Huffpost Entertainment
The Blog

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors

Caryn James Headshot

Non-Twinkling, Non-Cavorting, Wonderful Saving Mr. Banks

Posted: Updated:
Print Article

Mary Poppins meant nothing to me as a child. I'd never read the book and didn't love the movie. I didn't actively dislike the film the way I did The Sound of Music, and in hindsight it was probably all that Julie Andrews goody-goody-ness that made me gag. Whatever... the encouraging scene in the trailer for Saving Mr. Banks has Emma Thompson, as the recalcitrant author P.L. Travers, telling her agent why she does not want Walt Disney to put her heroine on screen. "I know what he'll do to her -- she'll be cavorting and twinkling," she says, with great derision. Finally, someone who gets it.

That hope for the film isn't misplaced, because Thompson is its bracing spine, her Travers as tightly wound as her crimped, unflattering perm -- the perfect visual sign of her rigorous hold on her emotions and her work. Thompson is so delightfully acerbic and convincing that she makes Saving Mr. Banks safe for people who find Disney films too saccharine.

Travers arrives in Los Angeles so that Walt -- he insists on being called Walt, she insists on being called Mrs. Travers -- can try to charm and twist her arm to get the rights to the film. Tom Hanks plays Disney with a twinkle in his eye, as if both the actor and the character are tickled at the idea that he is the man who created ever-happy Disneyland. (Who can blame him?)

The best scenes are in the rehearsal room, where Travers goes into battle against the creative team. Bradley Whitford plays the likeable writer Don DaGradi. As the brothers who composed the score, Jason Schwartzman is the cheerful Richard Sherman, and B.J. Novak the crankier Robert. All are utterly charming as they sing and dance and act out scenes, essentially auditioning their work for the scowling Travers, who never wanted the film to be a musical in the first place.

Side Effects Warning: Songs from Mary Poppins are likely to run through your head for days. Symptoms may include A Spoonful of Sugar, Let's Go Fly a Kite, and Feed the Birds.

(To see a three-minute feature about the music, with comments from Richard Sherman, please go to jamesonscreens.com)

The film's emotional undercurrent comes from the sparingly used yet effective flashbacks to Travers' childhood in Australia, with Colin Farrell as her charming, drunken, irresponsible yet imaginative and much-loved father, Travers Goff. It's not news that children's books often come from a dark place in the soul, but watching the young Helen Goff before she transformed herself into P.L. Travers -- adoring her hapless father, trying to save her suicidal mother -- is an acutely-drawn reminder. And it's a nice touch to have Aunt Ellie (Rachel Griffiths) arrive to help, standing at the door holding a parrot-handled umbrella.

Walt understands how much Travers must have loved her father to have chosen his name as her pen-name, and it may be that connection that finally wins her over. (That and dancing with the Shermans.) Hanks gets his Oscar-bait scene when he tells Travers about his modest childhood, and that his desire to be successful is a tribute to his own hard-working father. Saving Mr. Banks is, after all, a Disney film too, so there has to be a big, heart-tugging turning point near the end. If you're a person who cries at movies, this is your cue.

John Lee Hancock, who directed The Blind Side, similarly holds back the treacle for quite a while here. But eventually he has to give in. Really, Travers' affection for a giant stuffed Mickey Mouse goes too far. And the film looks as bright, sunny and undistinguished as any movie Disney cranked out in the '60s.

Hancock is not an adventurous director, but this is not an adventurous film. It is, however, so entertaining that it will win you over. In fact, it did the nearly impossible; it made me want to see Mary Poppins again. (Don't mention The Sound of Music, in any iteration.)

Do stay through the credits. As we see in the film, Travers insisted that Disney keep a record of her conversations with DaGradi and the Shermans, and Saving Mr. Banks ends with audio from those sessions. It is a hoot for us to hear the real Travers, but you can see why people in the room would have had a very different opinion.