definitely agree, Nenad. I miss the family-owned bookstores (there are so very few now) where you can relax, spend hours discovering old and new books, leave with several treasured books, and get to know the owners who notify you when they get books in they know will interest you. Human contact, a comfortable seat or couch, and maybe tea or coffee.
12:31 PM on 02/24/2011
I like the discussion - there are some good ideas coming out from which a new 'type of bookstore' might be created. I have been at the beginning (and end) of many publishing mediums in my professional lifetime. One example - I crossed over into the DVD business from theatrical film around the time the cinema business started to struggle in the 80's - while my serious 35mm big screen film pals were horrified I saw it as an opp to progress my career in the direction technology was headed. Years later I invented a boardgame called Let's Buy Hollywood which took me back into meetings with some of those cinema chains. The smart ones had reinvented their cinema space - Hello Multiplex. The multiplex while still about screening movies on big screens added on additional entertainment value that brought customers back through their doors. I read recently that many of these cinemas have been successful in expanding product lines beyond the blockbuster movie to indie and alternative films. Book chains and stores that want to survive the digital revolution will have to reinvent themselves in this way in my opinion. A bookstore is a clean, safe, friendly place where families can go and find books - and what else? CM Rubin
07:23 AM on 02/24/2011
How about the library?
07:37 PM on 02/23/2011
I too am nostalgic for the days when booksellers at Borders (as well as B&N) actually seemed to know and care about books. In recent years, I have felt as if I might as well be in a generic store selling anything for all the sellers seemed to know about books. Yesterday it took me the better part of twenty minutes to get a bookseller at B&N to find the new T.C. Boyle novel. It took several minutes for me to clarify who he was ("does he write mysteries?" "is his middle name Greg?") and then, because B&N does not have the self-service computers Borders at least provides, I had to wait while she worked through what must be an intricate computer system, as she immediately said, "Well, we must not have it." When I told her the online site said it was in the store, she checked again and finally located it. I don't expect all booksellers to be knowledgeable about all books or categories, but many of them seem not to be interested in books at all. It's just a job that is conveniently located in a space that also sells coffee and snacks. Alas, our only independent bookstore in Ithaca is in danger of going out of business, though many are working to try to find a solution.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Carol Hoenig
10:16 PM on 02/23/2011
Oh, I certainly hope that Ithaca's bookstore stays in business. (As someone who was raised in WAY upstate NY, I pass through Ithaca when I visit family, but I think I should stop in one of these days to check out that bookstore instead of just at the diner near the traffic circle.) Thanks for sharing and reading...
12:33 AM on 02/24/2011
One of the employees (it's called Buffalo Street Books) is trying to buy the store and convert it to a co-op, with people wanting it to remain open to buy shares at 250.00 each. Within days of sending out emails about the plan, he has received pledges for half the money he needs. So, there is hope. BSB has become a wonderful place, not just for buying books, but for readings, discussion groups, readers theatre, and so forth. Its closing would be more than simply losing a convenient place to buy books that may not be carried by the megastores; it would be losing a cultural center.
07:19 PM on 02/23/2011
It was a treat to go to my local Borders,pick up a few books and a latte and spend a few hours deciding on what to purchase. However, two things came into play that changed this for me, time and money. The prices at Amazon were so much lower, the convenience of taking the time online and the fact that I could shop for books at any time, other than my day off. I recently received a Kindle and I love it. I thought I would miss holding a book but in the end it's about the written work no matter how it is delivered. I miss my bookstore visits and I'm sorry for those who have lost their jobs. I wish progress at any speed could somehow eliminate the losses it creates. Some changes are not for the better. As an aspiring writer, I worry but realize I need to embrace e-books publication.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Carol Hoenig
10:23 PM on 02/23/2011
Good points, Vickie. I actually just asked my publisher to have my books available in ebook format, which they are doing, but I do also love the feel and smell of an actual book. It's visceral for me. Yet, today's generation is more in tune w/ digital gadgets. But the important factor is that as long as people are reading, that's a good thing. My hope is that they can find what is available to them. I suppose that is where the Internet comes into play. Thanks for reading and responding!
06:57 PM on 02/23/2011
nice article. i like bookstores. i like amoeba records in san francisco.

sitting at a computer to hear music or read pages isn't the same.

i like being around human beings.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Carol Hoenig
10:23 PM on 02/23/2011
That's how I feel! Thanks for reading and responding...
06:48 PM on 02/23/2011
As usual, Carol Hoenig says things so elegantly and nicely. How I also remember the days when bookstores were magical places, oases in the city turmoil, places where you met other people who cared for what you care for, the life of the mind and the heart. I'm not sure who will champion books, and even more crucial, who will champion the life of the mind and the heart. Or, as E. M. Forster said at the beginning of "Howard's End": "Only connect."
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Carol Hoenig
10:25 PM on 02/23/2011
Thanks, Perry, for your kind words. For you: Just keep writing!