More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Charles D. Ellison

Charles D. Ellison

Posted: November 22, 2010 10:01 PM

In the past two weeks, one could make the argument that African American politicians are somehow under siege.

With Republicans headed into a majority, the four Congressional Black Caucus Members lose Chairmanships over powerful House committees. Eighteen will give up subcommittee Chairs. House Majority Whip James Clyburn (D-SC) barely held on to finally end up with a specially designed "Assistant Leader" position to back midterm-demoted House Minority Leader-designate Nancy Pelosi (D-CA). Publicly, the CBC appears fine with it; privately, some cringe that Clyburn ultimately got a made-up political crumb.

Founding CBC Member Rep. Charlie Rangel's (D-NY) ethics trial ends up in an embarrassing vote for censure. Rep. Maxine Waters (D-CA) will be next to face the House Ethics Committee gavel. Two others, Rep. G.K. Butterfield (D-NC) and Rep. Alcee Hastings (D-FL), are in the immediate inquiry pipeline.

There is a larger issue of waning Black political influence nationwide. Much of it is simple partisan calculus: most Black elected officials are staunch Democrats, and there are few either willing or in an able position to leverage relationships on the other side of the aisle. Loss of 19 state legislatures to Republicans, who now wield the ruthless magic wand of redistricting, poses a political life-and-death scenario to the 630 Black and mostly Democratic state legislators spread throughout the fifty states. That also poses a problem to CBC Members enjoying safe majority-Black districts. Some are nervous they could lose seats to a happily gerrymandering GOP.

Even on the Republican side -- and despite major gains for the party on Nov. 2nd -- a chorus of GOP elected officials are calling for the resignation of Republican National Committee Chair Michael Steele, the party's first Black chair. Recently, Steele's own political director Gentry Collins resigned in a flashy public retort of Steele's tenure. Republican observers note Steele only has 50 of the 85 votes he'll need for reelection at the party's January Winter Meeting.

And while the majority of lost Chairmanships on Capitol Hill will simply transition into ranking member status, it's not the same as the full power associated with Chair. African American Members were once controlling the composition and flow of legislation; they're now relegated to loud dissenting opinions. While their White Democratic colleagues might be resigned to it, licking wounds from electoral losses, the stakes are higher for the Black Members who represent a larger community in desperate need of real political influence.

The uncomfortable jolt of reality is already spurring bold bids for Ranking Members positions on major Committees as Black Members find their bearing. Outgoing House Government Reform Committee Chair Rep. Edolphus Towns (D-NY), a longtime king of the Brooklyn political machine, wants to stay on as the committee's Ranking Member to the chagrin of leading Democrats - including one corner that needs him the most: the White House. Towns is ready to glove-up and go cage match with an emboldened incoming Chair Rep. Darrell Issa (R-CA), the loquacious center-right Congressman who's promised to blast the Obama Administration with a ceaseless barrage of inquiries, probes and subpoenas.

West Philly political brawler Rep. Chaka Fattah (D-PA) is ready to shake up the antiquated Democratic seniority system by running for ranking member of House Appropriations and directly bumping heads with longtime lawmaker Rep. Norm Dicks (D-WA). Jumping from his No. 22 spot is a move certain to rile both Dicks and senior Democrats who've been waiting in line.

The Black Caucus on the Hill is frantically searching for some footing on the new political landscape. Its predominant Democratic make-up creates the usual problems as it enters a Republican-led Congress next year. How they decide to interface with the two new Black Republicans on the block, Rep.-elect Tim Scott (R-SC) and Rep.-elect Allen West (R-FL), is unknown. Still, the newly-elected Chair of the CBC, Rep. Emmanuel Cleaver (D-MO), is famously known for his ability to reach across the aisle. And Cleaver, who barely managed to beat back a belligerent Republican challenger two weeks ago in a district only 30% Black, won't be expected to play defense for the White House all the time.

Black political power and influence appears somehow strafed and in serious condition since the midterm elections. Even President Barack Obama is not immune as he fends off assaults from both left and right, including a Washington Post column by two prominent Democratic strategists recommending he pass on reelection in 2012. A combination of scandal, Republican electoral tsunamis and lack of coordinated response to the new political climate have left Black politicos trapped in a smoky wilderness of uncertainty. And it could not have come at a worse time for African Americans, near paralyzed by unemployment double the national average, record foreclosure rates and a recession which vaporized a quarter of the Black middle class.

