iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Charlotte Safavi

Charlotte Safavi

Posted: January 9, 2011 04:48 PM

IranAir Crash

What's Your Reaction:

An IranAir passenger flight carrying 106 passengers crashed earlier today while attempting an emergency landing in the middle of a severe snowstorm outside the city of Orumiyeh in Western Azerbaijan.

Iranian media reported that 71 people onboard died and 35 survived with light to serious injuries.

The plane took off late owing to poor weather conditions on a direct flight from Tehran to Orumiyeh, 460 miles in a northwesterly direction.

The aircraft was an old Boeing 727, which has been out of production in the United States for more than a couple of decades.

Iranian airlines have frequent incidents of aircraft failure due to an aging fleet and poor maintenance. Many of the planes still in operation, especially the Boeings, were purchased before the 1979 Islamic Revolution. Since then, US sanctions have made the replacement and upkeep of these planes difficult, and Iran has continued to fly them.

If it is determined that mechanical failure had a part to play in this tragedy, this is another example of the steep price ordinary Iranians have to pay for the political situation they find themselves in.

 

Follow Charlotte Safavi on Twitter: www.twitter.com/CharlotteSafavi

 
 
  • Comments
  • 51
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ira7
06:22 AM on 01/12/2011
Come on--this is a non-issue. There was a snowstorm, and accidents happen.

And as far as I know, Iranian carriers follow adequate inspection procedures, unlike many countries.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Charlotte Safavi
Oxford-educated, published writer with opinions.
01:38 PM on 01/12/2011
I completely agree that this could have been a weather-related accident, not so sure on the rest and not sure if we'll ever hear the real cause from the Iranian Government. Either way, it's sometimes good to get a lively debate going.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
koroush1336
An human rights activist and totally anti-mullahs,
03:08 PM on 01/10/2011
In all countries, the aviation industries are one of the most, if not the most important duties of the governments. That is to say, if we have a government which is for the safeties of the people there! In Iran you have a different situation as compared to all other countries in the civilized world. In Iran you have a system which is so corrupted, up to the point which no one is able to imagine! This medieval regime knows nothing about the safeties of the citizens of Iran. In fact the mullahs are the only ENEMY of the people in Iran and at a constant WAR with IRANIANS.

So there is no way which anyone could in any way or means blame the SANCTIONS against the mullahs' regime. These are the same criminals who are giving $25,000,000.00 each month to the Hizbollah in Lebenon and millions more to other terrorist groups around the world. The money which should be used for the SAFETIES of the IRANIANS themselves. If there is someone to be blamed, there is no one else but the MULLAHS themselves.
06:16 PM on 01/10/2011
Absolutely correct. You have to ask yourself why a country with a rich cultural heritage and blessed with vast natural resources can't manage its aviation industry. Of course the religious ideologues have difficulty adapting their avionics to the Koran......tant pis.
06:30 PM on 01/10/2011
Well said Koroush jaan... as usual.   I'm not denying that sanctions are affecting the average Iranian but any suffering as a result of the sanctions is minimal to the suffering that the regime imposes upon them. 
12:43 PM on 01/10/2011
I appreciate, Ms Safavi, you don't wish to play the blame-game.
I don't, either, it's still one more instance where the tragedy overwhelms the anger, at least for the moment.

It is nevertheless true that US has targeted Iran for extreme even brutal interference ever since the 1950's. We still remember Mossadegh, don't we?
It bears repeating that the "U.S. sanctions prevent Iran from updating its 30-year-old American aircraft and make it difficult to get European spare parts or planes as well." (Globe & Mail, ca.)

Collateral damage comes in many unpredictable and incalculable shapes and forms. Ask the fleeing Iraqi Christians crashing off the shores of Australia just a week ago, or look at dead and the burnt at the air-crash in Iran yesterday.
10:07 AM on 01/10/2011
"Political situation" has absolutely nothing to do with it.
Iran is an oil-rich nation which spend untold billions to upgrade its military aircraft and missiles. It could've done the same with its civilian fleet.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Charlotte Safavi
Oxford-educated, published writer with opinions.
10:17 AM on 01/10/2011
Thanks for your comment. I agree. Iran makes political choices; according to your response, one the of these political choices is to "upgrade its military aircraft and missiles" and not their "civilian fleet", hence if mechanical failure is to blame for the crash, the ordinary Iranians died because of choices made by politicians.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atif Ahmed Choudhury
J.D. Candidate, William and Mary College of Law
02:50 PM on 01/10/2011
Actually jet engines and components are among whole-scale sanctioned items; hence why BOTH the Iranian military and civilian fleets have been experiencing such tragic crashes left and right:

http://www.yalibnan.com/2011/01/10/iran-probes-iranair-passenger-plane-crash/
06:49 PM on 01/10/2011
"Iran’s civil fleet is made up of planes in poor condition due to their age and lack of maintenance."
Fault of Iranian totalitarian government who's got a lots of sparkling missiles and and a fleet of 30 year old civilian planes.

