iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Cesar Vargas

GET UPDATES FROM Cesar Vargas
 

Mitt Romney: Show Us Your Papers!

Posted: 08/09/2012 10:42 am

Last month, Senator Lindsay Graham (R-SC) announced on the Senate floor, at a time where billionaires are avoiding taxes by denouncing their citizenship, that its the American way to avoid taxes. The speech was an attempt for the Senator and the Republican party to shield their presidential contender, Mitt Romney, from Obama campaign's recent strategy of hammering Romney on hiding assets overseas in well-known tax havens like Switzerland. 

In 2011, undocumented people paid over $11.2 billion in taxes. Every tax season has seen undocumented immigrants eagerly waiting in line to pay taxes. Mitt Romney can't have it both ways: on the one hand Romney wants to nationalize Arizona's discriminatory SB1070 "show me your papers" laws; however, on the other hand he refuses to show the public his own papers: his tax returns.

While there is nothing wrong with working hard and achieving the American dream and wealth, the country has seen an increase in public stories of wealthy Americans, or former Americans in the case of Facebook co-founder Eduardo Saverin, manipulating and avoiding the law to avoid taxes. Indeed, Senator Graham did not place the blame on these "patriotic" Americans but on Congress for enacting labyrinthine tax rules. He applauded Romney and others for taking advantage of loopholes, like the Romney's $77,000 tax deduction for their horse that competed in dressage at the Olympics.  These are tax breaks that working Americans, small businesses, or undocumented workers cannot hope to ever take advantage of. Even while not eligible for many of the benefits of the taxes they pay, undocumented workers continue to contribute into a tax system that is willing to look the other way on their immigration status. 

Some undocumented immigrants use Individual Taxpayer Identification Numbers (ITINs) but others also use an Employer Identification Number (EIN) demonstrating that undocumented immigrants are increasingly starting businesses and creating jobs. Undocumented immigrants have and are paying taxes as a symbol of their contribution to the United States.

Undocumented immigrants pay between $6 billion and $7 billion into the Social Security trust fund each year in addition to Medicare and unemployment insurance taxes the undocumented immigrants pay on the more than $72 billion in wages employers reported paying to individuals without Social Security numbers in 2009--the latest data available from the Social Security Administration. This is in stark contrast to wealthy Americans and American companies who are consistently avoiding taxes at any cost. Undocumented immigrants also pay federal, state, and local sales and excise taxes on food, clothing, gasoline, cigarettes and alcohol as well as state and local property taxes.

Of course, there are costs in government services that undocumented immigrants use. But rather than simply taking a free ride, undocumented immigrants are doing their part to offset the cost while they eagerly await full participation as American citizens to fulfill their full tax obligations. While the current Republican party and Mitt Romney appear to condone tax evasion as an American tradition, the new generation of aspiring Americans are willing to renew a sense of duty and responsibility to our country and our tax system. For those willing to live in the past, destinations like Switzerland or the Cayman Islands appear to be ideal destinations.

 

Follow Cesar Vargas on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@drmcapitolgrou

FOLLOW LATINO VOICES
Last month, Senator Lindsay Graham (R-SC) announced on the Senate floor, at a time where billionaires are avoiding taxes by denouncing their citizenship, that its the American way to avoid taxes. The ...
Last month, Senator Lindsay Graham (R-SC) announced on the Senate floor, at a time where billionaires are avoiding taxes by denouncing their citizenship, that its the American way to avoid taxes. The ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 23
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:53 PM on 08/15/2012
We have yet to see a REAL birth certificate and it's been how long? I say Mitt has along time until he needs to produce anything.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Eddie Martinez
09:56 AM on 08/11/2012
If Mitt's father was born in Mexico, dose that make him a Mexican-American?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BeasTT
03:41 PM on 08/11/2012
Indeed, but common sense like that has no place here.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bill Pilgrim
The Ten Cannots: Words to live by.
01:05 PM on 08/10/2012
While living overseas I was required to show my papers when ever asked. Those papers included my passport and Visa. While driving I was required if asked to show my papers those papers included my Passport, Visa, international drivers license , valid driver’s license from my home country and proof of insurance. The purpose of all this show of my papers was to establish my status in the country should I have been found to be in the country illegally I would be taken to the airport put on a plain and sent home, when your visa runs out they come to your house and escort you to the airport for a flight home. I might also address your belief that all these illegal immigrants pay so many taxes I would suggest a closer look at the expense created by their illegal activities vs. the so call tax wind fall they provide. Just for comparison my income tax rate overseas was 46 percent, they offer no deductions and failure to pay gets you, yes you guessed it a ride to the airport.
AlPal3
Had Enough? Vote Democratic
01:03 AM on 08/10/2012
As a true conservative, I support the Dream Act. All REAL conservatives do.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Viper1st
multi quasi faceted
10:37 PM on 08/09/2012
Cesar Vargas ~ show us YOUR papers!