There could also be an opportunity for needed change in political strategy or a realignment of the traditional guard. In reality, it may not be as much of a devastating blow to Black politicians as it is a moment of reflection. Politics, indeed, is an ugly blood sport and the sting of defeat is a regular occupational hazard. After rapid maturation over the past 40 years, course correction is essential as African American politicians evolve. However, we have not arrived, yet, and we cannot act as though we have -- high unemployment numbers, foreclosure rates, disproportionate public health indicators and the inability of many to afford a college education speaks to that. There's good -- but there's still quite a bit of bad and ugly. We're in the kitchen now. This is the heat.

 
 
 

Follow Charles D. Ellison on Twitter: www.twitter.com/charlesdellison

 
 
  • Comments
  • 71
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
MyNameIsJames
What should a person say in their micro-bio
10:08 PM on 12/14/2010
No Black Political Power is not under seige

BUT the Black managers of White wealth,power and privilege are being questioned about their effectiveness. Lets be clear from a geo-political point of view.
09:22 AM on 12/03/2010
whatever the problems of Michael Steele, they do not approach problems of Charlie Rangel. not sure whether african-american politicians are under siege ( i would hope not), but pretty sure liberal democrats are in deep trouble. huge change in american's opinion in last 2 years. seems the political winds shift at an ever increasing pace. not really surprising. information is disseminated at ever faster rates and opinions change when events inspire that change. new political winds not much related to race. there really is no longer "quite a bit of bad and ugly" rather there is an ever declining "little bit of..." . a couple of years ago my son introduced me to an african- american friend, i asked my son why he had not mentioned to me that the friend was black. it was as though my son did not even understand the question or why i would ask, i felt a little old and stupid.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:20 PM on 11/29/2010
Excellent article but what about the dismissal of the brilliant African American commander of the German based United States Africa Command (AFRICOM) General William "Kip" Ward with a white war-dog Army General Carter J. Ham?