I am sure Ahmadinejad and the military and religious elite travel in brand new planes.
09:58 AM on 01/10/2011
What a callow post. I might suggest that rather than blame America (Iran has plenty of money to buy Airbuses) the writer wait until the facts are in. The last big Iranian air disaster involved a Tupolev 154 (no doubt sabotaged by the CIA).
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Charlotte Safavi
Oxford-educated, published writer with opinions.
11:00 AM on 01/10/2011
Thanks for your comment. I'm surprised at the number of readers who think I am blaming America or Iran. I'm doing neither; I'm just presenting the limited facts that were available at the time of my post. I'm also saying that if mechanical fault is determined to be the cause of this crash, ordinary people are paying the price for political decisions made by governments...whether to sanction planes/parts (US, for example) or to mismanage civilian aircraft and spend money elsewhere (Iran, for example). If the planes are properly maintained and appropriately retired, the chance of crashes are minimal; if they are not, crashes happen.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Doctoress
02:05 AM on 01/10/2011
Total nonsens propaganda for which she is paid to please her masters in U.S.
Tell us what you "journalist" think about U.S. sanctions against selling passenger planes to Iran. But then, you couldn't say it, could you?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Charlotte Safavi
Oxford-educated, published writer with opinions.
09:10 AM on 01/10/2011
Please read the comments on this thread as a diversity of opinions are expressed. As a blogger, I'm simply sharing the news. I do believe, as I say in my blog, that ordinary Iranians pay the price of the political situation they find themselves in.
09:52 AM on 01/10/2011
This is not the first time that ordinary people pay the price. Remember the Iraq sanctions which took away the lives of half million children in early 90s and when Albright was asked if it worth it and she replied "I think this is a very hard choice, but the price--we think the price is worth it."?
schatsie
Wall Street is Worse than Vegas
11:06 PM on 01/09/2011
I think that it is quite remarkable that there were any survivors at all.....The staff must be very well trained...
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Charlotte Safavi
Oxford-educated, published writer with opinions.
08:38 AM on 01/10/2011
I agree. Many locals came out to help as well.
08:47 PM on 01/09/2011
The Iranian Government has had 31 years to replace the antiquated Boeing manufactured planes of Iran Air.
 
In that time the Iranians have purchased 50 Fokker and Airbus airliners from Europe and have had the opportunity to buy many more yet they chose to continue to fly a handful of planes they were unable to adequately maintain.
 
If Iran could not purchase the required spare parts and servicing for the Boeing planes then the planes should never have been flown.
 
Do not blame America for Iranian irresponsibility.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Charlotte Safavi
Oxford-educated, published writer with opinions.
09:09 PM on 01/09/2011
Thanks for your input. I agree with your POV. I am absolutely not blaming America. I am just saying that if mechanical problems caused the crash, ordinary Iranians pay the price for the political situation they are in. I rephrased the end of my blog to clarify this.
photo
SheilaKhani
can't read between the lines
10:44 PM on 01/09/2011
Due to the aviation embargo many of the purchased airplanes in the past 30 years are sitting in run ways across Europe and MiddEast. Just saying that purchased doesn't mean they are using them. However, the bigger problem lies with Islamic regimes' lack of care for their own people.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Sharmine Narwani
07:02 PM on 01/09/2011
So much for Obama's promises that this 4th round of sanctions against Iran would target very specific regime-related and nuclear-related interests. When Iranian passenger planes are prevented from being refueled in airports around the world and are denied spare parts, it is clear this US administration has lied through its teeth.

I would like to see some class action suits being presented to those institutions and companies that have a direct or indirect hand in Iran Air crashes. Perhaps that will make them think twice.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Charlotte Safavi
Oxford-educated, published writer with opinions.
07:23 PM on 01/09/2011
Thanks for your POV. I agree that somehow as Americans we have to be able to impose sanctions, yet not those that put innocent lives at risk or in obvious danger. Perhaps airplane maintenance is something we could offer, just to get dangerous craft out of the air. The exact cause of the crash is as yet unclear.
photo
SheilaKhani
can't read between the lines
10:48 PM on 01/09/2011
Actually the aviation embargo has been going on for almost 3 decades so is not Obama's 4th round of sanctions. Which is another joke by itself cause the Islamic regime seems to be doing really well trading with the Iraqi Kurds, Sunnis and Shias'. They just established their 3rd ice cream chain store in Baghdad next to America's Green Zone. So much for "specific" sanctions!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
koroush1336
An human rights activist and totally anti-mullahs,
03:15 PM on 01/10/2011
Sheila-,
This is not an ice cream chain. This is a cover for their terrorist activities of these criminal mullahs!
06:09 PM on 01/09/2011
Condolences to the family and loved-ones of the deceased and a speedy recovery to those hurt in this crash.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Charlotte Safavi
Oxford-educated, published writer with opinions.
06:43 PM on 01/09/2011
Thanks for your condolences. Most kind.
06:47 PM on 01/09/2011
Agreed.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Charlotte Safavi
Oxford-educated, published writer with opinions.
06:55 PM on 01/09/2011
Thanks.
05:49 PM on 01/09/2011
So sad that Iranians civilians are the ones to pay the price.....
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Charlotte Safavi
Oxford-educated, published writer with opinions.
06:56 PM on 01/09/2011
I couldn't agree more.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Richard Pearce
Atheistic-agnostic Canadian polymath
07:34 PM on 01/09/2011
Ah, but the question is, what are they paying the price for?
 
Those who feel that the legitimacy of a government comes only from how closely they follow the dictates of the 'only remaining superpower' will say it is because they live under an illegitimate government.
 
Those who take the view that the legitimacy of a government comes from that government serving the needs of its people will say it is because they live under a government that dared to not heel when told to by the superpowers.
 
And the reality is that, if the reports that this flight took off in severely bad weather for a destination that was also suffering severely bad weather are true, the cause for this, like many similar crashes throughout the world, is the ability of humans to convince themselves that running risks is somehow risk free.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Charlotte Safavi
Oxford-educated, published writer with opinions.
07:54 PM on 01/09/2011
Thanks for your comments, very interesting. Remains to be seen.