LMAO ~

The author of this article of DRM Capitol Group, whom bastardizes Mitt Romney for not showing his tax returns

> can not show us his immigration papers
> can not show us his SSN
> can not show us his New York State Driver's License
> can not show us his voter registration card
> can not show us his gun permit
> can not show us his ObamaCare Ins Policy
> can not show us his

Don't ya just love it when an illegal thinks he can bastardize U.S. Citizens & tell us what to do?

What an ASS
08:38 PM on 08/09/2012
You are not undocumented - you are breaking the law.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
inthedesert
Those who never question will fall for anything.
07:58 PM on 08/09/2012
It does not matter how much in taxes an illegal has paid, they are still illegal and need to be deported. This is easy stuff, right?
photo
realsurfin
Pardon me, can you help out a fellow American
09:33 PM on 08/09/2012
MITTS IDEA OF SELF DEPORTATION... DEATH SQUADS.. YOU CANNOT GET DEPORTED FASTER THAN THAT. PERMANENTLY.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dtairtime
It is what it is
06:39 PM on 08/09/2012
""In 2011, undocumented people paid over $11.2 billion in taxes.""

You mean to tell us the average illegal pays a whopping $930 a year in taxes?

Just the costs of education for illegals and their kids is more than that piddly amount.

Add in the costs for translations, justice system, public safety, roads, other infrastructure, military, border security, etc and we loose hundreds of billions a year.

Uneducated, low income people are a net loss - one of the biggest reasons why we have had such problems with the shrinking middle class and the massive rise in welfare use.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nasknit
Freedom isn't free.
06:26 PM on 08/09/2012
I want to see transcripts of Obama's college years, and his thesis. See what you can work out.
photo
realsurfin
Pardon me, can you help out a fellow American
09:34 PM on 08/09/2012
YEAH that is much more important than laundering money for people that run the Death Squads.
photo
ILoveFiction
That's unbelievable!
02:56 PM on 08/09/2012
I'd like to apply to be considered a horse for tax purposes.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
creek73
11:40 PM on 08/09/2012
Parts of you may already qualify!
photo
busterggi
I'm a Sally Randian
02:41 PM on 08/09/2012
"Indeed, Senator Graham did not place the blame on these "patriotic" Americans but on Congress for enacting labyrinthine tax rules."

Is that including himself for designing the rules and voting for them?
02:15 PM on 08/09/2012
The GOP hammerheads like Senators Graham and McConnell have been staunch obstructionists since President Obama was elected. No matter how many petitions we signed urging the GOP congress to pass the Dream Act they stonewalled it.
What really, really needs to happen is that we work TIRELESSLY to put representatives in office who recognize the importance of passing legislation that will move this nation forward.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
talyn530
Aggressively Progressive!
01:25 PM on 08/09/2012
Excellent article!! Well stated....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Len Lee
Devout Independent
12:29 PM on 08/09/2012
In before how undocumented-students-have-no-papers-to-show-similar-to-the-title joke...

On a serious note, it is sad how much the right wing demagogue Dream Act candidates while, under the cloak of patriotism and job creation, they still encourage crippled government and trickle-down theory.
12:26 PM on 08/09/2012
Why not demand every candidate and elected official make public the previous 5 years of tax returns that were filed? What are they all trying so desperately to hide? Why are they so afraid of what questions might be asked? This has NOTHING to do with privacy, it has EVERYTHING to do with causing embarresment and shame. We should pass laws immediately, if you are in office or want to run for any office you should make your tax returns public for the past 5 years, if not, you do not get to run or hold office. The public is sick of candidates that have been paid off, or bought before even getting into office, or being on the take once getting there. Is this integrity and honesty? No. Is there any chance this will happen? No, unless we demand it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tinarm
call me a proud FemaNazi according to Rush.
02:05 PM on 08/09/2012
There is something like that for cabinet post, you have to give over at least 3 years of returns. The thing is I don't think Romney plays by the same rules everyone else does.
09:07 PM on 08/09/2012
None of them play by the rules that we have to play by. Cabinet post positions are payback for the largest campaign donors and should be illegal anyway, most have them haven't been able to rob, steal and cheat long enough to be afraid to show their returns.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TooLooze
Someone should do something about all the problems
10:53 PM on 08/09/2012
Not to mention the mandatory and random drug tests.