Why is your medium quiet on this replacement? What about General Ham Senate Confirmation Hearing's self-admitting lack of intelligence on African Affairs? Is General Ward being promoted to a cabinet position?
03:35 PM on 11/23/2010
Black political power is neither under seige nor waning. Some loss of direct influence within our legislative bodies should be expected when the Democratic party which, as the author correctly notes includes most Black elected officials, takes an election drubbing. Of more significance is the 08 election of President Obama and the increasing election of new Black Republicans to national office. President Obama's election demonstrated that most non-Black Americans are clearly willing to seriously consider Black politicans as credible representatives of their interests, provided they share common values and aspirations. Playing the race card is slowly but inexorably losing traction in our political discourse. And moderates and conservatives of color, either as Independents or Republicans are beginning to be recognized by thoughtful voters as powerful political players. It is the African-American population's persistent, overwhelming allegiance to the Democratic Party and the liberal policies of perpetual victimhood and entitlement, which is causing a loss in its political clout; but that loss is only within the Democratic Party, which has long pandered to African-Americans to ensure their support, regardless the benefit to the African American community. African-Americans are breaking the bondage of federal government subsistence in ever-increasing numbers, and are empowering Black moderate and conservative Black politicians for what will be an increase in Black power, albeit in the moderate and conservative segments of our body politic.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Msquad99
Space is a vacuum because earth sucks.
07:43 PM on 11/23/2010
Much over reach and rhetoric here. The color of power is green, not as in ecology, as in money. All of this blabber regarding victimhood and entitlement is more of the bla, bla, bla,of someone who has not engaged very many, if any, African Americans in a dialogue regarding what we might or might not wish to see, hear and do within the body politic. We see racist assaults on the few institutions that feature our point of view, ACORN, NAACP. We see racist assaults on those who we support. We see racist hate so virulent that the very office of the President of the United States will be denigrated at levels unprecedented in the history of the nation, solely because a man of color was elected. We see the cynical decisions made on the right of deciding for us who our leaders should be, Clarence Thomas, Michael Steele. We see the non issues of entities such as the New Black Panther Party elevated to national dialogue and narrative when the African American community neither new that they existed or cared that they existed. The African American community struggles for survival just as most communities struggle for survival in this decimated economy. Unemployment has hit the communities of minorities harder than it has hit other communities. What posters such as this fail to understand is that most African Americans do not care for your labels (moderate, conservative) because we have had labels of our own for a couple, contd.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Msquad99
Space is a vacuum because earth sucks.
07:52 PM on 11/23/2010
of centuries at this point in time. We see no bondage in Federal Government assistance. It was the Federal Government that had to force the conservative society to allow us into schools, neighborhoods and onto the front of busses and lunch counters when the conservative communities did not give a damn for us, much like they do now. Why, in the name of good sense basic intelligence, would a community such as the African American community now ally itself with the right after this last two years and the campaign just finished? Do you not remember all that was said and done? Conservatives do not benefit the African American community. And let us be clear. There is no such thing as a "moderate". Moderates are right wingers with a conscience who cannot stomach the extremes of the their associates. We will not be fooled. Notice, we have been very quiet throughout the last two years until the NAACP spoke up about the racist associations in the Tea Party. And then the tactic on the right was deny, deny, deny. Yet everyone could see, see, see and hear, hear, hear. This poster is still drinking the tea and high on the aroma. Listen to a little Hip Hop next time, poster. We speak through the arts.
09:43 AM on 12/03/2010
wow ! very impressive that you seem to speak for all african-americans. so interesting to know that one must listen to hip-hop to understand all african- americans and that blacks "speak through the arts." prior to your comments i believed that many african americans also spoke with the voices of math and science. Maybe you should listen to something besides hip hop and understand that americans care less and less about race. and, yes i have listened to hip-hop and found good and bad just like any other genre. if you feel the need to be unique and relevant you may want to move beyond skin color.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tresco
Sistagirl Laughin' Thingy Award Winner!
01:46 PM on 11/23/2010
Having your political identity determined by the color of your skin is bad for you and the country as a whole. It's time to start thinking outside the box of "racial" identity politics. People need something better.
12:17 PM on 11/23/2010
Funny how all you libs want to blame Karl Rove and other on the right. What about when Obama goes on and implores all "African Americans, Latinos, women and TLTGs to get out and vote, or when he goes on Spanish TV and says to go out and vote to punish our enemies, do ya think that creates any racial divide? The post racial president has been the most racial polarizing President in our lifetime. He's set race relations back 50 years.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Msquad99
Space is a vacuum because earth sucks.
01:38 PM on 11/23/2010
You lie. The fact that a Black man was elected President brought out the worst in people all over this nation. I see the comments here. He is too "upity". He speaks like a "professor" and that is a detriment to many commentors who come here. This "boy", the community organizer wasn't up to the task. There was a HUGE racial divide before he got into office and his election only brought that to the surface. This is and was a racially polarized nation, has been that way for two centuries and his 2 years in office is the cause of all of this animus? Race relations are where they truly were all along. There is no setting them back. They never moved forward. You conveniently ignore the "Willie Horton" episode, the "Southern Strategy", racial profiling by major city police departments and a million other small and large cuts over that last five decades. Obviously this poster is not a person of any minority. From the moment this man took office that hoods went on. It was not necessary to create something that was already there. All this post racial President did was embolden the racists by his very presence. Period. There has been racial progress in this nation but that progress had fallen far short of what the right was so quick to profess. And it comes predominantly from the right, the ones who were so quick to profess the demise of racism. Funny, huh?
02:26 PM on 11/23/2010
"The fact that a Black man was elected President brought out the worst in people all over this nation"

It also brought out the best in people all over this nation. He would not have been elected without the support of a large majority of whites. And that is a measure of progress. If he fails to get re-elected, it won't be due to his race. It will be because those who supported him in 08 somehow lost a degree of confidence in him for other reasons.
01:53 PM on 11/23/2010
Nope, that responsibility pretty much falls squarely on the shoulders of the Flea Party. It was they who spent the past 2 years sending overtly racial messages and Fox news gave them the platform they needed.
12:12 PM on 11/23/2010
Noudidnt...You're exactly correct!
12:11 PM on 11/23/2010
Noudidnt...you're exactly correct!!
photo
George Hanshaw
There are none so blind as those who will not see.
11:30 AM on 11/23/2010
"There is a larger issue of waning Black political influence nationwide. Much of it is simple partisan calculus: most Black elected officials are staunch Democrats, and there are few either willing or in an able position to leverage relationships on the other side of the aisle."

The phenomenon of Black allegiance to the Democratic Party is something that bears more discussion. In a very truthful way you could say that this allegiance has been purchased, and by this I don't mean the historic 'walking around money' on election day, although that's certainly a part of it, but it has been bought with a certain amount of money from the public treasury - money flowing through such organizations as ACORN and others.

But the surprising thing is that it has been so thoroughly bought at such a modest price by the dems - at least a modest price that they pay out of anything other than the public treasury - in such an uneven exchange.

Dems would not exist as a competitive national party without the near-lockstep Black vote, but over the past 45 years since the war on poverty began, but this has little benefited Black America. Other groups that have come here in poverty have - fairly rapidly in most cases - achieved economic parity. Even non-native African-Americans who share all the genes (but not the culture) seem to do fine.

Perhaps Blacks should ponder the true cost of the political role they have chosen to play.
02:11 PM on 11/23/2010
It is not a simple issue of economics. What you are doing is trying to whittle it down to a welfare issue which is the pervasive myth that has existed since the 70's and beyond. Black people vote lockstep with the Democratic party because they are the only ones willing to address the myriad social issues that affect us. For example, the readjusting of the cocaine sentencing guidelines, police brutality, community development, education, hate crimes etc.
If the Republican party was not so hostile to minorities perhaps more of us would join, but they continually spout vitriol that attacks us as a community. I live in Georgia where our newly elected Republican Governor was quoted as making references to "ghetto grandma's" and proudly proclaimed voting against the voting rights act.
"Blacks" have pondered the cost of our political role and we find it to be much more beneficial than the alternative. And for the record not all black people are welfare babies as you are insinuating. Maybe if you NOT so rich Republican "Whites" pondered the true cost of the political role you play you would vote with us before you end up on the same welfare you accuse us of receiving because of your dedication to your racism. If you make less than 250K a year your precious Republicans DO NOT CARE about you regardless of color and they will make you poor before they are finished.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
The Albany Kid
From the 518 to the 651
03:26 PM on 11/23/2010
Co-sign
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Msquad99
Space is a vacuum because earth sucks.
09:17 PM on 11/23/2010
Faved
03:06 PM on 11/23/2010
George, great post. Sad that too few will listen.
10:46 AM on 11/23/2010
Please read Wayne Madsen's article, "Rahm Emanuel's night of the Long Knives," in it you will find that the war on the Democratic Black Caucus, the largest progressive caucus in congress, is being waged from within the Democratic party, from the DLC against the CBC. Also: like his predecessor, it's clear that Barack Obama doesn't care about black people who aren't his family.
10:22 AM on 11/23/2010
Blacks need to show up for for voting. One reaps what he sows
10:54 AM on 11/23/2010
Dems need to give them a reason. Indeed, sowing leads to reaping.
12:30 PM on 11/23/2010
This is a 2 party country, you have to pick the lesser of 2 evils. You can either pick someone who will address some of your issues, or pick someone who will address none of your issues. The choice is clear. You won't be getting no uplift for Republicans. They've made it clear.
02:44 AM on 11/24/2010
You got it backwards. If we show up and vote with regularity, they will HAVE to listen. Right now, we don't vote, so they don't give a shit what we think. It's that simple.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jeanrenoir
10:16 AM on 11/23/2010
Black political power has now been crushed by the brilliance of the far right. Blacks were always a small minority of the electorate--only 12% or so, not enough to elect a dogcatcher outside of a large coalition. Rove and friends have now eviscerated the coalition by successfully dividing "Reagan Democrat" whites from blacks once and for all. The Tea Party is the spear tip of the movement to pit lower-class, uneducated whites against blacks exactly as they were always pitted against blacks in the segregated South. Divide the lower classes and conquer for the top 1%. The whole domestic program of the Tea Party is to cut out all government programs that transfer tax dollars from white workers' pockets to needy blacks. This is totally OVERT now. Whites, from Sarah Palin on down, are sending the message that poor blacks should be on their own, to sink or swim by their own devices, just like poor whites. This genie is not going back into the bottle. Only upper-class white liberals can be manipulated with guilt now. Lower-class whites are openly angry at the stupid, self-destructive behaviors of urban blacks: teen pregnancy, no studying in school then dropping out unemployable, drug addiction, and crime. Poor whites feel NO guilt over the plight of blacks. After all, the poor whites never owned slaves. As far as the poor whites are concerned, it's a tough world out there, and if you are too lazy to work, you sink.
10:33 AM on 11/23/2010
This is a sickening commentary. If you could step out of your prism of stereotyping you might be able to at least understand the INDIVIDUAL tea party member and his or her motives. The book "The Bell Curve" looked at races based upon intelligence tests...a racist such as yourself would find the results very interesting. By the way, whites don't come out on top according to their research.
photo
George Hanshaw
There are none so blind as those who will not see.
11:34 AM on 11/23/2010
"Rove and friends have now eviscerated the coalition by successfully dividing "Reagan Democrat" whites from blacks once and for all. The Tea Party is the spear tip of the movement to pit lower-class, uneducated whites against blacks exactly as they were always pitted against blacks in the segregated South."

So you are saying that the 'Reagan Democrats' upon whom the dems have always depended for their success have always been a bunch of racist dimwit honkys? And that Rove is smarter at motivating them than the national dems are?

And I take it you don't believe the poll that said the Tea Party was wealthier and more educated than the national average?
11:34 AM on 11/23/2010
Here are some facts to debunk your theory that all white southerners owned slaves and thus racist.

US CENSUS OF 1860:
(1) 27M total pop. of US; (2) 8M total pop of South; (3) 385k of the 8M owned slaves or 4.8%; (4) 6.5% of Blacks in the South were Free or 262k of 4M(Blacks).

And a large slave owner "plantation" which meant you owned 50 or more slaves was 1% of the 4.8% who owned slaves.

But by your logic this means that 1.5% percent of all the whites in the US or 4.8%(South) who owned slaves means 100% of whites are at fault for all Blacks struggles and even worse somehow "racist"?
02:23 PM on 11/23/2010
Didn't have to own a slave to be racist. Remember that the NATIONAL consensus was that African Americans were 1/3 of a person for tax purposes. That means 3 of us to equal one white person for tax purposes. not to mention the sub-human treatment we received for years after slavery ended. Argument debunked.
09:31 AM on 11/23/2010
Black political power is marginal at best because it's monolithic. African Americans are the most predictable voting block in the country, and consequently their demands can be ignored by the Democratic party. What's their alternative? Vote Republican?
09:56 AM on 11/23/2010
Their demands are seldom ignored but there is often a lot of influential pressure applied to more mainstream their very liberal tendencies. Without this significant and predictable voting block the Democratic Party would be in disasterous shape.
10:39 AM on 11/23/2010
Their demands are often ignored, and what have these government programs achieved? They've decimated the black family and neutered the impulse of self reliance. Even the idea of school choice, a popular option within the African American community, is resisted by the Democratic Party because is threatens the teacher's union. Now that the country is broke, the government will not be able to handle the needs of so many.
10:56 AM on 11/23/2010
or not at all, which by the way, is leverage.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Marcospinelli
an old liberal Democrat, a 'New Deal'-Democrat
09:24 AM on 11/23/2010
The most important read of the day...perhaps of the year:

Power and the Tiny Acts of Rebellion
By Chris Hedges
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MacTheBlogger
Radical Independent. Keep your partisan BS.
09:22 AM on 11/23/2010
American minorities will make their greatest strides when the American Left stops identifying people simply by the color of their skin. Until then, the divisions that so damage our country will not be healed.

Why? Because the REAL r@cists out there (regardless of their skin color) will be more exposed and isolated when skin color is no longer relevant.

Unfortunately, there are too many people who have too much to gain by keeping us separated.
10:57 AM on 11/23/2010
"American minorities will make their greatest strides when the American Left stops identifying people simply by the color of their skin. Until then, the divisions that so damage our country will not be healed."

You first!